Assessment amendments agreedpublished at 15:19 British Summer Time 25 April 2018
Lib Dem MSP Alex Cole-Hamilton says his party have "anxieties" over Mr Tomkin's amendment opening the door for private companies, but says the Scottish government's similar amendment gets the balance right.
He welcomes the amendments put forward by Mark Griffin and Alison Johnstone, stating the latter will add an element of humanity to the system.
The minister's amendment 42 is agreed (for 96, against 26).
Mr Griffin's and Ms Johnstone's amendments are unanimously agreed.