Summary

  • MSPs debate and vote on the Brexit draft withdrawal agreement

  • SNP, Labour, Green and Lib Dem members at Holyrood will back a motion rejecting the proposals, as well as the prospect of leaving without any deal

  • The Scottish Conservatives will vote against the motion, arguing that it is "needless"

  • Theresa May has been accused of "misleading Parliament, inadvertently or otherwise" as the full legal advice on her Brexit deal was published

  1. 'Britain is broken and Brexit will shatter it completely'published at 16:32 Greenwich Mean Time 5 December 2018

    SNP MSP Stuart McMillanImage source, bbc
    Image caption,

    SNP MSP Stuart McMillan

    SNP MSP Stuart McMillan says MPs have been told it's this deal or no deal.

    "This is not a game show," he argues, warning against potential tragedy and suffering that a no deal could cause.

    Mr McMillan also argues the backstop will make Northern Ireland more competitive than Scotland.

    He insists: "Britain is broken and Brexit will shatter it completely."

  2. Tory MSP warns about 'the ramifications of not respecting' Brexit referendum votepublished at 16:29 Greenwich Mean Time 5 December 2018

    Tory MSP Jamie GreeneImage source, bbc
    Image caption,

    Tory MSP Jamie Greene

    Tory MSP Jamie Greene says some people are using today to rerun the debate about whether we should leave or remain in the EU, "a debate we have already had".

    Mr Greene argues this is a "sorry debate" and says he accepts this deal which is a compromise, although he concedes he was "not over the moon" about it.

    The Tory MSP insists the Labour arguments "reek of opportunism".

    Nobody knows if Jeremy Corbyn wants to leave the EU or not, he suggests.

    Mr Greene says the EU referendum was UK-wide and one million voters in Scotland voted to leave.

    "The ramifications of not respecting the outcome of that vote sets a very, very difficult precedent in my view."

  3. Brexit is 'bad news for Britain' says SNP MSPpublished at 16:25 Greenwich Mean Time 5 December 2018

    SNP MSP Jenny Gilruth
    Image caption,

    SNP MSP Jenny Gilruth

    SNP MSP Jenny Gilruth says the fact that the SNP, Greens, Labour and Lib Dems have teamed up should tell you something about the deal.

    Highlighting the increased experiences of racism since the EU vote, she tells the migrant community: "You will always be welcome in Scotland."

    Brexit is "bad news for Britain, and the prime minister knows it," Ms Gilruth insists.

    "The prime minister's plan is not fit for purpose."

  4. 'Flouting the will of the Scottish Parliament' is not democracy says Labour MSPpublished at 16:18 Greenwich Mean Time 5 December 2018

    Labour MSP Pauline McNeillImage source, bbc
    Image caption,

    Labour MSP Pauline McNeill

    Labour MSP Pauline McNeill says ignoring the 48% of people who did not vote leave and "flouting the will of the Scottish Parliament" is not democracy.

    Ms McNeill adds: "David Cameron, I believe, made one of the poorest judgement calls of any prime minister in history, and has risked the future of the United Kingdom".

  5. A moment of mirth in an otherwise tense debate......published at 16:14 Greenwich Mean Time 5 December 2018

    Deputy Presiding Officer Christine Grahame
    Image caption,

    Deputy Presiding Officer Christine Grahame accidentally causes offence

    Deputy Presiding Officer Christine Grahame interrupts Scottish Green co-convener Patrick Harvie's intervention, reminding him that this was an intervention, not a speak.

    She warns the chamber that interventions must be "short, sharp and interesting".

    A ripple of laughter goes through the chamber, leading Ms Grahame to clarify: "Mr Harvie, before you look piqued, I was not referring to your particularly intervention, it was a general comment."

  6. SNP MSP lambastes UK government deal and Tory MSPspublished at 16:12 Greenwich Mean Time 5 December 2018

    SNP MSP Tom ArthurImage source, bbc

    SNP MSP Tom Arthur lambastes the case put forward by the UK government "shamelessly and sadly supported by Tory MSPs".

