Summary

Media caption,

Watch the moment MPs back the bill

  1. 'Bill is about shortening death, not life'published at 13:32 British Summer Time

    Speaking next in the Commons is Conservative MP Peter Bedford, who claims that at least one Brit a week goes to Switzerland to seek an assisted death at a cost of around £12,000.

    He agrees better palliative care is needed across the UK.

    Bedford says that this legislation has received far more scrutiny than much of what MPs vote on and that they have been debating this subject for over 20 years.

    He says that this bill is not about shortening life, it's about shortening death.

  2. Safeguard measures weakened since previous vote, MP sayspublished at 13:30 British Summer Time

    Preet Kaur Gill in black blazer and shirt, holds stack of paper as she speak, part of the Common's wooden benches visible behind herImage source, UK Parliament

    Labour MP Preet Kaur Gill tells the Commons she opposed the bill at second reading after voicing concerns about safeguarding.

    She says some of the the safeguard measures have been "weakened" during the committee stage, noting some of the terminology in the legislation remains unclear.

    Kaur Gill also challenges the decision not to include stricter mental health checks on people seeking assisted dying services.

  3. MP says bill will create a society where people believe their lives aren't valuedpublished at 13:28 British Summer Time

    Conservative MP Jeremy Wright, a qualified barrister, says the "risk of not changing the law is that we leave some of our constituents in pain where it could be avoided".

    "I do not want to live in a society where any person, including the terminally ill, is encouraged in the belief that their lives are not valuable and valued to their very last moments," he adds.

    Wright says he believes, even if it not its intention, this bill brings "such a society closer - and that is why I cannot support it".

  4. MP shares brother's final months, saying bill offers humane end to lifepublished at 13:23 British Summer Time

    Speaking in the Commons as the debate into the assisted dying bill continues, Labour MP Maureen Burke shares the story of her brother David who was diagnosed with pancreatic cancer.

    Burke says that as his health declined in the last few months of his life, he told her that if there was a pill that he could take to end his life he would take it.

    She says that he would go on to suffer in silent pain for a further three weeks and urges her colleagues to make sure others don't go through what he went though.

    She says what her brother needed was a humane, safe and trusted process that would give him agency over his last weeks and months. That's what this bill offers, she says.

  5. Labour MP: 'We cannot legislate out inherent bias'published at 13:17 British Summer Time

    Warning: This post contains distressing details

    Labour's Jen Craft says she opposes the bill over concerns about the impact it could have on people with disabilities.

    Speaking from the experience of her own daughter's diagnosis with Down's Syndrome, she says a midwife immediately told her she could book her an abortion "within 48 hours".

    "This is a choice that so many women make, because they are ignorant of the value of disabled lives," Craft tells the Commons.

    She says she has had to "fight for so many things" for her daughter, because the "establishment does not see her life as valuable".

    Craft says she supports the principle of assisted dying, but cannot support the bill because "we cannot legislate out inherent bias".

  6. Bill opposer Tugendhat says it should be called 'assisted killing'published at 13:16 British Summer Time

    Conservative MP Tom Tugendhat is up next, he says this bill demonstrates a huge shift in the relationship between the individual and the state.

    Tugendhat calls for more honesty in the debate and says that they aren't debating assisted dying, it should be called assisted killing or assisted suicide.

    He tells the House that they have a responsibility to think not just for those who have options, but for the weak and the vulnerable.

    Tugendhat says that closest legal equivalent to this bill is the Canadian bill.

    He retells the experience of a Canadian man with a degenerative condition who says he has faced neglect and told to consider medical aid in dying.

    As a reminder, voluntary euthanasia or "medical assistance in dying" can be provided by a doctor or nurse practitioner in Canada.

  7. Labour MP refutes 'slippery slope' argumentpublished at 13:08 British Summer Time

    Back in the Commons now, we're hearing from Labour MP Dr Beccy Cooper who says that as a medical doctor specialising in public health she will be supporting the bill in today's vote.

    Cooper says "we are often met with the slippery slope argument" that legislating for a specific group would open the door to further legislation.

    "That's not what's in front of us today," saying further changes to the law would be subjected to additional parliamentary scrutiny.

    "As a public health physician, I am satisfied that I can vote [for the bill]," she says. "Ultimately, a good death is something that we all want for ourselves and for those we love and care for."

  8. Votes so far strengthen optimism of bill supporterspublished at 13:05 British Summer Time

    Henry Zeffman
    Chief political correspondent

    After taking stock of this morning's early votes here’s a closer look at how the morning’s voting went, and what it means.

