Summary

  • Canada's Transportation Safety Board says it is launching an investigation after the implosion of the Titan submersible left all five passengers dead

  • In the US, a separate probe will be launched involving the American counterpart and US Coast Guard

  • Tributes have been paid to Hamish Harding who would have turned 59 on Saturday, Shahzada Dawood, 48, and his son Suleman Dawood, 19, Paul-Henri Nargeolet, 77, and Stockton Rush, 61

  • Emails seen by the BBC show that concerns from an expert over the safety of the Titan sub were dismissed by OceanGate CEO Rush in 2018

  • Other industry experts have also raised questioned following the "catastrophic implosion"

  • But an OceanGate investor who has made the trip down to the Titanic told the BBC that the idea Rush had done anything wrong was "disingenuous"

  • It's emerged the US Navy originally detected “an acoustic anomaly consistent with an implosion” shortly after the Titan lost contact on Sunday

  1. Watch: The scene at St John's, Newfoundlandpublished at 11:10 British Summer Time 21 June 2023

    The BBC's Nadine Yousif is in Newfoundland - where the expedition to the Titanic wreck began.

    Media caption,

    Titanic sub: St John's hoping for safe return

  2. Missing sub could be at the surface, says former submarine commanderpublished at 11:03 British Summer Time 21 June 2023

    Victoria Gill
    Science correspondent

    A submarine search and rescue expert in Australia, Frank Owen, tells the BBC his “confidence went up by an order of magnitude” when he heard reports of banging being detected by floating sound detectors.

    “There's a couple of reasons for that,” he explains. “Firstly, on board this craft is a retired French navy diver. He would know the protocol for trying to alert searching forces… on the hour and the half hour you bang like hell for three minutes.”

    He says the sound signal being picked by a buoy close to the surface also suggests that the sub itself could be near or at the surface.

    “Below about 180 metres, the water temperature drops very rapidly,” he explained. “That creates a layer that the [sonar signal] bounces off. But if you’re in the same depth water it tends to go quite straight.”

    Even if Titan is at the surface, it will be difficult to spot. Very little of the small, white vessel sits above the water.

    But using an array of sound-detecting buoys to triangulate the signal could narrow down its position.

  3. 'If you tried to escape, you'd last less than a second'published at 10:51 British Summer Time 21 June 2023

    More now from Simon Boxall, senior lecturer in oceanography at the University of Southampton, who was on the World Service's Newsday programme earlier.

    "The pressure there [the Titanic wreck is 3,800m underwater] is phenomenal," Boxall says.

    "It would crush anyone who tried to get out of it. If you tried to escape at that depth, you'd last less than a second."

    Because of this, the sub needs to be brought to the surface, he says.

  4. How sound is being used as part of the rescue effortpublished at 10:29 British Summer Time 21 June 2023

    Jonathan Amos
    Science correspondent

    Sound is the way you communicate in the ocean. Whales and porpoises use it, and so do humans.

    All forms of electromagnetic radiation, for example, radio and radar, are pretty useless.

    But sound travels efficiently, it travels fast (1,500m/s) and over great distances.

    This is why the rescue operation has been dropping sonobuoys in the water, listening for any sounds that are out of the ordinary.

    If these reported bangings are real – and the authorities certainly consider them worth investigating – they can use them to locate the sub.

    If they’re transmitted as a regular pattern, you can time the arrival of that pattern at different sonobouys to get a fix on the source.

    The GPS receiver does something similar in your phone, using radio signals transmitted from different satellites.

    The sound approach is nothing like as accurate, but would be a major help in narrowing down the unmanned remotely operated vehicle's efforts.

  5. Noises give hope this is still a rescue operation - oceanographerpublished at 10:16 British Summer Time 21 June 2023

    Simon Boxall is a Senior Lecturer in Oceanography at the University of Southampton and earlier told the BBC that the underwater noises give hope that those on board are still alive.

    "There are plenty of sound sources in the ocean, but it does give hope," he told Newsday on the World Service.

    "I think one of the scenarios that everyone feared was that the submersible had basically imploded. So it does give some hope that this is still a rescue operation, rather than just a recovery operation."

  6. Titanic wreck site a dangerous place to be, says diverpublished at 10:03 British Summer Time 21 June 2023

    The port bow railing of the TitanicImage source, File photo

    Dik Barton, the first British diver to see the Titanic wreck, says the site is a "dangerous" and "hostile" place to be.

    "There's a local ebb and current of water which moves around, it's not consistent. The strength of the submersible is relatively limited," he told ITV's Good Morning Britain.

    "The thrusters are quite strong but, at the end of the day, you have to conserve your power because it's your life support system and navigation system."

    Sharing his thoughts on how the vessel could be found, Barton added it may have to be recovered back to the surface as there is no way of accessing the submersible on the sea bed.

  7. What we know about the missing Titanic sub...in 75 secondspublished at 09:47 British Summer Time 21 June 2023

    The BBC's Carl Nasman explains what happened with the lost submersible vessel and what is being done to try to find it.

