MOD will not change ceremonial dagger gifting rule after murders

  • Published
Collin ReevesImage source, Facebook
Image caption,

Collin Reeves used a ceremonial dagger to kill his neighbours

The Ministry of Defence will not change its rules allowing those leaving the military to be gifted knives.

It comes after veteran Collin Reeves murdered his neighbours Stephen and Jennifer Chapple using a dagger.

A senior coroner wrote to Defence Secretary Ben Wallace urging him to consider the appropriateness of using ceremonial daggers as leaving gifts.

Mr Wallace said current restrictions were "sufficient", adding that other knives were available to buy online.

However, he said the MOD had "learned lessons" and "corrective action is being taken".

Reeves, an ex-commando trained Royal Engineer who served in Afghanistan, was jailed for life in June 2022.

He was ordered to serve at least 38 years in prison after being convicted of the double murder in Norton Fitzwarren, Somerset.

Image source, Jennifer Chapple
Image caption,

Stephen Chapple, 36, and Jennifer Chapple, 33, were stabbed to death while their children slept upstairs

In a prevention of future deaths report, external, Senior Somerset Coroner Samantha Marsh said it was understood the dagger had been handed to Reeves following his retirement from the service.

The dagger was believed to be a "Fairbairn-Sykes fighting knife" - commonly referred to as a Commando Dagger and officially named a Combat Fighting Knife.

Writing to Mr Wallace, Ms Marsh asked him to "reconsider the appropriateness of providing anyone leaving the British Army, regardless of rank or status, with what is to all intents and purposes a deadly weapon".

Mr Wallace noted the dagger had never been recovered and that even if it had been, it would not have been possible to determine if it had been supplied through the MOD or legally purchased from a commercial UK source.

Image caption,

The local community was left in shock following the attack

He said "there are no records of combat fighting knives having been gifted", but added there was a "tradition" of presenting leaving gifts to individuals when they left the armed forces, and that a Combat Fighting Knife, as part of a presentational display, was "one of many gifts that may be presented to service personnel departing military units associated with the commando role".

He said these were provided using non-public funds, such as a collection from colleagues, and were also available from a range of commercial suppliers.

"MOD policy is very clear: No-one is permitted to make a gift of MOD property without specific approval from the correct authority," he said.

Mr Wallace said the MOD did not consider it appropriate to provide Combat Fighting Knives to anyone other than those who required such an item for a specific combat role.

'Horrific murder'

In the response Mr Wallace went on to argue that a standing order prohibiting service personnel gifting such items would be of "limited utility" and added that on Google there were in excess of 160,000 hits on "Fairbairn-Sykes knives for sale".

He concluded: "I consider existing restrictions upon gifting of MOD property to be sufficient, however, I have written to the Service Chiefs in order to inform them of this horrific murder and remind them of their duty to ensure that misappropriation of MOD items is identified and investigated."

Mr Wallace added that he would also be writing to the General Officers commanding the units entitled to these knives to remind them to ensure there was genuine requirement to issue such items to personnel.

Follow BBC West on Facebook, external, Twitter, external and Instagram, external. Send your story ideas to: bristol@bbc.co.uk

Related internet links

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.