BBC Homepage

Skip to content
Accessibility Help

Notifications

Home
News
Sport
Weather
iPlayer
Sounds
Bitesize
CBBC
CBeebies
Food
More menu

More menu

Search BBC

Home
News
Sport
Weather
iPlayer
Sounds
Bitesize
CBBC
CBeebies
Food

Close menu

BBC Sport

Home
Football
Cricket
Formula 1
Rugby U
Rugby L
Tennis
Golf
Boxing
Athletics

A-Z Sports

American Football
Athletics
Basketball
Boxing
Cricket
Cycling
Darts
Disability Sport
Football
Formula 1
Gaelic Games
Golf
Gymnastics
Horse Racing
Mixed Martial Arts
Motorsport
Netball
Olympic Sports
Rugby League
Rugby Union
Snooker
Swimming
Tennis
Winter Sports
Full Sports A-Z

More from Sport

England
Scotland
Wales
Northern Ireland
My Sport
Match of the Day
Sports Personality
5 Live Sport
News Feeds
Help & FAQs

Football
Scores & Fixtures
Tables
Gossip
Transfers
Top Scorers
Women
Champions League
FA Cup
All Teams
Leagues & Cups
Quizzes

Challenge Cup Dundee United 3 Dunfermline Athletic 0 Full time

Match Summary

Sat 9 Sep 2023

‧

Challenge Cup -

3rd Round

Dundee United 3 , Dunfermline Athletic 0 at Full time

Dundee UtdDundee UnitedDundee United

DunfermlineDunfermline AthleticDunfermline Athletic

Full time

Half Time Dundee United 3 , Dunfermline Athletic 0

HT 3-0

Key Events

Dundee United

L. Moult Goal 18 minutes
A. Comrie Own Goal 34 minutes
D. Glass Goal 37 minutes

Dunfermline Athletic

Assists

Dundee United,K. Fotheringham (18', 37')

