BBC Homepage
  • Skip to content
  • Accessibility Help
  • Your account
  • Notifications
  • Home
  • News
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • iPlayer
  • Sounds
  • Bitesize
  • CBBC
  • CBeebies
  • Food
  • More menu
More menu
Search BBC
  • Home
  • News
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • iPlayer
  • Sounds
  • Bitesize
  • CBBC
  • CBeebies
  • Food
Close menu
BBC Sport
Menu
  • Home
  • Football
  • Cricket
  • Formula 1
  • Rugby U
  • Rugby L
  • Tennis
  • Golf
  • Boxing
  • Athletics
  • My Sport
More
A-Z Sports
  • American Football
  • Athletics
  • Basketball
  • Boxing
  • Cricket
  • Cycling
  • Darts
  • Disability Sport
  • Football
  • Formula 1
  • Gaelic Games
  • Golf
  • Gymnastics
  • Horse Racing
  • Mixed Martial Arts
  • Motorsport
  • Netball
  • Olympic Sports
  • Rugby League
  • Rugby Union
  • Snooker
  • Swimming
  • Tennis
  • Winter Sports
  • Full Sports A-Z
More from Sport
  • England
  • Scotland
  • Wales
  • Northern Ireland
  • My Sport
  • Match of the Day
  • Sports Personality
  • 5 Live Sport
  • News Feeds
  • Help & FAQs
  • Football
  • Scores & Fixtures
  • Tables
  • Gossip
  • Transfers
  • Top Scorers
  • Women
  • Champions League
  • FA Cup
  • All Teams
  • Leagues & Cups
  • Quizzes

Hearts II v East Stirlingshire

Match Summary

Fri 7 Nov 2025
‧
Highland / Lowland -
Lowland League
Hearts II 3 , East Stirlingshire 3 at Full time
HeartsHearts IIHearts II
3
3
East StirlingEast StirlingshireEast Stirlingshire
Full time
FT
Half Time Hearts II 0 , East Stirlingshire 2
HT 0-2

Key Events

Hearts II

  • C. Dow (55', 90' pen)Goal 55 minutes, Penalty 90 minutes
  • K. Smutek (64')Goal 64 minutes

East Stirlingshire

  • F. Malcolm (7', 15')Goal 7 minutes, Goal 15 minutes
  • M. Docherty (67' pen)Penalty 67 minutes
Assists
Hearts II,O. Muirhead (64')
East Stirlingshire,S. O’Neill (15')

Venue:The Vanloq Community Stadium
  • Scores (active)
  • Tables
  • Line-ups
  • Head-to-head

Highland / Lowland Scores & Fixtures

Friday 7th November

Hearts II 3 , East Stirlingshire 3 at Full time
HeartsHearts IIHearts II
3
3
East StirlingEast StirlingshireEast Stirlingshire
Full time
FT
View all Highland / Lowland fixtures

