Summary

  • Nicola Sturgeon faces questions from opposition party leaders during FMQs

  • Carlaw and the FM clash over indyref2 and second Brexit referendum

  • Sturgeon defends public service record as Leonard cites mental health issues among education staff

  • Agreement from FM in condemning Serco's lock-change eviction policy raised by Harvie

  • Rennie asks about mental health of police and Sturgeon insists officers are supported

  1. Clash over investment and support for public servicespublished at 12:15 Greenwich Mean Time 14 November 2019

    Mr Leonard says he does not want to see the future in the hands of the Tories, rather in the hands of a Labour government.

    He pivots to the "growing crisis of mental health" in NHS workers and social workers.

    The Scottish Labour leader argues the first minister has failed to deliver the investment required and he says the first minister has threatened to bring down a Labour government.

    Ms Sturgeon accuses Mr Leonard of taking his party back to 1979.

    She accuses him of preferring a Tory government at Westminster to self-government for Scotland.

    The first minister insists her government is supporting public services right across the country instead of the "empty rhetoric" from Labour.

    Richard Leonard
  2. Sturgeon points to increase in social worker and teacher numberspublished at 12:12 Greenwich Mean Time 14 November 2019

    Mr Leonard says there are 3,000 fewer teachers now than when the SNP took office.

    He pivots to a new Unison Scotland report indicating 90% of staff are considering walking out of their jobs in social work.

    He cities pressures on staff to hit savings targets and extra hours without pay.

    Ms Sturgeon says there are more teachers now than when she became first minister.

    We have also seen a 5.4% increase in the number of practicising social workers, she adds.

    Nicola Sturgeon
  3. Leonard cites teachers' mental health issuespublished at 12:09 Greenwich Mean Time 14 November 2019

    Richard LeonardImage source, bbc

    Scottish Labour leader Richard Leonard says new figures from the charity Education Support , externalshow more than a third of those working in education have experienced mental health issues.

    The health of our teachers is being harmed as are the life chances of our children, adds Mr Leonard.

    We value our teachers and education funding is rising in Scotland Ms Sturgeon replies, citing the recent pay deal.

    The first minister adds all of the evidence is that attainment is rising.

  4. Sturgeon: I believe Scotland will back independencepublished at 12:07 Greenwich Mean Time 14 November 2019

    Nicola Sturgeon

    The Tory interim leader suggests the SNP will always come up with ideas for a "grievance rematch", leading to indyref3 and indyref4.

    The Tories will never stand up for Scotland as demonstrated by them ignoring Scotland's vote to remain in the EU, replies the first minister.

    I believe Scotland will back independence in indyref2 she adds.

  5. Postpublished at 12:06 Greenwich Mean Time 14 November 2019

    This Twitter post cannot be displayed in your browser. Please enable Javascript or try a different browser.View original content on Twitter
    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    Skip twitter post

    Allow Twitter content?

    This article contains content provided by Twitter. We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as they may be using cookies and other technologies. You may want to read Twitter’s cookie policy, external and privacy policy, external before accepting. To view this content choose ‘accept and continue’.

    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    End of twitter post
  6. Does the FM want a 'grand alliance' after the election?published at 12:05 Greenwich Mean Time 14 November 2019

    Mr Carlaw says the priority for the first minister used to be education, now its independence.

    The Scottish Conservative interim leader asks how Ms Sturgeon can form a "grand alliance" with the people she wants to walk out on.

    The first minister says her priority to give the Scottish people the choice to choose independence.

    Ms Sturgeon says yes she would like to form an alliance to lock the Tories out of Westminster.

  7. FM reiterates call for 2020 indyref2published at 12:04 Greenwich Mean Time 14 November 2019

    Mr Carlaw says the first minister's track record shows she "always loses" referendums.

    When will the referendums she is seeking happen, will they be on the same day or will one come first, he asks.

    My priority is to give the people of Scotland the opportunity to choose independence next year, replies the first minister.

    Ms Sturgeon says in the 2016 EU referendum she campaigned for Remain and Scotland voted to remain in the EU.

    Why is Jackson Carlaw so willing to ignore this, she asks.

    Nicola Sturgeon
  8. Carlaw raises indyref2 and a second EU referendumpublished at 12:03 Greenwich Mean Time 14 November 2019

    Jackson Carlaw

    Scottish Conservative interim leader Jackson Carlaw begins saying the first minister has confirmed she wants two referendums next year.

    Given she has ignored the results of the last two how can we trust the first minister to behave differently this time, he asks.

    "Well I'm rumbled, because I want the people to escape a Tory Brexit," hits back Nicola Sturgeon.

  9. First minister's questions is next.....published at 11:57 Greenwich Mean Time 14 November 2019

    First minister's questionsImage source, bbc/PA
  10. Will the election come up at FMQs?published at 11:54 Greenwich Mean Time 14 November 2019

    Presiding Officer Ken MacintoshImage source, bbc
    Image caption,

    Presiding Officer Ken Macintosh

    As we approach first minister's questions Presiding Officer Ken Macintosh beseeches MSPs to "try not to keep direct political election campaiging in their question or answer."

