Finance secretary is 'proud' of budgetpublished at 17:16 Greenwich Mean Time 31 January 2018
Labour MSP Iain Gray accuses Derek Mackay of bringing the budget to parliament containing a mistake.
"He is not on the strongest ground when it comes to fiscal competency, is he?"
Derek Mackay says the local government settlement is up in real terms before council tax rises are considered.
He notes Cosla has welcomed this.
Tory MSP Brian Whittle says South Ayrshire Council is having to make a number of service reductions, asking how the finance secretary reconciles this with the first minister's assertion that education is her priority.
Derek Mackay says the council will get £9.4m extra.
"And he's going to vote against it," we here John Swinney shout... repeatedly.
Mr Mackay points to "popular support" for the proposals and concludes by saying he is proud to present the budget today.