Highland / Lowland Table

On Friday 7th November
Skip to table keyMatch Participants:
  • East Stirlingshire, Position 18, Points 8
TeamPlayedWonDrawnLostGoals ForGoals AgainstGoal DifferencePointsForm, Last 6 games, Oldest first
1
Clydebank
15113144152936
  • D
    Result Draw
  • W
    Result Win
  • W
    Result Win
  • W
    Result Win
  • L
    Result Loss
  • W
    Result Win
2
Linlithgow Rose
15110445202533
  • W
    Result Win
  • W
    Result Win
  • L
    Result Loss
  • L
    Result Loss
  • L
    Result Loss
  • W
    Result Win
3
Tranent
16102434171732
  • L
    Result Loss
  • W
    Result Win
  • W
    Result Win
  • W
    Result Win
  • W
    Result Win
  • W
    Result Win
4
Broxburn Athletic
16101538261231
  • W
    Result Win
  • W
    Result Win
  • W
    Result Win
  • W
    Result Win
  • W
    Result Win
  • L
    Result Loss
5
Bonnyrigg Rose
1583432171527
  • L
    Result Loss
  • D
    Result Draw
  • W
    Result Win
  • W
    Result Win
  • W
    Result Win
  • W
    Result Win
6
Bo'ness United
158253324926
  • L
    Result Loss
  • D
    Result Draw
  • W
    Result Win
  • L
    Result Loss
  • W
    Result Win
  • W
    Result Win
7
Caledonian Braves
147342718924
  • W
    Result Win
  • D
    Result Draw
  • L
    Result Loss
  • D
    Result Draw
  • W
    Result Win
  • W
    Result Win
8
Cumbernauld Colts
167363027324
  • W
    Result Win
  • L
    Result Loss
  • D
    Result Draw
  • W
    Result Win
  • W
    Result Win
  • W
    Result Win
9
Celtic II
155552734-720
  • D
    Result Draw
  • L
    Result Loss
  • W
    Result Win
  • L
    Result Loss
  • W
    Result Win
  • L
    Result Loss
10
Stirling University
165473642-619
  • W
    Result Win
  • W
    Result Win
  • L
    Result Loss
  • W
    Result Win
  • L
    Result Loss
  • D
    Result Draw
11
Berwick Rangers
155462733-619
  • W
    Result Win
  • L
    Result Loss
  • W
    Result Win
  • L
    Result Loss
  • W
    Result Win
  • L
    Result Loss
12
Cowdenbeath
165471929-1019
  • W
    Result Win
  • L
    Result Loss
  • D
    Result Draw
  • L
    Result Loss
  • L
    Result Loss
  • D
    Result Draw
13
CS Strollers
165382138-1718
  • W
    Result Win
  • W
    Result Win
  • W
    Result Win
  • L
    Result Loss
  • L
    Result Loss
  • L
    Result Loss
14
Gala Fairydean Rovers
155282130-917
  • L
    Result Loss
  • L
    Result Loss
  • L
    Result Loss
  • L
    Result Loss
  • L
    Result Loss
  • D
    Result Draw
15
Albion Rovers
155282539-1417
  • L
    Result Loss
  • L
    Result Loss
  • L
    Result Loss
  • L
    Result Loss
  • W
    Result Win
  • L
    Result Loss
16
Hearts II
173682636-1015
  • L
    Result Loss
  • L
    Result Loss
  • W
    Result Win
  • L
    Result Loss
  • L
    Result Loss
  • D
    Result Draw
17
Gretna 2008
1623112647-219
  • L
    Result Loss
  • L
    Result Loss
  • D
    Result Draw
  • L
    Result Loss
  • W
    Result Win
  • D
    Result Draw
18
East Stirlingshire
1722132948-198
  • W
    Result Win
  • L
    Result Loss
  • L
    Result Loss
  • L
    Result Loss
  • L
    Result Loss
  • D
    Result Draw
View latest Highland / Lowland table

Key

  • Position 1 : Champion Play-off

Last Updated 7th November 2025 at 21:41

Please Note: All times UK. Tables are subject to change. The BBC is not responsible for any changes that may be made.

Team Lineups

home team, Hearts II

Manager: Angus Beith

Formation: 4 - 4 - 2

Pitch Formation

Diagram of half a football pitch showing the home team formation.
  • 23, Lyon, Goalkeeper
    23
    Lyon
  • 17, Alfie Wilson, Defender
    17
    Alfie Wilson
    4, Smutek, Defender
    4
    Smutek
    6, Osborne, Defender
    6
    Osborne
    3, Lister, Defender
    3
    Lister
  • 29, Donkor, Midfielder
    29
    Donkor
    25, Walker, Midfielder
    25
    Walker
    24, Wilson, Midfielder
    24
    Wilson
    10, Haddow, Midfielder
    10
    Haddow
  • 27, Robb, Striker
    27
    Robb
    9, Dow, Striker
    9
    Dow

Starting lineup

  • Number 23,
    J. Lyon
  • Number 3,
    H. Lister
  • Number 6,
    A. Osborne
  • Number 4,
    K. Smutek (c), Captain
  • Number 17,
    A. Wilson
  • Number 10,
    A. Haddow O. Muirhead 40', substituted for O. Muirhead at 40 minutes
  • Number 24,
    S. Wilson
  • Number 25,
    L. Walker G. Crookston 72', substituted for G. Crookston at 72 minutes
  • Number 29,
    J. Donkor
  • Number 9,
    C. Dow
  • Number 27,
    C. Robb

