Summary

  • Moscow has accused Ukraine's military of shooting down a plane, which it says was carrying 65 Ukrainian prisoners of war

  • The plane came down near the Russian city of Belgorod, close to the Ukrainian border

  • "On board were 65 captured Ukrainian army servicemen being transported for exchange, six crew members and three escorts," Russia says

  • The local governor says there are no survivors - the BBC cannot yet verify who was on board, or what caused the plane to crash

  • Ukraine does not rule out shooting down the plane, saying Kyiv hadn't been asked to ensure the "safety of airspace near the city of Belgorod" at the agreed time

  • The plane was flying from the Chkalovsky air base near Moscow to Belgorod, Russia says

  1. Analysis

    Difficult to say for sure what caused the plane crashpublished at 12:44 Greenwich Mean Time 24 January

    Pavel Aksenov
    BBC Russian defence correspondent

    Russian Telegram channels claim that the IL-76 was shot down by Ukrainian air defence systems. This theory could be confirmed by a video showing the missile trace or the actual moment of the aircraft being hit.

    However, we haven't seen such a video, and based on the available footage, it's difficult to say for sure what caused the plane crash.

    We can see the aircraft descending towards the ground. At some point, a large fragment detaches from it, and presumably afterwards, flames erupt around the left wing.

    This cannot be considered as conclusive evidence that the plane was shot down, nor does it disprove this version.

    The crash site is located about 50 km from the Ukrainian border, potentially allowing Ukraine to use certain medium-range anti-aircraft missile systems.

    For example, the Patriot SAM could have potentially been used. The IRIS-T SLM, which is known to be in Ukraine’s arsenal, has a range of 40k and is unlikely to reach such a distance.

    If Ukraine, as claimed by some in Russia, used the Patriot SAM, then the range of its PAC 2 missile family is 160 km. On the one hand, with this range, there is no need to position the complex near the border, risking exposure to Russian drones or artillery strikes.

    On the other hand, its value in defending strategically important objects is significant. It's not clear whether Ukraine would risk using such crucial weaponry to shoot down an aircraft when they could use them against Russian "Kinzhal" missiles instead.

    In the discussions about supplying Ukraine with Western weapons, particularly ground-to-ground missiles, concerns were expressed in the United States that Kyiv might use them against targets on Russian territory. However, officially no such restrictions have been placed.

  2. Ukraine-Russia prisoner exchange was being prepared - Radio Libertypublished at 12:26 Greenwich Mean Time 24 January

    A prisoner exchange between Russia and Ukraine was being prepared for today, a spokesman for Ukraine’s military intelligence told Radio Liberty.

    Andriy Yusov is quoted as saying: "I can state that the exchange planned for today is not taking place yet."

    He adds that the information provided by Russia, that prisoners of war had been on board the plane which crashed in Belgorod, was being checked.

  3. What's been happening in the Ukraine-Russia war?published at 12:05 Greenwich Mean Time 24 January

    A woman standing on a pile of rubbleImage source, Reuters
    Image caption,

    Residents at the scene of a Russian missile strike on Kharkiv on 23 January

    As we continue to monitor developments from Belgorod, let's look at what's been happening in the Ukraine-Russia war in recent months.

  4. Ukraine urges against spreading of 'unverified information'published at 11:57 Greenwich Mean Time 24 January

    As we've been reporting, Russia says that the plane which crashed in Belgorod region was carrying 65 Ukrainian prisoners of war.

    We have now had a statement from the Coordination HQ on Treatment of the Prisoners of War (POWs), which is a Ukrainian government body.

    The statement urges the "mass media and citizens to refrain from spreading unverified information," and adds it is collecting more information.

    "We emphasise that the enemy is actively carrying out special information operations directed against Ukraine," the statement says.

    Russia and Ukraine have exchanged hundreds of prisoners since the start of the war, including the biggest swap yet taking earlier this month, when 230 Ukrainians were exchanged for 248 Russians.

  5. Russia accuses Ukraine of downing military plane, Tass reportspublished at 11:40 Greenwich Mean Time 24 January

    Russia's foreign ministry says Ukraine downed the military plane that crashed in Russia's Belgorod region, calling it a "barbaric" act, state news agency TASS reports.

    The BBC cannot yet verify who was on board, or what caused the plane to crash.

    We'll bring you more as we have it.

  6. BBC Verify

    How we know where and when the plane crashedpublished at 11:30 Greenwich Mean Time 24 January

    So far, we are working from an initial video of the moment of impact.

    In it, a church in the middle-distance with a distinct spire beside it, a single-storey blue building closer to the camera, and the layout of the roads are all matches for satellite imagery of the Yablonovo village in Belgorod Region on both Google and Yandex (the Russian equivalent of Google).

    We can also be confident the video is from today: satellite weather data shows heavy cloud over the area, as we can see in the video, as well as some flurries of snow in the morning, matching the snow seen on the ground in the video.

    Two still images from the video were also reverse-searched – combing the internet for any pre-existing copies – and none were found, meaning the video was very likely recently uploaded for the first time.

