Summary

  • The education committee takes evidence on the exam diet and curriculum and attainment trends

  • Transport, infrastructure, connectivity, and justice ministers face questions

  • The Scottish Tories lead a debate calling for the scrapping of standardised assessments for P1 pupils

  • A member's debate marks 10 years of BBC ALBA

  1. Transport Billpublished at 14:13 British Summer Time 19 September 2018

    SNP MSP Bob Doris asks how proposals in the goernment's Transport Bill aim to support the improved planning and delivery of socially-desirable bus routes.

  2. Transport secretary details work on south Scotland roadspublished at 14:12 British Summer Time 19 September 2018

    Transport Secretary Michael Matheson

    Transport Secretary Michael Matheson says the contract for the construction of the Maybole bypass is expected to be awarded by the end of the year.

    This will improve journey times along the A77, he adds.

    In addition, a study of transport on the Borders which recommended a range of action is being considered, he says.

    Tory MSP Oliver Mundell seeks an update on the A76 reopening and investment in the A75.

    Mr Matheson says the Scottish government will continue to make investments and points to the south west Scotland transport study opened today which will shape the strategic approach to road improvements.

    Labour MSP Colin Smyth insists a larger amount of investment in these roads is required than has been given in recent years.

    Again Mr Matheson says the south west Scotland transport study will guide where investments are needed.

  3. Trunk road network in Sout Scotland regionpublished at 14:09 British Summer Time 19 September 2018

    SNP MSP Joan McAlpine asks what action the government has to improve the trunk road network in the South Scotland region.

  4. Connectivity minister updates chamber on Stirling area broadbandpublished at 14:09 British Summer Time 19 September 2018

    Connectivity Minister Paul WheelhouseImage source, bbc
    Image caption,

    Connectivity Minister Paul Wheelhouse

    Connectivity Minister Paul Wheelhouse highlights 16,200 premises in the Stirling area have access to broadband as a result of the programme.

    Mr Wheelhouse says the Scottish government has responded to the failure of the UK government and has intervened.

  5. Background: Edinburgh and Stirling next for ultrafast broadbandpublished at 14:06 British Summer Time 19 September 2018

    Broadband cablesImage source, Thinkstock

    In April we reported that Edinburgh and Stirling were to be the next cities for installation of ultrafast broadband cabling into customers' homes and businesses.

    CityFibre announced the Scottish cities would follow Aberdeen in getting one gigabit per second potential speeds, along with Coventry and Huddersfield.

    Those that were already set for the roll-out - in a tie-up with Vodafone - are Aberdeen, Peterborough and Milton Keynes.

    CityFibre said it aimed to make digital inadequacy "a thing of the past".

  6. Broadband connectivitypublished at 14:05 British Summer Time 19 September 2018

    SNP MSP Bruce Crawford ask what percentage of households in the Stirling constituency have faster broadband connectivity.

  7. Minister highlights work on projectpublished at 14:04 British Summer Time 19 September 2018

    Transport Secretary Michael Matheson
    Image caption,

    Transport Secretary Michael Matheson

    Ms Baker says Levenmouth is the largest conurbation in Scotland without a rail line and it has below average car ownership.

    She seeks a meeting with the cabinet secretary to discuss the project.

    Transport Secretary Michael Matheson says a considerable amount of work has been taken forward on the issue.

    He agrees to a meeting with the member and other stakeholders.

    SNP MSP Jenny Gilruth invites the cabinet secretary to come to Leven to see the benefits of the rail link.

    Mr Matheson accepts the invitation.

  8. Levenmouth rail projectpublished at 14:01 British Summer Time 19 September 2018

    Labour MSP Claire Baker asks the Scottish government what recent discussions it has had with Transport Scotland regarding the Levenmouth rail project.

  9. Portfolio questions........transport and infrastructure and connectivity ministers are up firstpublished at 14:00 British Summer Time 19 September 2018

    Tansport and connectivityImage source, ScotRail/Getty Images
  10. Coming up................published at 12:26 British Summer Time 19 September 2018

    Child writing and John SwinneyImage source, Thinkstock/PA

    All eyes will be on the chamber this afternoon as the Tories bring a motion calling for ministers to "halt the tests in P1", while the government insists "assessments are a key tool" for identifying the needs of the children

    Ahead of this, portfolio questions focuses on transport, infrastructure and connectivity, and justice ministers and law officers.

    The evening member's debate will celebrate 10 years of BBC Alba.

    Join us for extensive coverage and analysis.

  11. Tory MSP ask if there has been enough road testing of initiativespublished at 12:19 British Summer Time 19 September 2018

    Tory MSP Oliver MundellImage source, bbc
    Image caption,

    Tory MSP Oliver Mundell

    Tory MSP Oliver Mundell asks if there has not been enough road testing of initiatives.

    Prof Scott argues any major Scottish initiative takes ten to 15 years to bed in.

    He points out rushing something ends up with it not working.

    The professor says it would have been very helpful to have central national modelling of the CfE.

