Summary

  • FOR LIVE COVERAGE SCROLL DOWN

  • The Finance Committee took evidence on the Scottish Fiscal Commission Bill and on the Scottish Rate of Income Tax

  • This week's portfolio questions focused on finance and the economy

  • Scottish Labour then led a debate entitled Supporting Scotland's Children looking at restoring tax credits cuts

  • The future of the troubled Scottish steel industry was the topic of this evening's member's debate

  1. Restore tax creditspublished at 14:47

    Scottish Labour MSP Jackie Baillie believes the UK government's proposed changes to tax credits would leave working families worse off and calls on the Scottish government to restore tax credits to families using the new powers being devolved. 

  2. 'SNP not stronger for working families' - Ms Bailliepublished at 14'45

    Ms Baillie says she is willing to do something about austerity rather than sit and wring her hands and do nothing. 

     She says: "I am willing to unlock the powers of devolution." 

     The Labour MSP says the SNP are not stronger for working families. 

  3. SNP must back Labour or they prefer 'the politics of grievance'published at 14:42

    Labour MSP Jackie Baillie says if the SNP do not back Labour's motion this would confirm the "politics of grievance is more important to them than helping working families in Scotland". 

    Jackie Baillie
  4. Background:published at 14:43 Greenwich Mean Time 4 November 2015

    The SNP is to oppose a Labour motion calling on Holyrood to use new tax and welfare powers to restore tax credits. 

    It said the proposals were unworkable and accused Labour of making empty promises to vulnerable people.

    Instead, SNP MPs have lodged amendments to the Scotland Bill calling for working tax and child tax credits to be devolved in full. 

    But Labour said powers to restore tax credits were already coming to the Scottish Parliament. 

    Unveiling her proposals at the Scottish Labour conference in Perth at the weekend, leader Kezia Dugdale said it would be funded by not progressing with SNP plans to cut Air Passenger Duty by 50% before abolishing it altogether.

    A future Scottish Labour government would also not increase the threshold at which people start to pay income tax at 40%, she said. 

    The Scottish government has said it will bring forward plans to support those on low incomes following the UK government spending review, and said "the first priority must be to stop cuts to tax credits completely" 

    tax credits
  5. Scottish Labour leads a debate on its plans to restore the money lost from tax credit cuts to working families.published at 14:40

    Scottish Labour leads a debate entitled 'Supporting Scotland's Children debate'.

    Scottish Labour leader Kezia Dugdale announced the move in her keynote speech to Scottish Labour conference in Perth last week, outlining that the party would pay for the move by cancelling the planned SNP tax cuts on air passenger duty and Tory cuts for higher rate tax payers. 

    Tax Credits
  6. Future funding formula for NHS boardspublished at 14:39

    Conservative MSP Nanette Milne asks what assessment the finance secretary has made of the future funding formula for NHS boards. 

  7. Support for businessespublished at 14:37

    SNP MSP Chic Brodie asks what plans the finance secretary has to provide financial support for businesses in the social enterprise sector in the south of Scotland. 

  8. Onshore coal and gas extraction licensingpublished at 14:34

    Independent MSP John Wilson asks what meetings the Scottish government has had with the UK Government regarding the devolution of onshore coal and gas extraction licensing. 

  9. Chancellorpublished at 14:33

    SNP MSP Bob Doris asks the Scottish government when the finance secretray last met the chancellor and what issues were discussed. 

  10. Scotland Bill requires entrenchment of the Sewel Conventionpublished at 14:33

    Finance Secretary John Swinney says many of these issues would be better protected if there was entrenchment of the Sewel Convention in the Scotland Bill. 

    Mr Swinney says the issue will be assiduously monitored by the Scottish government. 

  11. Background:published at 14:31 Greenwich Mean Time 4 November 2015

    Plans to introduce "English votes for English laws" for MPs have been voted through in the House of Commons. 

    The government won the backing of MPs by 312 to 270 votes. A series of amendments by Lib Dem and Labour MPs were also defeated. 

    English and Scottish flagsImage source, Getty Images

    Commons leader Chris Grayling dismissed objections to the new law as "nonsense" during a bad-tempered debate. 

    The SNP's Pete Wishart said the "stupid" plans would make Scottish MPs "second class citizens". 

  12. English votes for English lawspublished at 14:31

    SNP MSP Bill Kidd asks the Scottish government what analysis it has carried out of the possible impact on its finances of English votes for English laws.

  13. Unemployed footballers' supportpublished at 14:31

    Business Minister Fergus Ewing says PACE is dedicated to helping workers and employers facing redundancies or whose contracts have not been renewed. 

    Thus, unemployed professional footballers are entitled to all the help that PACE can provide. 

    Mr Ewing says both football clubs and authorities take very seriously their responsibilities, but he agrees to ask PACE to speak with the SPA and SFL. 

    Fergus Ewing
  14. Unemployed professional footballerspublished at 14:28

    Labour MSP Mark Griffin asks what support the PACE team can provide to unemployed professional footballers who have been released by their club. 

  15. Superfast broadbandpublished at 14:23

    SNP MSP George Adam asks whether for an update on the rollout of superfast broadband. 

  16. Tax devolutionpublished at 14:22

    SNP MSP Dave Thompson asks what additional powers over tax it considers should be devolved. 

  17. Steel taskforce measurespublished at 14:21

    Business Minister Fergus Ewing details the measures the Steel Taskforce has already taken. Mr Ewing says Transport Scotland are carrying out a review to see what more can be done. 

    The minister says there are possibilities in the area of shipbuilding. He says he visited Dayell yesterday and a suggestion was made that steel for bridges and road could be produced. 

  18. Jobs at steel plantspublished at 14:21

    Labour MSP James Kelly asks the Scottish government what action it is taking to protect jobs at the Dalzell and Clydebridge steel plants.  

  19. Background: Sturgeon does not rule out steel plants public ownershippublished at 14:21 Greenwich Mean Time 4 November 2015

    First Minister Nicola Sturgeon has pledged to do "everything possible" to help find a buyer and keep production going at two threatened steel plants. 

    Asked about a Prestwick Airport-style government rescue, she said.

    Nicola Sturgeon outside TATA steelImage source, Getty Images

    Her comments came after she held talks with the workforce and management at Tata Steel's plants in Motherwell and Cambuslang. 

    On 20 October, Tata confirmed plans to mothball both facilities putting 270 jobs at risk. 

  20. Local authorities welcomed devolution of business rates - ministerpublished at 14:18

    Mr Swinney says the reduction by a council in business rates would be fully funded by that council. 

     The finance secretary says this is a power that local authorities welcomed.