    The votes strengthened the optimism of those supporting the proposed assisted dying law.

    The flurry of initial votes concerned specific proposals to amend Kim Leadbeater’s law.

    Each fell by a majority of around 50 votes.

    While not a perfect proxy, those votes are a reasonable proxy for the mood of the House of Commons.

    It is likely that some MPs who did not vote on those amendments will come to the Commons to take part in the big vote this afternoon.

    Still, if you are looking for evidence that there has been a big shift since November, you would not find it in what has happened so far today.

  9. A look back at the early votes - and how this differs from November's debatepublished at 13:01 British Summer Time

    Sam Francis
    Political reporter

    As we take a brief step away from the ongoing debate in the Commons, here's a quick reminder that this bill is slightly different to the one debated in November due to this morning's early voting.

    Let's take stock of the outcome of those votes:

    MPs agreed to ban assisted dying for people who have voluntarily stopped eating or drinking. This was aimed at closing the so-called "anorexia loophole" – safeguards to stop people qualifying for assisted dying on the basis of life-threatening malnutrition.

    Another change means the government must publish a review of palliative care services within a year of the law’s start.

    Most of the changes came from the bill’s proposer, Kim Leadbeater, most aimed at clarifying terms and tidying up the bill following on from previous amendments.

    Leadbeater saw off attempts to limit the scope of bill in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, and there is now also less chance that a future Welsh government can veto the whole bill coming into force in Wales, amendment 94 limits the scope of control the Senedd can have.

    Attempts to block access to assisted dying for people suffering mental health problems and a proposal to require people prove they are of sound mind before choosing assisted were defeated.

    The need for a special protection to ensure the bill does not shift the NHS's focus from saving lives was also projected.

    This is now the final form of the bill MPs will vote on. If it passes, it gets sent to the House of Lords for more detailed scrutiny.

  10. As debate continues, protesters on both sides gather in Parliament Squarepublished at 12:54 British Summer Time

    Yasmin Rufo
    Reporting from outside Parliament

    While the debate is ongoing inside the House of Commons, outside in Parliament Square protesters are crowding.

    Those against the bill are lining the streets chanting “we are not dead yet” while behind them, mainly dressed in pink, are those who hope Parliament will vote in favour of assisted dying.

    One campaigner for the bill says it’s about giving people freedom of choice, but a doctor who opposes assisted dying says he “doesn’t want to be made into a killer”.

    Stay with us for the latest developments throughout the day, both inside and outside the Commons.

    parliament
  11. 'I've witnessed realities of palliative care', says MP who worked as NHS intensive care nursepublished at 12:53 British Summer Time

    Labour MP Kevin McKenna, a former NHS intensive care nurse, says he has "witnessed the realities of end-of-life care countless times".

    "I've seen patients find peace in their final days, but also patients who have been unconscious or unaware that their death was coming - or others endure pain or anxiety that no palliative intervention, none, will alleviate for them," he tells MPs.

    McKenna says these experiences have "reinforced my belief that individuals should all have the autonomy" to make decisions about the end of their lives.

    McKenna concludes that he believes the bill has improved and is ready to be sent to the House of Lords, adding his intention to vote in favour of it.

  12. 'This bill is not about choosing death, but how to face it'published at 12:50 British Summer Time

    Conservative MP Kit Malthouse, who supports the bill, says the House has a responsibility to give voice to dying people.

    "This bill is not about choosing death, it's about choosing how to face it when death is already at the door", he continues.

    Malthouse says the bill has been built in the right way and that all concerns have been considered carefully.

    On arguments of a "slippery slope" he says there is no pathway for expansion by stealth and that the panel is there to make sure oversight is in place.

  13. MP says several issues haven't been addressed and time is running outpublished at 12:37 British Summer Time

    Labour MP David Smith says several issues highlighted during the second reading of the bill haven't been addressed and time is now running out to debate them.

    He says the proposed legislation still fails to provide a definition for coercion - asking who will be able to define it when MPs can't?

    Smith also raises concerns about the potential "marketisation" of assisted dying, saying the limited resources currently available within the NHS increase the risk of these services becoming extensively privatised.

  14. 'I'm terrified someone I love may choose to accelerate their death' - MP tells Commonspublished at 12:34 British Summer Time

    Conservative MP Mike Wood tells the House of Commons he disagrees with colleagues who say the bill is stronger now than it was last time MPs voted during the second reading.