    We shall see how successful this admonishment is shortly.

  11. Coming up....first minister's questionspublished at 10:13 Greenwich Mean Time 14 November 2019

    FMQsImage source, bbc
    Image caption,

    We'll bring you extensive coverage of first minister's questions from noon

    Here's what's coming up in the chamber this afternoon:

    11:40am: General Questions

    12:00pm: First Minister's Questions

    12:45pm: Members' Business: Ruth Maguire: Day of the Imprisoned Writer

    What impact will US tariffs have on Scotch whisky?Image source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    What impact will US tariffs have on Scotch whisky?

    2:30pm: Portfolio Questions: Government Business and Constitutional Relations

    2:50-5:00pm: Scottish government debate: Implications of the Imposition of US Tariffs on Scottish Products

  12. Tackling locum spend key part of Highland saving planspublished at 10:12 Greenwich Mean Time 14 November 2019

    Mr Sarwar highlights NHS Highland locum fees have risen to £15.6m and wonders about the pay of individual locums.

    Joanne Brown says reducing locum spend is a key part of their savings plans, with controls being put in place currently.

    She says she will get the information about individuals' pay from the health board for the committee.

    The public part of this meeting draws to a close and the committee moves into private session.

  13. How seriously are health boards carrying out their own reviews?published at 10:10 Greenwich Mean Time 14 November 2019

    Labour MSP Anas Sarwar asks if the auditor general is picking up a theme of workforce issues across the NHS.

    Yes, replies Ms Gardner, who highlights the pressure on staff in the NHS.

    All health boards have been asked to address the general issues raised by the Sturrock review into NHS Highland.

    Mr Sarwar asks how seriously all health boards are about carrying out their own reviews.

    Labour MSP Anas SarwarImage source, bbc
    Image caption,

    Labour MSP Anas Sarwar

    The auditor general says she wouldn't say boards are not taking the reviews seriously but they are facing real pressures and tensions.

    Should a Scotland wide review be carried out, taking health boards out of the equation, asks Mr Sarwar, to which Ms Gardner replies it is too soon to say.

    She warns against immediately imposing things on health boars from the outside.

  14. Background: Charity criticised over NHS Tayside payoutspublished at 09:57 Greenwich Mean Time 14 November 2019

    HospitalImage source, SPL

    In February, BBC Scotland reported regulators had criticised an NHS charity after it used its funds to help plug a deficit at NHS Tayside.

    It came after the Tayside Health Fund used £3.6m to help pay for new projects, including an IT system in 2014.

    The charity temporarily changed its procedures to allow retrospective funding applications for the projects.

    The Scottish Charity Regulator (OSCR) said there was "mismanagement" over the decision, but no rules were broken.

    Read more.

  15. NHS Highland audit committee has not held executives to accountpublished at 09:54 Greenwich Mean Time 14 November 2019

    Joanne Brown

    Tory MSP Bill Bowman notes the auditor general's report found the audit committee in NHS Highland was not as effective as it should be.

    Joanne Brown explains there are a number of outstanding internal audit recommendations, and this list has continued to grow with many going past their due date.

    The audit committee has been slow to hold the executive team to account on delivery, but the chief executive has made a committed to reduce the list as far as practicable, which will be looked at in 2019-20 audit she explains.

  16. Still significant vacancies at NHS Taysidepublished at 09:51 Greenwich Mean Time 14 November 2019

    Ms Gardner says both boards are now at level four in terms of the intervention framework.

    Leigh Johnson says there has been encouraging progress at NHS Tayside.

    Fiona Mitchell-Knight says since the report was written a permanent chair has been appointed and there has been progress, but there are still significant vacancies.

  17. What causes overspend on prescriptions?published at 09:43 Greenwich Mean Time 14 November 2019

    auditor general

    SNP MSP Willie Coffey turns the discussion to overspends on prescriptions, noting this has been an issue for several years for many health boards.

    The auditor general says drug cost inflation tends to be higher than general inflation due to things like patents.

    We've seen some real improvements in bringing costs down as well, she says, pointing to GPs prescribing generic drugs.

    The NHS does a lot of work nationwide to put procurement contracts in place so the real differences between health boards is to do with doctors having discretion over what is used, Ms Gardner tells the committee.

    She says that prescribing has historically been more expensive in NHS Tayside than the rest of Scotland due to more items being prescribed and more expensive items being chosen.

  18. Agreement both boards 'not doing badly' against national standardspublished at 09:35 Greenwich Mean Time 14 November 2019

    operationImage source, MEGAFLOPP/THINKSTOCK

    Mr Neil says one of the common themes between the two reports is that their performance is not that bad, although NHS Highland has performed badly in terms of the national waiting time guarantee.

    The former health secretary says in other areas both boards are performing better than the average.

    He argues a lot of the problems are not in the day-to-day delivery of healthcare, but are in non-frontline management.

    Ms Gardner agrees the two boards are not doing badly at all against the national standards.

    The auditor general says there has been concerns across the NHS with the focus being on financial performance, not clinical delivery.