Summary

  • UK environment secretary declines to commit to CCC target of net-zero emissions by 2050

  • Scroll back the play icon to watch both evidence sessions with Michael Gove or down the page for reports

  • MSPs quiz rural economy ministers during portfolio questions

  • The Lib Dems lead debates on treatment time guarantees and on education

  1. Coming up in the chamber..........published at 13:58 British Summer Time 15 May 2019

    Pupil takes testImage source, PA
    Image caption,

    The new standardised tests assess pupils' literacy and numeracy skills

    Portfolio questions is followed by two Lib Dem debates: the first on NHS waiting times; and the second on education and P1 testing.

    Labour MSP Kezia Dugdale will then mark Foster Care Fortnight 2019.

  2. NEWS: Gove does not commit to net-zero emissions targetpublished at 12:05 British Summer Time 15 May 2019

    Michael Gove was giving evidence on the impact of Brexit via video-linkImage source, bbc
    Image caption,

    Michael Gove was giving evidence on the impact of Brexit via video-link

    Michael Gove has told MSPs he could not announce the UK government's commitment to reaching net-zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050, as set out by the Committee on Climate Change.

    The UK environment secretary was giving evidence to Holyrood's environment and rural affairs committees.

    Green MSP Mark Ruskell reminded the UK environment secretary about the target and asked: "Have you got good news for us in this committee this morning?"

    "I'm afraid I can't make that announcement," replied Mr Gove.

    The UK cabinet secretary explained there are overlapping and separate responsibilities with his department and with the Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy department (BEIS).

    The Scottish government will legislate to reduce greenhouse gas emissions to net-zero by 2045 after receiving fresh advice from the CCC.

    Climate change campaigners have staged protests in EdinburghImage source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    Climate change campaigners have staged protests in Edinburgh

  3. Background: Brexit: UK will apply food tariffs in case of no dealpublished at 11:53 British Summer Time 15 May 2019

    CowsImage source, Getty Images

    In February Environment Secretary Michael Gove promised that the government will apply tariffs to food imports in the event of a no-deal Brexit, to provide "specific and robust protections" for farmers.

    His remarks come as the government is poised to release details of tariffs (taxes on imports) that would apply to thousands of products coming in from around the world, if the UK leaves the EU without a deal.

    Many supporters of Brexit argue that tariffs on food and other items should be scrapped in order to lower prices for consumers. But farmers fear that cheap imports and lower standards would destroy many parts of British agriculture.

    "Your concerns have absolutely been heard," Mr Gove told a conference of the National Farmers' Union (NFU). "It will not be the case that we will have zero-rate tariffs on food products.

    Read more here.

  4. Tory MSP raises concerns about UK government's approach to tariffspublished at 11:52 British Summer Time 15 May 2019

    Tory MSP Peter ChapmanImage source, bbc
    Image caption,

    Tory MSP Peter Chapman

    Tory MSP Peter Chapman says the UK government's approach to tariffs means there is a great deal of unfairness.

    Tariffs on UK exports to the EU are much higher than tariffs on imports to be imposed by the UK government, Mr Chapman explains.

    This would have a "catastrophic affect" on our agricultural industry, he adds, calling for a change to the approach to tariffs.

    Mr Gove explains tariffs are to protect producers and prices in the shops.

    He argues the UK government's approach in the case of a no-deal Brexit would be to protect the agricultural sector more vigorously than anyone else.

  5. EU countries not expected to lower standards on exports after no-deal Brexitpublished at 11:51 British Summer Time 15 May 2019

    Michael Gove

    SNP MSP John Mason seeks an update regarding borders and border control.

    Michael Gove says IT systems and other preparations were in place if the UK had left the EU in March.

    If we leave on 31 October without a deal there will be bumps in the road but we are confident government departments have taken steps to mitigate them, he insists.

    The UK government's approach is continuity wherever possible so we do not expect EU countries to lower their animal and environmental standards when exporting to the UK if there was a no deal, explains Mr Gove.

    It is within the EU's power to apply rules to a greater or lesser degree, he adds.

    Mr Gove says there were lots of signals that countries like France for example would prioritise speed of flow over having the most comprehensive checks in place.

  6. Under EU law geographical indicators will continue to be respectedpublished at 11:48 British Summer Time 15 May 2019

    ScotchImage source, bbc
    Image caption,

    Scotch whisky has an EU registerd GI

    Labour MSP Colin Smyth pivots to geographical indicators (GIs) and access to markets.

