Summary

  • Donald Trump has testified briefly at a New York court as part of his defence in a defamation case brought by fashion writer E Jean Carroll

  • A judge has already ruled Trump's statements were defamatory and the jury will now decide how much Trump must pay in damages

  • Just before taking the stand, Trump was heard saying "I never met this woman" - and was told off by the judge for interrupting proceedings

  • A jury in a previous civil fraud trial found Carroll was sexually abused by Trump in the 1990s, but this case is about comments he made about her in 2019

  • Carroll seeks $10m (£7.8m), saying the comments harmed her reputation and unleashed a torrent of death threats. Trump denies any wrongdoing and says he never instructed anyone to harm her

  • The case is one of several legal issues unfolding against Trump while he campaigns for the Republican presidential nomination

  1. A rapid-fire testimony from Trumppublished at 23:08 Greenwich Mean Time 25 January

    So, that's it - Donald Trump has testified in his second civil defamation trial brought by writer E Jean Carroll. We're now wrapping up our live coverage.

    His brief testimony lasted just four minutes, which took us all a bit by surprise here in the newsroom.

    The short time on the stand was because Judge Lewis Kaplan had given Trump a very limited scope of what he could talk about. A separate trial last year found Trump sexually assaulted Carroll, so it meant he couldn't repeat his denials and had to stick to what was relevant in the case.

    Court returns tomorrow for closing arguments and the jury to be sent off for deliberations. For a write-up of today, that's here.

  2. In pictures: Trump testifies in courtpublished at 22:58 Greenwich Mean Time 25 January

    We've had some court sketches of the moments before and during Trump's testimony this afternoon.

    Former U.S. President Donald Trump exclaims to U.S. District Judge Lewis Kaplan "I never met this woman" as his lawyer Alina Habba stands during the second civil trial where E. Jean Carroll accused Trump of raping her decades ago, at Manhattan Federal Court in New York City, U.S., January 25, 2024 in this courtroom sketchImage source, Reuters
    Image caption,

    Court artist Jane Rosenberg captured the moment Trump was told off by the judge for interrupting

    Former U.S. President Donald Trump testifies as he takes the stand watched by U.S. District Judge Lewis Kaplan during the second civil trial where E. Jean Carroll accused Trump of raping her decades ago, at Manhattan Federal Court in New York City, U.S., January 25, 2024 in this courtroom sketch. REUTERS/Jane RosenbergImage source, Reuters
    Image caption,

    Trump answered two questions from his lawyer Alina Habba in his few minutes on the stand

  3. What happened in court today?published at 22:14 Greenwich Mean Time 25 January

    Chloe Kim
    Reporting from court

    We heard from prosecution witnesses:

    • The day began with evidence from E Jean Carroll's old boss, former Elle editor-in-chief, Roberta Myers, who described Carroll as a "truth teller". Habba asked her about the advice column that Carroll wrote, suggesting that Carroll wrote her opinion and was not a "fact-checking journalist"
    • Carol Martin, a long-time friend of Carroll, then took the witness stand. Habba pointed to multiple texts from Martin suggesting that Carroll was enjoying the attention from this case. Martin said she had "misused words" and describes herself as a "hyperbolic" person

    Then it was Trump. What did he testify?

  4. Why was Trump not allowed to repeat his denial of sexual assault?published at 21:40 Greenwich Mean Time 25 January

    Sam Cabral
    US reporter

    As we noted earlier, the discussion about what Donald Trump could say on the stand lasted longer than the testimony itself.

    Lyrissa Lidsky, a law professor at the University of Florida, says the reason is quite simple.

    This trial was solely about how much Trump should pay, since a different jury has already found him liable for sexually abusing E Jean Carroll.

    "Trump wanted to repeat his message that E Jean Carroll was lying, but the judge did not allow that because the jury in the previous trial had already found that she was not lying," Lidsky tells the BBC.

    "Unable to testify that Carroll was lying, Trump did not have much else to say."

  5. What happens now?published at 21:22 Greenwich Mean Time 25 January

    Former U.S. President Donald Trump greets to his supporters, as he arrives from his second civil trial after E. Jean Carroll accused Trump of raping her decades ago, outside a Trump Tower in the Manhattan borough of New York City, U.S., January 25, 2024.Image source, Reuters

    The defence has rested its case, and court will resume at 9:30 local time (14:30 GMT) on Friday for jury instruction.

