MSPs clash over amendments and it's the first division!published at 15:23 Greenwich Mean Time 21 March 2018
Mr Tomkins speaks to his amendment saying he does not want to put a time limit on protecting the union, as he says Mr Findlay does.
The Union has endured for three centuries and it should endure for three more, he says.
Mr Findlay says Mr Tomkins has been shown up as someone who takes his orders from the Prime Minister's office.
Long way from consensus as we come to the first vote on the Labour MSP's amendment 14A, which leads to a five minute suspension for the first division.