Summary

  • The government approves the controversial HS2 rail project

  • The PM criticised the HS2 company's management but said that did not detract from the value of the scheme

  • Boris Johnson will appoint a full-time minister to oversee the project

  • The route, to be completed by 2040, will link London to Birmingham, and then Manchester and Leeds

  • Supporters say it will improve travel, create jobs and rebalance the UK's economy

  • Critics point to the project already being over budget, behind schedule and damaging to the environment

  1. HS2 costs 'will exceed benefits'published at 11:21 Greenwich Mean Time 11 February 2020

    Dr Richard Wellings, head of transport at think tank the Institute of Economic Affairs, is "deeply disappointed" over the decision to go ahead with HS2. He said:

    Quote Message

    With the predicted costs ballooning to £106bn, the costs are now likely to exceed the benefits. And the project is highly unlikely to transform the North in the ways that have been promised. Investment in alternative schemes - such as incremental improvements to existing infrastructure in northern towns and cities - would deliver far larger economic gains."

  2. Cummings: 'We need PJ Masks on the job'published at 11:17 Greenwich Mean Time 11 February 2020

    This Twitter post cannot be displayed in your browser. Please enable Javascript or try a different browser.View original content on Twitter
    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    Skip twitter post

    Allow Twitter content?

    This article contains content provided by Twitter. We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as they may be using cookies and other technologies. You may want to read Twitter’s cookie policy, external and privacy policy, external before accepting. To view this content choose ‘accept and continue’.

    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    End of twitter post

    For the uninitiated, PJ Masks is a children's cartoon featuring Amaya, Connor and Greg who lead normal lives by day, but at night they transform into superheroes and use their powers to fight villains and solve mysteries. Not sure they've had a go at building a huge railway line yet...

  3. 'What happened to joined-up thinking?'published at 10:58 Greenwich Mean Time 11 February 2020

    Green Party co-leader tweets

    This Twitter post cannot be displayed in your browser. Please enable Javascript or try a different browser.View original content on Twitter
    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    Skip twitter post

    Allow Twitter content?

    This article contains content provided by Twitter. We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as they may be using cookies and other technologies. You may want to read Twitter’s cookie policy, external and privacy policy, external before accepting. To view this content choose ‘accept and continue’.

    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    End of twitter post
  4. Your views on HS2published at 10:54 Greenwich Mean Time 11 February 2020

    Working on HS2

    There's a mixed reaction from readers on the news that HS2 is set to be green-lighted today.

    Jackie Vincent is far from happy. "I think it is appalling that this monstrosity is being allowed to continue, regardless of the cost," she says, adding: "I think this 'white elephant' will only benefit the few and not be the magic wand to help the North."

    Meanwhile Kieran Conaty is angry that the plans don't extend beyond Leeds. "So the North stops at Leeds, does it?" he asks. "I presume anyone residing north of Leeds won’t be required to pay any tax towards this £100bn investment?"

    But Simon Lambert has a positive view and reckons HS2 will help benefit Britain's steel industry. "Hopefully the steel needed will come from UK plants. We cannot be a global player without a steel industry," he says.

    He also addresses some of the environmental objections by pointing out that: "Any project will destroy woodland, road, rail or clothes lines."

  5. 'We need HS2 and Northern Powerhouse Rail delivered in full'published at 10:49 Greenwich Mean Time 11 February 2020

    Mayors Andy Burnham (right) and Steve RotheramImage source, Getty Images

    Connecting Britain, a coalition of business and political leaders in northern England including Andy Burnham, pictured right, and Steve Rotheram - metro mayors of Greater Manchester and the Liverpool City Region, say the north of England needs new rail lines that go north-south and west-east.

    In a statement, they say: "London isn't being forced to choose, it's getting Crossrail and HS2. We shouldn't be forced to either.

    "We need HS2 and Northern Powerhouse Rail (high-speed rail links across the Pennines) delivered in full.

    "The government needs to be clear we will not accept a gold-plated high-speed line between London and Birmingham, then once again the North getting the scraps."

  6. Fabricant: I cannot support HS2published at 10:39 Greenwich Mean Time 11 February 2020

    Media caption,

    Michael Fabricant on HS2: 'I, for one, cannot support this'

    Conservative backbencher Michael Fabricant has said he cannot support the building of HS2.

    He said there was "no doubt" about capacity problems on the West Coast mainline, but he said in "years to come" people will ask if the design of the new link could have been better.

