Summary

  • In Cardiff, farmers took to main roads and outside the Senedd protesting against environmental subsidy plans

  • Police warned motorists to expect delays around the Welsh capital and gave farmers demonstrating in their tractors a strict route to follow

  • Farmers are objecting to proposals which would require 10% of their land to be used for trees and another 10% for wildlife habitat

  • Unions brand the plans "unworkable" but the government argues that the scheme, which is under consultation, is designed to support all farmers

  • Today's action is the latest in a series of protests that have been held across Wales in recent weeks

  • Similar demonstrations have taken place in European countries, including France, Belgium and Germany

  1. That's all for todaypublished at 15:39 Greenwich Mean Time 28 February

    That brings an end to today's live coverage of the farmers' protest in Cardiff - thanks for sticking with us this afternoon.

    Let's have a recap on what's happened:

    • Thousands of farmers held a protest in front of the Senedd building in Cardiff Bay
    • Farmers are objecting to proposals which would require 10% of their land to be used for trees and another 10% for wildlife habitat
    • Speakers, including former international rugby union referee Nigel Owens, took to the steps of the Senedd to voice their support for the farmers
    • The debate then moved into the Senedd chamber where Rural Affair Questions were taking place
    • The Welsh government argues that the scheme, which is under consultation, is designed to support all farmers and nothing is set in stone yet

    For the latest on the protest, click here.

  2. In pictures: Protesters at the Seneddpublished at 15:30 Greenwich Mean Time 28 February

    We've just had some more pictures come in of the protest outside Wales' parliament.

    Farmers gathered in Cardiff for a protest against the Welsh government's environmental subsidy plans.

    People of all ages have come together to demonstrate outside the Senedd.

    A protester holds a placard reading "What's my future in farming?" outside the Senedd on February 28, 2024 in Cardiff, WalesImage source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    Farmers in Wales say they are concerned about their rural way of life

    Tractors with signs reading "No Farmers No Food!" arrive at a holding area at the Queens Gate traffic Roundabout on February 28, 2024 in Cardiff, WalesImage source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    The protesting farmers drove their tractors to Cardiff to protest outside Wales' parliament

    A child is pulled along on a toy tractor during protests outside the Senedd on February 28, 2024 in Cardiff, WalesImage source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    A much smaller tractor has also arrived...

    Protesters holding placards gather outside the Senedd on February 28, 2024 in Cardiff, WalesImage source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    Young protestors have also been seen at the demonstration

  3. How will these proposals tackle climate change?published at 15:21 Greenwich Mean Time 28 February

    Esme Stallard
    Climate reporter, BBC News

    A bumblebee nectaring on pink cherry blossomImage source, National Trust Images/PA

    Farming is responsible for less than 2% of carbon dioxide emissions in the UK, but is a massive source of other greenhouse gas emissions responsible for climate change.

    In 2020 the government estimated, external farming produced 69% of total nitrous oxide emissions and 48% of all methane emissions.

    These gases are produced by livestock, from using farming machinery such as tractors and are released by the soil.

    The two key targets of this scheme are to plant more trees and increase the amount of natural habitat like hedgerows.

    Planting trees will help to absorb carbon dioxide while restoring the environment can improve the health of soils which helps them to store more greenhouse gas emissions.

    Improving the soil quality not only helps to tackle climate change but can reduce the risk of flooding and increase crop yields.

  4. Debate moves into the Seneddpublished at 15:11 Greenwich Mean Time 28 February

    Gareth Lewis
    BBC Wales political editor

    After the loud voice of protest outside, it is now the loud voice of debate in the Senedd.

    Conservative Samuel Kurtz accuses the Welsh government of being “cynical” in sending invites out last night to potential members of a TB advisory group and says that it takes a protest and strength of feeling to get things done.

    His Plaid Cymru counterpart Llyr Gruffydd says he can’t see the new subsidy scheme being ready as scheduled by 2025 and urges for a new date of 2026.

