Summary

  • Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh says three of his sons have been killed in an Israeli air strike in Gaza

  • Haniyeh, who lives in Qatar, tells Al Jazeera that several of his grandchildren were also killed in the attack

  • It follows reports in a Hamas-affiliated news agency in Gaza that Hazem, Amir, and Muhammad Ismail Haniyeh died in a strike in Beach refugee camp

  • The IDF has confirmed its aircraft has "eliminated" the three brothers, describing them as "Hamas military operatives"

  • Haniyeh says the deaths will not affect the militant group's demands in ongoing ceasefire negotiations

  • The news comes as Palestinians in Gaza are marking Eid-al-Fitr, the end of Ramadan, amid the continuing conflict

  1. Thank you for joining our coveragepublished at 19:43 British Summer Time 10 April

    The car in which three sons of Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh were reportedly killed in an Israeli air strike is pictured in al-Shati camp, west of Gaza CityImage source, AFP via Getty Images
    Image caption,

    The car in which three sons of Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh were reportedly killed in an Israeli air strike is pictured in al-Shati camp, west of Gaza City

    We’re now ending today's live coverage on the Israel-Gaza war.

    Thank you for staying with us today for the latest developments in the region and the ways Palestinians celebrated Eid despite the war.

    Here is a look at the most recent developments:

    • The IDF has confirmed the killing of three sons of Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh in an air strike in the central Gaza Strip
    • The force named the three individuals as Amir, Mohammad and Hazem Haniyeh. The IDF said they were “Hamas military wing operatives”
    • It followed Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh saying three of his sons and several of his grandchildren were killed in an Israeli air strike
    • Haniyeh said in an interview with Al Jazeera that his sons' deaths would not affect the ceasefire negotiations with Israel
    • US President Joe Biden has criticised Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's handling of the war in Gaza, saying "I think what he's doing is a mistake. I don't agree with his approach"
    • It comes as people across Gaza marked Eid al-Fitr, with Palestinians filmed praying on the ruins of a mosque destroyed in an air strike

    Read more on how Palestinians are marking Eid here, and for the latest on the killing of Haniyeh's sons click here.

  2. Killing Haniyeh's family may hamper ceasefire effortspublished at 19:01 British Summer Time 10 April

    Jeremy Bowen
    International Editor in Jerusalem

    Ismail Haniyeh is the head of the political apparatus of Hamas outside Gaza and the Palestinian territories. Israel makes no distinction between the different branches of Hamas – military and political – and says they are all terrorists.

    After he was told that his three sons and their children were targeted and killed, Haniyeh said that the lives of his children are no more valuable than those of any other Gazans. And that it wouldn’t affect Hamas’ position in the ceasefire talks in which he is a leading negotiator.

    The Americans want Hamas to soften their position, so perhaps killing Haniyeh’s children may not be the best way of achieving that.

    There are critics of Prime Minister Netanyahu in Israel who claim that he wants to prolong the war and he doesn’t want to do a ceasefire deal. And at the same time, Netanyahu is under immense amounts of pressure from the US to reach a compromise and allow an exchange of Palestinian prisoners in return for the hostages in Gaza.

    It’s now emerged that the Israel Defense Forces deliberated targeted the Haniyeh family, claiming that they were “on the way to carry out an act of terrorism.”

    So it might be seen by his critics as further proof that Netanyahu and the Israeli government are not committed to a deal.

  3. BBC Verify

    This isn’t the first time Haniyeh’s family has been targetedpublished at 18:46 British Summer Time 10 April

    In November, the Israeli army said that its fighter jets had struck the residence of Hamas’ senior leader, Ismail Haniyeh, which they claimed at the time was being used as “terrorist infrastructure”.

    In a message posted on Telegram at the time, it added that the residence had often served as a meeting point for senior leaders of Hamas. The BBC has not independently verified these claims.

    In October, 14 members of Haniyeh’s family were reportedly killed in an Israeli air strike on a family home in Sheikh Radwan.

    In an interview with Al Jazeera Arabic on Wednesday, Haniyeh said 60 members of his extended family had been killed in Israeli strikes.

