Dundee

Watch Sportscene pundits Peter Grant and Michael Stewart analyse Dundee's display in their vital win at Hearts.

Jonathan Sutherland
Sportscene presenter

Dundee's 1-0 win over Hearts on Saturday put a bit of breathing space between them and Ross County and St Johnstone below - they've got two players in my team of the week.

Goalkeeper Trevor Carson was assured and did what he had to do, while the return of Joe Shaughnessy at the back for the relegation fight is a huge boost.

A special mention goes to Simon Murray. I was gutted to leave the Dundee goal machine out of the starting XI, but there was stiff competition this week. After a 22nd goal of the season, I would definitely send him on for the last half hour at least.

Brian McLauchlin
BBC Sport Scotland Senior Reporter

Image source, SNS

Striker Simon Murray says Dundee must maintain their current levels of performance to end the season on a high.

Murray scored the only goal of the game against Hearts at Tynecastle to elevate Dundee out of the relegation play-off spot in the Premiership table.

It was Murray's 22nd goal of the season for Dundee and he says to keep a clean sheet in defence was one of the key elements of their game plan on the day.

"We knew how tough it was going to be," he said. "But we felt in the last few weeks, bar the Hibs game, we've been in pretty good form. We've shown good performances.

"We had to be patient. We had more of a game plan without the ball and used our strength on the counter really well.

"Obviously, clean sheets isn't something we've done a lot of as a team this year and today I thought we were absolutely solid. They never really threatened us, even though they had a bit of the ball."

Murray's goals have brought about calls for him to be included in the Scotland squad for the summer friendlies against Iceland and Lichtenstein.

However, he says his sole concentration is on his club football and ensuring Dundee retain their Premiership status for next season.

"When you grow up as a kid, to play for your national team's the goal, isn't it? That's the dream for every player," added Murray.

"It would obviously be amazing, but I know how good the players are on that team. I just need to keep doing what I'm doing for my club. Just keep working hard and whatever happens, happens."

We asked for your views on Dundee's 1-0 win against Hearts.

Here's what some of you said:

Gary: There'll have been some raised eyebrows with that team selection (mine included) but the spine of the team was really solid and with other strong performances around the park it turned out to be a great three points! Let's hope they can continue at home next weekend!

Ally: Simon Murray is an absolute star, he has got Dundee a good few points.

Carl: Deserved victory for us, good team formation, great effort from every player, and a spot of good luck now and again got us three vital points. To see us playing for each other as a team was the icing on the cake. Thanks guys, onward and upward!

Mark: Best result of the season. We have now beat Hearts away and Dundee United away. These two results buck the trend of many a year. Win our two home games and we will finish best of the rest. Sir Tony Docherty arise.

Kevin: Great gutsy display, tactics spot on and I thought it was a masterstroke using Antonio Portales in midfield, a steady display, and with Murray up top we always have a chance.

Ross: We got it right. Defensively we were immense. A win next week should be enough to keep us up.

Image source, SNS

• Hearts have failed to win in their last four games in the Premiership, their last longer winless streak was from 15 May 2024 to 6 October 2024, a run of 10 games.

• Simon Murray has scored 16 goals in the Premiership this season (one in this game), more than any other Dundee player.

• Hearts attempted 624 passes in this match, higher than their season average of 436.7 in the Premiership.

• Dundee have a record of W6, D0, L3 when leading at half time in the Premiership this season.

Dundee boost their Scottish Premiership survival hopes with a slender but deserved victory as Hearts are jeered from the pitch by a furious home support.

Simon Murray's goal, his 21st of the season, pushes Dundee up to 10th in the division and two points clear of Ross County, who lost at Kilmarnock.

What did you make of that, Dundee fans? Do you feel that's you safe now?

Who impressed you? And how good is Simon Murray?

Let us know your thoughts here.

Image source, SNS

Dundee manager Tony Docherty told BBC Scotland: "Huge credit to the players, I'm absolutely delighted with the endeavour they showed, the intelligence and work rate they showed. You saw a team with a real team ethic there.

"We executed that game plan to the letter and I couldn't be more proud of them, putting in that level of performance. It's been a tough two weeks, we let our standards drop against Hibs.

