Summary

  • Constitutional Relations Secretary Mike Russell gave a statement on the Referendums (Scotland) Bill earlier

  • He says the Scottish government intends to hold indyref2 within this parliament

  • A citizens assembly will begin in autumn

  • Adam Tomkins says the bill is about the 'diktat' of ministers while Richard Leonard says indyref2 is a distraction

  1. Tories do not want this parliament to decide on indyref says Russellpublished at 13:50 British Summer Time 29 May 2019

    Michael Russell and Nicola Sturgeon

    Mr Russell says the plan to give Scots the choice on independence was sent to every household in the country as part of the EU election campaign.

    Regarding the bill, he says parliament will be able to scrutinise and decide on every single detail.

    If there are developments to this bill which Mr Tomkins would like to see, he will be able to lodge amendments to it, adds the Brexit secretary.

    Mr Tomkins doesn't want this parliament to decide, he wants Westminster and the Tory prime minister to decide, Mr Russell says.

  2. Background: Sturgeon wants Indyref2 in 'second half of 2020'published at 13:48 British Summer Time 29 May 2019

    Media caption,

    Nicola Sturgeon on her next stops in wake of European elections

    First Minister Nicola Sturgeon has called for a new Scottish independence referendum in the second half of 2020.

    Speaking in Dublin Ms Sturgeon said the "latter half" of next year would be the "right time" for a new poll.

    The SNP leader predicted victory in a second vote, with Scotland becoming "an independent country just like Ireland".

    Read more.

  3. Bill would allow ministers to dictate indyref2 question and timetable says Tory MSPpublished at 13:46 British Summer Time 29 May 2019

    Tory MSP Adam Tomkins

    Tory MSP Adam Tomkins says "here we are again talking about Nicola Sturgeon's pet obsession".

    There is a case for legislation on campaign rules for referendums, he accepts, but the Referendums (Scotland) Bill goes much further than that.

    He says it means ministers can pick the question and set the date on any referendum going forward.

    This bill is about the "diktat of ministers", Mr Tomkins says, asking why ministers should determine questions and not the parliament.

    The Tory MSP also wonders what other matters could be put to a referendum.

  4. Citizens assembly to begin from autumnpublished at 13:44 British Summer Time 29 May 2019

    Mr Russell says he intends to begin a first round of cross-party talks on the next step next month.

    Turning to the citizens' assembly, he says there is a clear interest in this and he hopes other parties will come forward with suggestions for this.

    We intend to hold a first session of the assembly in the autumn and for it to conclude next spring, he confirms.

  5. Scottish government will consider accelerated indyref timetable if requiredpublished at 13:41 British Summer Time 29 May 2019

    Mr Russell says there must be a new, meaningful respect for the position of the Scottish government and parliament under the next prime minister.

    There must be a commitment to respect the legislative consent mechanism, he adds.

    The cabinet secretary says the Referendums (Scotland) Bill should pass by the end of this year and the Scottish government hopes to hold indyref2 later in this parliamentary term.

    We will consider an accelerated timetable if things change, he adds.

  6. Background: Indyref2 'framework' bill published at Holyroodpublished at 13:39 British Summer Time 29 May 2019

    Saltire outside HolyroodImage source, Getty Images

    Legislation which could pave the way for a new Scottish independence referendum has been tabled at Holyrood.

    The Scottish government wants to put the question of independence to a new public vote in the second half of 2020.

    However, the Referendums (Scotland) Bill does not set a date or question, with ministers seeking agreement with the UK government

    First Minister Nicola Sturgeon said "now more than ever it is essential that we keep Scotland's options open".

    Read more.

  7. Becoming an independent European nation is best way forward, says Russellpublished at 13:38 British Summer Time 29 May 2019

    Michael Russell

    Any deal which takes Scotland out of the EU against the wishes of the majority of people living here provides us with a mandate to hold another independence referendum, as set out in the SNP manifesto, the Brexit secretary argues.

    We continue to support a second referendum on EU membership, he states.

    But Mr Russell says becoming an independent European nation is the better way forward.

    We must try and break the current log-jam with fresh ideas and do so in a spirit of openness, he argues.

    The cabinet secretary accepts this will not be easy but at least we start with consensus around the "basic fact" that the Westminster system is broken.

  8. Russell: Scotland must not be forced against our will over cliff edgepublished at 13:34 British Summer Time 29 May 2019

    Michael Russell

    Constitutional Relations Secretary Michael Russell says the EU elections demonstrated Scotland wants to remain a European nation.

    Elections can be brutal judgements on parties and politicians, but they can also be fresh starts, he says.

    We can find a way to put the divisions of Brexit behind us and move forward together, he states.

    Mr Russell says the Brexit stalemate looks set to continue while a Tory leadership election takes place, which he says means we continue to face the prospect of a no-deal Brexit.

    "Scotland must not be forced against our will" to go over the cliff edge, he argues.

  9. Statement: Next Steps on Scotland's Futurepublished at 13:23 British Summer Time 29 May 2019

    Constitutional Relations Secretary Mike Russell is about to make a statement following the publication of the Referendums (Scotland) Bill this morning.

    The legislation will pave the way for a new vote on Scottish independence - but does not set out a timetable.

  10. Coming up...published at 11:36 British Summer Time 29 May 2019

    Saltire outside HolyroodImage source, Getty Images

    Constitutional Relations Secretary Mike Russell will give a statement at 1:30pm on the legislation to pave the way for a new Scottish independence referendum.

