Concern for pub's future as application rejected

Parish councillors are concerned for the future of the Forresters Arms in Kilburn

An attempt by villagers to have a rural pub listed as an asset of community value has failed amid concerns about the venue's future.

North Yorkshire Council rejected an application from the local parish council to give the designation to the Forresters Arms in Kilburn near Thirsk.

Inclusion on the list would mean the owners have a duty to allow the community to bid on the premises should they sell it.

But a report by North Yorkshire Council officers concluded there was not enough evidence that the pub was being used by the community.

Kilburn Parish Council had applied for the pub, which is owned by pubco the Stonegate Group, to be given the designation following a change in leaseholder last year.

Its application said: "The recent unexpected and early change of lessor has given rise to uncertainty and concern regarding the future of the pub.

"Its future may be uncertain taking account of the owners, Stonegate, and their publicly declared inclination to dispose of poor-performing pubs.

"Added to this, the future of commercially owned country pubs is generally uncertain.

"Community ownership at the right price, as with an increasing number of country pubs, would be the best way of preserving this vital community asset."

'Limited evidence'

The parish council said the Forresters was the only pub, and one of only three public buildings, in the village.

It added that the venue hosted regular meetings such as the village book club and meetings of the Kilburn Feast organisation committee.

It said: "It is frequently used by locals for general socialising, wedding receptions, wakes and other social gatherings.

"Alternative venues are some miles away and can be problematic for Kilburn's ageing population and the absence of local public transport."

But North Yorkshire Council ruled that the pub should not be included on its list of assets of community value.

The pub was shut when officers visited as part of their assessment, and they were unable to contact the operators by phone.

The officers' report said: "Overall, there was nothing substantive to demonstrate significant actual use as a public house providing a community facility for cultural, social and recreational activities that were non-ancillary.

"Evidence that the nominated site furthers the social interests, wellbeing of the local community of Kilburn was very limited."

The Forresters Arms was badly damaged by fire in May 2019, but reopened in 2020 after repairs and refurbishment.

The pub's current leaseholder is Doug Glendon, who took on the business in November last year.

A spokesperson for the pub said Mr Glendon was unavailable.

Stoneygate Group has been contacted for comment.

Listen to highlights from North Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North.