    Mr Gove tells the Labour MSP that under EU law they will continue to respect our GIs.

    The protections, known as "geographical indications", stop products being copied by firms outside the area where they are traditionally made.

    Mr Smyth asks if continued protection of GIs in the EU market be a red line in negotiations with the EU and US on trade deals.

    The UK rural secretary replies: "We are absolutely committed to making sure that the benefits continue to be available to producers across the UK."

    Read more about geographical indications and Brexit from SPICe., external

  7. Any trade agreement must work for all parts of the UK says Govepublished at 11:46 British Summer Time 15 May 2019

    Mr Greene asks about the role devolved administrations can play before trade negotiations with other countries begin.

    I think it's critical, replies Mr Gove, adding any trade agreement must work for all parts of the UK.

    He says efforts are made to ensure any sector with a particular interest is represented during negotiations.

    For Scotland this often means making sure salmon and whisky sectors are not undermined he adds.

  8. Tory MSP asks about soft fruit industries ability to access labour marketpublished at 11:37 British Summer Time 15 May 2019

    StrawberriesImage source, PA

    Tory MSP Jamie Greene returns to access to the labour markets for the soft fruit industry and other seasonal workers.

    Mr Greene asks about the pilot scheme for migrant workers.

    Government plans to allow UK fruit and vegetable growers to recruit non-EU seasonal workers after Brexit have been criticised inside the industry as insufficient.

    The government's proposed pilot scheme would allow the recruitment of up to 2,500 workers on six-month visas between the spring of 2019 and December 2020.

    Mr Gove insists there has been an "enthusiastic" take up for the Seasaonal Agricultural Workers Pilot going beyond the EU to places like Ukraine and Moldova.

  9. UK could get through 'turbulence' caused by no-deal Brexit insists Govepublished at 11:34 British Summer Time 15 May 2019

    Lib Dem MSP Mike Rumbles
    Image caption,

    Lib Dem MSP Mike Rumbles

    Lib Dem MSP Mike Rumbles asks if the PM's deal is not passed, whether the cabinet secretary was doing all he could to ensure the UK does not leave the EU without a deal.

    Mr Gove says leaving without a deal would create a real risk the UK economy as a whole and in particular to farming.

    We can put in place measures to mitigate the impact of that he says.

    While the UK could get through the turbulence a no deal would cause, we want to avoid that turbulence he insists.

    Mr Rumbles again calls for the cabinet secretary to commit to avoiding a no-deal Brexit.

    Mr Gove says there are challenges to no deal but he says it is one of a number of possible scenarios for which we have to be prepared.

  10. Background: Post-Brexit farming funding set out by Michael Govepublished at 11:32 British Summer Time 15 May 2019

    MPs say imports of food produced with lower welfare standards should not be allowedImage source, PA
    Image caption,

    MPs say imports of food produced with lower welfare standards should not be allowed

    In January we reported plans for the way farming subsidies would be dealt with after Brexit were set out by Michael Gove.

    Farmers will receive payments for "public goods", such as access to the countryside and planting meadows.

    The environment secretary told farmers the government would guarantee subsidies at the current EU level until the 2022 election. There would then be a "transitional period" in England.

    The National Farmers Union said it was time for "a new deal" for the UK.

  11. Does Gove understand devolution better than the Scottish government?published at 11:29 British Summer Time 15 May 2019

    Green MSP John FinnieImage source, bbc
    Image caption,

    Green MSP John Finnie

    Green MSP John Finnie asks: "You know better than the Scottish government on devolved matters?

    "You know better than the Scottish Parliament on devolved matters?"

    "No," replies Mr Gove.

    "Well that's reassuring," quips Mr Finnie

    Mr Gove goes on to say he respects the devolution settlement but he is not satisfied all the devolved powers are being used in the right way, but he adds that is for the Scottish government.

    He says NFU Scotland has pointed out the Scottish government has not offered the same clarity and future vision for agriculture that the UK government has.

  12. Background: Minister agrees Gove 'shafted Scottish hill farmers' over convergence cashpublished at 11:26 British Summer Time 15 May 2019

    SNP MSP Bruce CrawfordImage source, bbc
    Image caption,

    SNP MSP Bruce Crawford

    Yesterday we reported that SNP MSP Bruce Crawford said: "Does the minister agree with me that it is shameful Michael Gove, the UK environment secretary, has shafted Scottish hill farmers on the matter of convergency money?"