    After that, health and local government ministers face portfolio questions.

    Scottish Labour leads a debate on BiFab and renewables contracts.

    Finally, Green MSP Mark Ruskell has a member's debate on expanding Scotland's railways.

  11. Data sharing under GIRFEC petitionpublished at 11:33 British Summer Time 29 May 2019

    The committee will now discuss a petition, external calling for an inquiry into the gathering and sharing of personal information as part of the Getting It Right For Every Child (GIRFEC) agenda.

    The committee agrees to write to the Scottish government and the International Commissioner's Office seeking further information.

  12. Music tuition chargespublished at 11:30 British Summer Time 29 May 2019

    committee

    MSPs are considering a petition calling for music instrument tuition to be free, external to all school pupils.

    The committee agrees to close the petition.

  13. Schools in deprived areas offer fewer Highers says Green MSPpublished at 11:24 British Summer Time 29 May 2019

    Mr Greer highlights that schools in disadvantaged areas are more likely to offer fewer subjects at Higher than those in the wealthiest areas.

    "I would have to look carefully as to whether there's a pattern there," replies Mr Swinney.

    He says it would depend on where the deprivation was judged to exist - the location of the school or residency of pupils.

    The Green MSP asks if research commissioned by the Scottish government will look at this further.

    The research is looking at breadth of offer but not just at qualifications specifically, the education secretary explains.

    The session draws to a close.

  14. Are Education Scotland responsible if there is evidence of inequality?published at 11:22 British Summer Time 29 May 2019

    MSP Ross Greer

    Green MSP Ross Greer asks if there was evidence of inequality in the system nationally, would the responsibility lie with Education Scotland?

    Mr Swinney says any evidence would emerge in discussions around the strength and efficacy of individual schools, and that scrutiny comes at school level, local authority level, and through work shared through Education Scotland at delivering best practice.

    If Education Scotland detects a pattern emerging out of inspections then it is an issue they would raise with me, the education secretary confirms.

  15. Background: Lack of subject choice for some exam pupilspublished at 11:19 British Summer Time 29 May 2019

    Jamie McIvor
    BBC Scotland education correspondent

    Pupils at whiteboardImage source, Getty Images

    Some youngsters get the chance to do just six qualifications in S4 while others do more.

    The situation varies from school to school and from council to council.

    But does the number of qualifications a youngster obtains in S4 really matter?

    In the old days, it was simple.

    At the overwhelming majority of state and private schools, an academically able student would sit eight O Grades in S4 then study for four or five Highers in S5.

    Fast forward 30 or 40 years and it's all very different.

    The emphasis in schools now is on what qualifications someone has by the time they leave school - not what they have by the end of a particular year.

    Read more here.

  16. Education models must not be imposed on schools - Swinneypublished at 11:13 British Summer Time 29 May 2019

    education secretary

    Tory MSP Oliver Mundell asks about the 18-subject model in South Ayrshire and whether it is right for a local authority to tell all schools about what they should offer.

    I understand the council engaged with schools on the matter leading to this decision, the education secretary says.

    Asked whether this approach should be rolled out by more councils, Mr Swinney says schools must be satisfied with any model deployed because they are the educators.

    He argues it would not have been appropriate if the model was imposed on schools.

  17. Postpublished at 11:10 British Summer Time 29 May 2019

    Quote Message

    Multi-level teaching has been part of Scottish education. I will look carefully at the issues involved in it, but I've not seen yet any evidence of educational disadvantage."

    John Swinney, Education Secretary

  18. Swinney: 'Nothing inherently damaging about multi-level teaching'published at 11:05 British Summer Time 29 May 2019

    Ms Lamont asks about an "explosion" of multi-level teaching and whether Mr Swinney believes it is acceptable for it to become the norm.

    The education secretary says he has not seen any data that would allow him to make a judgement and he doesn't think that data exists.

    I have not seen any educational argument that says there is something inherently damaging about multi-level teaching, which has been part of the Scottish system for a long time, Mr Swinney adds.

    Ms Lamont accepts it has been used in the past but warns against it becoming the norm, and calls for research into whether it does impact performance.

    The education secretary agrees to consider the matter further once the education committee has published its conclusions.

  19. Is there enough opportunity for those who leave school at S4?published at 11:00 British Summer Time 29 May 2019

    Labour MSP Johann Lamont

    Labour MSP Johann Lamont highlights some young people will leave school after their fourth year.

    So how do we ensure they leave school with enough qualifications, she asks.

    Mr Swinney says young people should have access to enough opportunities at S4 to give them a range of qualifications.

    Ms Lamont seeks a commitment that the education secretary will look at opportunities for the most disadvantaged young people, including care leavers, who tend to leave school earlier than their peers.

  20. Background: Does the exam system restrict choice?published at 10:56 British Summer Time 29 May 2019

    Jamie McIvor
    BBC Scotland education correspondent

    TestImage source, Getty Images

    It is no surprise that different schools use the new qualifications in different ways.

    That was an intentional part of the new qualifications system, and individual schools and councils took decisions on what they believed was right for their local circumstances.

    The most popular curricular model allows students to obtain up to six qualifications in S4.

    However, a significant number of schools offer seven - while smaller numbers offer five, eight or even routinely avoid presenting candidates for qualifications in S4.

    Some have warned that some subjects - including art and modern languages - are being squeezed out in S4 so choice is being restricted.

    It is argued that time constraints led to some schools offering six qualifications in S4 - rather than a belief that this was the best possible model.