Substitutes

home team, Hearts II

  • Number 2,
    G. Crookston
  • Number 14,
    O. Muirhead
  • Number 7,
    M. Ross
  • Number 5,
    L. Smith
  • Number 21,
    L. Tas

away team, East Stirlingshire

Manager: Callum Tapping

Formation: 4 - 4 - 2

Pitch Formation

Diagram of half a football pitch showing the away team formation.
  • 1, Cantley, Goalkeeper
    1
    Cantley
  • 11, O’Neill, Defender
    11
    O’Neill
    6, Gomis, Defender
    6
    Gomis
    3, Docherty, Defender
    3
    Docherty
    25, Kenzie Mitchell, Defender
    25
    Kenzie Mitchell
  • 18, Hislop, Midfielder
    18
    Hislop
    16, McCafferty, Midfielder
    16
    McCafferty
    15, MacDonald, Midfielder
    15
    MacDonald
    10, Murray, Midfielder
    10
    Murray
  • 14, Malcolm, Striker
    14
    Malcolm
    9, McRoberts, Striker
    9
    McRoberts

Starting lineup

  • Number 1,
    J. Cantley
  • Number 25,
    K. Mitchell
  • Number 3,
    M. Docherty
  • Number 6,
    M. Gomis (c), Captain
  • Number 11,
    S. O’Neill
  • Number 10,
    C. Murray A. Taylor 63', substituted for A. Taylor at 63 minutes
  • Number 15,
    A. MacDonald
  • Number 16,
    F. McCafferty
  • Number 18,
    J. Hislop 33', Yellow Card at 33 minutes
  • Number 9,
    L. McRoberts B. Lamont 26', substituted for B. Lamont at 26 minutes
  • Number 14,
    F. Malcolm C. Dowie 80', substituted for C. Dowie at 80 minutes

away team, East Stirlingshire

  • Number 19,
    C. Dowie
  • Number 7,
    B. Lamont
  • Number 20,
    A. MacAlpine
  • Number 21,
    N. Mitchell
  • Number 12,
    C. Tapping
  • Number 23,
    A. Taylor
  • Hearts II (active)
  • East Stirlingshire

home team, Hearts II

Manager: Angus Beith

Formation: 4 - 4 - 2

Pitch Formation

Diagram of half a football pitch showing the home team formation.
  • 23, Lyon, Goalkeeper
    23
    Lyon
  • 17, Alfie Wilson, Defender
    17
    Alfie Wilson
    4, Smutek, Defender
    4
    Smutek
    6, Osborne, Defender
    6
    Osborne
    3, Lister, Defender
    3
    Lister
  • 29, Donkor, Midfielder
    29
    Donkor
    25, Walker, Midfielder
    25
    Walker
    24, Wilson, Midfielder
    24
    Wilson
    10, Haddow, Midfielder
    10
    Haddow
  • 27, Robb, Striker
    27
    Robb
    9, Dow, Striker
    9
    Dow

Starting lineup

  • Number 23,
    J. Lyon
  • Number 3,
    H. Lister
  • Number 6,
    A. Osborne
  • Number 4,
    K. Smutek (c), Captain
  • Number 17,
    A. Wilson
  • Number 10,
    A. Haddow O. Muirhead 40', substituted for O. Muirhead at 40 minutes
  • Number 24,
    S. Wilson
  • Number 25,
    L. Walker G. Crookston 72', substituted for G. Crookston at 72 minutes
  • Number 29,
    J. Donkor
  • Number 9,
    C. Dow
  • Number 27,
    C. Robb

Substitutes

  • Number 2,
    G. Crookston
  • Number 14,
    O. Muirhead
  • Number 7,
    M. Ross
  • Number 5,
    L. Smith
  • Number 21,
    L. Tas

away team, East Stirlingshire

Manager: Callum Tapping

Formation: 4 - 4 - 2

Pitch Formation

Diagram of half a football pitch showing the away team formation.
  • 1, Cantley, Goalkeeper
    1
    Cantley
  • 11, O’Neill, Defender
    11
    O’Neill
    6, Gomis, Defender
    6
    Gomis
    3, Docherty, Defender
    3
    Docherty
    25, Kenzie Mitchell, Defender
    25
    Kenzie Mitchell
  • 18, Hislop, Midfielder
    18
    Hislop
    16, McCafferty, Midfielder
    16
    McCafferty
    15, MacDonald, Midfielder
    15
    MacDonald
    10, Murray, Midfielder
    10
    Murray
  • 14, Malcolm, Striker
    14
    Malcolm
    9, McRoberts, Striker
    9
    McRoberts