    Mr Arthur argues they have "debased themselves to underlings and schills".

  7. Pro-EU Tory MSP insists democracy must be respectedpublished at 16:07 Greenwich Mean Time 5 December 2018

    Tory MSP Liz Smith
    Image caption,

    Tory MSP Liz Smith

    Tory MSP Liz Smith begins by explaining she still believes staying in the EU would be better for the UK.

    But she says she accepts that the people of the UK believed the economic advantages were outweighed by political disadvantages.

    "We should accept that democracy is the important side of that," she says.

    Labour MSP Kezia Dugdale intervenes to insists the facts have changed so people should be able to vote again.

    Ms Smith responds that we cannot keep taking votes just because we disagree with the outcome.

  8. Brexit: Release of full legal advice sparks political rowpublished at 16:04 Greenwich Mean Time 5 December 2018

    Media caption,

    The SNP's Ian Blackford says the Brexit deal denies Scottish rights

    Theresa May's Brexit backstop plan risks a "stalemate" and "protracted rounds of negotiations" with the EU, the full legal advice, externalon her deal says.

    Newly published documents show the PM was told an arrangement designed to prevent a hard Irish border could last "indefinitely" and the UK could not "lawfully exit" without EU agreement.

    The Democratic Unionists said this would be "devastating" for the UK.

    But Mrs May rejected SNP claims she has misled Parliament on the issue.

    Ministers were forced to publish Attorney General Geoffrey Cox's full advice after ministers were found in contempt of Parliament on Tuesday for providing only a legal overview earlier this week.

    Speaking in the Commons, the prime minister said there was "no difference" between the two documents and the legal position on her proposed "temporary" customs arrangement with the EU was clear.

  9. SNP MSP 'totally opposed to this deal' despite having voted for Brexitpublished at 15:59 Greenwich Mean Time 5 December 2018

    SNP MSP Alex NeilImage source, bbc
    Image caption,

    SNP MSP Alex Neil voted for Brexit but does not back Theresa May's deal

    SNP MSP Alex Neil begins saying the one thing about Theresa May's draft withdrawal agreement is that it has brought about a level of unity between Brexiteers and remainers, even among the SNP.

    Mr Neil adds that, as someone who voted for Brexit, he is totally opposed to this deal.

    He says: "In my view it is the worst of all possible worlds and the best of none."

    "It is neither fish nor fowl," Mr Neil adds.

    He says the backstop in the Brexit deal would be an "economic disaster".

    The SNP MSP claims that EU member states could refuse to let the UK out of the backstop meaning they could "have us over the proverbial barrel".

  10. Reality Check: Legal advice on the Brexit dealpublished at 15:54 Greenwich Mean Time 5 December 2018

    Chris Morris highlights some of the key points in the legal advice on the Withdrawal Agreement.

    Read More
  11. 'This deal does not meet the aspiration of our fishing communities'published at 15:47 Greenwich Mean Time 5 December 2018

    Labour MSP Rhoda Grant
    Image caption,

    Labour MSP Rhoda Grant

    Labour MSP Rhoda Grant says vibrant rural communities are integral and warns the Brexit deal puts these communities at risk.

    If we do not get a general election, the fishing community will because "rule takers" for the foreseeable, the Labour MSP adds.

    "This deal does not meet the aspiration of our fishing communities."

    She also warns about the impact that World Trade Organization rules would have on agriculture.

  12. Background: How Westminster Brexit debate and vote will workpublished at 15:44 Greenwich Mean Time 5 December 2018

    CommonsImage source, Getty Images

    Now, of course this evening's vote at Holyrood is very important and symbolic, but time is ticking towards D-day for Theresa May on 11 December, when the House of Commons will deliver its verdict on her Brexit deal.

    Most political observers agree that the prime minister currently does not have the numbers to get it through Parliament. But before any voting takes place, MPs will have to fill five days of debate on the deal, starting on Tuesday.

