St Johnstone

Watch Sportscene analysis St Johnstone's performance in their 3-2 defeat by St Mirren in the Scottish Premiership.

We asked for your thoughts on St Johnstone's 3-2 Premiership loss against St Mirren.

Here's what some of you said:

Sandy: Still a naivety up front, but naivety or lack of confidence pervades the whole team at times - the other Saints won the first half easy with some Perth players out of position, but there was certainly improvement in the second half.

Henri: Ignoring the poor refereeing decisions, to go 2-1 up and still have four pretty tired attackers on the field is shocking. I understand Simo Valakari was looking for a more attacking mindset, but only bringing one substitute on the entire match is pretty disappointing. Bringing on some more defensive players would have probably secured the three points.

Image source, SNS

• Benjamin Kimpioka has scored six goals in the Premiership this season (one in this game), more than any other St Johnstone player.

• St Mirren have won six points from losing positions in the Premiership this season, only Dundee (nine) and Kilmarnock (11) have recovered more.

• St Johnstone have conceded eight goals to opposition substitutes in the Premiership this season, more than any other team.

• St Mirren have scored three goals in a game for the first time since 30 October 2024 against St Johnstone, a game they won 3-1.

St Johnstone could only blame themselves following Saturday's 3-2 defeat by St Mirren, says McDiarmid Park manager Simo Valakari. (Courier - subscription), external

Read Sunday's Scottish gossip

Mark O'Hara's initial spot-kick was saved but goalkeeper Josh Rae was off his line, allowing Idowu to slam in the second attempt.

Killian Phillips had put the visitors in front after just 10 minutes when he slotted beyond Josh Rae.

St Johnstone equalised in the second period when captain Nicky Clark set up Mackenzie Kirk before Benjamin Kimpioka put the hosts in front.

Youngster Evan Mooney equalised on the 88th minute before St Mirren were awarded a penalty for a handball deep into stoppage time.

St Mirren move into the top six, although Dundee have a game in hand, while the Perth side remain in 10th.

St Johnstone fans, were you at McDiarmid Park or following the action from home? Either way we want your views on the performance, external.

Charlotte Cohen
BBC Sport Scotland

Image source, SNS

It was a poor opening 45 minutes from Simo Valakari's side who failed to create any real opportunities.

A much better start to the second period got St Johnstone back on level terms and then in front.

But their attacking intent, instead of focusing on seeing out the match, probably cost them the victory as they stay stuck in the danger zone at the bottom end of the Premiership.

Image source, SNS

St Johnstone manager Simo Valakari: "We started very badly, it was my fault I put three strikers there.

"At half-time we were able to talk and change a couple of positions then in the second half it was very good. We scored two beautiful goals.

"We needed to have cool heads, at 2-1 we still wanted to push instead of seeing the game out then we lose the whole match which is disappointing.

"It's the hardest lesson we have learned because we were totally in control. I understand the players wanted to go for the third and fourth goal and we lost it a little bit, the emotions the street smartness. We need to learn from that.

"We need to start getting those points. We are not yet there that we can play a full 90 minutes, we need to learn to do that. We have extremely good spells in our game, we have some very bad moments as well. Nothing has changed where we are in our process.

"The table doesn't lie, we are not doing enough good things to climb the table."

Lewis Neilson, 21, is happy to be playing a versatile role at St Johnstone. (Courier - subscription), external

Read Saturday's Scottish gossip

Image source, SNS

St Johnstone have Andre Raymond and Bozo Mikulic back but Barry Douglas remains out along with long-term absentees Uche Ikpeazu (knee), Cammy MacPherson (hip) and Sam McClelland (Achilles).

The suspended Alex Gogic drops out for St Mirren but Alex Iacovitti could return. Charles Dunne remains out with a hamstring problem.

Tyrone Smith
BBC Sport Scotland Senior Reporter

Image source, SNS

St Johnstone's Lewis Neilson says there has been "a mentality shift" since manager Simo Valakari came to the club.

"There is a lot more positivity around the place and also expectation to go and get results," said defender Neilson.

"The way we are training every week I think the tempo has been boosted, the morale has been boosted so 100% there is a mentality to go and try and get three points in every game we play."

Speaking prior Saturday's Premiership visit of St Mirren, Neilson believes it won't be long before ninth-place St Johnstone start turning their performances into wins.

"I think we are seeing that game on game [improvement] since the new manager has been in, there are plenty of positives to take from each game, we are starting to play a lot more football," he added.

"Hopefully we can put a few wins together."

Defender Neilson arrived on a season-long loan from Hearts in the summer.

"That is what I am on loan for, to play as many games as possible and get as much experience as possible in the Premiership," he said.

"I am really enjoying it, it is a great club. I have played multiple positions now this season so I am happy as long as I am on the pitch getting minutes in."

Tyrone Smith
BBC Sport Scotland Senior Reporter

Image source, SNS

Simo Valakari says the no-fear approach among his St Johnstone players "gives me confidence" in what they can achieve.

After being appointed in October, the Finn has overseen a marked improvement in performances.

While wins have been hard to come by - just two in Valakari's seven games so far - he is happy with the mentality within the group.

The Perth boss said: "The very first day we made a promise to each other that we go without fear because if you start playing football with fear you start being afraid of the mistakes, it doesn't take you anywhere.

