Summary

  • The Smith Commission recommends the full control over income tax rates and bands be devolved to Holyrood

  • The commission, set up after the "No" vote in the independence referendum, reached an agreement at its final meeting

  • It says a share of VAT should be assigned to the Scottish Parliament, and that Air Passenger Duty should be fully devolved

  • It also recommends Holyrood be given powers to allow 16 and 17-year-olds to vote in Scottish elections

  1. Glasgow Airport reactionpublished at 12:53 Greenwich Mean Time 27 November 2014

    Amanda McMillan, managing director of Glasgow Airport, said: "We welcome the findings of the Smith Commission which has recommended the devolvement of Air Passenger Duty (APD) to the Scottish Parliament.

    Glasgow Airport departures loungeImage source, PA

    "APD is the highest form of aviation tax in the world and it is important it is devolved and reformed as soon as possible.

    "APD is a damaging, regressive tax which in addition to dissuading airlines from adding new routes, makes it extremely challenging to maintain existing services.

    "Having full control of APD will play a major role in strengthening Scotland's connectivity and provide yet a further boost to our burgeoning tourism industry."

  2. 'Time to heal divisions'published at 12:38 Greenwich Mean Time 27 November 2014

    Alistair Carmichael says today represents "a time to heal the divisions, to bring the people of Scotland together".

    alistair carmichael

    He adds: "We had a vote and we said we would deliver change. We have now told the people of Scotland today what that change will be.

    "It's time to get together and use the powers that the Scottish Parliament has, and will get, and to use them for the good of the Scottish people and the Scottish economy."

  3. Nicola Sturgeon at FMQspublished at 12:37 Greenwich Mean Time 27 November 2014

    At First Minister's Questions earlier, Nicola Sturgeon said the proposals fall short of genuine home rule, which she says was promised ahead of the independence referendum.

    Nicola Sturgeon

    Ms Sturgeon added it was her belief that the opinion of the Scottish people would be the powers are not enough, and that they will show that at the next election.

  4. Smith Commission at FMQspublished at 12:33 Greenwich Mean Time 27 November 2014

    Douglas Fraser
    Business and economy editor, Scotland

    Nicola Sturgeon at FMQs: says she would raise top tax to 50%, if she could now. Cites Scottish Trade UnionCongress and SCVO disappointment at Smith Commission.

  5. Carmichael's claimpublished at 12:32 Greenwich Mean Time 27 November 2014

    Tim Reid
    Political correspondent, BBC News

    SNP disputing Carmichael's claims that more than 50 % of revenue spent will be raised by Scottish Parliament.

  6. Abortion devolutionpublished at 12:30 Greenwich Mean Time 27 November 2014

    Labour MP Sandra Osborne, in the House of Commons debate, backs the decision not to immediately recommend the devolution of abortion powers "which would have caused all sorts of problems".

    sandra osborne

    Mr Carmichael, in response, said: "There is a clear statement that it is considered by the commissioners to be an anomalous situation and I can understand why they take that view.

    "However, we have always dealt with abortion differently - we have always made it the subject of a free vote in this house.

    "And I think the compromise they reached in the commission to have a recognition of the anomaly that currently exists but saying a new process will have to be devised in order to deal with that is a sensible one."

  7. 'Positive and exciting'published at 12:28 Greenwich Mean Time 27 November 2014

    Annabel Goldie also spoke to the BBC News Channel earlier. She was one of the representatives on the Smith Commission for the Scottish Conservatives.

    She said: "It was challenging. You'd expect robust discussion, from five different parties, in many respect with quite disparate views.

    Annabel Goldie

    She said: "I thought it was a measure of the commitment to Scotland and Scotland's future, that we managed to bang our heads together, iron out the differences, because we wanted to come out with an agreed position and I'm delighted that's what we've managed to do.

    "A very positive position, a very exciting position, for the future of Scotland."

  8. Smith Commission at FMQspublished at 12:26 Greenwich Mean Time 27 November 2014

    Douglas Fraser
    Business and economy editor, Scotland

    FMQs at Holyrood: rarely can there have been such a stairheid rammy about a consensus. #smithcommission

    Nicola Sturgeon at FMQs quotes IEA saying Smith Commission is a "dangerous half-way house". (It then warns blame game continues, more tax and red tape).

  9. 'This is home rule for Scotland'published at 12:25 Greenwich Mean Time 27 November 2014

    Michael Moore, speaking on the BBC News Channel earlier, said: "This is home rule for Scotland. We have got a substantial package of financial measures coming to the Scottish parliament. It will raise something like 60% of the spending that its responsible for, in taxes directly or indirectly.

    Michael Moore

    "It has also got the beginnings of separate Scottish welfare system that builds on the social union from the cradle to the grave but also roots Scotland still very firmly within the UK; particularly that matters for job and wealth creation."

