Summary

  • PLEASE SCROLL DOWN FOR LIVE TEXT COVERAGE

  • The Health Committee questioned the author of legislation that would introduce a soft opt-out for organ donation, as well as Scotland's top organ transplant clinician and the public health minister

  • Topical questions on flooding and the Glasgow bin lorry tragedy

  • The transport minister delivered an emergency statement on the Forth Road Bridge closure

  • MSPs debated the Criminal Justice Bill which sets out police powers to arrest, question and detain people

  • The member's debate focused on the campaign against Aberdeen's controversial Marischal Square project

  1. Background: Nicola Sturgeon denies Forth Road Bridge maintenance cutspublished at 14:22 Greenwich Mean Time 8 December 2015

    First Minister Nicola Sturgeon has said it is "absolutely" not true that cuts to maintenance budgets led to the closure of the Forth Road Bridge.

    The bridge will be closed to all traffic until the new year after a defect was found in one of the support beams on the north tower.

    First Minister Nicola Sturgeon meeting maintenance workersImage source, PA

    Ms Sturgeon said all maintenance that had been required to be done on the bridge had been done.

    She said the crack that resulted in the bridge closure was "unforeseeable".

    The bridge was closed on Friday after a failure of the "inner link support beam to the North east tower truss end link".

  2. Forth Road Bridge closure an issue of national significancepublished at 14:22

    Transport Minister Derek Mackay thanks communities around the Forth Road Bridge for their continuing patience at this time. 

    Transport Minister Derek Mackay

    Mr Mackay says this is an issue of national significance.   

  3. Background: Why is the Forth Road Bridge closed?published at 14:21 Greenwich Mean Time 8 December 2015

    The Forth Road Bridge is to be closed until new year because of structural defects. The 51-year-old bridge has been hit by numerous problems over the past decade. What has happened this time?

    From the end of next year, the Forth Road Bridge will cease to be the most important link between Fife and Edinburgh when it is replaced by the new Queensferry crossing.

    The decision to build a new crossing came after years of problems with corrosion in the steel cables which support the existing suspension bridge's 13,800-tonne weight.

    However, the latest closure is for a completely different failure.

    Diagram showing location of defective steel component
    Image caption,

    this diagram shows the location of the defective steel component

    Chartered engineer Mark Arndt, from maintenance contractor Amey, told a media conference he had been faced with an "unprecedented set of circumstances".

    He described the fault as a failure of the "inner link support beam to the North east tower truss end link".

    The engineer went on to explain how a crack of about 20mm in width had appeared in the load-bearing link.

    If the same had gone on to happen on the other side, the road deck could have fallen by a minimum of 150mm (6in).

  4. Ministerial statement on the closure of the Forth Road Bridgepublished at 14:21

    Transport Minister Derek Mackay is updating the parliament on the closure of the Forth Road Bridge.

  5. Crown will look at any bill of letters forthcomingpublished at 14:20

    Scottish Labour MSP Jackie Baillie asks what the Crown and the government can do to facilitate the private prosecution of Harry Clarke. 

    Mr Mullholland says the decision not to prosecute was not taken in a vaccum and was not taking without assessing what the law of evidence was. 

    He says he will look at any bill of letters that is forthcoming. 

  6. 'Fit for purpose'published at 14:18

    Lord Advocat Frank Mullholland says the Crown has already been in touch with the CPS and the DVLA and will ensure any future prosecution is fit for purpose. 

  7. Nothing undermines the decision not to prosecute the driver of the bin lorry.published at 14:17

    Lib Dem MSP Alison McInnes says the driver was never formally interviewed by the police. 

    Lib Dem MSP Alison McInnes

    Is the lord advocate certain the investigation was as rigorous as it should have been, she asks. 

    Mr Mullholland says nothing undermines the decision not to prosecute the driver of the bin lorry. 

    He says the Crown recognises this is unpopular but the law must be followed. 

    Ms McInnes says the Crown acts in the public interest in these cases. 

  8. Background: The Glasgow bin lorry crash report at-a-glancepublished at 14:16 Greenwich Mean Time 8 December 2015

    A fatal accident inquiry into the bin lorry crash in which six people died has made a series of recommendations, mainly relating to how a driver's fitness to drive is recorded.

    Sheriff John Beckett said the most effective way of preventing a similar tragedy is

    The sheriff said responsibility for this lies with drivers and the DVLA (Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency), the UK-wide body that issues licences to drivers.

    Glasgow bin lorry

    He said the current fitness-to-drive regime was a self-reporting system which was "vulnerable to the withholding and concealing of relevant information by applicants".

    The sheriff said the current rules were unlikely to prevent a "deliberate deception" such as that by driver Harry Clarke, who had a history of dizziness and blackouts which were not reported to the DVLA.

