Summary

  • Donald Trump has been ordered to pay a total of $83.3m (£65.6m) for defaming the writer E Jean Carroll while he was president

  • The jury in his defamation trial said he must pay $18.3m in compensation damages for emotional and reputational harm, and $65m in punitive damages

  • Carroll called it a "huge defeat for every bully who has tried to keep a woman down". Trump called the outcome "Absolutely ridiculous!"

  • The former president was in court on Friday for closing arguments, but was not in the room when the verdict was read out

  • A jury in a previous civil fraud trial found Carroll was sexually abused by Trump in the 1990s, but this case was about comments he made in 2019 while he was president

  • A judge had already ruled Trump's statements were defamatory and the jury's job was to decide how much he should pay. Trump denied any wrongdoing

  • The case is one of several legal issues unfolding against Trump while he campaigns for the Republican presidential nomination

  1. Trump ordered to pay $83.3m in damagespublished at 21:42 Greenwich Mean Time 26 January 2024
    Breaking

    Jurors have ordered Donald Trump to pay E Jean Carroll $18.3m in compensatory damages and $65m in punitive damages.

    That amounts to $83.3m (£65.6m) in total damages.

  2. Trump not in courtpublished at 21:38 Greenwich Mean Time 26 January 2024

    Nada Tawfik
    Reporting from New York

    We're just waiting for the jury's decision to be read out.

    It looks like Trump is not here in court - he left earlier and hasn’t returned.

  3. Jury has been deliberating for just under 3 hourspublished at 21:35 Greenwich Mean Time 26 January 2024

    The seven-man, two-woman jury in federal court in Manhattan started deliberating at just after lunchtime on Friday, at about 13:40 local time (18:40 GMT).

    That means they've been deliberating for just under three hours.

    They have to reach a unanimous verdict.

    Due to intense media and political scrutiny, the jurors are anonymous and have even been urged to use fake names when talking to each other. They’re also being moved by secure means from undisclosed locations to the courthouse - a set up usually used in cartel cases.

  4. Jury returning with a verdictpublished at 21:29 Greenwich Mean Time 26 January 2024
    Breaking

    We're just hearing from our reporters in court that the jury have returned with a verdict.

    We'll bring you more as we have it.

  5. How the jury is making its decisionpublished at 21:28 Greenwich Mean Time 26 January 2024

    Question one

    Jurors have been given three questions to consider, to help them reach a decision on how much Trump must pay.

    Question one was whether Trump should pay compensation damages to Carroll - both for reputational harm and emotional harm caused by his statements in 2019.

    Carroll's lawyers were seeking $24m (£18m) in compensation, broken down into $12m for reputational harm and $12m for emotional harm.

    Then, questions two and three focus on whether to make Mr Trump pay punitive damages - which are considered punishment.

    They look at each defamatory statement Trump made (one on 21 June 2019, and one on 22 June 2019) and ask whether Trump acted "maliciously, out of hatred, ill will, or spite, or in wanton, reckless, or willful disregard of Ms Carroll's rights."

    question 2 on the verdict sheet
  6. Trump left court during closing argumentspublished at 20:45 Greenwich Mean Time 26 January 2024

    Brandon Livesay
    Reporting from court in New York

    Former U.S. President Donald Trump walks out during attorney Roberta Kaplan's closing argument, during E. Jean Carroll’s second civil trial as Carroll accused Trump of raping her decades ago, at Manhattan Federal Court in New York City, U.S., January 26, 2024, in this courtroom sketch.Image source, Reuters
    Image caption,

    A courtroom sketch captures the moment Trump walked out

    At one point this morning, Trump walked out of court during closing arguments from Carroll's lawyer.

    Before leaving, Trump was seen shaking his head as lawyer Roberta Kaplan repeatedly brought up that Trump had sexually assaulted Carroll.

    Trump was found liable for the sexual assault in a separate civil trial last year.

    Judge Kaplan, (no relation to the lawyer Kaplan), told the court that the record "will reflect that Mr Trump rose and walked out of the courtroom".

    Trump, wearing a red tie, later returned to court. He sat with his hands clasped together and glancing over his right shoulder to watch his lawyer Alina Habba’s closing arguments.

  7. Carroll wants $24m, Trump wants to pay nothing - now jury will decidepublished at 18:12 Greenwich Mean Time 26 January 2024

    Madeline Halpert
    Reporting from court in New York

    In just a matter of minutes, it’ll be up to a jury to decide how much Donald Trump should pay for spreading lies about E Jean Carroll.

    Judge Kaplan has ordered members of the jury to remain anonymous as they face a high-stakes decision against a polarising former president.

    Speaking to jurors in closing arguments this morning, E Jean Carroll lawyer Roberta Kaplan argued Trump should pay upwards of $24m for destroying Carroll’s reputation.

    She's asking for $12m for reputational damages and $12m for emotional damages, and then the jury should decide on any other punitive damages.

    Fighting with the judge, Trump's lawyer Alina Habba argued he should pay nothing.

  8. What's happened this morning?published at 18:03 Greenwich Mean Time 26 January 2024

    Brandon Livesay and Madeline Halpert
    Reporting from court in New York

    E. Jean Carroll walks outside the Manhattan Federal Court, for the second civil trial after she accused former U.S. President Donald Trump of raping her decades ago, in New York City, U.S., January 26, 2024.Image source, Reuters
    Image caption,

    Carroll arrives at court in Manhattan on Friday morning

    The case in New York began to wrap up this morning, and we had closing arguments from lawyers for both sides.

    What the prosecution said:

    • Carroll’s lawyer Roberta Kaplan (no relation to the Lewis Kaplan who is the judge) said Trump was a liar who thought the rules did not apply to him. She said Carroll's reputation had been severely harmed by the former president's comments denying he sexually assaulted her
    • She said that Trump had "continued to defame Carroll even as this trial was ongoing" - and "this trial is about getting him to stop once and for all"
    • "This case is also about punishing Donald Trump," Kaplan added

    What Trump's defence said:

    • Alina Habba argued the jury should award Carroll no damages, saying her arguments have "more holes than Swiss cheese"
    • She said Trump "should not have to pay" for threats made on Twitter against Carroll, adding: "He does not condone them. He did not direct them.”
    • Habba told the court that Carroll was happy to have the fame, claiming she now makes more money than she did in 2019, when the defamatory comments were made. And she sought to portray Carroll as a "scandalous" character

    More here.

  9. Jury about to begin deliberations in defamation casepublished at 17:53 Greenwich Mean Time 26 January 2024

    Francesca Gillett
    Live reporter

    Donald Trump is back in court in New York again today for the wrapping up of his defamation trial brought by fashion writer E Jean Carroll.

    We heard closing arguments from both sides this morning - which we’ll bring you a recap of shortly - and the jury is now receiving instructions from the judge.

    After that, the jury will then be sent out to start deliberating.

    At one point this morning, Trump stood up and walked out of the courtroom in the middle of closing arguments. He later returned to hear his lawyer argue his case.

    We have reporters in court and don't have any idea of when a verdict will come, but we're on standby and waiting to see what happens.