    As a reminder, MPs voted to back the Leadbeater bill by 330 to 275 in November 2024.

    Wood says he still supports the principle of assisted dying, but he is terrified by the idea that "someone I love might choose to accelerate their death".

    He goes on to say the bill as currently written lacks "adequate safeguards" and he will be voting against it.

  15. MP tells member not to vote against bill 'because we've lacked time - we have not'published at 12:31 British Summer Time

    We're now hearing from Andy Slaughter, who says after meeting with many constituents, groups and faith groups, his support for the assisted dying bill remains unchanged from November.

    "I have not changed my mind, I am still driven by the plight of those suffering unnecessarily at the end of life," he says.

    "I've tried to see both sides on every issue," Slaughter says, but that he cannot agree with those who ask whether the bill has thus far seen due process.

    He urges members not to vote against the bill because "we've lacked the time or information to make a decision - we have not".

  16. If the bill passes we'll have death on demand, Conservative MP sayspublished at 12:22 British Summer Time

    Conservative MP Sir Edward Leigh tells the Commons he is taking a "pragmatic approach" to the bill despite many thinking he will oppose it due to his religious beliefs.

    Leigh calls for a full study to work out how we can help people in their final hours.

    He says he's spoken to many experts in palliative care who say that they now have resources and skills to make the final hours of a person's life pain free.

    Leigh tells the Commons that they're voting on a bill which is riddled with difficulties and inconsistencies, as he calls for a "pause" on the bill.

    He says that if this bill passes, we will move in the direction of Canada: "We will have death on demand."

    For context: In Canada, voluntary euthanasia or "medical assistance in dying" can be provided by a doctor or nurse practitioner, either in person or through the prescription of drugs for self-administration.

  17. Commons chamber almost full as MPs listen closely to debatepublished at 12:20 British Summer Time

    Susan Hulme
    Parliamentary correspondent

    Usually, only a smattering of MPs turn up in the Commons on a Friday.

    This time, the green benches are almost full. And not only full, but MPs are listening intently.

    No-one seems to be scrolling on their phones, no-one getting on with their paperwork.

    Instead, there have been vigorous nods and cheers for whichever speech individual MPs agree with, as impassioned arguments for and against assisted dying range back and forth through the debate.

    Whatever the result of the vote this afternoon, the House of Commons will certainly not have spoken with one voice on this difficult issue.

  18. Co-sponsor of bill says it has compassion at its corepublished at 12:14 British Summer Time

    Labour MP Rachel Hopkins in a white blazer and red and white floral dress stands in the Commons to deliver speech, two sheets of paper in her right handImage source, UK Parliament

    We're now hearing from Labour MP Rachel Hopkins, co-sponsor of the bill, who says people who are dying are "at the heart of this bill".

    She says the law needs to be changed to ensure people "have an element of control over their last days".

    Hopkins says she welcomes the additional scrutiny the proposal received - noting the bill has been subjected to lengthier debate than any other piece of legislation.

    She adds the bill will provide one of the "tightest and safest" assisted dying laws in the world, saying the proposed legislation has "compassion at its core".

  19. Palliative care in the UK is simply not good enough - Iain Duncan Smithpublished at 12:06 British Summer Time

    Iain Duncan Smith in a dark blue suit, white shirt and lighter blue tie, partially leaning left as he gestures while delivering a speech, two colleagues sitting on the Commons' benches behind himImage source, UK Parliament

    Tory MP Sir Iain Duncan Smith says professional bodies consulted on the bill are mostly "very strongly opposed" to it.

    Lib Dem MP Daisy Cooper intervenes by saying that all medical bodies are neutral on it, with two major ones welcoming amendments to it.

    Duncan Smith disagrees and says medical bodies are split on it, with many opposing the bill.

    He adds that palliative care in the UK is "simply not good enough", especially for the most vulnerable people to access.

  20. Disabled people want MPs to assist them to live, not die - Foxcroft sayspublished at 12:04 British Summer Time

    We're now hearing from Labour's Vicky Foxcroft who says this is her first time speaking in the Commons since the general election, adding she wished she didn't have to speak up today.

    In the debate, she says that during her four years as shadow minister for disabled people she spoke to hundreds of disabled people and organisation.

    "They were and remain extremely fearful of assisted dying," she says.

    As a reminder, Vicky Foxcroft has resigned as a Labour whip over the government's plans to cut disability benefits.

    Foxcroft says that they "need the health and social care systems" to be fixed first and they want MPs "to assist them to live, not to die".