Starting lineup

  • Number 1,
    J. Cantley
  • Number 25,
    K. Mitchell
  • Number 3,
    M. Docherty
  • Number 6,
    M. Gomis (c), Captain
  • Number 11,
    S. O’Neill
  • Number 10,
    C. Murray A. Taylor 63', substituted for A. Taylor at 63 minutes
  • Number 15,
    A. MacDonald
  • Number 16,
    F. McCafferty
  • Number 18,
    J. Hislop 33', Yellow Card at 33 minutes
  • Number 9,
    L. McRoberts B. Lamont 26', substituted for B. Lamont at 26 minutes
  • Number 14,
    F. Malcolm C. Dowie 80', substituted for C. Dowie at 80 minutes

Substitutes

  • Number 19,
    C. Dowie
  • Number 7,
    B. Lamont
  • Number 20,
    A. MacAlpine
  • Number 21,
    N. Mitchell
  • Number 12,
    C. Tapping
  • Number 23,
    A. Taylor

Match Officials

Referee:
Clyde Buchan
Assistant Referee 1:
Liam Coulter
Assistant Referee 2:
Alexander Anderson

Head to Head

Season so far

Highland / Lowland

  • Skip to form guide
  • Skip to previous meetings
  • Skip to previous scores
Hearts

Key

East Stirling
Key, Hearts v East Stirling
16th

League position

18th
League position, Hearts II 16th, East Stirlingshire 18th
15

Total points

8
Total points, Hearts II 15, East Stirlingshire 8

Form guide

All competitions

  • Skip to previous meetings
  • Skip to previous scores
  • Skip back to season so far
Hearts II
East Stirlingshire
L
Hearts II lose
v Bo'ness United
3
1
Highland / Lowland
L
East Stirlingshire lose
v Cumbernauld Colts
3
2
Highland / Lowland
L
Hearts II lose
v Celtic II
0
1
Highland / Lowland
L
East Stirlingshire lose
v Gretna 2008
2
3
Highland / Lowland
W
Hearts II won
v Linlithgow Rose
3
0
Highland / Lowland
L
East Stirlingshire lose
v Clydebank
3
1
Scottish Cup
L
Hearts II lose
v Berwick Rangers
1
3
Highland / Lowland
L
East Stirlingshire lose
v Stirling University
5
3
Highland / Lowland
L
Hearts II lose
v East Kilbride
3
2
Challenge Cup
L
East Stirlingshire lose
v Tranent
2
4
Highland / Lowland

Previous meetings

All competitions

  • Skip to previous scores
  • Skip back to form guide
  • Skip back to season so far
Hearts II and East Stirlingshire

Played 6

HEA
Won
5
EST
Won
0
Draw
1
Draw 1
Hearts II Won 5East Stirlingshire Won 0

Previous scores

All competitions

  • Skip back to previous meetings
  • Skip back to form guide
  • Skip back to season so far

Highland / Lowland

East Stirlingshire 1 , Hearts II 2 on the 22nd of February 2025
East StirlingEast StirlingshireEast Stirlingshire
1
2
HeartsHearts IIHearts II
22nd of February 2025
22 FEB 2025
Hearts II 4 , East Stirlingshire 1 on the 26th of July 2024
HeartsHearts IIHearts II
4
1
East StirlingEast StirlingshireEast Stirlingshire
26th of July 2024
26 JUL 2024
Hearts II 5 , East Stirlingshire 3 on the 5th of April 2024
HeartsHearts IIHearts II
5
3
East StirlingEast StirlingshireEast Stirlingshire
5th of April 2024
5 APR 2024

Best of the BBC

  • Nicôle Lecky's provocative new drama is here

    • Attribution
      iPlayer

    Added to Watchlist
    Wild Cherry has been added to your iPlayer Watchlist.
    Wild Cherry
  • Side-splitting comedy starring Lucy Punch and Joanna Lumley

    • Attribution
      iPlayer

    Added to Watchlist
    Amandaland has been added to your iPlayer Watchlist.
    Amandaland
  • The award-winning spy thriller starring Tom Hiddleston

    • Attribution
      iPlayer

    Added to Watchlist
    The Night Manager has been added to your iPlayer Watchlist.
    The Night Manager
  • Daddy Issues is back for a new series

    • Attribution
      iPlayer

    Added to Watchlist
    Daddy Issues has been added to your iPlayer Watchlist.
    Daddy Issues
  • Home
  • News
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • iPlayer
  • Sounds
  • Bitesize
  • CBBC
  • CBeebies
  • Food
  • Terms of Use
  • About the BBC
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookies
  • Accessibility Help
  • Parental Guidance
  • Contact the BBC
  • Make an editorial complaint
  • BBC emails for you

Copyright © 2025 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.