Sudden mechanical failure likely cause of Orkney ferry grounding

All 60 passengers were taken ashore by lifeboats

A sudden mechanical failure is likely to have been the cause of a car ferry grounding in Orkney, the coastguard has said.

The MV Pentalina had 60 people on board when it grounded at St Margaret's Hope on Saturday night.

Smoke had been detected in the engine room of the Pentland Ferries vessel beforehand.

The RMT maritime union has called for a thorough investigation into how the incident happened.

Emergency services, including lifeboats which took passengers ashore, were called to the scene at about 19:30 after the ferry issued a mayday message. It has since been refloated and berthed at St Margaret's Hope.

• Orkney ferry runs aground with 60 people on board

• Chartered CalMac catamaran to begin sea trials

• Why a CalMac catamaran is such a big deal

The Maritime and Coastguard Agency (MCA) said it would be assessing the extent of any damage and added: "While the facts haven't been established yet, initial reports from the operator point to the cause of the grounding being a sudden mechanical failure."

It defended the fact that the ferry had been issued with a passenger ship safety certificate following surveys of the vessel on 18 April.

"At this time the vessel met the standards required for issue of this certificate," it said.

It added that MCA surveyors would carry out initial fact-finding to establish the cause and circumstances surrounding the incident.

Gary Brown and his pregnant partner Lauren Haston were on board the Pentalina at the time of the accident.

The pair were out on the deck when they noticed smoke coming from the engine room followed by "flustered" members of the crew.

Lauren Haston and partner Gary Brown were on board the vessel and noticed smoke coming from the engine room

Mr Brown said it was some time before any information was given to those on board. One crew member then started "abruptly" telling passengers to "find something to hold on to".

He said he was "panicking inside", but tried to remain calm for his partner. He said "overall people were calm", but a "lack of communication" was worrying.

Within about an hour, the passengers were escorted off the ferry on to lifeboats and have now been told they can collect their cars and belongings from the vessel.

Pentland Ferries sails across the Pentland Firth from Gills Bay in Caithness to St Margaret's Hope on the Orkney Islands.

The Pentalina came back into service on Wednesday after time in dry dock to allow another ferry, the MV Alfred, to service other routes to islands on the west coast.

It suffered technical problems on Friday then on Saturday night the ferry grounded on the shoreline, about 100 yards (91m) from its destination in Orkney.

The 56 adults, three children, and a baby, as well as several dogs, were taken ashore by RNLI lifeboats.

There were no reports of injuries and passengers described the rescue operation as calm and professional.

A number of lifeboat crew were called out to the grounded ferry

A spokesman for the RMT said: "A thorough investigation will be needed to establish how this major incident aboard the Pentland Ferries vessel occurred."

Gordon Martin, Scottish Organiser for the RMT told BBC Scotland the union had "raised a number of safety concerns" over the years about the Pentalina.

He said: "A major disaster has been averted we could've had a real, real situation on our hands.

"We're going from a crisis to a farce in the ferry sector in Scotland at the moment," he added.

Last week, Pentland Ferries main vessel, the newer and larger catamaran MV Alfred, began a nine-month charter with CalMac on the west coast, which is costing the Scottish government £9m.

It is not clear when the MV Pentalina will return to service.

The MCA said the MV Pentalina was refloated at about 05:30 after being towed by a tug and taken to its berth in St Margaret's Hope.

A spokeswoman said there were no signs of pollution and added that the ferry would be surveyed to establish the extent of any damage.

She added that the Marine Accident Investigation Branch (MAIB) had been informed.

Coastguard teams from St Margaret's Hope, Stromness and Kirkwall and the Stromness and Longhope RNLI lifeboats were involved in the rescue.

Pentand Ferries said: "The vessel was moved from the beach to the linkspan at 6.30 this morning and is now undergoing a survey, from which we will know what (if any) damage has been sustained. Only when we know the extent of the problem, can we formulate a plan to resume service.

"The Maritime Coastguard Agency (MCA) is conducting a survey and the Marine Accident Investigation Branch are expected to arrive on Tuesday (2 May).

"We understand the impact this will have on the local community and those with travel plans. Our customer service team is currently contacting all pre-booked passengers to inform them of the situation. In the meantime, we thank everyone for their patience and understanding."