    Rural Affairs Minister Lesley Griffiths repeats the Welsh government line that nothing is set in stone, that the consultation is still running and on the thorny issue of tree planting, that she doesn’t expect to change everyone’s mind but "does expect to see solutions".

  5. 'I'm proud to be Welsh today'published at 15:03 Greenwich Mean Time 28 February

    Nelli Bird
    Reporting from Cardiff Bay

    Rhian Lewis from Carmarthen is giving her nine-month-old son Guto an on-the-go lunch during the protest.

    The mum-of-two says: "I just think it's important to stand up here today and show that farmers can't be pushed over.

    "It's been brilliant. I'm proud to be Welsh today, it's an amazing turnout."

    Media caption,

    Mum-of-two joins protesting farmers in Cardiff Bay

  6. What else is angering Welsh farmers?published at 14:50 Greenwich Mean Time 28 February

    Steffan Messenger
    BBC Wales environment correspondent

    Although a plan for all farms in Wales to ensure 10% tree coverage in exchange for future funding is getting lots of headlines, there's a combination of things angering farmers.

    On top of the Welsh government's Sustainable Farming Scheme, there's also a row about temporary environmental payments in 2024.

    The amount offered financially under the Habitat Wales Scheme - to reward farmers for helping wildlife - is 45% lower than under the old system, the Glastir scheme.

    Another controversy is a change in more widespread, stricter rules on the storage and spreading of man-made fertilizer and animal manure in order to protect water quality in rivers.

    Last, but not least, is the effort to tackle tuberculosis in cattle. Some farmers think this is the most important reason for dissatisfaction.

    Most farmers insist a badger cull program is needed but that's something the Welsh government refuses to introduce.

    Rising costs of farming. Increased average farming costs in Wales from 2021-22 to 2022-23 [ 15% Total farm business costs ] [ 53% Fertilisers  ],[ 41% Machinery fuels  ],[ 34% Share of interest payments  ],[ 25% Feed and fodder  ],[ 24% Crop protection  ], Source: Source: Annual Farm Business Survey/Stats Wales, 2024, Image: Dairy farm
  7. Watch: Sunak criticises 'shocking' subsidy planspublished at 14:39 Greenwich Mean Time 28 February

    Farmers have held numerous protests against the Welsh government's plans across the county already - including at the Welsh Conservative conference.

    UK Prime Minister Rishi Sunak, who does not support the Welsh Labour government's plans, told campaigners in Llandudno last week: "We're going to do everything we can because we've got your back".

    He said the plans "by their own assessment would cost thousands of jobs, reduce our food security and damage farm income - and that's why those plans have rightly been described as damaging and shocking".

    Watch some of Sunak's remarks below:

    Media caption,

    Prime Minister Rishi Sunak criticises Welsh government farming plans

  8. Welsh farmers join Europe-wide protestspublished at 14:18 Greenwich Mean Time 28 February

    French farmers burn straw in ParisImage source, EPA-EFE/REX/Shutterstock
    Image caption,

    French farmers have been protesting in France for months burning and destroying crops and dumping slurry

    Farmers gathering today in Cardiff are joining thousands across Europe who have been protesting in recent months over the state of the sector.

    French farmers descended on Paris at the start of the year, Spanish farmers blocked roads in February and yesterday up to 10,000 Polish farmers took to the streets of Warsaw. Read more on all that here.

    Although today's protest is in response to the Welsh government's new subsidy scheme, there are common concerns among all these groups.

    They say that high inflation is driving up fuel costs, they are being undercut by foreign imports and now have stricter regulation to adhere to - all of which adds up to tighter margins.

  9. Watch: Protesters turn main road into car park for tractorspublished at 14:06 Greenwich Mean Time 28 February

    Protesting farmers have turned a normally busy main road in Cardiff into a car park, as they demonstrate against Welsh government environmental subsidy plans.

    Take a look:

    Media caption,

    Protesters turn main road into tractor car park

  10. 'Very serious for the future'published at 14:04 Greenwich Mean Time 28 February

    Nelli Bird
    Reporting from Cardiff Bay

    I've been speaking to protesters who tell me that they decided to join today's demonstration because they want the Welsh government to listen to them.

