Summary

Phil McNulty Q&A - get your questions in

  1. Postpublished at 13:32 BST

    Alex Fletcher
    BBC Sport journalist

    Looks like we've got a split for who takes that spot down the left-hand side of England's attack.

    Anthony Gordon, Phil Foden and Jack Grealish are all good options.

    Gordon arguably has had the best of the last 12 months but there is no denying Foden's quality and Grealish has started this season superbly.

    Who'd want to be Thomas Tuchel? Not me.

    Over to you Phil McNulty...

  2. 'Grealish has an uphill battle to get into the squad'published at 13:24 BST

    McNulty Q&A

    Phil McNulty
    BBC Sport chief football writer

    Jack GrealishImage source, Getty Images

    Mark: Hi. Do you think Jack Grealish has a future in Tuchel’s plans?

    Morning, Mark. I think it is going to be tough for him, despite making such an outstanding start at Everton this season.

    Tuchel is a confirmed admirer, but he has so many other players in contention where Grealish would play, either as a “number 10” or on the left-flank. I think Tuchel will continue to watch Grealish as he does like him, but I think he has an uphill battle to get back into the England squad

  3. Get involved - McNulty's starting XI reactionpublished at 13:17 BST

    Get in touch with the form at the top of this page

    Looks like one Phil backing another is proving to be a point of contention.

    Phil McNulty has Phil Foden in his starting XI.

    Scratching my head as to what Foden has done in 45 caps to deserve a starting spot. Good performances against Iceland in 2020+ Wales in 2022 are the only ones I can think of. Literally any other forward who has played for England in that time is a better option.

    Stephen

    England line up: GK Pickford, LB Skelly, CB Guehi, CB Konsa, RB Spence/James, CDM Anderson/Wharton, CM Rice, CAM Bellingham, LW Gordon, RW Saka, ST Kane.

    Jack

    England XI- Pickford; James, Stones, Guehi, Lewis Skelly/Hall; Bellingham, Wharton, Rice; Saka, Kane, Eze. As much as I like Foden, he hasn't done it for England. Wharton needs to be in this team - gives Rice the freedom he has at Arsenal.

    RP

  4. 'England’s world does not revolve around Bellingham'published at 13:12 BST

    McNulty Q&A

    Phil McNulty
    BBC Sport chief football writer

    Thomas Tuchel and Jude BellinghamImage source, Getty Images

    Justin: Phil - what is your take on the Jude Bellingham/England situation? Is the coach right and is avoiding a star system to build a team mentality or cutting his nose off to spite his face?

    I actually think the decision to exclude Jude Bellingham from the latest England squad was based on sound common sense because when the squad was selected he had only started one game for Real Madrid after shoulder surgery.

    Tuchel has also taken to opportunity to demonstrate that England’s world does not revolve around Jude Bellingham – and I have no problem with that either.

    I covered England when Sven-Goran Eriksson effectively operated a star system, shoe-horning all his biggest players into his starting eleven rather than build a team. It did not work. Tuchel has expressly stated it is the team that matters.

    I do not believe for one second that Bellingham will not be in England’s World Cup squad and he will most likely be in the team. Tuchel, however, is within his rights to show loyalty to those who have performed for him.

  5. Postpublished at 13:10 BST

    Alex Fletcher
    BBC Sport journalist

    So it is likely that Jude Bellingham goes to the World Cup.

    But, there are questions around his involvement in the starting XI.

    Do England need to play him?

  6. 'I do not believe Tuchel would exclude Bellingham'published at 13:05 BST

    McNulty Q&A

    Phil McNulty
    BBC Sport chief football writer

    Bellingham and TuchelImage source, Getty Images

    Luke: Hi Phil. Obviously Tuchel clearly values a settled team, do you think that might stretch as far as omitting the likes of Jude Bellingham and Phil Foden altogether for the World Cup? Surely, no matter what, we're better with them in the team, let alone the squad?

    I was asked earlier to pick my team for England’s first World Cup game if the tournament started next week and included both, so I obviously think Thomas Tuchel’s side would be better with them included.

