'SNP under-performance'published at 15:03 Greenwich Mean Time 14 December 2017
Conservative MSP Dean Lockhard says there has been "14 years of SNP under-performance."
He asks: "Why has finance secretary ignored advice that any increase in tax will cause long-term damage to the Scottish economy."
Derek Mackay says "This is a good budget for business."
He asks: "Doesn't the UK government take any responsibility for the economy.
"The UK economic model does not work for Scotland."