  4. IDF confirms killing of Hamas leader's three sonspublished at 18:26 British Summer Time 10 April
    Breaking

    The Israel Defense Forces (IDF) has confirmed that its aircraft killed three sons of Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh, describing them as "Hamas military operatives".

    The IDF issued a statement saying:

    "The IDF and ISA [the Israeli Security Agency] eliminated three Hamas military wing operatives in the central Gaza Strip Earlier today [Wednesday], directed by IDF and ISA intelligence, IAF aircraft struck three Hamas military operatives that conducted terrorist activity in the central Gaza Strip.

    "The three operatives that were struck are Amir Haniyeh, a cell commander in the Hamas military wing, Mohammad Haniyeh, a military operative in the Hamas terrorist organization, and Hazem Haniyeh, also a military operative in the Hamas terror organization.

    "The IDF confirms that the three operatives are the sons of Ismail Haniyeh, chairman of Hamas's political bureau."

  5. Eyewitnesses say a car carrying Haniyeh's sons was hit by strikepublished at 18:16 British Summer Time 10 April

    Sebastian Usher
    Jerusalem

    As we've been reporting, the political leader of Hamas, Ismail Haniyeh, says three of his sons and several of his grandchildren have been killed in an Israeli strike in Gaza.

    Eyewitnesses say that a car carrying three of Ismail Haniyeh's sons and several of his grandchildren was hit in Al-Shati camp on the beach to the west of Gaza City.

    They say the members of Haniyeh's family were on their way to visit a family member to celebrate the first day of the Muslim holiday, Eid.

    Haniyeh received the news in the Qatari capital, Doha, where he lives - as he was visiting Gazans receiving medical treatment.

    His response was to thank God for the honour bestowed on him by what he called the martyrdom of his sons.

    He also accused Israel of killing them in order to try to shift Hamas' position in the current ceasefire talks. He said that would not happen.

  6. I do not know how to be happy, says a child from Gazapublished at 17:51 British Summer Time 10 April

    Sara El Shaer is 10 years old and lives in Gaza
    Image caption,

    Sara El Shaer is 10 years old and lives in Gaza

    Sara El Shaer, another 10 year-old girl from Gaza, tells BBC Arabic's Gaza Lifeline programme that despite the collapse of their house and the loss of their things "due to the fierce bombing of war, we will celebrate and rejoice in Eid".

    But not all the children are celebrating, some are reluctant this year. Like Thuria El-Masry.

    "I am seven years old, during Eid I want to celebrate it, but because of the violent bombing, I do not know how to be happy.

    "I want to be happy on Eid night as I used to be before, and to take the Eid gifts and play with other children", Thuria says.

    Seven-year-old Thuria El-Masry lives in Gaza
    Image caption,

    Seven-year-old Thuria El-Masry lives in Gaza

  7. 'There is no Eid' - sombre mood in East Jerusalem communitiespublished at 17:35 British Summer Time 10 April

    Reha Kansara
    Global religion reporter

    Ilham's family in East Jerusalem as they break their fast
    Image caption,

    Ilham's family in East Jerusalem as they break their fast

    The mood in occupied East Jerusalem is sombre. Members of one Palestinian community told me, “there is no Eid”.

    Ilham, 35, lives a stone’s throw away from al-Aqsa mosque – the third holiest site in Islam, where it is believed Prophet Mohammed ascended to heaven. It is also sacred in Judaism and known as Temple Mount.

    "It's a spiritual gift," Ilham says. "Everyone envies me for it. They say to me, 'You're so lucky!'"

    The social worker is one of about 450 Afro-Palestinians, descendants of pilgrims from Chad, Nigeria, Senegal, and Sudan, who live in an enclave in part of the old city's Muslim quarter, that were once prisons used by the Ottomans before the British took control over Jerusalem in 1917.

    But Ilham tells me that there is no happiness this year. "We haven't decorated our homes; we have no visitors. Only the spiritual and ritualistic elements of Ramadan remain."

    Members of the Afro-Palestinian community and the wider Palestinian community in Jerusalem say prayer in the past month has become a form of resistance and Eid is only being celebrated in name.

