'Impending shortage' of asylum seeker homes in the UK

  • Published
Iranian asylum seeker Mohammed Bagher BayzaviImage source, PA
Image caption,

The committee said it was "clearly wrong" that asylum seekers' doors in Middlesbrough were painted red

There is an "impending shortage" of housing for asylum seekers in the UK, the home affairs committee has warned, external.

The issue is being made worse by a lack of "fair and equal dispersal", with some areas receiving hundreds of people and others getting none, its MPs said.

The report includes Home Office figures showing where asylum seekers are being housed, external, with Glasgow having the most - 3,084 people - as of the end of 2015.

The Home Office said it was committed to providing safe and secure housing.

The committee said its findings "leave major questions" to be answered about the running of government contracts to provide asylum support services - collectively called Compass.

Why do so many asylum seekers live in Middlesbrough?

As part of the scheme, asylum seekers are found accommodation while their applications are being considered, often in areas where cheap housing is available.

Local authorities in those areas are then required to provide any education, health or specialist services those people may require.

Committee chairman Keith Vaz said the dispersal system "appears unfair, with whole swathes of the country never receiving a single asylum seeker".

"The majority are being moved into low-cost housing in urban areas such as Glasgow, Stoke, Cardiff and of course Middlesbrough, where the ratio is one asylum seeker per 137 people.

"However, on the data we have received, local authorities in areas such as Maidenhead, Lincoln and Warwick have housed none."

Other areas listed in the report as having no-one in receipt of aid given to asylum seekers - known as Section 95 support, external - in the final quarter of 2015 included Cambridge, Cornwall, Midlothian and York.

Local authorities with few asylum seekers, or none, should be "actively encouraged by ministers to volunteer" to take some, the MPs said.

Analysis

Image source, PA

By Danny Shaw, BBC home affairs correspondent

The three private firms that operate the programme known as Compass, the Home Office and the home affairs committee all agree that getting more councils on board is the key to easing the chronic accommodation shortage. At present, 200 local authorities are involved.

It may well become a crisis if the number of asylum applicants continues to increase.

At 38,000 the rate is at its highest since 2004. Some councils would take part if the contractors could find enough suitable and affordable properties; in other areas, it may be the fear of a voter backlash which is putting off local politicians from agreeing to participate.

With the government committed to resettling 20,000 Syrians by 2020, as well as accommodating asylum seekers, ministers will have to find a solution - or face the prospect of housing more of them in two-star and three-star hotels.

The main Compass contractors are G4S, Clearsprings and Serco, and the committee said delivery "has been mostly unsatisfactory to date".

"G4S, Serco and Clearsprings receive millions of pounds of public money to house asylum seekers, and revelations in recent months have been alarming," Mr Vaz said.

"The compulsory wearing of wrist bands and the infamous red doors demonstrate an unacceptable attitude towards vulnerable people.

"The Home Office has failed to provide proper oversight and inspection, and must do better."

MPs also condemned an "appalling" episode where asylum seekers in Cardiff were told to wear wristbands to demonstrate their eligibility for a service run by the Clearsprings Group.

There was also an instance in Middlesbrough - under a contract awarded to G4S - in which many asylum seekers' doors were painted the same colour, making the properties easily identifiable.

Image caption,

Glasgow has the most asylum seekers, followed by Birmingham, Liverpool and Cardiff. Manchester, Rochdale and Bolton also each house more than 1,000

The Local Government Association - which represents more than 400 local authorities in England and Wales - said councils had shown in their response to the Syrian refugee crisis that they are willing to "step in and help".

But it said authorities were "anxious" that no council was given an unfair burden.

The Home Office said it was working with areas that had not been involved so far in asylum dispersal.

A spokesman said: "The Home Office has worked closely with our providers to improve property standards over the lifetime of the Compass contract.

"Where a contractor is found to be falling short of these standards, we work with them to ensure issues are quickly addressed. When they are not, we can and do impose sanctions.

"All suppliers are meeting the contractual requirements to provide safe, habitable, fit for purpose and correctly equipped accommodation in compliance with the Housing Act 2004 and the Decent Homes Standard."