'Great bit of business' or 'a big mistake'? - fans on Ramsey to Newcastlepublished at 12:05 15 August


We asked for your views on Jacob Ramsey leaving Villa Park in a £40m deal to Newcastle.
Here are some of your comments:
Paul: I would have preferred to keep him too as he is a raw talent who on his day is better than most in my opinion. His ability to carry the ball and see passes others don't will be massive for Newcastle. Good luck Ramsey!
Anthony: I really like Ramsey. I think he gives something a bit different to other players on that side. He had a great season a couple of years ago, but he's had a few injuries and not really got back to those heights. It's a harsh reality that we need to sell players and Ramsey is an obvious choice. I hope we have someone else coming in, with him and potentially Leon Bailey going. In Unai we trust!
Brian: Selling Ramsey is a big mistake. He has the potential to to be one of the best English players in recent years and to sell to a Premier League rival is crackers.
Richard: Honestly? I'm OK with this. He's a great player, but 40m is a good price at a time when we need income. Last season, we played just as well without him as with him, and he's not an impact sub. He's a squad player at this stage.
Paul: A tough one, and also puzzling really. A player who had good moments but too often injured since his broken foot for the under-21s. Not a regular starter so feeling is we've done well to get that price. Not sure where Newcastle are going to play him, and if he would actually start either. Seems a bit of a panic buy for them. I could understand interest from West Ham but he would be too good for them. History will tell if PSR forced Villa into a mistake.
Jason: Not disappointed with this sale at all. Newcastle think they're getting Ramsey from two years ago. Great bit of business for Villa.
Ian: So disappointed to see him go. Has the profile in age and ability that fits what I would like to see coming to the club, not leaving. Only consolation is that he is going to a club with great set of fans and a talented manager under whom he can continue to progress.