  8. Sons' killings won't affect ceasefire talks - Haniyehpublished at 17:23 British Summer Time 10 April

    More now on reports that three sons and at least two grandchildren of Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh have been killed in an air strike.

    Haniyeh told Al Jazeera that the deaths will not affect the group's demands in ceasefire talks with Israel, which have failed to yield an agreement despite growing international pressure.

    "Our demands are clear and specific and we will not make concessions on them. The enemy will be delusional if it thinks that targeting my sons, at the climax of the negotiations and before the movement sends its response, will push Hamas to change its position," Haniyeh told Al Jazeera.

    "The blood of my sons is not dearer than the blood of our people," he added.

    Hamas has, in public at least, stuck with its initial demands of a permanent ceasefire, the complete withdrawal of Israeli troops and the return of displaced Palestinians to northern parts of the territory without restrictions.

    Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu meanwhile insists that Israel will continue fighting until Hamas is destroyed and hostages are free.

    Read more on truce talks - Can US pressure deliver Israel-Hamas truce in Gaza?

  9. Despite the 'blood, death and shelling' Palestinians want to rejoice todaypublished at 17:16 British Summer Time 10 April

    A small Palestianian child standing amidst the ruins of a mosque in Rafah, Gaza whilst muslims pray on the ground next to and in front of them.Image source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    Muslims pray amidst the rubble in Rafah during Eid al-Fitr.

    Eid celebrations marking the end of the holy month of Ramadan are taking place in Gaza and the West Bank. Palestinians say today's Eid is markedly different from previous years, amid Israel's ongoing war.

    Father-of-four Ahmed Qishta, 33, tells AFP new agency that there has never been "such an Eid - all sadness, fear, destruction and a grinding war".

    Abir Sakik, 40, who had to flee her family's home in Gaza City and is now living in a tent in Rafah, says Gazans "want to rejoice despite all the blood, death and shelling".

    "We are tired and weary, enough, enough of war and destruction."

    Tens of thousands of Palestinians are also praying at the Al-Aqsa Mosque in Jerusalem, Islam's third holiest site.

    Nurse Rawan Abd, 32, from Israeli-annexed East Jerusalem tells AFP it is "the saddest Eid ever, at the mosque you could see the sadness on people's faces."

  10. The UN is negotiating with Israel for more aid to enter Gazapublished at 17:01 British Summer Time 10 April

    People unload medical aid from a truck, near Kamal Adwan Hospital in the northern Gaza StripImage source, Reuters
    Image caption,

    People unload medical aid from a truck, near Kamal Adwan Hospital in the northern Gaza Strip

    We're reporting today that with the threat of famine looming in Gaza, few Muslims are able to hold a traditionally opulent Eid.

    Andrea De Domenico, head of the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) tells the BBC that the lack of "abundance of food and festive ornaments" means today is "not an Eid like others".

    He says UN organisations are negotiating with Israel to get more aid into Gaza, and that many challenges remain, even for the trucks that do get into the enclave.

    "We have done a calculation, from 1 April to 9 April, collectively 14 convoys that have been going to the north have been waiting 29 hours to get the green light to get through the checkpoint.

    "There are so many challenges that are still there, are still unresolved and those depend, and are under the control of the Israel military, and so we are really engaging with them daily to try to figure out solutions and improve the situation," De Domenico says.

  11. Haniyeh got news of his sons' deaths as he visited wounded Palestinianspublished at 16:47 British Summer Time 10 April

    Sebastian Usher
    BBC Arab Affairs Editor

    Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh received the news of his sons' and grandchildren's deaths as he was visiting wounded Palestinians who had been taken to the Qatari capital Doha for treatment.

    He said he thanked God for what he called the "honour bestowed on me with the martyrdom of my children and grandchildren".

    He also said that the incident would not affect the demands of Hamas in the current ceasefire talks.

    The Israeli army has so far not commented.

  12. Who is Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh?published at 16:37 British Summer Time 10 April

    haniyeh in Tehran in MarchImage source, Reuters

    We've just reported that Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh says three of his sons have been killed in an air strike. Here's some background on Haniyeh, the man widely considered Hamas's overall leader.

    A prominent member of the movement in the late 1980s, Israel imprisoned Haniyeh for three years in 1989 as it cracked down on the first Palestinian uprising.

