Summary

  • The constitution committee hosts a roundtable session on common UK frameworks post-Brexit

  • The conveners of Holyrood's committees quiz the first minister on the programme for government

  • Health and sport ministers face portfolio questions

  • Scottish Labour leads two debates: the first on Monklands hospital and the second on inequality

  • An SNP MSP opens a debate on support for families of loved ones killed abroad

  1. Governments must not be sole authors of frameworkspublished at 10:22 British Summer Time 24 October 2018

    Tory MSP Adam Tomkins
    Image caption,

    Tory MSP Adam Tomkins

    Tory MSP Adam Tomkins says there is a need for high level principles which will allow more politically contentious issues to be considered under the umbrella of these principles.

    Michael Clancy from the Law Society of Scotland says governments and administrations should not be the sole authors of frameworks in order to guard against shifting priorities as governments change in the future.

    He also calls for more transparency and accountability, a point which receives some support from others.

    Green MSP Patrick Harvie wonders if a voluntary, non-binding arrangement could result in a stronger outcome, using the Committee on Climate Change - which covers both Scotland and the UK - as an example.

  2. Background: UK ministers want temporary control of devolved areas post-Brexitpublished at 10:17 British Summer Time 24 October 2018

    Food labellingImage source, PA
    Image caption,

    Food labelling is one such area where a common framework may be required

    Back in March, the UK government named 24 devolved areas where it wanted to temporarily retain power following Brexit.

    Ministers in the Scottish and Welsh governments wanted subjects such as food labelling and animal welfare to come under their control.

    However, UK ministers were bidding to oversee those areas, and others on the list, external, until a "new UK approach" could be established.

    The Scottish government accused the UK government of a power grab.

    Read more here.

  3. Uncertainty may persist for some time warns academicpublished at 10:03 British Summer Time 24 October 2018

    Anthony Salamone from the Scottish Centre for European Relations
    Image caption,

    Anthony Salamone from the Scottish Centre for European Relations

    Anthony Salamone from the Scottish Centre for European Relations suggests the uncertainty we face now may persist for some time, and as a result it's difficult to prepare.

    Prof Paul Beaumont suggests the UK government should set up a secretariat to consider what is meant by the UK internal market as part of discussions of frameworks.

    Prof Michael Keating says this would simplify matters as it would establish a set of standards to measure the policy impacts against.

  4. Experts express concern about short timescalespublished at 09:47 British Summer Time 24 October 2018

    Prof Michael Keating
    Image caption,

    Prof Michael Keating highlights the complexity of issues being discussed

    Prof Michael Keating warns we are trying to address complex constitutional issues in too short a period of time.

    "We could end up with a terrible muddle," he says.

    Michael Clancy from the Law Society of Scotland agrees, adding that decisions made in a rush may not end up being the right decisions.

    Lloyd Austin of RSPB Scotland
    Image caption,

    Lloyd Austin of RSPB Scotland

    Lloyd Austin of RSPB Scotland explains environmental issues are inherently cross-border, which is why international measures are helpful.

    The UK Cabinet paper did not recognise the need for cooperation in some areas, he says.

    He calls for better inter-governmental mechanisms for this purpose.

  5. Background: What is the issue with common frameworks?published at 09:35 British Summer Time 24 October 2018

    Philip Sim
    BBC Scotland political reporter

    Mike RussellImage source, Getty Images

    Ministers agreed that some powers currently exercised from Brussels should go into UK-wide frameworks - similar to how they were used previously but across the UK's "internal market" instead of the European one.

    The row is about how these common frameworks are set up, and who has the final say over them where ministers fail to agree.

    UK ministers say that some areas are so important that in the first few years after Brexit, they can't afford splits in that "internal market" over things like food standards.

    Scottish ministers reckon this is a "power grab", leaving Westminster free to impose its will on Holyrood.

    Read more from Philip Sim here.

  6. And we're off........published at 09:33 British Summer Time 24 October 2018

    Committee

    The committee is taking evidence from a roundtable, comprising:

  7. Committee begins shortlypublished at 09:25 British Summer Time 24 October 2018

    ChamberImage source, Getty Images

    The constitution committee will kick off shortly with a session on common UK frameworks.

    A roundtable will be asked about the principles and policy areas of common frameworks, how they should be agreed and implemented, how they should be enforced and funding arrangements.

    Read the committee papers here., external

    And you can read more about the inquiry here., external

  8. Good morning and welcome to Holyrood Live!published at 12:13 British Summer Time 22 October 2018

    ministerial meetingImage source, PA

    Welcome to Holyrood Live on Wednesday 24 October 2018.

    The constitution committee will take evidence on the all important common UK frameworks from a raft of witnesses from 9.30am.

    Over lunchtime, committee conveners have a chance to quiz the first minister on her programme for government.

    Hospital staffImage source, Getty Images

    Portfolio questions this week focuses on health and sport.

    Scottish Labour have the floor after that and will be focusing on the Monklands hospital site and then inequality.

    SNP MSP Angela Constance will then lead a member’s debate on support for families of loved ones killed abroad.