    I do not believe for one second Tuchel would exclude Bellingham from his squad and believe he will start the first game if fit. I think Foden faces more of a battle as there is a lot of competition, but I would include him.

  7. Get involved - McNulty's starting XI reactionpublished at 13:04 BST

    Get in touch with the form at the top of this page

    Jude Bellingham did make Phil McNulty's starting XI, but the selections made by BBC Sport's chief football writer did not meet universal approval...

    Foden on the left wing? He never plays there. It has to be Gordon, Rashford or Grealish.

    Chris

    I can agree with most of Phil's team. I'd just swap Foden for Grealish at the moment, he's more in form and better at sticking to the wings. Foden still likes to come inside too much for me.

    Matt

    With all players fit, my XI would be: Pickford; Spence, Stones, Guehi, Hall; Rice, Bellingham (as an 8), Foden (as 10); Eze, Kane, Saka

    Harry

  8. What has happened with Bellingham?published at 13:01 BST

    Latvia v England (19:45 BST)

    Bellingham and Thomas TuchelImage source, Getty Images

    One final question before we give the floor back to Phil McNulty.

    At the start of the year it would seem unthinkable to have an England squad for the World Cup without Jude Bellingham in it.

    However, the Real Madrid midfielder has missed the first two camps of the season, the first through injury and the second because he was not selected.

    England manager Thomas Tuchel on Bellingham in June: "If he smiles, he wins everyone [over]. But sometimes you see the rage, the hunger and the fire and it comes out in a way that can be a bit repulsive, for example, for my mother when she sits in front of the TV. I see that but, in general, we are very happy to have him. He's a special boy."

    Tuchel has since apologised for the statement, saying the use of the word repulsive was "unintentional" but the situation provided an awkward stage of their relationship.

    The England manager admitted earlier this month that England are a "better team" with Bellingham in it, but said they could not cancel the World Cup if he was unavailable through injury.

    It is highly likely he will still be selected for the squad next summer, but will he be in the starting XI?

  9. If not Kane, who else?published at 12:59 BST

    Latvia v England (19:45 BST)

    Harry KaneImage source, Getty Images

    Which leads us back to this question.

    Harry Kane might be the first name on the England team sheet but the biggest problem is who could replace him?

    Let's take a look at Thomas Tuchel's centre-forward options:

    Ollie Watkins: Appearances - 20 Goals - 6

    Watkins made his England debut in 2021 and netted six times in 20 appearances, including hitting the winner in England's Euros 2024 semi-final win over the Netherlands. The forward has struggled at club level this term, netting just once in 10 games.

    Marcus Rashford: Appearances - 65 Goals - 18

    So far this season, the Manchester United man, on loan at Barcelona, has three goals in 10 appearances. The 27-year-old has experience on his side. Rashford has 18 goals for England - the most after Kane in Tuchel's current squad.

    Dominic Solanke: Appearances - 3 Goals - 0

    Tottenham's record signing Solanke has yet to be called up to a Tuchel England squad and is another striker battling an injury. The 28-year-old has managed just 31 minutes of Premier League football this season.

    Liam Delap: Appearances - 0 Goals - 0

    A summer move to Chelsea may have seen Delap have one eye on the World Cup. However, three games into the season he tore his hamstring and has yet to make his international debut.

    Ivan Toney: Appearances - 7 Goals - 1

    The 29-year-old was used as an impact sub during Euro 2024, assisting Kane's extra-time winner in the last 16 and scoring his spot-kick in the shootout in the quarter-finals. Toney's last match for England was a two-minute cameo in a 3-1 defeat by Senegal in June.

  10. Who are the first names to be selected?published at 12:56 BST

    Latvia v England (19:45 BST)

    Kane, Rice and PickfordImage source, Getty Images

    There are few 'guarantees' when it comes to selecting a squad for a major tournament, injuries could prove disruptive over the course of the season, but there are some players who are highly likely to get their place in Thomas Tuchel's squad.

    Harry Kane: Appearances - 109

    The England captain is arguably the first name on the team sheet for the Three Lions. His six goals at the World Cup in 2018 won him the Golden Boot and helped England to a first semi-final in 28 years. The 32-year-old is the country's all-time leading goalscorer and has played at five major tournaments.