    He was then exiled in 1992 to a no-man's-land between Israel and Lebanon, along with a number of Hamas leaders.

    After a year in exile, he returned to Gaza. In 1997 he was appointed head of the office of Hamas's spiritual leader, strengthening his position.

    Haniyeh was appointed Palestinian prime minister in 2006 by President Mahmoud Abbas after Hamas won the most seats in national elections, but was dismissed a year later after the group ousted Abbas' Fatah party from the Gaza Strip in a week of deadly violence.

    Haniyeh rejected his sacking as "unconstitutional", stressing that his government "would not abandon its national responsibilities towards the Palestinian people", and continued to rule in Gaza.

    He was elected head of Hamas's political bureau in 2017.

    In 2018, the US Department of State designated Haniyeh a terrorist. He has lived in Qatar for the past several years.

    Read more about the group's main leaders

  13. Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh says sons killed in air strikepublished at 16:21 British Summer Time 10 April
    Breaking

    Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh has confirmed to Arabic media that three of his sons have been killed in an air strike in Gaza.

    It follows reports in a Hamas-affiliated news agency in Gaza that three sons - Hazem, Amir, and Muhammad Ismail Haniyeh - and several of his grandchildren had died in the strike in Beach refugee camp in the west of Gaza City.

    The head of Hamas's political bureau, who is based in Qatar, told Al Jazeera in a phone interview that his sons had remained in Gaza during the war.

    Blurred images shown on the network showed bodies being covered as they lay on rubble.

    These are not the first members of Haniyeh's family to have been killed in the war - another son was reportedly killed in February, while his brother and nephew were killed in October, followed by a grandson in November.

  14. WATCH: Netanyahu is making 'a mistake' - Bidenpublished at 16:12 British Summer Time 10 April

    President Biden says Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is making "a mistake" with Israel's operation in Gaza.

    Speaking to the American Spanish-language network Univision, Biden says the Israeli air strikes which killed seven aid workers were "outrageous" and calls for a ceasefire.

    The hour-long interview was recorded last Wednesday before airing on Tuesday night. Watch the moment he talks about the mistake he believes Israel is making.

    Media caption,

    Watch: Biden says Netanyahu making 'a mistake' in Gaza during interview

  15. Palestinian mother tells of horror of losing her eight-year-old daughterpublished at 15:51 British Summer Time 10 April

    We've been hearing more testimonies from people in Gaza.

    Feda'a Murjan is living in Rafah, and while she tries to celebrate Eid, her thoughts are preoccupied with memories of Habiba, her eight-year-old daughter who was killed on 13 October.

    "As you know we all used to gather, wear the best clothes we had, [eat] the best chocolate and celebrate days of happiness and joy - but unfortunately this Eid is very different from any Eid before," Feda'a tells BBC News.

    "I'm a defeated, sad mother. No words can describe the terrible, horrible combination of very bad feelings".

    Feda'a says Habiba died after an airstrike hit her neighbour's house, "without any warning before", partly reducing her own home to rubble.

    "She was drawing a picture at the table," Feda'a says.

    She adds that people in Rafah are suffering from a lack of food, water and medical treatment, and have nowhere else to go.

    "It's not safe at all - they are bombing here, they are destroying the homes over the heads of the people here. There is no safe space in this little spot of the world".

  16. How many aid trucks are getting into Gaza?published at 15:30 British Summer Time 10 April

    Jake Horton
    BBC Verify

    A convoy of aid trucks drives into Gaza from the Rafah crossing on 9 AprilImage source, Reuters

    The Israel Defense Forces (IDF) has said 400 plus aid trucks have entered Gaza on each of the last two days. But the UN has said that figure was less than 250 on Monday.

    But why the different figures?

    The UN says Israel only counts what it screens and allows over the border, whereas the UN counts the trucks that arrive at their warehouses in Gaza.

    “It's complicated, and let me be upfront here, we will never get these truck numbers to match,” said the UN’s Jens Laerke.

    According to the UN, all trucks entering Gaza are checked by Israel. But screening requirements mean they are typically only half full, says the UN.