  8. Ship with life-saving chamber en routepublished at 09:36 British Summer Time 21 June 2023

    Royal Canadian Navy ship HMCS Glace Bay and Canadian Coast Guard Ship John CabotImage source, HMCS Glace Bay / Facebook

    More help is on the way. The Royal Canadian Navy ship HMCS Glace Bay is expected to arrive at the scene of the search on Thursday at midday local time.

    Onboard the ship is a medical team specialising in dive medicine, and a six-person mobile hyperbaric recompression chamber.

    If the sub is located, the recompression chambers on board this ship can be used to treat or prevent decompression sickness. When divers are exposed to rapid decreases in pressure, nitrogen forms bubbles in tissue and blood.

    A Canadian Coast Guard Ship, the Terry Fox, is already at the scene, on standby to load search and rescue equipment and personnel.

  9. Rescue mission a 'race against time'published at 09:18 British Summer Time 21 June 2023

    Hamish Harding and Terry Virts
    Image caption,

    Terry Virts (right) with his friend Hamish Harding, who is one of the passengers on board the Titan

    Colonel Terry Virts, who is a former commander of the International Space Station and a friend of Hamish Harding, has been speaking to the BBC and says the rescue mission is a race against time.

    "I believe that if they can be rescued they will be just because of the amount of effort that's being put in," he tells Newsday.

    "But they're in a tough situation and the clock is ticking. According to the company specs and the submarine spec, on Thursday they will probably be out of oxygen.

    Quote Message

    "So either we get them up in the next day or two or it's not looking good. The clock is definitely ticking."

  10. French diver on board has considerable experiencepublished at 09:07 British Summer Time 21 June 2023

    Jonathan Amos
    Science correspondent

    On a positive note, we should remember that one of the crew of the Titan submersible has immense naval experience.

    Paul-Henry Nargeolet, who’s one of the world’s foremost Titanic experts, spent 25 years in the French Navy.

    He will know the protocols to follow to give the rescue operation at the surface the greatest chance of finding the lost vehicle.

    Has Nargeolet instigated some routine of banging to attract the attention of the sonar surveys?

    It’s all speculation at the moment, but every potential lead must be followed up at pace with the life support system onboard reckoned to have only a day’s breathable air left.

  11. Difficult to interpret banging noises for now, experts saypublished at 08:56 British Summer Time 21 June 2023

    Jonathan Amos
    Science correspondent

    Deep-sea experts we've spoken to say it’s hard to determine what these noises might be without seeing the data.

    But it’s possible they could be short, sharp, relatively high frequency noises made by hitting the titanium end bell with another piece of metal or hard object within the pressure vessel.

    This ought to be distinguishable from the general white noise of the ocean, especially if it has a regular pattern at timed intervals.

    Certainly, it would seem the rescue operation is sufficiently convinced by the sounds to pursue them further, even moving their ROV (remotely operated vehicle) operations to a different location.

  12. Underwater robots ready to help locate subpublished at 08:56 British Summer Time 21 June 2023

    We've heard from the Explorers Club, who are offering to help locate the submersible using remotely operated vehicles (ROV) or underwater robots from the UK's Magellan company (see previous post).

    The remote-operated vehicles can go as deep as 6,000 metres and have been to the wreckage of the Titanic before, Explorers Club president Richard Garriott has said.

    Two of those on board the submersible, Hamish Harding and Paul-Henri Nargeolet, are members of the club, a global network for scientific exploration.

    Garriott noted that there had been signs of life as the search entered crucial hours - banging sounds were earlier reported in the area where the submersible is believed to be located.

    Magellan Remotely operated vehicleImage source, Magellan Equipment and Resources
    Image caption,

    Magellan's remotely operated vehicle

  13. OceanGate asked UK deep ocean specialists to helppublished at 08:46 British Summer Time 21 June 2023

    Magellan, a British firm that specialises in deep ocean investigations and recovery operations, has said it is supporting the rescue mission for the Titan.

    The company said in a statement on its website it had experience operating at even deeper depths.

    Magellan said it was contacted by OceanGate early on Monday and "immediately offered our knowledge of the specific site and also our expertise operating at depth considerably in advance of what is required for this incident".

    "We have been working full-time with UK and US agencies to secure the necessary air support to move our specialist equipment and support crew.

    "We are ready to support, and we are fully mobilised to help," the firm said.

  14. How do you search for the sub?published at 08:37 British Summer Time 21 June 2023

    On the surface:

    The sub might be able to alert rescuers if it can reach the surface through radio transmitters and GPS signals. It has strobe lights and radar reflectors to help the rescue teams spot them.

    But locating the sub may be hard, especially from the air because it's white in colour. Changeable weather and poor visibility will also pose a challenge to the teams.

    Underwater:

    Rescuers must also comb depths that could reach nearly 4km (2.5 miles) to look for the craft, which is 6.7m (22ft) long. The US Coast Guard has extended the search into deeper waters.