    Then, it's up to the jury to retire and decide this - whether Trump harmed Carroll with specific defamatory statements he made in 2019 while he was president, and if so, how much money he must pay her in compensation.

    We have no idea how long jury deliberations will take.

    Due to intense media and political scrutiny, the jury is remaining anonymous and jurors have even been urged to use fake names when talking to each other. They're also taken to the courthouse by secure means from undisclosed locations - a set up usually used in cartel cases.

  6. Trump's different strategies for inside and outside court - legal expertpublished at 20:56 Greenwich Mean Time 25 January

    Sam Cabral
    US reporter

    After pushing for delays so he could take the stand in this case, Donald Trump testified for less than five minutes on Thursday.

    That's because Judge Lewis Kaplan has taken such a firm hand on this case, making clear in advance that neither Trump nor his attorney could veer into territory irrelevant to what the jury is considering, says RonNell Andersen Jones, a law professor at the University of Utah.

    "The judge has repeatedly said that he would not allow this to be a “do-over” of the case that already decided these were defamatory lies. He enforced that," she tells the BBC.

    That shows us "the wide gap between Trump’s strategies in court and his strategies outside of it", she adds.

    "In his very short time on the stand, he made a couple of statements that were relevant and admissible for this jury and several that were not. I expect that his game plan will be to emphasize the former in the courtroom and the latter to his audiences outside of it in speeches and social media posts."

    Jones believes that, though Trump said he was motivated by a desire to defend himself, a jury may not be easily persuaded by that claim - given there's new evidence daily that the former president continues to spread his claims about Carroll undeterred outside the courtroom.

  7. Analysis

    Trump is testing the limits of court - and it's a winning formulapublished at 20:22 Greenwich Mean Time 25 January

    Nada Tawfik
    Reporting from court in New York

    Outlining the ground rules for Donald Trump’s testimony took longer than the testimony itself.

    The judge left no room for him to go beyond the agreed terms, making it impossible for him to launch into a monologue or to campaign from the witness stand.

    But that still didn’t stop the former president from uttering his thoughts from the defence table, where he wasn’t under oath.

    Trump is testing the limits of the courts in his legal cases. It’s keeping his base invested and tuned in.

    And more importantly, it’s leading to considerable press coverage as he looks set to be the Republican presidential nominee.

    It’s a winning formula for his campaign that he’s unlikely to abandon.

  8. Trump leaves court without speaking to mediapublished at 20:06 Greenwich Mean Time 25 January

    Brandon Livesay
    Reporting from court in New York

    Trump's motorcade

    Trump's motorcade was idling in a back alley next to the court, although it has just gone.

    It's a high-security zone, with a large area fenced off and no-one allowed in.

    A police officer tells me Trump wont be speaking to media. This is a change to other court cases in recent weeks, where Trump has given news conferences to reporters near court.

  9. 'This is not America', Trump says as he leaves courtroompublished at 20:02 Greenwich Mean Time 25 January

    We've just had a few more details of what happened in court earlier, from our US partner CBS News.

    Before Trump took the stand the judge outlined severe restrictions on what Trump could say. Judge Kaplan was clear that Trump had “sexually abused” Carroll - something that was established in a separate civil case last year.

    Trump shook his head as the judge was saying this, and could be heard making a noise of disgust like “ugh", CBS reported.

    While the judge was setting restrictions, Carroll's lawyer said they heard Trump insisting that he would violate the rules.

    Moments later as Habba was speaking, Trump did break the rules, saying: "I don’t know who the woman is. I never met this woman", causing the judge to reprimand him for “interrupting".

    After his testimony, a reporter with WCBS heard Trump saying, while leaving the courtroom: "It’s not America. This is not America.”

  10. Court finishes for the daypublished at 19:53 Greenwich Mean Time 25 January

    Court has now adjourned.

    It will resume tomorrow morning at 9:30 local time (14:30 GMT) for closing arguments and jury deliberation.

  11. Question about Trump's state of mind not allowedpublished at 19:43 Greenwich Mean Time 25 January

    Chloe Kim
    Reporting from court in New York

    Trump's lawyer Habba originally wanted to ask about what Trump’s state of mind was at the time he made the defamatory statements - it was one of three questions she planned to ask when he was on the stand.