    After border checks, goods are moved onto a new set of vetted trucks to travel on into Gaza.

    These trucks are filled nearer to capacity. This means the number of trucks arriving at UN warehouses is often lower than the original number screened at the border.

    Israel denies hindering humanitarian relief into Gaza.

    We’ve asked the Israeli authorities whether they only screen half-full lorries and why, but they haven’t responded.

  17. 'Not a single aid truck' has passed through Erez crossing - charitypublished at 15:23 British Summer Time 10 April

    Map should points of crossing into Gaza

    No trucks have entered Gaza via the Erez crossing despite the recent announcement by Israel that it would be reopened, a charity says.

    "If the Erez crossing opens it would be step in the right direction, as it would make it possible for aid to come straight into the north," says Karyn Beattie, team leader for Save the Children's response in Gaza, but adds that so far "not a single aid truck" has come through.

    Israel has said that the crossing, which has been closed since 7 October, would reopen following the deaths of seven aid workers in an air strike on 1 April.

    The crossing's reopening would bring more aid into the north, where starvation is most acute.

    Aid agencies and foreign officials have long urged Israel to open more crossings. Read more on the possible reopening of aid routes here.

  18. 'We are children and we have the right to rejoice in Eid'published at 14:59 British Summer Time 10 April

    Nabeel Sami Al-Saroura says he wants to celebrate Eid as before
    Image caption,

    Nabeel Sami Al-Saroura says he wants to celebrate Eid as before

    BBC Arabic’s Gaza Lifeline programme is continuing to speak to children in Gaza today about celebrating Eid this year.

    Nabeel Sami Al-Saroura, who is 10 years old, tries to stay positive. He says that despite the war and the fear, he is "determined to enjoy Eid like other children in the world."

    "Last year's Eid was full of joy, but this one is filled with fear and shelling because of the war and the continuous bombing," he says.

    "Despite the destruction of our homes and the loss of our belongings, and despite the sadness dominating the streets, we will celebrate and rejoice this Eid," he says.

    Yousra Adnan Abu Ataya, who is 12 years old, also says that she wants to enjoy Eid. "We are children and we have the right to rejoice in Eid".

  19. Analysis

    Little hope on the horizon for Gazans on first day of Eidpublished at 14:46 British Summer Time 10 April

    Sebastian Usher
    Middle East analyst in Jerusalem

    Heavy rain blanketed Gaza for much of the first morning of Eid, further underscoring the bleakness of the usually joyful occasion this year. But the voices of children singing in Gaza City somewhat lightened the mood, if only for a moment.

    There's little hope on the horizon for Gazans - some of whom have been returning to the ruins of their homes after the bulk of Israeli forces withdrew.

    The latest round of ceasefire talks is faltering on, with both Hamas and the Israeli government yet to deliver their final verdict.

    Israeli officials say the government has made a significant concession in agreeing to allow150,000 displaced Palestinians to return to northern Gaza.

    Meanwhile, Iran and Israel have been trading further threats, with the Israeli Defence Minister Yoav Gallant saying that "decisive offensive action" would be taken against the territory of whoever attacks Israel.

  20. 'No semblance of celebration,' says Gaza residentpublished at 14:31 British Summer Time 10 April

    Insaf Abbas
    BBC News

    Elham's childrenImage source, Handout
    Image caption,

    Elham's children

    I've been speaking to Elham, a 40-year-old mother in the southern city of Rafah, where 1.5 million Palestinians are sheltering. Elham's home is now a mass of rubble, bar one room that survived the bombing - and that her family now lives in.

    I asked her how - if at all - she was marking Eid.

    "We have no Eid, no new clothes, no semblance of celebration," she told me.

    "It's a very sad day full of tears for our children who were martyred in the war, including my sister's children."

    Eid-al-Fitr marks the end of the holy month of Ramadan, when Muslims fast. It's usually a day for gathering with family and eating large meals.

    But amid a looming famine, the situation in Gaza looks very different. Elham says she's unable to afford the little food available.

    "I have no food for myself," Elham says.

    "My children have bread and cheese, but I have nothing."

    Elham's children look out from the remnants of their house in RafahImage source, Handout