Tasered man wins case against Merseyside Police

  • Published

A man who suffered a cardiac arrest after being Tasered has won a negligence claim against Merseyside Police in a landmark case.

James McCarthy, 25, was struck twice in the chest outside a hotel at the Albert Dock, Liverpool, in September 2012.

His solicitor said it is the first case in the country where police have been held liable for negligence relating to care after the use of a Taser.

Merseyside Police said it would consider appealing.

Two years ago, the Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC) said officers used "reasonable force" but Mr McCarthy did not accept the findings.

'Violent situation'

The County Court in Manchester ruled against the force, saying the second Taser discharge, which lasted for 11 seconds, was "excessive and disproportionate".

The judgement found the force to be negligent because of delays in getting Mr McCarthy treated.

Solicitor, Sophie Khan said her client will now look to claim damages.

In a statement, Merseyside Police said the force "notes the decision of the court" and is "considering its options with regards to an appeal".

Officers were called to the Premier Inn hotel in 2012, where a group of men were fighting.

The IPCC's inquiry had found it was a "violent situation" and use of the stun gun was "proportionate" due to the potential threat of violence.

Related internet links

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.