Transport Scotland said Pentland Ferries would assess the condition of the vessel and any next steps to determine whether there would be any loss of services on the Pentland Firth.

It said that any further action to support capacity to Orkney would be considered in due course.

A spokesperson said: "Ministers were quickly made aware of the incident involving the MV Pentalina and kept informed of developments throughout the night.

"We were relieved that all passengers and crew are safe and that arrangements were made to support passengers with onward travel. "We would also like to express our appreciation to all those involved in the evacuation, including RNLI crews and other emergency services."

'Pitiful lack of resilience'

Hayley Green, vice chairperson of Orkney's Local Emergency Co-ordination Group (OLECG) said: "The situation, including the impact on ferry provision across the Pentland Firth, will be reviewed over the coming days."

She praised the efforts of all agencies involved, including the local community and volunteer lifeboat crews.

Scottish Conservative MSP Jamie Halcro Johnston, who is from Orkney, said the incident exposed the "pitiful lack of resilience in Scotland's ferry network".

He said: "The Pentalina was only summoned back into action this week because the MV Alfred had to be seconded from Pentland Ferries to help plug gaps in the ageing, unreliable CalMac fleet.

"While it will be important to know just how this incident came about, my immediate concern is for what this means for Orkney and how long this vital link for our islands will be severed."

He added: "There are a number of questions the Scottish government needs to answer, including whether the £9m agreement between CalMac and Pentland Ferries allows for the MV Alfred to be recalled to Orkney early, or if the Alfred will stay on the west coast and Orkney will be left without a key service."

Orkney MSP Liam McArthur said there were also important questions for the Maritime and Coastguard Agency to answer over the fact that it had recently inspected and certified the Pentalina as fit for service.

He added: "Answers are required too from the Scottish government whose failure to procure new ferries in a timely fashion has left services both in the north and on the west coast extremely vulnerable. As a result islanders and island communities are left paying the price."

The MV Alfred ran aground in the Pentland Firth in Swona in July last year, with 97 people on board who were transferred to lifeboats.

No Sunday papers on the shelves

By BBC Scotland's Rob Flett in Orkney

The immediate impact of the disruption to Pentland Ferries service to mainland Scotland is already being felt in Orkney. There are no Sunday papers on the shelves here today.

As the Pentalina's passengers alighted from two buses last night they were keen to avoid making the headlines. People we spoke to, including regular travellers and first time visitors alike, appeared quite thrilled by the evacuation process. They had nothing but praise for the ferry's crew and also the RNLI who'd transported everyone to shore - including half a dozen dogs.

Pentland Ferries is a company which inspires fierce loyalty in Orkney. Over the last 20 years it has transformed travel to and from the islands without a penny of public subsidy. It serves the community to the east of the archipelago from its home port of St Margaret's Hope in South Ronaldsay.

Orkney's subsidised lifeline ferry service is operated by Northlink some 28 miles to the west in the town Stromness. The debate about the merits of each service can be intense and some people find it hard to hear any criticism of their favourite provider, no matter what happens.

Orkney is no different to any island community, which can often be fervent breeding grounds for rumour and gossip. Pentland Ferries main vessel, the newer and larger catamaran MV Alfred, grounded on the island of Swona in the Pentland Firth last July.

The Marine Accident Investigation Branch has yet to report the results of its inquiry, but most islanders will believe they know exactly what happened during that incident through information from their friends and contacts. Locally, the feeling here already is that the circumstances around this grounding of MV Pentalina are entirely different.

People are already demanding MV Alfred is brought back to Orkney from its charter to CalMac. By the time the MAIB releases any reports, the community will have long since moved on.

The cornerstone of Pentland Ferries' commercial success has been winning a great deal of the bread and butter freight traffic to the islands. It transports many of the trucks bringing essential food and supplies across the Pentland Firth, landing them in South Ronaldsay before they continue their journey by road across the four Churchill Barrier causeways constructed in World War Two, and on to local shops and suppliers.

Maintaining ferry capacity on the Pentland Firth is critical to keeping the shelves here supplied. The local debate is now raging about what, if anything, this latest incident says about the individual merits of Orkney's external ferry operators.

The big question is what will be done now to ensure the flow of goods, vehicles and people is maintained unhindered while any official investigations run their course.