    One of them is Tom Huntley, a farmer from Pontypridd, who says there is a real strength of feeling in the crowd.

    "We've all come down today because the ministers are just not listening. It could be very serious for the future," he says.

    Tom Huntley
  11. Wellies lined up to symbolise expected job lossespublished at 13:52 Greenwich Mean Time 28 February

    Protesters have lined up wellies on the steps of the Welsh Parliament as a symbol of future job losses, which could happen as a result of these new subsidy plans.

    The government's own assessment of the scheme, external estimates that, if introduced, it could lead to an 11% reduction in farm labour.

    NFU Cymru says this could translate to more than 5,500 jobs being lost.

    But the assessment does say workers may still be needed for other non-farm related work, such as management of woodland.

    Different size wellies are lined up on the steps outside the Senedd
  12. Ex-rugby ref Nigel Owens takes to the stagepublished at 13:42 Greenwich Mean Time 28 February

    One of the speakers at the steps of the Senedd is no stranger to a crowd.

    Nigel Owens, former international rugby union referee, calls it an honour to speak and support the farmers.

    "In 2015, I was very privileged to referee the World Cup final in Twickenham - the proudest moment of my career.

    "But today I'm even prouder to come and speak in front of good, decent people."

    Nigel OwensImage source, PA Media
  13. 'Don't awaken the sleeping Welsh dragon'published at 13:28 Greenwich Mean Time 28 February

    Steffan Messenger
    Reporting from Cardiff Bay

    Speeches have started in front of a crowd of about 2,500 people

    Farmers' Union of Wales president Ian Rickman says he and others have been warning the Welsh government for months "not to awaken the sleeping Welsh dragon".

    "The dragon is now well and truly awake."

    Abi Reader, NFU Cymru deputy president says it is "absolutely amazing to stand here and look at all of you".

    "We are all completely united. People have come from the hills and mountains, from the valleys and coastal areas."

    She brands the subsidy plans "crazy" and urges the crowd to "remember we are an ambitious industry" and one that is prepared to help meet net zero targets and produce food.

    This was met by boos from some, but others rounded on those objecting, shouting at them to "stop it".

    Protesters in Cardiff BayImage source, PA Media
    Image caption,

    Farmers Union of Wales said he and others had been warning the Welsh government for months

  14. We want to work with sector and get this right - rural ministerpublished at 13:18 Greenwich Mean Time 28 February

    Lesley GriffithsImage source, Getty Images

    Lesley Griffiths, minister for rural affairs in Wales, says the targets included in the Welsh government plans follow UK-wide climate change guidance.

    She says she wants to "continue to work with the sector to make sure the sustainable farming scheme is absolutely right".

    "We need sustainable food production but we also need farmers to help us with the climate emergency,” she added.

    Speaking on BBC Radio Wales Breakfast, she says the proposals are not "set in stone", but the 10% target comes from "the advice and recommendations from the UK Climate Change Committee".

    "We know we need to have more carbon storage."

  15. Watch: Scene outside the Senedd as protest gets under waypublished at 13:11 Greenwich Mean Time 28 February

    BBC Wales reporter Nelli Bird is in Cardiff Bay, where about 2,500 people are at the Welsh Parliament building, known as the Senedd.

    They are objecting to proposals to change farm subsidies, which would require 10% of agricultural land to be used for trees and another 10% for wildlife habitat.

    You can see the latest scenes outside the Senedd by pressing play below:

    Media caption,

    Farming: Protesters gather outside Senedd in subsidies row

  16. In pictures: Protest numbers grow outside Welsh Parliamentpublished at 13:01 Greenwich Mean Time 28 February

    We've just got some pictures in of the protest outside Wales' parliament, the Senedd, which has just kicked off.

    Some farmers are getting very creative with their signs...

