'Charlie Hurley number one by a distance' - fans on best CBs debatepublished at 19:01 4 July


We asked for your views on Danny Collins' list of the top five Sunderland centre-backs of the past 50 years (scroll to 12:26 BST on 4 July to see his choices).
Here are some of your comments:
Paul: How could any Sunderland supporter leave out Charlie Hurley? Number one by a distance.
Frank: Dave Watson and Charley Hurley were both phenomenal centre-backs. None of the others could compare - apart from Steve Bould (who was there with them), but there were not enough games under his belt.
John: Absolutely agree. Watson was not the biggest player, but for timing, athleticism and a sheer will to win every header and tackle, I've never seen a better one. Hurley may win it by the number of goals scored. You should have been at the matches to hear the whole crowd chanting "Charlie, Charlie, Charlie" for him to come up for a corner.
Colin: Really depends on how old you are, but Hurley was the best centre-half to play for Sunderland that I saw. Watson was great too.
Steve: King Charlie wasn't someone you would like to experience too often in a tussle.
Paul: Shaun Elliott and Jeff Clarke?