"Hearts have got excellent players, and they kept changing and trying to find the answers. But we limited them and as the game went on, they crossed from deeper and we became more comfortable.

"We've faced a lot of adversity in terms of injuries. Joe Shaughnessy has missed 31 games for me this season. Clark Robertson and Trevor Carson. When they're back, they give a solidity to the team.

"They allow the young talent, Cameron, Mulligan, Adewumi, a chance to express themselves. We're in good form, excluding the Hibs game, and that's important. We can take pride in that performance."

Andrew Petrie
BBC Sport Scotland

Image source, SNS

There won't be many happier than Tony Docherty tonight. His side had a game plan and executed it to perfection.

Absorb the Hearts attack, sting them on the counter. It almost paid off a few times, before Murray's simple strike.

He's the kind of talisman that inspires teammates, especially in times of trouble. He fights for every ball, noises up fans, pesters opposition defenders. The kind of player every fan wants on their team.

At the back, the return of Joe Shaughnessy has been heralded and he's been helped aptly by Clark Robertson, the veteran defender who is finally returning from injury.

Trevor Carson, who has been in and out of the team so often this season, also stood up when it counted.

The old guard are providing Dundee with just the experience they need to steer them to safety.

Image source, SNS

Simon Murray. Never has his influence been more apparent. Dundee looked doomed at one point but as his form has picked up, so has the Dee's. Eight in eight for him now.

A word for Seb Palmer-Houlden, too. The target man was a nuisance and filled in for the injured Oluwaseun Adewumi very well.

Image source, SNS

Hearts captain Lawrence Shankland is a doubt after going off with muscle tightness in the Scottish Cup semi-final defeat by Aberdeen.

Michael Steinwender and Cammy Devlin are both available despite being sent off in that match as their suspensions are competition-specific, but James Wilson is still suspended. Gerald Taylor (knee) and Aidan Denholm (hamstring) remain out.

Dundee have doubts over Ziyad Larkeche, Lyall Cameron, Charlie Reilly, Jordan McGhee and Oluwaseun Adewumi, but hope most if not all of the players will make the game.

Scott Fraser is pushing for a comeback after groin trouble.

Image source, SNS

Dundee defender Ryan Astley says there is a steely belief among the club's players as they attempt to secure their top-flight status.

Tony Docherty's side occupy the relegation play-off spot with five league matches remaining, five points ahead of bottom side St Johnstone.

They start their post-split fixtures away to Hearts and for Astley, the situation is simple.

"It's five cup finals for us now, everyone is aware of that," he said. "I'm looking forward to it, to show what we can do.

"The mood's great. Everyone is just focused and ready for it. Obviously the game against Hibs was a bit of a dip but before that we were in good form and we are hopefully going to carry that into this game.

"We are all confident we can get out of this with hard work. You can see that we core goals, we have great attacking players. We just have to be more solid at the back, which I know we can be. We know we can turn it around."

Dundee manager Tony Docherty is unsurprised Josh Mulligan, 22, is attracting interest amid reports Rangers are interested in the versatile Dens Park player. (Courier - subscription required), external

Read Friday's Scottish gossip

Image source, SNS

• Hearts have won their past three Scottish Premiership home games against Dundee, last winning more in a row on home soil against them in the top fight from September 1999 to November 2001 (six).

• Dundee have lost five of their past six league meetings with Hearts, winning the other 3-1 in August this season.

• Hearts have failed to score in their past three league games despite attempting 34 shots (11 on target) worth 3.35 expected goals. Hearts last went four without scoring in the Scottish Premiership in November 2018.

• Only Kilmarnock have kept fewer clean sheets (0) and conceded more goals (41) away from home in the Scottish Premiership this season than Dundee (one clean sheet, 35 goals conceded), who have shipped 2+ goals in each of their last five on the road (17 in total).

• Dundee's games in the Scottish Premiership this season have seen more goals (121 – 50 for, 71 against) than any other side, while only Dundee United's (81) have had fewer than Hearts' (87 – 43 for, 44 against).

With 21 goals in 41 appearances this season for a struggling Dundee side, should striker Simon Murray be in the frame for a Scotland call-up for this summer's friendlies with Iceland and Liechtenstein?

The uncapped 33-year-old says playing for his country is an "ambition" but insists his full focus is on helping to keep Dundee in the Premiership.