    Woman protesting outside Senedd with a sign that reads: "Drakeford doesn't give a duck"Image source, PA Media
    Women protests outside Senedd in cow costume with sign that reads: "We will not be mooooved".Image source, PA Media
    Farmers stand outside Senedd with sign that reads "Farms can't be green if we are in the red"Image source, PA Media
    Two male protestors hold up sign that reads "Elected to govern not dictate. Now listen to the people"Image source, PA Media
  17. Welsh government promises review of payments schemepublished at 12:44 Greenwich Mean Time 28 February

    So how has the Welsh government responded to the unrest from farmers?

    Well, last night, after extensive talks with the unions, it said it would introduce a number of measures into the Sustainable Farming Scheme to try and address the farming community's concerns.

    In a joint statement, the Minister for Rural Affairs Lesley Griffiths and First Minister Mark Drakeford said the environmental requirements of the scheme would be targeted "at improving the economic resilience of farms".

    "Ensuring woodland and habitat requirements do not make farms unviable," the statement said.

    It added other means of capturing carbon, aside from planting trees, would be looked at.

    In England, farmers can receive subsidies for planting hedgerows and improving soil health which all help to absorb carbon, a warming greenhouse gas.

  18. Ministers not listening, says ex-deputy president of unionpublished at 12:38 Greenwich Mean Time 28 February

    Aled Scourfield
    Reporting from Pembrokeshire

    Before the farmers boarded their coach this morning I managed to speak to Brian Thomas, the former deputy president of the Farmers' Union of Wales

    Brian has been a beef and sheep farmer in Llanfyrnach since he was 15.

    "We're going to Cardiff today for a simple reason - the Senedd doesn't listen. It doesn't listen to the unions.

    "I've been involved with the unions and I can see that they have their own agenda and they just won't budge on that.

    "It was nice to hear last night that [the government] are budging slightly - but there's a very long way to go, especially on TB."

    Brian Thomas
  19. Crowds starting to gather in Cardiff Baypublished at 12:28 Greenwich Mean Time 28 February

    Joe Langstaffe
    At the Senedd in Cardiff Bay

    Protesters walking to the Senedd

    Numbers are slowly building outside the Welsh Parliament building, also known as the Senedd, in Cardiff Bay.

    As many as 10,000 people are expected to arrive over the next couple of hours and while the atmosphere is relaxed and jovial, the anger towards the Welsh government is nonetheless clear.

    Banners reading "enough is enough" and "no farmers, no food" are everywhere. Others are aimed more explicitly at Welsh Labour and Drakeford himself.

    The feeling from farmers here is there is a disconnect between their livelihoods and the decisions being made in Cardiff Bay.

    A long line of tractors in Cardiff for the protestImage source, Jacob Anthony
  20. 'This is a perfect storm. Everything is against us'published at 12:18 Greenwich Mean Time 28 February

    Aled Scourfield
    Reporting from Pembrokeshire

    Angela Windsor
    Image caption,

    Angela Windsor, a farmer from Moylegrove, described the scheme as a "perfect storm"

    This morning I spoke to farmers travelling from Crymych, a tiny village in north-east Pembrokeshire, to Cardiff for the protest about why they've decided to protest today.

    Angela Windsor, a farmer from Moylegrove, tells me: "We're not happy about this sustainable farming scheme proposed by the Welsh Government. It doesn't include farming at all.

    "For some people who haven't got any trees or habitat - they're going to lose 20% of their land."

    She's also angry about the proposed extension of the nitrate vulnerable zone regime - which controls how farmers spread slurry and fertiliser to protect rivers.

    "It will mean either reducing [our] cows, which is a loss of profit and personal pride, and also - who's going to afford a new slurry tank?

    "This is a perfect storm. Everything is against us," she adds.

    Another protester, John, tells me that he is proud of farmers coming together: "All of us on this bus will have very different reasons for why we are going to what will be a historical symbol of unity in the name of the Senedd (Wales' parliament).

    "A protest of this magnitude hasn't been seen since 1999. This tells you very clearly of the anxiety and concern that surrounds the industry and the rural way of life."