Summary

  • Nicola Sturgeon is quizzed by opposition party leaders during FMQs

  • Jackson Carlaw goes on the issue of Brexit, asking if backers of PM's deal are traitors too

  • Richard Leonard also goes on the rejection of no-deal and is pressed by FM on 'People's Vote'

  • The dumping of waste is the focus of Willie Rennie's question this week

  1. No modelling on audience impactpublished at 10:52 Greenwich Mean Time 14 March 2019

    Tory MSP Alexander Stewart

    Tory MSP Alexander Stewart says it is difficult to imagine Global will remain relevant whilst it reduces local content and cuts jobs.

    What modelling was put together on the impact on audience figures he asks.

    Will Harding says it is a judgement rather than modelling, and if we get it wrong the audience will tell us.

    The new breakfast shows will be entertaining, informative, popular programmes he says.

  2. 'If we get it wrong we will suffer'published at 10:48 Greenwich Mean Time 14 March 2019

    Mr Gibson points out the BBC has just launched a Scottish channel, but commercial radio seems to be going in the opposite direction.

    Mr Harding accepts: "If we get it wrong we will suffer."

    The BBC are not under the same commercial pressure we are, he points out.

  3. Why reduce to the minimum set by Ofcom?published at 10:45 Greenwich Mean Time 14 March 2019

    SNP MSP Kenneth Gibson

    SNP MSP Kenneth Gibson points out the Ofcom guidelines set out a minimum standard for local content.

    Why have you chosen to reduce to this minimum, because it seems like you view local content as a burden the MSP says.

    We are exploiting the flexibility of network programming, Mr Harding accepts.

    That is the only change we are making in Scotland, while elsewhere we have opted to combine shows he says.

  4. Join us for a stellar debate at 3.20pm.......published at 10:42 Greenwich Mean Time 14 March 2019

    This Twitter post cannot be displayed in your browser. Please enable Javascript or try a different browser.View original content on Twitter
    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    Skip twitter post

    Allow Twitter content?

    This article contains content provided by Twitter. We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as they may be using cookies and other technologies. You may want to read Twitter’s cookie policy, external and privacy policy, external before accepting. To view this content choose ‘accept and continue’.

    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    End of twitter post
  5. 'I didn't say I didn't care'published at 10:40 Greenwich Mean Time 14 March 2019

    WitnessesImage source, bbc

    "I didn't say I didn't care and I certainly did not mean to be flippant," says Mr Harding.

    There is no doubt this is a challenge for the industry, he concedes.

    Mr Adam warns you'll end up getting some grey person broadcasting form London, you'll be better off listening to the BBC.

    Everyone, including the BBC must offer choice, replies Mr Harding, who goes on to say if the commercial industry stands still it will be lost and there will be no local content.

  6. Smooth has cut Scottish news content by a third says SNP MSPpublished at 10:37 Greenwich Mean Time 14 March 2019

    SNP MSP George Adam
    Image caption,

    SNP MSP George Adam

    SNP MSP George Adam asks how the proportion of Scottish news output has changed on Smooth in recent years.

    Corrie Martin is unable to reply - leading Mr Adam to reveal the answer is that it is 30% less from 2005.

    Mr Harding says we have to make a difficult decision to balance content and the difficult truth is that listeners want more music rather than speech.

  7. Postpublished at 10:36 Greenwich Mean Time 14 March 2019

    This Twitter post cannot be displayed in your browser. Please enable Javascript or try a different browser.View original content on Twitter
    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    Skip twitter post

    Allow Twitter content?

    This article contains content provided by Twitter. We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as they may be using cookies and other technologies. You may want to read Twitter’s cookie policy, external and privacy policy, external before accepting. To view this content choose ‘accept and continue’.

    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    End of twitter post
  8. Short burst info inserts and pulling back to local for major events possible - Globalpublished at 10:34 Greenwich Mean Time 14 March 2019

    Ms Baker accepts there will still be a robust news bulletin but there will now no longer be interaction with a Scottish presenter.

    Ms Martin says additional short burst information can be dropped in and if there is a major situation we can pull back to local programming.

    When the Manchester terrorist attack happened that is what happened to allow Global to "super serve" the local audience, she says.

  9. Global Radio defends local offeringpublished at 10:31 Greenwich Mean Time 14 March 2019

    Corrie Martin, news director for the regions at Global Radio
    Image caption,

    Corrie Martin, news director for the regions at Global Radio

    Corrie Martin, news director for the regions at Global Radio, says most of the time news bulletins go well beyond the requirement of their needing to be one local story.

    We punch hugely above our weight, she insists.

    "We cover all the big stories as well as covering the day-to-day."

  10. 'You will hear fewer local voices' but local news remains unchanged says Globalpublished at 10:29 Greenwich Mean Time 14 March 2019

    "You will hear fewer local voices," Mr Harding says, but reiterates that local news will not be changing.

    Ms Baker says she finds that hard to accept.

    Mr Harding says the production of news bulletins is entirely separate, adding there will be no changes to the news bulletins.

  11. Background: Radio stations able to produce fewer hours of local content under Ofcom changespublished at 10:26 Greenwich Mean Time 14 March 2019

    Radio

    The latest review of Ofcom's guidance for local radio has meant fewer locally-produced programmes have to be aired.

    FM stations which provide at least hourly peak-time local news now only have to have six hours of local programmes between 6am and 7pm, down from 10 hours under the previous guidelines.