Venue:CalForth Construction Arena at Tannadice Park

Attendance:2,408

Scores
Line-ups
Match Stats
Head-to-head
Live Text

Challenge Cup Scores & Fixtures

Saturday 9th September

East Fife 2 , Albion Rovers 1 at Full time

East FifeEast FifeEast Fife

AlbionAlbion RoversAlbion Rovers

Full time

Raith Rovers 3 , Cliftonville 0 at Full time

Raith RoversRaith RoversRaith Rovers

CliftonvilleCliftonvilleCliftonville

Full time

Annan Athletic 0 , Peterhead 2 at Full time

AnnanAnnan AthleticAnnan Athletic

PeterheadPeterheadPeterhead

Full time

Arbroath 4 , Inverness CT 2 at Full time

ArbroathArbroathArbroath

InvernessInverness CTInverness CT

Full time

Cove Rangers 0 , Montrose 2 at Full time

Cove RangersCove RangersCove Rangers

MontroseMontroseMontrose

Full time

Dumbarton 1 , Kelty Hearts 3 at Full time

DumbartonDumbartonDumbarton

Kelty HeartsKelty HeartsKelty Hearts

Full time

Dundee United 3 , Dunfermline Athletic 0 at Full time

Dundee UtdDundee UnitedDundee United

DunfermlineDunfermline AthleticDunfermline Athletic

Full time

Edinburgh City 1 , East Kilbride 4 at Full time

Edinburgh CityEdinburgh CityEdinburgh City

East KilbrideEast KilbrideEast Kilbride

Full time

Greenock Morton 2 , Elgin City 1 at Full time

MortonGreenock MortonGreenock Morton

ElginElgin CityElgin City

Full time

Partick Thistle 2 , Queen of the South 3 at Full time

PartickPartick ThistlePartick Thistle

Queen SouthQueen of the SouthQueen of the South

Full time

Stirling University 2 , Airdrieonians 3 at Full time

Stirling UnvStirling UniversityStirling University

AirdrieoniansAirdrieoniansAirdrieonians

Full time

Coleraine 1 , Hamilton Academical 3 at Full time

ColeraineColeraineColeraine

HamiltonHamilton AcademicalHamilton Academical

Full time

Bala Town 0 , Queen's Park 3 at Full time

BalaBala TownBala Town

Queen's ParkQueen's ParkQueen's Park

Full time

View all Challenge Cup fixtures

Team Lineups

home team, Dundee United

Manager: Jim Goodwin

Formation: 4 - 2 - 3 - 1

Pitch Formation

Shirt number unknown, Walton, Goalkeeper

Walton

Shirt number unknown, Grimshaw, Defender

Grimshaw

Shirt number unknown, Gallagher, Defender

Gallagher

Shirt number unknown, Graham, Defender

Graham

Shirt number unknown, McMann, Defender

McMann

Shirt number unknown, Tillson, Defensive Midfielder

Tillson

Shirt number unknown, Glass, Defensive Midfielder

Glass

Shirt number unknown, Middleton, Attacking Midfielder

Middleton

Shirt number unknown, Watt, Attacking Midfielder

Watt

Shirt number unknown, Fotheringham, Attacking Midfielder

Fotheringham

Shirt number unknown, Moult, Striker

Moult

Starting lineup

J. Walton
S. McMann , substituted for F. Duffy at 75 minutes
R. Graham
D. Gallagher
L. Grimshaw
D. Glass
J. Tillson , Yellow Card at 88 minutes
K. Fotheringham
T. Watt , Captain, substituted for S. Constable at 75 minutes
G. Middleton , substituted for M. Anim Cudjoe at 64 minutes
L. Moult , substituted for O. Stirton at 64 minutes

Substitutes

home team, Dundee United

R. Adams
M. Anim Cudjoe
S. Constable
O. Denham
F. Duffy
K. Freeman
K. Holt
B. Mwangi
O. Stirton

away team, Dunfermline Athletic

Manager: James McPake

Formation: 3 - 5 - 2

Pitch Formation

Shirt number unknown, Little, Goalkeeper

Little

Shirt number unknown, Comrie, Defender

Comrie

Shirt number unknown, Hamilton, Defender

Hamilton

Shirt number unknown, Otoo, Defender

Otoo

Shirt number unknown, O'Halloran, Midfielder

O'Halloran

Shirt number unknown, Chalmers, Midfielder

Chalmers

Shirt number unknown, Tod, Midfielder

Tod

Shirt number unknown, Allan, Midfielder

Allan

Shirt number unknown, Fenton, Midfielder

Fenton

Shirt number unknown, Moffat, Striker

Moffat

Shirt number unknown, Sutherland, Striker

Sutherland

Starting lineup

M. Little
E. Otoo
C. Hamilton , Captain
A. Comrie
M. Fenton , substituted for J. Edwards at 53 minutes
P. Allan
A. Tod
J. Chalmers
M. O'Halloran
T. Sutherland , substituted for L. McCann at 53 minutes
O. Moffat , substituted for E. McLeod at 62 minutes

away team, Dunfermline Athletic

A. Collier
J. Edwards
L. Hoggan
L. McCann
E. McLeod
J. Sutherland

Dundee United
Dunfermline Athletic

home team, Dundee United

Manager: Jim Goodwin

Formation: 4 - 2 - 3 - 1

Pitch Formation

Shirt number unknown, Walton, Goalkeeper

Walton

Shirt number unknown, Grimshaw, Defender

Grimshaw

Shirt number unknown, Gallagher, Defender

Gallagher

Shirt number unknown, Graham, Defender

Graham

Shirt number unknown, McMann, Defender

McMann

Shirt number unknown, Tillson, Defensive Midfielder

Tillson

Shirt number unknown, Glass, Defensive Midfielder

Glass

Shirt number unknown, Middleton, Attacking Midfielder

Middleton

Shirt number unknown, Watt, Attacking Midfielder

Watt

Shirt number unknown, Fotheringham, Attacking Midfielder

Fotheringham

Shirt number unknown, Moult, Striker

Moult

Starting lineup

J. Walton
S. McMann , substituted for F. Duffy at 75 minutes
R. Graham
D. Gallagher
L. Grimshaw
D. Glass
J. Tillson , Yellow Card at 88 minutes
K. Fotheringham
T. Watt , Captain, substituted for S. Constable at 75 minutes
G. Middleton , substituted for M. Anim Cudjoe at 64 minutes
L. Moult , substituted for O. Stirton at 64 minutes