    But the judge declined and said that if she is asking if he stands by his deposition, then that should cover it. She did ask that, and Trump said he "100%" stood by his deposition.

    So in the end, it was just two questions in Trump's testimony.

  12. A quick testimony - the discussion about what he was allowed to say took longerpublished at 19:37 Greenwich Mean Time 25 January

    Chloe Kim
    Reporting from court in New York

    Prior to testifying, Trump was heard saying "I never met this woman".

    Judge Kaplan told him: "Mr. Trump you're interrupting these proceedings by talking loudly...and that is not permitted."

    Then, Trump's testimony was over in under five minutes.

    The questions between Trump's legal counsel and the judge about what he was allowed to say in testimony took longer than his actual testimony.

  13. Did you instruct anyone to harm Carroll? 'No,' says Trumppublished at 19:33 Greenwich Mean Time 25 January

    Chloe Kim
    Reporting from court in New York

    More now from Trump's testimony.

    Trump's lawyer Alina Habba asked if he instructed anyone to harm Carroll. Trump replies: “No”

    This follows Carroll's evidence last week, when she said Trump's statements unleashed a torrent of death threats, rape threats, and online vitriol.

    He goes on to say he was "just trying to defend myself" - but the judge says to strike that part from the record - because of the rules over what Trump can say in court.

  14. Trump says he '100%' stands by his depositionpublished at 19:29 Greenwich Mean Time 25 January

    Chloe Kim
    Reporting from court in New York

    Here are some details of what just happened when Trump took the stand.

    In his testimony, his lawyer Habba asked if he had seen the sworn deposition testimony that he gave in the case, and whether he stands by that.

    Trump says on the stand: “100% yes”

  15. Trump finishes testimony - after just four minutespublished at 19:27 Greenwich Mean Time 25 January

    Trump has now finished his testimony - it was over almost as quickly as it began, lasting just four minutes.

    We're still waiting to hear from our reporters in court about what was said and the key exchanges.

    We'll bring you those updates very shortly.

  16. Trump takes the standpublished at 19:23 Greenwich Mean Time 25 January
    Breaking

    Former President Donald Trump has taken the witness stand in his second defamation case against E Jean Carroll.

    It follows days of speculation as to whether he would testify in his own defence. Earlier, Carroll's lawyers raised concerns that Trump would refuse to follow court rules while offering testimony - but the judge set down some rules.

  17. Trump is being sworn inpublished at 19:21 Greenwich Mean Time 25 January

    Donald Trump is swearing in to take the witness stand.

  18. Judge lays down strict rules for Trumppublished at 19:21 Greenwich Mean Time 25 January

    Brandon Livesay
    Reporting from court in New York

    Judge Kaplan tells Trump he is not allowed to deny that he sexually assaulted Carroll.

    Trump's lawyer, Alina Habba, said her client would comply, as the judge continued to outline what Trump could say on the stand, asking if that was "100% of what he would say".

    Habba replied that she "can't say what he is going to say".

    Kaplan told Habba that she could only ask Trump about his actions after the allegations, not the substance of them.

  19. Trump muttering under his breath, Carroll's team saypublished at 19:19 Greenwich Mean Time 25 January

    Brandon Livesay
    Reporting from court in New York

    The judge says he will instruct the jury that "regardless of what he says in court today, he did it" - meaning the sexual assault, which he was found liable for in a separate case last year.

    Carroll's legal team also said they heard Trump muttering under his breath while the judge was laying down the rules, implying he was saying he has never met Carroll.

  20. Judge outlines rules for Trump's testimonypublished at 19:17 Greenwich Mean Time 25 January

    Brandon Livesay
    Reporting from court in New York

    The judge is outlining his expectations for Trump's upcoming testimony.

    He asks Trump's lawyer Alina Habba what her client will be saying and demands specifics.

    "I want to know everything he's going to say," the judge says, to which Habba replies: "I'm not testifying for my client".

    Habba says she will ask only three questions:

    • whether he stands by his deposition
    • what his state of mind was when he was speaking to reporters (when the defamatory comments were made)
    • and that he never instructed anyone to hurt Carroll.