Covid-19 and football: Should players be hugging?
- Published
- comments
Updated guidelines have been issued by the Premier League
Manchester City boss Pep Guardiola believes stopping players celebrating goals could prove "difficult" - but insists his side will follow new Premier League guidelines aimed at limiting contact.
It comes after footballers were reminded this week that "handshakes, high fives and hugs must be avoided" with extra scrutiny on every aspect of life under lockdown in a coronavirus pandemic.
"It is difficult. I don't know if we will be able to do it," Guardiola said, while stressing that players are frequently tested.
"We are going to do it, we are going to respect the protocols. But the moment you score a goal and one guy runs and the others don't go to celebrate with him, it is weird and uncomfortable."
Guardiola's side beat Brighton 1-0 on Wednesday and afterwards the Spaniard lamented not being able to shake the hand of his counterpart, Seagulls boss Graham Potter.
Potter agreed players might find it hard to change their habits but said he believed the seriousness of the situation would see them adapt.
"It is difficult but it should be manageable," he said.
BBC Sport looks at the arguments on both sides of this debate.
'Stand by for lots more controversy' - analysis
BBC sports editor Dan Roan
Regardless of how often players are tested, at a time when hospitals are overwhelmed and the government is desperate to persuade people to respect social distancing, it is easy to see why the scenes of players flouting football's rules on unnecessary contact when celebrating is unhelpful.
With most of us unable to hug our relatives, and so much in life and work shut down, the onus is naturally on those in elite sport to be seen to set the right example, follow what appear to be simple rules devised by top medics to minimise risk, and justify the privilege they enjoy in being allowed to carry on.
Others however, fear it is unfair and contradictory to ask players to provide entertainment, while at the same time suppressing their natural instincts. Some believe it is a tactic by politicians to divert from other issues, and robs the game of much-needed joy.
Ministers are not minded to suspend elite sport again at this stage. They recognise it is a welcome distraction for many, does not drive transmission in the community, and that protocols and testing have largely been a success. Another shutdown would be financially devastating for the sport industry.
But after players breached restrictions while off-duty over the festive period, and with the prospect of the national lockdown being tightened, the sports minister has now issued his sternest warning to date, and football's authorities are under pressure to punish transgressions, as has already been seen sports such as rugby league for instance.
Sadly, every goal celebration will now be scrutinised, and it will be fascinating to see what is deemed to be excessive, and whether the threat of fines changes behaviour. Stand by for lots more controversy.
Case for
Since it restarted after the first lockdown early last year, football has shown it can adapt and operate to the unprecedented circumstances it finds itself in.
Elite footballers are among the most tested people in the country, with those in the Premier League and English Football League (EFL) tested for coronavirus twice a week.
And, given the outside nature of the sport, the risk of transmission of the virus is lower.
In the updated guidelines issued by the Premier League this week, players were reminded of the importance of good hygiene and wearing face masks.
They were also reminded of the importance of social distancing, including during goal celebrations.
But in the spur of the moment, how could this be policed? Who could deny Sheffield United a little celebration after they secured their first win of the Premier League season on Tuesday night? Or when Manchester United went top of the table for the first time since the Sir Alex Ferguson era?
BBC football reporter Simon Stone says: "I have been lucky enough to go to a lot of games since Project Restart.
"Obviously there are no fans but aside from that and social distancing among substitutes and coaching staff, on the pitch, everything is more or less the same.
"Players argue with referees, managers moan at fourth officials, players dive, they deliberately foul and obstruct each other, they make hard tackles and try to get an edge that can make a difference. I would say they are 'in the zone' of being an athlete."
The Premier League has reiterated that protocols include a ban on players shaking hands or hugging
Case against
Quite simply, we are in a global pandemic. More than 80,000 people have died with coronavirus in the UK alone, and we are, once again, living under lockdown.
For almost a year, we have been unable to hug loved ones and many people have not left their home in months, while parents are having to take on the added pressures of home-schooling their children.
So when they are seeing players embracing each other after goals, singing their hearts out in changing rooms, arms flung around shoulders, it is, for some, a kick in the teeth.
England's Deputy Chief Medical Officer, Jonathan Van-Tam, is among those who have called for players to show restraint when celebrating.
When asked whether players should be hugging after a goal, he told LBC Radio on Wednesday: "Every close human contact that is avoidable should be avoided because one in three of us will get the infection and have no symptoms at all."
But it's not just on-the-field breaches or those within the football environment which are causing issues. Over the festive period, there were several breaches of coronavirus protocols with players from various clubs attending or hosting parties.
In recent weeks, many clubs have reported outbreaks of coronavirus, leading to several Premier League matches being postponed.
Reaction
Allow Twitter content?
This article contains content provided by Twitter. We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as they may be using cookies and other technologies. You may want to read Twitter’s cookie policy, external and privacy policy, external before accepting. To view this content choose ‘accept and continue’.
Speaking after Manchester United's win over Burnley on Tuesday, manager Ole Gunnar Solskjaer said: "It's an emotional game. We have to understand the players when they celebrate."
However, he did concede that they "understand the concern nowadays for a bit of less emotions and less hugging".
Crystal Palace manager Roy Hodgson said: "People have ingrained habits when a goal is scored. The emotion and joy of that moment, there is a risk players will still run to each other. I don't know what managers and coaches can do more than hammer home the messages and protocols."
"We want to adhere as closely as we can because we understand the seriousness of it," Brighton's Graham Potter said.
"We will do our best. Unfortunately sometimes the brain is a sub-conscious one and you are just there in the moment. You are not thinking. It is an instinctive reaction but clearly we want to reduce that because we respect why the protocols are there, why the rules are there and we want to do our best with that."
Although Manchester City's Pep Guardiola felt ignoring instinct could prove difficult for players, he stressed Premier League clubs were working hard to minimise risk.
"We are tested maybe five or six times in the last 10 days. Everyone is negative. We are outdoors where the virus is less aggressive."
Mark Wright joins Crawley Town: Can the TV personality make it as a pro footballer?
The Serpent: New drama brings the chilling crimes of Charles Sobhraj to life