Substitutes

R. Adams
M. Anim Cudjoe
S. Constable
O. Denham
F. Duffy
K. Freeman
K. Holt
B. Mwangi
O. Stirton

away team, Dunfermline Athletic

Manager: James McPake

Formation: 3 - 5 - 2

Pitch Formation

Shirt number unknown, Little, Goalkeeper

Little

Shirt number unknown, Comrie, Defender

Comrie

Shirt number unknown, Hamilton, Defender

Hamilton

Shirt number unknown, Otoo, Defender

Otoo

Shirt number unknown, O'Halloran, Midfielder

O'Halloran

Shirt number unknown, Chalmers, Midfielder

Chalmers

Shirt number unknown, Tod, Midfielder

Tod

Shirt number unknown, Allan, Midfielder

Allan

Shirt number unknown, Fenton, Midfielder

Fenton

Shirt number unknown, Moffat, Striker

Moffat

Shirt number unknown, Sutherland, Striker

Sutherland

Starting lineup

M. Little
E. Otoo
C. Hamilton , Captain
A. Comrie
M. Fenton , substituted for J. Edwards at 53 minutes
P. Allan
A. Tod
J. Chalmers
M. O'Halloran
T. Sutherland , substituted for L. McCann at 53 minutes
O. Moffat , substituted for E. McLeod at 62 minutes

Substitutes

A. Collier
J. Edwards
L. Hoggan
L. McCann
E. McLeod
J. Sutherland

Referee:: Craig Napier
Assistant Referee 1:: Daniel McFarlane
Assistant Referee 2:: Alastair Taylor

Match Stats

Key, Dundee Utd v Dunfermline

Dundee Utd

Key

Dunfermline

Overall possession

DUU

54%

DUN

46%

Dundee United 54%Dunfermline Athletic 46%

Shots

Dundee United 8Dunfermline Athletic 10

Shots on target

Dundee United 2Dunfermline Athletic 0

Goalkeeper saves

Dundee United 0Dunfermline Athletic 0

Fouls

Dundee United 6Dunfermline Athletic 4

Corners

Dundee United 3Dunfermline Athletic 6

Head to Head

Season so far

Challenge Cup

Skip to form guide
Skip to previous meetings
Skip to previous scores

Dundee Utd

Key

Dunfermline

Key, Dundee Utd v Dunfermline

Form guide

All competitions

Skip to previous meetings
Skip to previous scores
Skip back to season so far

Dundee United

Dunfermline Athletic

Dundee United won

v Airdrieonians

Championship

Dunfermline Athletic draw

v Inverness CT

Championship

Dundee United won

v Ayr United

Championship

Dunfermline Athletic lose

v Raith Rovers

Championship

Dundee United draw

v Dunfermline Athletic

Championship

Dunfermline Athletic draw

v Dundee United

Championship

Dundee United won

v Arbroath

Championship

Dunfermline Athletic won

v Airdrieonians

Championship

Dundee United won

v Carlisle United

Club Friendlies

Dunfermline Athletic won

v Albion Rovers

League Cup

Previous meetings

All competitions

Skip to previous scores
Skip back to form guide
Skip back to season so far

Dundee United and Dunfermline Athletic

Won

Played

Won

Dundee United Won 28Dunfermline Athletic Won 18

Draw

Draw 22

Previous scores

All competitions

Skip back to previous meetings
Skip back to form guide
Skip back to season so far