  12. Labour MSP briefly raises standardised assessmentspublished at 12:13 British Summer Time 19 September 2018

    Dr Alan Britton

    Labour MSP Johann Lamont seeks a view on standardised assessments and how this sits with the curriculum for excellence.

    Dr Alan Britton says he is not seeing evidence of consultation and consensus-building on this policy decision.

    Prof Jim Scotts explains academics can only look at an initiative and evidence to suggest it would be beneficial, but we have not seen sufficient evidence that this is the case.

    Join us for the Scottish Conservative-led debate this afternoon which is calling for assessments at P1 to be scrapped.

  13. SNP MSP raises the issue of the mental health of pupils taking examspublished at 12:10 British Summer Time 19 September 2018

    SNP MSP Jenney Gilruth
    Image caption,

    SNP MSP Jenny Gilruth

    SNP MSP Jenny Gilruth says in certain high schools the pupils dictate the curriculum through their choice.

    Ms Gilruth highlights the issue of the mental health of children facing exams and asks whether this could be staggered.

    Dr Janet Brown points out assessments can be done at any time of the year and insists it is a flexible environment.

  14. Young people want 'more fluid' assessmentpublished at 12:07 British Summer Time 19 September 2018

    Dr Janet Brown of the SQA
    Image caption,

    Dr Janet Brown of the SQA

    Mr Greer asks about the impact on pupil's expectation of themselves.

    Dr Brown from the SQA highlights a steep increase in workload from S4 onwards.

    Dr Burton suggests getting in touch with young people's organisations but he says there is very limited research.

    Dr Brown says the SQA has been working with Young Scot on young people's views around assessment, which suggests they want more fluid assessment.

    This piece of work will be published in October, she confirms.

  15. Background: Lack of subject choice for some exam pupilspublished at 11:59 British Summer Time 19 September 2018

    PupiplsImage source, Getty images

    Concerns over the choice of subjects available in some secondary schools came to the fore at First Ministers Questions in May.

    Conservative leader Ruth Davidson highlighted how some youngsters get the chance to do just six qualifications in S4 while others do more.

    The situation varies from school to school and from council to council.

    But does the number of qualifications a youngster obtains in S4 really matter?

    In the old days, it was simple.

  16. Postpublished at 11:57 British Summer Time 19 September 2018

    This Twitter post cannot be displayed in your browser. Please enable Javascript or try a different browser.View original content on Twitter
    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    Skip twitter post

    Allow Twitter content?

    This article contains content provided by Twitter. We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as they may be using cookies and other technologies. You may want to read Twitter’s cookie policy, external and privacy policy, external before accepting. To view this content choose ‘accept and continue’.

    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    End of twitter post
  17. We are 'piling initiatives on initiatives' warns academicpublished at 11:50 British Summer Time 19 September 2018

    Prof Scott suggests it should be mandatory for headteachers to speak to parents about the curriculum on offer.

    Research indicates this does not happen everywhere, he explains.

    Green MSP Ross Greer

    Green MSP Ross Greer asks about recent events which have caused more confusion for headteachers.

    Prof Scott points to the removal of unit assessments, with teachers being unsure about how this effects them and their students.

    There is a problem with how we are "piling initiatives on initiatives", he warns.

    I can show you evidence of abandoned initiatives, truncated initiatives, things-that-didn't-work-out-as-planned initiatives, which all have an impact on children.

  18. Call for more research into young people dropping out of the systempublished at 11:47 British Summer Time 19 September 2018

    Tory MSP Oliver Mundell raises the issue of the number of young people have dropped out of the system.

    Prof Scott argues there needs to be more work done here.

    The Dundee University academic tells the committee: "The ones who are hardest to track are the ones who are least able to survive the environment they find themselves in."

    "I am a little bit ashamed that I have turned up without an answer to that question, because I think equity is the most important thing we do."

  19. CfE core principles sound but no consensus on implementationpublished at 11:38 British Summer Time 19 September 2018

    Prof Scott

    I've found no teacher or headteacher who disagrees with the core principles guiding the curriculum for excellence, Prof Scott tells the committee.

    The documentation does not just cover school choices but also the wider experiences of young people, he states.

    There is not a common consensus in Scotland about what CfE consists of and local authorities have interpreted it differently, he states.

    Prof Scott suggests a curriculum self-help book should be provided nationally, pointing to informal examples.

  20. Subject choice reduction becomes self fulfilling prophesypublished at 11:30 British Summer Time 19 September 2018

    Lib Dem MSP Tavish Scott
    Image caption,

    Lib Dem MSP Tavish Scott

    Lib Dem MSP Tavish Scott suggests subject choice reduction starts to become a self-fulfilling prophesy because it will lead to fewer teachers being employed and therefore fewer courses being on offer.

    Prof Jim Scott agrees this may be the case.

    Mr Scott asks how the narrowing of education can be fixed and Prof Scott calls for a mid-point upgrade.

    Prof Scott says research into education has not be utilised particularly well.