Ethan Hampton
Fan writer

This weekend Dundee return to Tynecastle for the third time this season. It's the toughest possible start to the split, but also the perfect chance to make a statement.

I can only assume the Hearts camp is deflated following their Scottish Cup semi-final defeat to Aberdeen in extra time.

The Dark Blues have a point to prove - the past three meetings with the Jambos have all ended in defeat. I'm hoping we go to Edinburgh fired up to do ourselves justice.

Goalscoring midfielders seem to be a dying breed in the modern game. Yet last season Dundee had two: Luke McCowan - now at Celtic - finished as the club's top scorer with 10 goals while Lyall Cameron chipped in with five. This season, Cameron has already matched last term's total with five games still to go.

Historically, it's an area Dundee have been consistent with. Gary Harkins, Mark O'Hara, Paul McGowan, Charlie Adam and even Jordan McGhee when played in midfield, these players were all capable of contributing to output in front of goal.

Last week, I stated the return of Scott Fraser and Cameron could just be the impact Dundee need to hit the ground running into the split.

As established, Cameron - objectively a talented midfielder - is also a source of goals. Only Simon Murray has scored more this season for the Dark Blues.

Fraser has only played three games this season due to injury - a massive loss, considering he was brought in with the view of replacing McCowan. With nearly 400 senior games and 139 goal contributions (61 scored, 78 assisted), his pedigree is obvious.

Regardless of how this season goes, a lack of goals from midfield is an issue Dundee will need to address in summer. Cameron is departing for Rangers and Fraser is out of contract, as is Josh Mulligan. Mulligan, in particular, has huge potential. If he polished his finishing, he'd be unstoppable. Yet he's still searching for his first goal of the season.

It's quite spectacular that only Celtic and Rangers have netted more goals in the league than Dundee this campaign, yet we have only had five goals scored from midfield - all from one man, Cameron.

Murray has done an excellent job as Dundee's main goal getter, but less weight needs to be put on his shoulders.

Nick McPheat
BBC Sport Scotland

How many times have you heard a relegation-threatened manager talk about the need to hit the coveted 40-point mark?

Well, the truth is, no Scottish Premiership team has ever required that total to avoid the bottom two since the play-offs were brought back more than a decade ago.

However, that is projected to change this season.

Based on current points-per-game averages, 11th-placed Dundee are set to end on a total of 39, meaning 40 could be the magic number to guarantee safety.

If that is the case, that would mark the highest tally required to ensure survival in Scotland's top tier since 38-game seasons were reintroduced in the 2000-01 campaign.

That would also mean Hearts are effectively safe, given they are already on 40 points and four teams would need to make up ground on them, while eighth-placed Motherwell would need just a single point from five post-split games.

With Kilmarnock in ninth and Ross County in tenth both currently on 35, which is just one more than Dundee's 34, the fight to avoid 11th is clearly likelier to be between those three.

But that is not set in stone. The nature of the split means each team in the bottom half will face the other before the end of the campaign, so there is scope for points-per-game averages to fluctuate.

And what does all of this mean for St Johnstone? Well, the 33 points Simo Valakari's side are projected to finish on would be the highest for a bottom-placed team in the Premiership since 2017.

That would be no consolation for the Perth club if they go down, but that is certainly not guaranteed to happen just yet.

However, they have a real fight on their hands to make up a five-point gap while improving their inferior goal difference.

Dundee manager Tony Docherty is backing "huge talent" Seun Adewumi to finish his loan spell from Burnley on a high, with he and the 20-year-old midfielder having five matches to steer their side clear of relegation trouble. (The Courier), external

Read Monday's Scottish Gossip in full.

Image source, SNS

Dundee have dropped 23 points from winning positions in the Scottish Premiership this season - more than any other side.

Hibs, who are currently third, have dropped the second most points (20).

However, a positive for the Dark Blues is they have gained 11 points from losing positions - their highest tally since before the 2014-15 season.

Only three teams - Rangers, Kilmarnock and Hibs - have recovered more (13).

Dundee technical director Gordon Strachan says the Camperdown stadium project must be built to take the club and the city to the next level. (The Courier- subscription), external

Read the rest of Thursday's Scottish gossip.