    And those which provide local news hourly any time between 6am and 7pm only need to have three hours, down from seven.

    Ofcom said the alterations were due to changes in competition and listening habits across the radio sector.

  12. No-one is welcoming the changes says Labour MSPpublished at 10:22 Greenwich Mean Time 14 March 2019

    Claire BakerImage source, bbc

    Labour MSP Claire Baker quotes a post on the Capital Scotland Facebook page saying Global clearly have no idea why people listen to Capital in the morning.

    Mr Harding says radio listeners are passionate and accepts they are disappointed by the changes announced.

    Ms Baker points out no-one is welcoming the changes out of over 650 posts.

    Mr Harding replies Capital Scotland has thousands of listeners and while it does not make his life any easier, the Facebook posts reflect the passion of the listeners.

  13. How much money is Global Radio saving?published at 10:19 Greenwich Mean Time 14 March 2019

    The convener suggests Global Radio asked questions in such a way as to get the answers it wanted.

    Mr Harding disagrees, saying questions were to find out what is important to listeners.

    Local presenters come some way down the list of priorities and that is consistent between our research and Ofcom's he explains.

    Mr Harding

    How much money are you saving from these changes, asks Ms McAlpine.

    In Scotland the savings are very modest, Mr Harding replies.

    The material cost saving is not in Scotland, but rather in the reduction of broadcast centres in England he adds.

  14. Scottish talent being dropped says committee convenerpublished at 10:14 Greenwich Mean Time 14 March 2019

    Committee convener Joan McAlpineImage source, bbc

    Committee convener Joan McAlpine says Global seem to have used the Scottish talent for the brand launch and now they are being ditched.

    Mr Harding argues nothing has changed in terms of local output since 2010.

    "Well it will change because you're dropping them," points out Ms McAlpine.

    The Global Radio representative accepts that local programming will reduce from seven hours to three as a result of the latest changes.

    WitnessesImage source, bbc
  15. Global Radio 'absolutely committed' to delivering high quality local newspublished at 10:10 Greenwich Mean Time 14 March 2019

    Radio

    Local and regional content listeners most value is local news and local information (such as travel and school closures) Will Harding states.

    This is must more important to them than where presenters and programmes are based, he explains.

    We remain absolutely committed to delivering high quality local news, Mr Harding insists.

  16. Cutting local breakfast shows due to Ofcom changespublished at 10:05 Greenwich Mean Time 14 March 2019

    Will Harding from Global RadioImage source, bbc
    Image caption,

    Will Harding from Global Radio

    Will Harding from Global Radio says the market share in Scotland is 14%.

    We recently announced we are launching three UK-wide breakfast shows which will be broadcast in Scotland, says Mr Harding.

    There will be new local drive-time shows, he adds.

    Mr Harding is as a result of Ofcom changes to local broadcasting requirements.

  17. Background: Capital, Heart and Smooth cull local radio showspublished at 10:02 Greenwich Mean Time 14 March 2019

    Vick Hope and Roman Kemp, and Jamie Theakston with Emma BuntonImage source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    Vick Hope and Roman Kemp present Capital breakfast in London, while until recently Jamie Theakston co-hosted Heart breakfast with Emma Bunton

    Global media has announced it will launch UK-wide national breakfast shows on Capital, Heart and Smooth radio.

    Global say they will be creating the three largest commercial radio breakfast shows in the UK, with 4.8m, 3.7m and 2.7m listeners respectively each week.

    But it means a reduction in locally produced programmes, with more than 100 jobs at risk due to the changes.

    Ofcom has approved the move following a change in guidelines, external for local radio.

    What does this mean for Scotland?

    • Capital London's breakfast show will replace 14 breakfast programmes on the Capital network in England, Scotland and Wales
    • Heart will have a single breakfast show across England, Scotland and Wales instead of the current line-up of 22 breakfast shows
    • Smooth will create a new national breakfast show replacing breakfast programmes in East Midlands, West Midlands, North West, Lake District, North East, Scotland and Wales

    Read more here.

  18. Local radio session beginspublished at 09:58 Greenwich Mean Time 14 March 2019

    Global Radio reps

    Convner Joan McAlpine summarises the planned changes at Global Radio.

    She then introduces:

    • Corrie Martin from Global Radio
    • Will Harding, also from Global Radio
  19. 'If it was me, I suppose I wouldn't even bother to get UK ministers'published at 09:55 Greenwich Mean Time 14 March 2019

    Panel

    SNP MSP Stuart McMillan says the committee has repeatedly requested UK government ministers to appear before it.

    This says a lot of the lack of respect the UK government affords this parliament, he insists.

    "If it was me, I suppose I wouldn't even bother to get UK ministers here because I know that they wouldn't want to come," replies Prof Cairney.

    He adds: "It wouldn't be an information-sharing exercise, it would be a kind of who can look most powerful exercise."

    On that notes, the session ends.

  20. Possible for Scotland to be involved in pan-European organisations after Brexitpublished at 09:54 Greenwich Mean Time 14 March 2019

    Brexit and the EUImage source, Thinkstock

    I don't know of a precedent where a sub-state government engages directly with the EU, Prof Keating tells the committed.

    Green MSP Ross Greer wonders about utilising the European Committee of the Regions.

    There are many pan-European organisations for regions that come and go, Prof Keating says.

    It would be possible for Scotland to get into some of these networks, or remain in some of these networks, he adds.

    Being a part of the European Committee of the Regions would be difficult because Scotland would not be part of a member state, he says.