  7. RMT union: The government has dithered for far too longpublished at 10:37 Greenwich Mean Time 11 February 2020

    Mick Cash
    Quote Message

    This government has dithered over this decision for far too long, which has meant uncertainty and delays to this vital rail project. Now that they are on the point of giving the go-ahead, the government and HS2 must take steps to ensure that jobs on the project are directly-employed, with union agreements, a safe workplace, and without the scourge of blacklisting. "While we await the details of the full package it is essential that the government guarantees that the northern route of HS2 is not downgraded and commit to investing in an affordable, accessible and publicly-owned railway fit for the 21st Century."

    Mick Cash, Rail, Maritime and Transport union general secretary

  8. HS2 environmental concerns 'are ill-founded'published at 10:33 Greenwich Mean Time 11 February 2020

    WoodlandsImage source, Getty Images

    Some of the biggest objections to the HS2 project are on environmental grounds. They’re ill-founded, Nigel Harris, the editor of Rail Magazine, told the BBC News Channel.

    “HS2 will take about 0.01% of our ancient woodlands. Over the entire 345-mile network that’s 58 hectares of land," he pointed out.

    "If you look at the lower Thames motorway crossing that’s coming , that takes 54 hectares, almost as much, over just 14 miles of track.

    "The designers of HS2 have worked very hard to save bits of ancient woodland here and there and they’ve come up with an optimum route.

    "There are 11,000 acres of ancient woodlands in The Chilterns and HS2 takes one hectare.”

  9. HS2 will lead to 'widespread enviromental destruction'published at 10:26 Greenwich Mean Time 11 February 2020

    BBC News

    Jonathan Bartley

    Jonathan Bartley, co-leader of the Green Party is one person disappointed at the expected thumbs up for HS” the government will announce today.

    “We are disappointed,” he told the BBC News Channel. “We’re huge fans of trains at the Green Party but we just think this is the wrong project.

    “The cost has ballooned out of all proportion and now we know there will be widespread environmental destruction with over 100 ancient woodlands destroyed,” he warned.

    “It is likely to lead to increased airport expansion at Manchester and Birmingham. This is not the way to move to the low-carbon economy.”

    He said £100bn should instead be borrowed to upgrade the existing network.

  10. HS2 'mired in politics and emotion'published at 10:17 Greenwich Mean Time 11 February 2020

    BBC News Channel

    Nigel Harris

    "It is absolutely the right decision [to give HS2 the go-ahead]," Nigel Harris, the editor of Rail Magazine, told the BBC News Channel.

    "It has been mired in politics and, of course, emotion, but if you strip them away we need that capacity.

    "Our railways are full. You’d have to close our main lines every weekend for 25 years to do an upgrade on the existing network and you wouldn’t get the same capacity increase that HS2 gives us."

    Responding to suggestions that the cash could be better spent elsewhere he said: “The idea that’s there’s a £100bn pot that could dipped into is a fanciful myth. The way these projects are funded is through borrowing,” he pointed out.

  11. More firms 'will move out of London on back of HS2'published at 10:09 Greenwich Mean Time 11 February 2020

    HS2

    HS2 will encourage more companies to move out of London, reckons Richard Butler of the CBI.

    “It’s not just Birmingham that will benefit,” he pointed out, “High Speed 2 will go to Nottingham, Sheffield, Leeds, Manchester, albeit further down the line in terms of timing.

    “A large number of companies have already come to Birmingham on the back of what HS2 will do. Assuming we have a positive decision today, more companies will make that move out of London and the South East for a whole variety of economic reasons.”

  12. 'Our Victorian rail system is creaking'published at 10:01 Greenwich Mean Time 11 February 2020

    Responding to criticisms that the money being spent is too much or could be better spent elsewhere, the CBI’s Richard Butler said: “I note those points, but we have a Victorian rail system that is creaking at the seams.

    "We need to do something about capacity and it’s almost impossible to upgrade the current network without closing it down indefinitely to achieve that.

    "High Speed 2 is the only way of bringing in that extra capacity we need," he said.

  13. CBI: Three reasons why HS2 is positive newspublished at 09:52 Greenwich Mean Time 11 February 2020

    BBC News Channel

    Richard Butler

    Richard Butler regional director of the CBI in the West Midlands is looking forward to today's HS2 announcement, he told the BBC News Channel.

    “It’s an important day,” he said. “It’s positive for a number of reasons.

    “We need additional rail capacity in the UK, we need to regenerate the north and we need to speed up travel times to London.

    “High Speed 2 has the capability of addressing all those three points.”