    Jordan Pickford: Appearances - 79

    As important as Kane is, Pickford has been England's number one at the last four major tournaments and has played a huge role in the development of the national team in recent years. His experience will no doubt prove crucial next summer, not to mention the fact he's saved four penalties in major tournament shootouts - more on his England form in a moment.

    Declan Rice: Appearances - 69

    Rice was captain in the absence of Kane against Wales last week and is another significant leader on the pitch for England. The 26-year-old is entering the peak of his career and has been a part of the England squad for the past three major tournaments.

  11. How many players can England take to the World Cup?published at 12:53 BST

    Latvia v England (19:45 BST)

    EnglandImage source, Getty Images

    More on that Kane question in a moment, but first we are going to ask you to step into England manager Thomas Tuchel's shoes.

    He still has time to decide who will be on the plane for next summer's World Cup, should his side qualify for the tournament tonight.

    Fifa are yet to confirm squad sizes for next summer, but for the 2022 tournament in Qatar they increased the limit to 26.

    The change was largely due to the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, with previous years only allowing squad of 23 players.

  12. Postpublished at 12:51 BST

    Craig Nelson
    BBC Sport reporter

    An injury to a key player seems to be part and parcel of England's build-up to any major tournament.

    It's about this time that England fans become experts in obscure body parts, such as metatarsals.

    As part of this Three Lions tradition, the injured player is often a key member of the squad.

    With such a vast array of talent to choose from, Thomas Tuchel could probably point to a ready-made replacement in almost every position.

    But as Chris Sutton said, take Harry Kane out of the side and England are suddenly viewed in a very different light.

    With that in mind, we asked you to ponder: If not Kane, then who else?

  13. 'Plenty of time for Tuchel to study all of his options'published at 12:43 BST

    McNulty Q&A

    Phil McNulty
    BBC Sport chief football writer

    Thomas Tuchel in trainingImage source, Getty Images

    Jack: I know we have a decent record in international competitions of late, but we still have problems creating and scoring against better teams. I feel Tuchel is still not sure of his best line-up. We seem to play quicker and more freely without Kane but lack goal threat. What do you think?

    Afternoon Jack. I suspect in his own mind Thomas Tuchel is very close to formulating most (if not all) of his best line-up, but there is no reason why he needs to know his best side yet and there is still plenty of time to study all of his options.

    I was asked earlier what would be my England team for the first World Cup game if the tournament started next week. As an example, I picked Elliott Anderson but I can’t get away from the fact that I think Adam Wharton could also be an outstanding international.

    As for Kane, Chris Sutton said last week that if the Bayern Munich striker quit international football today you would immediately view England in a totally different light. England are better for having Harry Kane. As might be discovered if he is ever injured for any length of time.

  14. England looking to make it 37 qualifiers unbeatenpublished at 12:35 BST

    Paul Birch
    BBC Sport

    If England avoid defeat tonight in Latvia it will extend their unbeaten run in World Cup qualifiers to 37 matches and would lift the Three Lions into outright second on the all-time Uefa list.

    However, they are still a long way off catching Spain, who went an incredible 66 World Cup qualifiers without a loss between 1993 and 2021. Their run of 52 wins and 14 draws was finally ended by Sweden.

    England last lost a qualifying match for a World Cup back in October 2009 against Ukraine and have won 28 and drawn eight of their 36 games since.

    They have only lost a total of four World Cup qualifiers in the past 30 years, while their last defeat in a Euros qualifier was away at Czech Republic in October 2019.

    Belgium are not far behind England, their victory over Wales last night took them to 34 World Cup qualifiers without defeat.

    If you include the European Championship, their unbeaten streak in qualifiers across the two tournaments is a very impressive 56 games dating back to 2015.

    Graphic showing the best unbeaten runs in Uefa World Cup qualifying matches
  15. Postpublished at 12:33 BST

    Latvia v England (19:45 BST)

    Craig Nelson
    BBC Sport reporter

    As you can see, questions are already being put to Phil about England's participation in the 2026 World Cup, as if they are already there.