    Radio and GPS signals can't travel through water, so the only other way to detect the sub is through sonar and sonar bouys, often used in hunting for enemy submarines.

    They work by detecting movements and sounds in the water - like the one the US Coast Guard reported - or by bouncing a sonar "ping" off the surface of the vessel (active detection) and listening for the returning echo.

    Read more about how the teams are locating the sub here.

    Visual guide to the Titan sub hunt
  15. Who is involved in search efforts?published at 08:28 British Summer Time 21 June 2023

    The BBC Verify team looks at all the ships in the area and who can help with the rescue.

    Media caption,

    Who is involved in search efforts

  16. What do we know about the Titan?published at 08:20 British Summer Time 21 June 2023

    A picture of the Titan submersible
    • Weighs about 23,000lbs (10,432kg)
    • Its length is 6.7m (22ft)
    • Capable of reaching depths of up to 4,000m (13,123ft) below sea level
    • Four electric thrusters help it reach speeds of about 3 knots, or about 3.5 miles per hour (4km/h)
    • When it dives, GPS is not an option. The Titan has a special text messaging system that allows its crew to receive instructions from the team on the surface vessel above
    • The pilot steers with a modified video game controller
    • The sub is bolted from the outside - that means the crew cannot open it from the inside
    • The sub is owned and operated by OceanGate, external, a private company which "provides submersibles for commercial projects, scientific research and exploration" according to its website
  17. The keen scuba diver behind the OceanGate travel firmpublished at 08:14 British Summer Time 21 June 2023

    Stockton Rush CEO of OceanGateImage source, OceanGate
    Image caption,

    Stockton Rush is a trained engineer and CEO of OceanGate

    OceanGate's chief executive Stockton Rush is one of the five people in the submersible.

    In 2017, he spoke to the BBC's Business Correspondent, Beth Timmins, about his business.

    Rush said at that time that a trip to explore the Titanic for eight days would cost $105,129 (£82,000). It was the first time a journey that deep had been opened up to tourists.

    Now, the expedition costs $250,000 per person to travel around 645km (400 miles) into the Atlantic to the wreckage site.

    Rush said he had always wanted to be an astronaut, but after completing an aerospace degree and engineering work on the US fighter programme, he was told that his 20/25 eyesight wouldn’t allow him to be an air force pilot.

    As a keen scuba diver, he decided to launch submersible trips to depths that were previously the remit of government submarines.

    Among his previous OceanGate guests are Everest climbers, nautical archaeologists and filmmakers. He's also had travellers as old as 92 and and as young as 12 on his vessels.

  18. British passengers Shahzada Dawood and Suleman Dawoodpublished at 08:01 British Summer Time 21 June 2023

    Pakistani businessman Shahzada DawoodImage source, SETI Institute

    Pakistani businessman Shahzada Dawood and his son Suleman are two of the five passengers on board the sub.

    Their family in Pakistan told the BBC in a statement they are British citizens.

    The family is one of Pakistan's richest. Dawood is a trustee at the SETI Institute - a organisation researching the origins and prevalence of life and intelligence in the universe.

    He is also on an advisory board for the Prince's Trust international and has links to the British Asian Trust, organisations set up by the King as Prince of Wales, according to his profile on the SETI website.

  19. Titanic sub: Why it's so hard to findpublished at 07:50 British Summer Time 21 June 2023

    The search and rescue effort under way in the North Atlantic to find the submersible has gone on for more than three days.

    Alistair Greig, professor of marine engineering from University College London, explains why the search is so challenging.

    Media caption,

    Titanic sub: Why it's so hard to find

  20. Who is searching and what have they found?published at 07:42 British Summer Time 21 June 2023

    Here's a summary of the US-Canada led search efforts for the Titan so far:

    • The US Coast Guard continues to lead the complex search over an area of ocean "larger than the state of Connecticut" - about 20,000 sq km
    • A Canadian P-3 aircraft detected "underwater noises" in a search area for the Titan sub, the Coast Guard has confirmed
    • The data from the P-3 aircraft is the first possible breakthrough in the three-day search, with authorities relocating their search
    • Rescue teams from Canada's navy, air force and coast guard, as well as the New York air guard are assisting
    • A French research vessel has also joined the efforts
    • The Titan submersible is thought to be approximately 900 miles (1,450km) east and 400 miles (643km) south of Newfoundland's capital, St Johns
    • Contact was lost with the sub one hour and 45 minutes into its two hour dive down to the Titanic wreck site which lies at a depth of 3,800m.
    • According to earlier US Coast Guard estimates, at this point the Titan has less than 30 hours of oxygen remaining on board
    At a port in St John's, US Air Force equipment is loaded onto the Horizon Arctic, one of the vessels deployed to the search areaImage source, Reuters
    Image caption,

    At a port in St John's, US Air Force equipment is loaded onto the Horizon Arctic, one of the vessels deployed to the search area