  14. Latest HS2 plans 'more thoughtful,' Lord O'Neill sayspublished at 09:43 Greenwich Mean Time 11 February 2020

    Today Programme
    BBC Radio 4

    Visualisation of Birmingham Interchange airport shuttleImage source, HS2
    Image caption,

    Visualisation of Birmingham Interchange airport shuttle

    Lord O’Neill is a cross-bench peer, vice-chair of the Northern Powerhouse Partnership, and former Conservative treasury minister.

    He has become a lot more positive on HS2, and says the latest plans are a lot more "thoughtful" than earlier versions.

    "I think the London to Birmingham bit is actually about speed," he told the Today programme.

    "It allows business and humans to almost arbitrage the price differentials - you can see it already in terms of house prices – London’s are declining and Birmingham’s are not. A lot of businesses are starting to make noises about Birmingham."

    The crucial thing now, he says, is faster connectivity between the northern cities.

    The economist adds that he is torn when it comes to the cost of the project, but says that the productivity boost for the north of England will be so big that it will boost the growth potential of the whole country... so the costs will be justifiable.

  15. 'HS2 has completely wrecked our lives'published at 09:31 Greenwich Mean Time 11 February 2020

    This Twitter post cannot be displayed in your browser. Please enable Javascript or try a different browser.View original content on Twitter
    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    Skip twitter post

    Allow Twitter content?

    This article contains content provided by Twitter. We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as they may be using cookies and other technologies. You may want to read Twitter’s cookie policy, external and privacy policy, external before accepting. To view this content choose ‘accept and continue’.

    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    End of twitter post
  16. RAIL magazine says 'get HS2 done'published at 09:23 Greenwich Mean Time 11 February 2020

    This Twitter post cannot be displayed in your browser. Please enable Javascript or try a different browser.View original content on Twitter
    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    Skip twitter post

    Allow Twitter content?

    This article contains content provided by Twitter. We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as they may be using cookies and other technologies. You may want to read Twitter’s cookie policy, external and privacy policy, external before accepting. To view this content choose ‘accept and continue’.

    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    End of twitter post
  17. HS2 'environmentally damaging' says MP Fabricantpublished at 09:13 Greenwich Mean Time 11 February 2020

    Today Programme
    BBC Radio 4

    Visualisation of Birmingham InterchangeImage source, HS2
    Image caption,

    Visualisation of Birmingham Interchange

    Michael Fabricant, Conservative MP for Lichfield in Staffordshire, says he supports HS2 on a "philosophical" level.

    But he is critical of the final plans for the project, which mean it will not go into Birmingham New Street, the city's main interchange. He says there is also an awkward change to other services when trains arrive in London.

    He also says the route will cause unnecessary damage to the countryside.

    “People are still going to fly because of the change of trains in London, so my argument is the lack of connectivity and also that it is so damaging environmentally.

    “Instead of using existing transport corridors, which it will do as it goes into the North in phase 2, between Birmingham and London it crashes through unspoiled countryside.”

    "I certainly believe we need two extra lines because of capacity problems on the West Coast mainline but I think in years to come people will look back on this project and say 'they could have done it so much better'."

  18. Labour Party statement on HS2published at 09:03 Greenwich Mean Time 11 February 2020

    Andy McDonald
    Quote Message

    HS2 has been appallingly mismanaged by the Conservative party, which has failed to deliver a single major infrastructure project on time or within budget. If HS2 is going to get back on track, the project has to be integrated with Crossrail for the North, it needs to be managed as part of an advanced rail network, and it must eventually extend into Scotland so that we remove the need for domestic flights. The government must also commit to running HS2 services under public ownership. That way it is the UK public – not private or overseas state-owned companies – who will see a return on this investment.

    Andy McDonald MP, Labour’s Shadow Transport Secretary

  19. HS2: When will the line open and how much will it cost?published at 08:44 Greenwich Mean Time 11 February 2020

    Stop HS2  posterImage source, Reuters

    The government is expected to give the final go-ahead to HS2, the high-speed railway connecting London to Birmingham and then Manchester and Leeds.

    The infrastructure project, currently the largest in Europe, has been delayed and faced mounting concerns over the exact route and spiralling costs.

    While the whole line will be built, the government is expected to review the sections of the route that cover the North.

    So what is the proposed route and why has the project gone over budget?

    Read more here.

  20. JD Sports shares ahead in early tradepublished at 08:29 Greenwich Mean Time 11 February 2020

    Shares in JD Sports are up 2% after competition watchdog the CMA said it was concerned about the sport retailer's planned takeover of Footasylum.

    In early morning trade shares were up 18.00 pence, or 2.13%, at 864 pence.