Kardashian v Capulet - Who is the better role model?

  • Published
Kim KardashianImage source, Pascal Le Segretain/Getty

When our colleagues at BBC Entertainment tweeted a story about a school head's views about Kim Kardashian, Shakespeare and feminism, it was too potent a cocktail for social media to remain silent. Here is the tweet that launched many more.

Young women 'should model themselves on Shakespeare's heroines instead of Kim Kardashian'Image source, Twitter

Shakespeare certainly created some formidable female characters. The line, "Do you not know I am a woman? When I think, I must speak," is one iconic line delivered by Rosalind in in the play 'As You Like It'.

But are Shakespeare's heroines really the kind of role models women should aspire to, some users asked. They tweeted the @BBCNewsEnts, external account, armed with examples to prove their case.

What about Isabella from 'Measure for Measure'? Her stony silence at the end to the Duke's proposal is widely interpreted to be her acceptance that she must give up her dream of chastity. Is she worthy of imitation?

Give up your dream of becoming a nun to marry a tyrant you don't love! Pretend to be a statue till your husband behaves himselfImage source, Twitter

Or Juliet? Many have hailed her romance with Romeo, but on closer inspection, is she to be admired?

Fall in love at 13, have underage sex and then poison yourself after taking other illegal substances.Image source, Twitter

Or Katherine from 'Taming of the Shrew'.

An independent woman is psychologically abused by her husband until she becomes compliant...Image source, Twitter

And let's not forget the three witches in Macbeth. The supernatural activities of the three weird sisters sets the ominous shadow for the tale, and encourages Macbeth to war.

WitchesImage source, Twitter

But why was Kim Kardashian dragged into this? Hadn't she had an awful enough week already?

Following a terrifying robbery at gunpoint in Paris, she perhaps wasn't that concerned that a leading British head teacher had expressed "worry" that Kardashian is "the dominant role model" for girls. Jane Lunnon, head of Wimbledon High School, said that too many teenagers girls look up to women in popular culture, instead of female protagonists from the world of the Bard.

Kardashian's defenders exercised their tweeting fingers.

1)30s entrepreneur in loving marriage, two lovely kids 2) married her own brother for political power then killed herself w/ a snake.Image source, Twitter

Kardashian, with her hugely-successful reality TV show, reportedly earns $200,000 per Twitter endorsement, external. We can safely say that none of Shakespeare's heroines have done that or have earned millions from their own personal range of emojis.

cool to know people think white man's fictional characters > successful, actually real business womanImage source, Twitter

Some of those commenting weren't fans either.

I mean, I'm all in favour of abandoning Kim Kardashian as a role model but Lady Macbeth was hardly a moral paragon.Image source, Twitter

But perhaps the real issue, many argued, was that women don't need to be told who to look up to at all.

No. Stop telling us what to do.Image source, Twitter
Young women should model themselves on whomever they please tweetImage source, Twitter
"A big No. No to impunity. Like ['No' campaigner and former President] Pastrana said: 'WE deserve peace but with justice.'"Image source, Twitter

Social media reacts as Colombians vote to reject deal to end Farc conflict. READ MORE

You can follow BBC Trending on Twitter @BBCtrending, external, and find us on Facebook, external. All our stories are at bbc.com/trending.