    As a rule of thumb, we start to find copies of videos from Ukrainian or Russian incidents about two to three hours after they happen.

    A Google Street View of the area of impactImage source, Google
    Image caption,

    Google Street View allows us to recreate the point-of-view in the video of the impact

  7. All passengers on board military plane killed, local governor sayspublished at 11:21 Greenwich Mean Time 24 January
    Breaking

    All passengers on board the military plane which crashed in Belgorod region have died, local governor Vyacheslav Gladkov says.

    "A transport plane crashed in the Korochansky district. It fell in a field near the village. All those on board were killed," Gladkov writes on Telegram. , external

    He adds that the crash site has been cordoned off and an investigation is being carried out.

  8. Child among 9 injured in latest Russian strikes on Kharkivpublished at 11:13 Greenwich Mean Time 24 January

    A damaged building in Kharkiv is inspectedImage source, AFP
    Image caption,

    Several buildings have been damaged

    Meanwhile Russia has continued its strikes on Ukraine.

    A four-year-old child and eight other people have been injured in the latest Russian attacks on the city of Kharkiv, the regional governor says.

    Oleh Sinehubov adds that four people were taken to hospital but their injuries are not thought to be life-threatening.

    The National Academy of Legal Sciences of Ukraine is among the buildings that have been damaged.

    Wednesday's strikes come a day after eight people were killed in the city.

  9. Where did the plane crash?published at 10:56 Greenwich Mean Time 24 January

    The video of the crash verified by the BBC was taken from the village of Yablonovo, in Russia's Belgorod region.

    Yablonovo is about 108 miles (174km) from the Ukrainian city of Kharkiv across the border.

    The city of Belgorod has come under missile attacks recently. On 30 December, a missile and drone attack killed 25 people, in the deadliest attack on Russian territory since the start of the conflict.

    A map of Ukraine and Russia, highlighting where Belgorod isImage source, .
  10. Russian MP claims a second plane was turned aroundpublished at 10:39 Greenwich Mean Time 24 January

    Steve Rosenberg
    BBC Russia editor

    The Ilyushin 76 military transport plane crashed in Russia’s Belgorod Region.

    Mobile phone footage shot at a distance shows an aircraft falling from the sky, then seconds later a fireball rising.

    Russian news agencies quoted the Russia’s defence ministry as saying there were 74 people on board the aircraft - including 65 Ukrainian prisoners of war who Moscow says were to be part of a prisoner exchange.

    As yet, there is no independent confirmation of this.

    Later the head of the Russian parliament’s defence committee claimed there’d been a second plane in the air transporting another 80 Ukrainian prisoners, but the aircraft, he claimed, had turned around.

  11. Russian MP says plane shot down by Ukraine - but does not provide evidencepublished at 10:24 Greenwich Mean Time 24 January

    A Russian MP says the military transport plane was shot down by three missiles fired by Ukraine.

    Speaking in the Russian parliament, the Duma, Andrei Kartapolov, a retired general, said the missiles were of types that the West has supplied to Ukraine.

    Kartapolov did not state the source of his information, or provide evidence.

    He added that investigations would reveal whether the missiles were Patriots or IRIS-Ts.

  12. BBC Verify

    Watch: Moment Russian plane crashespublished at 10:21 Greenwich Mean Time 24 January

    The BBC has verified this video showing the moment the Russian aircraft - reportedly an Il-76 - crashes near Belgorod.

    A warning, the video below contains distressing images. And as a reminder - we do not know what caused the crash.

    Media caption,

    Moment Russian aircraft crashes in Belgorod

  13. Regional governor reported 'incident' before ministry statementpublished at 09:57 Greenwich Mean Time 24 January

    Francis Scarr
    BBC Monitoring

    As we just reported, the Russian Defence Ministry says an Il-76 military transport aircraft carrying 65 Ukrainian prisoners-of-war has crashed in the Belgorod region.

    Regional governor Vyacheslav Gladkov earlier confirmed on his Telegram channel that an "incident" had occurred in Korochansky district, but provided no other details.

    Local channel Bletgorod posted footage purporting to show the aircraft rapidly losing altitude before hitting the ground and catching fire.

    A file photo of a a Russian Il-76 MD airlifter seen during the 2021 International Army Games in RussiaImage source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    A file photo of a Russian Il-76 MD airlifter seen during the 2021 International Army Games in Russia

  14. What we know so farpublished at 09:53 Greenwich Mean Time 24 January

    • The Russian Defence Ministry says a military plane carrying 65 Ukrainian prisoners of war has crashed in southern Russia
    • The crash happened in the Belgorod region and involved a Il-76 military transport aircraft, the ministry says
    • The ministry says six crew members and three attendants were also on board.

    The BBC is working to verify who was on the plane, and what caused the crash

  15. Russian military plane crashes in Belgorod regionpublished at 09:51 Greenwich Mean Time 24 January
    Breaking

    Nadia Ragozhina
    Live reporter

    A Russian military plane has crashed in Russia’s Belgorod region, reportedly carrying 65 Ukrainian prisoners of war.

    Stay with us as we bring you the latest from our teams in London, Moscow, and Kyiv.