    "But we have devolved substantial powers to assist people getting to work to the Scottish parliament."

  10. Postpublished at 12:24 Greenwich Mean Time 27 November 2014

    Tim Reid
    Political correspondent, BBC News

    Stewart Hosie: Proposals to not reflect the powerhouse parliament many thought they had been promised #smithcommission

  11. Your reaction on Twitterpublished at 12:24 Greenwich Mean Time 27 November 2014

    Sean McPartlin:, external Coalition line: "This is Home Rule for Scotland" - either means they are daft, or they think we are. #smithcommission

    Calum Findlay:, external At least we get 100% control of speed limits and road signs! #smithcommission

    Mark Bolsover:, external #smithcommission whilst their are *some* positives (e.g. change of franchise for 16/17 yr olds), the, frankly, obfuscatory checks make it seem like a maintenance of the status quo, couched in apparently well-meaning platitudes...

    Kirstein Rummery:, external #smithcommission achieved cross party consensus - that is actually a *huge* achievement. Wish all politics looked like this

  12. What about England?published at 12:23 Greenwich Mean Time 27 November 2014

    Conservative MP Andrew Percy, in the House of Commons debate on the Smith Commission, says people in England are "getting the fluffy end of the lollipop."

    Andrew Percy
  13. On Radio Scotlandpublished at 12:22 Greenwich Mean Time 27 November 2014

    John Beattie
    BBC Scotland

    On air on BBC Radio Scotland - what do you think of the conclusions of the Smith Commission report?

    You can text me on 80295.

  14. Vow 'delivered'published at 12:15 Greenwich Mean Time 27 November 2014

    Jackie Baillie MSP, who is standing in at First Minister's Questions until the Scottish Labour Party finds a new leader, says the vow made to people of Scotland ahead of the referendum has been delivered ahead of schedule.

  15. Proposals 'underwhelming'published at 12:12 Greenwich Mean Time 27 November 2014

    Scottish Socialist Party (SSP) national spokesperson Colin Fox says that Smith proposals were "underwhelming" and did nothing to tackle key problems facing working people.

    Mr Fox said: "As tax raising powers are devolved the block grant to Holyrood will fall leaving power still very much in London's hands.

    "On key problems facing thousands of Scots it has no real answer. No new power to tackle fuel poverty, introduce a desperately needed wage of £10 an hour or tackle the scandal of zero hours contracts.

    "What the commission shows is the stark reality between its tinkering and spin and the failure to address the crying needs for jobs, fair pay and real change.

    "It will not settle the increasing demand for independence reflected in public opinion since September 18th and underlines the SSP's view that independence has not been defeated but deferred."

  16. Business sectors reaction to commissionpublished at 12:11 Greenwich Mean Time 27 November 2014

    Douglas Fraser
    Business and economy editor, Scotland

    Free market Institute of Economic Affairs says the Smith deal "dangerous 1/2-way house". Blame game goes on, with the prospect of more regulation and higher tax.

    Brad Mackay, of the Edinburgh University Business School, says business leaders don't want single market disrupted and would prefer Holyrood to keep tax rates consistent with UK.

    Meanwhile, Scottish Retailers say more devolution is not an end in itself, adding: "Priority is simple, make it easier and less costly for firms to invest, grow and hire"

  17. Sturgeon on Smith Commissionpublished at 12:10 Greenwich Mean Time 27 November 2014

    Nicola Sturgeon, in First Minister's Questions, asks how Labour has managed to find itself on same side as Conservatives and on different side from STUC over Smith proposals.

    She points to comments from various charities and unions which have expressed disappointment over what is on offer and says there are no powers to create jobs.

  18. FMQspublished at 12:05 Greenwich Mean Time 27 November 2014

    Graham Fraser
    BBC Scotland

    If you want to watch First Minister's Questions, where MSPs are discussing the Smith Commission, you can do so on the 'Live Coverage' tab of this page or follow it on the BBC's live blog and video of the Scottish Parliament.

  19. 'The Vow Plus'published at 12:04 Greenwich Mean Time 27 November 2014

    Labour MP Dame Anne Begg describes the Smith recommendations as "The Vow Plus".

    dame anne begg

    But she adds: "It is quite right that pensions, and in particular state pensions, should remain reserved as there is no doubt that throughout the referendum campaign and polling that voters, and indeed Yes voters, wanted it to remain within the UK."

  20. #SmithCommission trendingpublished at 11:59 Greenwich Mean Time 27 November 2014

    Reaction on Twitter going wild for the Smith Commission.

    Smith Commission trendingImage source, TRENDSMAP

    It was the 8th most tweeted about topic in UK, and 5th most tweeted about in Scotland.