Counter-terror plans criticisedpublished at 21:33 Greenwich Mean Time 28 January 2015
Sean Curran
Parliamentary correspondent, BBC News
A former head of MI5 has criticised plans by Home Secretary Theresa May to put a programme to stop young Muslims being radicalised by extremists on a statutory footing. At the moment the Prevent programme involves community groups but the Counter-Terrorism and Security Bill gives some organisations and councils legal duties.
During a House of Lords debate on the bill, Lady Manningham-Buller, who was head of the security service at the time of the 7/7 bombings in London in 2005, added her voice to criticism of the plans. A number of peers complained that the proposals would undermine freedom of speech in universities because non-violent extremists would be banned from speaking.
Lady Manningham-Buller, a cross-bench (or independent) peer, said she understood the government's concern, but added "we have been reminded only recently that we have a right to insult and we should avoid double standards here". She said the work to stop people becoming extremists needed to be carried out with "sensitivity, proportionality and care", and she feared that putting the scheme on a statutory basis in universities would jeopardise all three.