"How much they have changed I cannot say, but I can say I see them every day in training and there are hungry boys who want to improve as individuals and as a team. If I see that, that gives me confidence.

"I have said it to the boys that if you don't prepare as well as we can, if we don't do the things we have tried to do during the week in a match, if you don't work hard for the team, then after the match there is no point in being disappointed because we didn't do our job."

Ninth-place Saints welcome St Mirren, who are four points above them, to McDiarmid Park on Saturday.

The Perth side go into the game in good spirits after impressing during a 1-1 draw at Aberdeen last time out.

"It is all about getting these wins because three points is so massive," added Valakari.

"We know our weaknesses, we try to hide them as much as possible, but at the same time we know what we are very good at, so we try to play with our strengths as much as possible.

"We need a result but we can't focus too much on the results. We need to focus on the performance then the results will follow."

Tyrone Smith
BBC Sport Scotland Senior Reporter

Image source, SNS

St Johnstone manager Simo Valakari has been speaking to the media before Saturday's Premiership visit of St Mirren.

Here are the key lines from the Perth boss:

• Valakari says it is a "big game" against a "very interesting team" who have "a clear identity of what they are trying to do".

• While happy with his team during last weekend's 1-1 draw at Aberdeen, he says there are a lot of areas they can improve.

• On the mentality of his squad since he came took charge, he says: "From the very first day, we made a promise to each other that we go without fear."

• Despite having just one victory in their last six games, St Johnstone's performances have been improving – but Valakari says "it is all about getting these wins", adding that keeping their performance levels high will give them a good chance.

• The Finn says every player and manager wants the top six, but he doesn't "spend one minute" looking at league table permutations, adding "we only concentrate on the concrete things that we can do".

• There are no fresh fitness issues. Bozo Mikulic and Andre Raymond return from injury.

Andy Campbell
BBC Sport Scotland

Makenzie Kirk bolstered his burgeoning reputation last weekend with the opening goal as St Johnstone drew 1-1 with Aberdeen.

It was the 20-year-old forward's fifth goal in all competitions this season, which includes one for Saints Under-20s in the SPFL Trust Trophy.

Kirk is following in the footsteps of his father, Andy, who played and scored in Scottish football with Hearts and Dunfermline and also represented Northern Ireland. Kirk senior is of course part of the coaching staff at St Johnstone.

For the younger Kirk, St Mirren are in his sights. The Buddies side are coming off a defeat before this Saturday's contest in Perth.

The gap between the sides stands at four points with St Johnstone ninth and St Mirren seventh.

With sixth-placed Dundee among the sides not playing this weekend, it's an opportunity for both sides to make up some ground.

Read all the weekend Premiership picks

St Johnstone manager Simo Valakari hopes Achilles injury victim Sam McClelland, 22, can return before the end of the season. (Courier - subscription), external

Read Friday's Scottish gossip

Sam Miller
Fan writer

I've never known a St Johnstone manager to have built up so much credit in the bank with the fans as Simo Valakari.

In his short time with the club the Finn has conducted himself magnificently.

He has turned up to fan forums and charity football matches. If you asked him, he would turn up to the opening of an envelope if it was to help the club or local community.

The way he comes across in interviews as well is first class.

The players must be buzzing playing for someone like that and I really hope the board back him next month in the transfer window.

A little bit more quality and we will be okay.

Sam Miller can be found at Dogger Saints podcast, external

Image source, SNS

• St Johnstone have only lost one of their last 11 home league meetings with St Mirren (W7 D3), going down 1-0 in April 2022. The Perth side have kept nine clean sheets in this spell.

• St Mirren have won three of their last four top-flight meetings with St Johnstone (L1), as many as their previous 12 beforehand (D6 L3).

• In 2024, St Johnstone have picked up fewer home points (10) and lost more home matches (10) in the Scottish Premiership than any other side.

• Only Ross County (3) have earned fewer away points in the Premiership this season than St Mirren (4), who have lost six of their last eight on the road in the competition (W1 D1).

• Both of St Johnstone's last two league goals have been scored by 20-year-old Makenzie Kirk. A goal against St Mirren will see Kirk become the youngest player to score in successive league appearances for the Perth club (20 years, 312 days) since Ali McCann in February 2020 (20y 63d).

Nicky Clark, 33, is enjoying being St Johnstone captain and being a creative force in their team. (Courier - subscription), external

Read Thursday's Scottish gossip

Jack Sanders: A stout performance at the back from the St Johnstone defender as Simo Valakari's side impressed at Pittodrie to earn a valuable point against high-flying Aberdeen.

We asked for your views on St Johnstone's 1-1 draw against Aberdeen.

Here's what some of you said:

Jim: We are playing better since Simo Valakari arrived, his positivity is filtering through to the players. The small crowd of us Saints fans at Pittodrie were very vocal and were rewarded with a good team performance. The only thing missing is getting the second goal, which will come and will bring us more points.

Dunc: Slowly and surely progress is being made. After the shambles of the dying embers of Callum Davidson's reign, and whatever Craig Levein was doing, we can begin to breathe more easily. Work in progress.

Willie: The players are buying into the manager's philosophy. The signs are positive and the fans must get behind the team. The battle of the Saints next week is huge.