Championship

Dundee United 1 , Dunfermline Athletic 1 on the 12th of August 2023

Dundee UtdDundee UnitedDundee United

DunfermlineDunfermline AthleticDunfermline Athletic

12th of August 2023

12 AUG 2023

Dunfermline Athletic 2 , Dundee United 0 on the 29th of February 2020

DunfermlineDunfermline AthleticDunfermline Athletic

Dundee UtdDundee UnitedDundee United

29th of February 2020

29 FEB 2020

Dundee United 2 , Dunfermline Athletic 0 on the 26th of October 2019

Dundee UtdDundee UnitedDundee United

DunfermlineDunfermline AthleticDunfermline Athletic

26th of October 2019

26 OCT 2019

Live Text

Postat 90 minutes plus 4
Match ends, Dundee United 3, Dunfermline Athletic 0.
Full Timeat 90 minutes plus 4
Second Half ends, Dundee United 3, Dunfermline Athletic 0.
Postat 90 minutes plus 3
Attempt missed. Josh Edwards (Dunfermline Athletic) right footed shot from the left side of the box is high and wide to the right following a corner.
Postat 90 minutes plus 3
Corner, Dunfermline Athletic. Conceded by Declan Gallagher.
Postat 90 minutes
Foul by Owen Stirton (Dundee United).
Postat 90 minutes
Josh Edwards (Dunfermline Athletic) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Bookingat 88 minutes
Jordan Tillson (Dundee United) is shown the yellow card.
Postat 88 minutes
Attempt missed. Ewan Mcleod (Dunfermline Athletic) right footed shot from outside the box is too high.
Postat 81 minutes
Attempt missed. Paul Allan (Dunfermline Athletic) right footed shot from outside the box misses to the right.
Postat 77 minutes
Foul by Jordan Tillson (Dundee United).
Postat 77 minutes
Lewis McCann (Dunfermline Athletic) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Postat 77 minutes
Mathew Anim Cudjoe (Dundee United) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Postat 77 minutes
Foul by Josh Edwards (Dunfermline Athletic).
Postat 75 minutes
Corner, Dunfermline Athletic. Conceded by Ross Graham.
Substitutionat 75 minutes
Substitution, Dundee United. Flynn Duffy replaces Scott McMann.
Substitutionat 75 minutes
Substitution, Dundee United. Scott Constable replaces Tony Watt.
Postat 72 minutes
Corner, Dunfermline Athletic. Conceded by Liam Grimshaw.
Postat 72 minutes
Foul by Declan Glass (Dundee United).
Postat 72 minutes
Michael O'Halloran (Dunfermline Athletic) wins a free kick on the right wing.
Postat 66 minutes
Attempt missed. Lewis McCann (Dunfermline Athletic) right footed shot from the left side of the box misses to the right.

Page 1 of 4

Best of BBC iPlayer

A classic action blockbuster

Attribution
iPlayer Films

Mandy returns for a Christmas special

Attribution
iPlayer

An enjoyable film for the whole family

Attribution
iPlayer Films

Charlie escapes modern Christmas

Attribution
iPlayer

Home
News
Sport
Weather
iPlayer
Sounds
CBBC
CBeebies
Food
Bitesize
Arts
Taster
Local News
Three

Terms of Use
About the BBC
Privacy Policy
Cookies
Accessibility Help
Parental Guidance
Contact the BBC
Make an editorial complaint
Get Personalised Newsletters
Why you can trust the BBC

Dundee United

Dunfermline Athletic

Challenge Cup Scores & Fixtures

Saturday 9th September

Team Lineups

home team, Dundee United

Pitch Formation

Starting lineup

Substitutes

home team, Dundee United

away team, Dunfermline Athletic

Pitch Formation

Starting lineup

away team, Dunfermline Athletic

home team, Dundee United

Pitch Formation

Starting lineup

Substitutes

away team, Dunfermline Athletic

Pitch Formation

Starting lineup

Substitutes

Match Officials

Match Stats

Overall possession

Shots

Shots on target

Goalkeeper saves

Fouls

Corners

Season so far

Form guide

Previous meetings

Previous scores

Championship

Live Text