    Here are the main points from the sheriff's findings:

  9. Lord advocate offers his heart felt sympathiespublished at 14;15

    Lord Advocate Frank Mulholland says the FAI findings raise significant issues for consideration. 

    Lord Advocate Frank Mulholland

    Mr Mullholland says the solicitor general has offered her assistance to implement the relevant recommendations. 

    He offers his heart felt sympathies to all the families for their losses.  

  10. Backgound: Glasgow bin lorry crash: Family to prosecute Harry Clarkepublished at 14:13 Greenwich Mean Time 8 December 2015

    A family which lost three members in the Glasgow bin lorry crash is to go ahead with a bid to stage a private prosecution of the driver.

    The decision came after an inquiry found thatthe tragedy could have been avoided if Harry Clarke had not lied about his history of blackouts.

    Mr Clarke, 58, was unconscious when the lorry veered out of control on 22 December 2014, killing six people.

    Victims of the Glasgow bin lorry crash

    The inquiry found he had "repeatedly lied in order to gain and retain jobs".

    Relatives of Erin McQuade and Jack and Lorraine Sweeney made the announcement about the private prosecution after a fatal accident inquiry (FAI) into the crash published its findings.

    In their statement, they criticised a decision by the Crown Office not to prosecute Mr Clarke and said they had instructed their own lawyers to take action.

  11. Question on the findings of the FOI into the Glasgow bin lorry crashpublished at 14:13

    Lib Dem MSP Alison McInnes ask the Scottish government what its response is to the findings of the fatal accident inquiry into the Glasgow bin lorry crash. 

  12. Discussions between Cosla and the Scottish government on flooding prevention schemespublished at 14:13

    South of Scotland MSP Jim Hume, a Lib Dem, raises the issue of the Bellwin Scheme and damage in Selkirk.

    Mr Swinney says discussions will take place between Cosla and the Scottish government to decide which flooding prevention schemes will be taken forward. 

  13. Hawick's flood prevention schemepublished at 14;10

    Conservative MSP for Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire John Lamont asks about plans for Hawick's flood prevention scheme. 

  14. Call for flooding prevention schemespublished at 14:09

    Labour MSP for Dumfries Elaine Murray asks the minister to encourage organisations to work with the council and bring flood defences forward.

    Flood damageImage source, PA

    Mr Swinney agrees with Elaine Murray that the work of the emergency services and those working to protect against the weather are deserving of praise.

  15. Minister details activation of the Bellwin Schemepublished at 14:06

    Finance Secretary John Swinney says Dumfries and Galloway, the Borders and Tayside were all hit by flooding and that is why he has activated the Bellwin Scheme. 

    Finance Secretary John Swinney

    Ms McAlpine asks what lessons can be learned in Scotland by the failure of flood defences in Cumbria. 

    Mr Swinney says the situation in Cumbria has been dramatically more difficult, although Scotland has had some very significant impacts due to flooding. 

    He says careful planning for flood defences is essential. 

  16. Background: Flooding minister Aileen McLeod inspects Hawick flood damagepublished at 14:04 Greenwich Mean Time 8 December 2015

    Scottish flooding minister Aileen McLeod is visiting Hawick to see the damage it suffered over the weekend. 

    Hundreds of people were evacuated from their homes sparking calls to speed up the implementation of a flood prevention scheme. 

    Flood damage

    The Scottish government has announced the floods have triggered their Bellwin Scheme which helps councils with the cost of such natural emergencies. 

    Another rain warning is in place for parts of Scotland later this week. 

  17. Question on help for communities affected by floodingpublished at 14:03

    SNP MSP Joan McAlpine asks the Scottish government what action it is taking to help communities affected by storms and flooding. 

  18. Time for reflectionpublished at 14:00

    Welcome back for what promises to be a very busy afternoon at Holyrood.

    Reverend George R Fiddes from St Nicholas Parish Church, Prestwick.

     First up, as ever, is time for reflection, to be delivered by Reverend George R Fiddes from St Nicholas Parish Church, Prestwick.  

  19. Questions on flooding, the Glasgow Bin Lorry tragedy and a Forth Road Bridge statement from 2pmpublished at 13:14

     From 2pm: Topical questions on flooding and the FAI into the Glasgow Bin Lorry tragedy.

    Forth Road Bridge
    Image caption,

    Forth Road Bridge

    This will be followed by a ministerial statement on travails of the Forth Road Bridge and their impact on Scotland.   

  20. That ends the evidence session on the Transplantation Billpublished at 12:38

    That ends the evidence session on the Transplantation Bill.

    Anne McTaggart, Diane Barr, Louise Miller
    Image caption,

    That concludes the evidence session with Labour MSP Anne McTaggart

    We'll be back at 2pm with topical questions on flooding and the FAI into the Glasgow Bin Lorry tragedy.

    This will be followed by a ministerial statement on travails of the Forth Road Bridge.