    It certainly feels more like a case of "when" rather than "if", especially considering England's recent record in qualifiers - more on that in a minute.

    Before we check out that record, have a read of this post from earlier, which explains what England need from their final three matches to secure automatic qualification...

  16. 'Teams will have to adapt to the heat'published at 12:29 BST

    McNulty Q&A

    Phil McNulty
    BBC Sport chief football writer

    FIFA World Cup 2026 StadiumImage source, Getty Images

    Nick: How much do you think the heat will impact on England's chances at the World Cup next summer? I think back to Shizouka in 2002 when the players were running on empty in the second half against Brazil, even against 10 men.

    Tell me about it, Nick. I was in Shizuoka covering that game for the BBC. To say it was hot and humid is putting it mildly. It was incredibly uncomfortable just watching. England’s cause was not helped by David Beckham being clearly unfit as well.

    I am sure preparation techniques and data have moved on a fair bit since then so I'm pretty certain Thomas Tuchel and his sports scientists will be absorbing every piece of information.

    Other European teams will also have to adapt.

    If England do not perform, I do not believe it will be down to the climate.

  17. Phil McNulty Q&A - recappublished at 12:24 BST

    Right, we are up to speed on the European qualifying groups, so let's return to England, team selection and our Q&A with BBC Sport's chief football writer Phil McNulty.

    Phil has been flying through your questions, so make sure you keep sending them in to us using the Get Involved button.

    Just joining us? Let's take a look at some of what you've missed so far:

    We have also brought you the latest from the England camp as Harry Kane is declared fit to start by Tuchel, who has also challenged Marcus Rashford to reach his full potential.

    In other news, four England fans have been arrested in Riga ahead of tonight's match.

    And Alexander Isak and Viktor Gyokeres are involved in a real struggle to qualify with Sweden.

  18. Where do Wales stand?published at 12:16 BST

    Wales 2-4 Belgium

    Wales

    Group J table

    Wales went into last night's match at home to Belgium knowing that victory in their final three games would secure top spot in Group J and automatic qualification.

    They took the lead through Joe Rodon's seventh-minute header, but their lead was wiped out by Kevin de Bruyne's controversial penalty and the visitors took the lead through a hammer blow from Thomas Meunier.

    Another penalty from De Bruyne in the second half and fourth goal from Arsenal's Leandro Trossard, either side of a fine strike from Wales' Nathan Broadhead sealed a 4-2 win for Belgium.

    Wales' hopes of qualifying for the World Cup now rest largely on securing a play-off spot.

    North Macedonia were held at home by Kazakhstan, meaning the two sides are now left in a shootout for second place, should Belgium finish top of the group.

    Next up for Wales is a trip to bottom side Liechtenstein.

    Win that and their final game at home to North Macedonia will be a winner-takes-all-match at the Cardiff City Stadium.

  19. Does qualifying need a change in format?published at 12:09 BST

    McNulty Q&A

    Phil McNulty
    BBC Sport chief football writer

    FIFA Qualifiers bannerImage source, Getty Images

    Tom: Phil, do you think the Euros qualification would benefit from the new Champions League format? Feels like it would lead to more exciting matches against the better European nations, less friendlies, quicker playoffs etc.

    Hello, Tom. I can certainly see why such a move would be considered because there is a danger too many of the qualifiers are simply very routine these days. It would need a lot of thinking through, though, purely because of the number of countries involved.

  20. Woltemade scores first international goalpublished at 12:04 BST

    Northern Ireland 0-1 Germany

    Germany

    It was a memorable night for Newcastle United's record signing Nick Woltemade in Belfast.

    The £69m signing from Stuttgart is finding his feet in the Premier League and his goal against Northern Ireland - however fortunate the final touch - will be a pleasurable sight for Magpies fans.

    Germany now top Group A on goal difference, with games against Luxembourg and Slovakia to come in the November international break.

    Take a look for yourself... sometimes it doesn't matter how they go in, as long as they go in!

    Media caption,

    Woltemade nets first Germany goal