The verdict on Mings, Grealish and McGinnpublished at 07:40 BST 15 July

Image source, Getty ImagesWe asked you if you think a return to Aston Villa would work out for Jack Grealish as it came up as a point of debate in a BBC Radio WM fan forum that aired on Monday.
We also wanted to know if you would keep Tyrone Mings and John McGinn at Villa Park given their futures are also discussed on the show.
Here are some of your comments:
Martyn: Since Jack left and Unai took charge we have become a much more structured side so I doubt coming back now would suit Jack or Villa. With a need to reduce our wage expenditure I'm not convinced this would work financially either.
Steve: McGinn going wouldn't be the worst thing - a decent player but I think we need better to progress.
Kasad: I'm a big fan of Mings and I feel he is a far better defender than Torres. Mings and Konsa to start I hope .
Adam: I think Grealish back at Villa would be great for both parties. There is obviously a talented player there whose natural play has been suppressed in Guardiola's system and he could thrive at Villa if given the freedom to express his natural game
Anthony: Jack Grealish isn't good enough to get into the Villa team.
Gary: I think Jack returning would work. I think Unai works miracles with players and would raise Jack back up to the standard he was when City bought him.
Ian: McGinn and Mings are going nowhere.
