    "Well I couldn't agree more with that" replied Rural Affairs Minister Mairi Gougeon.

    Ms Gougeon said it was wrong of the UK government to "shaft us" in terms of convergence money.

    The deputy presiding officer said to both members she was not terribly happy with "that word".

  13. Call for £160m to be paid to sheep farmerspublished at 11:24 British Summer Time 15 May 2019

    Ms Watt calls for upland sheep farmers to be given the £160m convergence money "that they're due", suggesting this would help alleviate some uncertainty.

    The review is looking at all the issues concerns, replies Mr Gove, to ensure farmers across the UK are given a fair allocation of funding in the future.

    He also calls for parliamentarians to get behind the PM's deal because it is the best way forward.

  14. What impact will no-deal Brexit have on the Scottish sheep sector?published at 11:22 British Summer Time 15 May 2019

    SNP MSP Maureen WattImage source, bbc
    Image caption,

    SNP MSP Maureen Watt

    SNP MSP Maureen Watt points out the EU is the number one export destination for Scotch lamb and she says there are horror stories about the possibility of mass culls of sheep.

    Ms Watt ask what impact will a no-deal Brexit have on the Scottish sheep sector.

    Mr Gove says the MSP is absolutely right that it would hit the sheep meat sector worst and immediately.

    That's why the UK government will support the income of sheep farmers in the case of no-deal, he adds.

    The UK cabinet secretary tells the committee a model of looking at the number of breeding ewes farmers have is being considered.

  15. Background: UK government review of post-Brexit farm fundingpublished at 11:20 British Summer Time 15 May 2019

    The review is to look at how funding is sharedImage source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    The review is to look at how funding is shared

    The UK government has to set up an independent review into how farm funding should be distributed around the United Kingdom after Brexit.

    An independent advisory panel is looking at subsidies going to England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland to ensure they are "fairly split".

    NFU Scotland has said it was "bitterly disappointing" that it would not address previous funding decisions.

    The Scottish government said farmers should receive the £160m they are due.

  16. Farm support level will continue until 2022published at 11:17 British Summer Time 15 May 2019

    SNP MSP Richard Lyle turns discussion to CAP convergence payments.

    When will additional money be allocated, he asks.

    Mr Gove says he does not want to preempt the conclusions of the independent review taking place.

    He accepts the money should have been allocated in a different way in the past as the money was received due to Scotland's unique geography.

    Mr Gove

    The allocation of support for farmers will be a matter for the Scottish government after Brexit, he states.

    Agriculture funding is not subject to the Barnett formula so Scotland gets more than would normally be allocated under the formula he adds.

    That will not change, Mr Gove says.

    The UK government will preserve current EU funding right up until 2022 confirms the cabinet secretary.

  17. Are amendments to UK Agriculture Bill holding back Scottish legislation?published at 11:11 British Summer Time 15 May 2019

    Committee convener Edward MountainImage source, bbc
    Image caption,

    Committee convener Edward Mountain

    Committee convener Edward Mountain pivots to the UK Agriculture Bill and Fergus Ewing's assertion that Scottish government tabled amendments to that are holding up a Scottish Agriculture Bill.

    I do not support that view, replies Mr Gove, who insists Scotland has done less on agriculture's future than the UK government has.

    The UK rural secretary says if the Scottish government had opted to use the UK legislation it would have provided more certainty.

  18. Relationship between UK and Scottish governments is constructive insists Govepublished at 11:07 British Summer Time 15 May 2019

    SNP MSP John Mason

    SNP MSP John Mason asks about the resolution of disputes between the UK and Scottish governments.

    Mr Gove says they must be resolved by discussion and consensus.

    He insists the relationship between the two is constructive and pragmatic, despite there being political disagreements.

    There are some areas where it is absolutely right for some areas of policy to diverge, hence the devolution settlement, he states.

    We will do everything possible to facilitate such differences, Mr Gove adds.

  19. Fish processing plants must have access to 'wide sources of labour' - Govepublished at 11:02 British Summer Time 15 May 2019

    SNP MSP Stewart Stevenson raises concerns about the workforce in the processing plants post-Brexit.

    The UK government is consulting on a minimum salary requirement of £30,000 for skilled migrants seeking five-year visas.

    Mr Gove agrees it is important to have access to wide sources of labour.

    We need to look flexibly at what a "skilled worker" means, he adds.

    Tens of thousands of low-skilled migrants could come to the UK to work for up to a year under the proposed new post-Brexit immigration rules., external