    According to the government's proposals, there can be up to six amendments to the motion. Any MP can put down an amendment but it is up to the Speaker - John Bercow - to decide which ones end up being put to the House of Commons.

    At the end of the fifth day of debate - Tuesday, 11 December - MPs will get to vote on amendments before voting on the final motion, whether amended or not.

    Read more.

  13. All available at Parliaments Online of course!published at 15:41 Greenwich Mean Time 5 December 2018

    This Twitter post cannot be displayed in your browser. Please enable Javascript or try a different browser.View original content on Twitter
    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    Skip twitter post

    Allow Twitter content?

    This article contains content provided by Twitter. We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as they may be using cookies and other technologies. You may want to read Twitter’s cookie policy, external and privacy policy, external before accepting. To view this content choose ‘accept and continue’.

    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    End of twitter post
  14. Migration bill not published because it would 'terrify' business says SNP MSPpublished at 15:40 Greenwich Mean Time 5 December 2018

    SNP MSP Joan McAlpine
    Image caption,

    SNP MSP Joan McAlpine

    SNP MSP Joan McAlpine says the prime minister is trying to "intimidate" the country by saying it is her deal or a "cliff edge Brexit".

    The Brexit "is what it is because Mrs May boxed herself in with rigid red line," Ms McAlpine argues.

    She highlights projections indicating the working age population in Scotland will decrease without migration.

    The migration bill remains unpublished because it would "terrify" businesses further and increase opposition to the deal, she insists.

  15. 'This deal is pragmatic'published at 15:36 Greenwich Mean Time 5 December 2018

    Tory MSP Donald Cameron
    Image caption,

    Tory MSP Donald Cameron

    Tory MSP Donald Cameron insists Mrs May's deal respects the result of the 2016 referendum.

    "This deal is pragmatic," he says.

    Mr Cameron warns that a rejection of the deal would create considerable uncertainty for business.

    The deal ensures there will be no hard barriers put in place on the day we leave the EU, he adds.

  16. SNP MSP says people are 'sick to the back teeth' of this 'sorry mess'published at 15:30 Greenwich Mean Time 5 December 2018

    SNP MSP Bruce CrawfordImage source, bbc
    Image caption,

    SNP MSP Bruce Crawford

    SNP MSP Bruce Crawford says he, like many other Scots, "voted with my head, my heart and my soul to remain in the EU".

    Mr Crawford argues people are "sick to the back teeth" of this "sorry mess".

    He says he is pleased with the joint motion today and that only the Tories oppose it.

    The constitution committee convener says he is "just sad" at their opposition.

    The Tory MSPsImage source, bbc
  17. Lib Dem MSP says it is the people who must determine the futurepublished at 15:21 Greenwich Mean Time 5 December 2018

    Mr Scott says there is no easy way out of the backstop.

    The Lib Dem MSP adds the UK's own financial settlement says every person will be worse off as a result of Brexit.

    He says seven UK ministers have left since the deal was published.

    So what is the alternative, he asks himself.

    The Lib Dem MSP says it is the people who must determine the future, calling for a "People's Vote".

    "The prime minister's deal is dead," he says, accusing the Scottish Tories of being like "lemmings" rushing towards the cliff edge.

  18. 'The end cannot be far away'published at 15:18 Greenwich Mean Time 5 December 2018

    LIb Dem MSP Tavish ScottImage source, bbc
    Image caption,

    LIb Dem MSP Tavish Scott

    LIb Dem MSP Tavish Scott says this is a UK government which is in contempt of parliament for the first time in history and one that faced three defeats in one day

    "The end cannot be far away," he adds.

  19. 'This is not a government fit to take us out of this crisis. They are the crisis.'published at 15:14 Greenwich Mean Time 5 December 2018

    The Scottish Green MSP says ultimately his ambition is for an independent Scotland, which would be an independent member of the EU.

    However, that's not for today and he points to the combined motion today and goes on to say he is proud to have co-authored it.

    He reiterates the Greens backing for a second referendum.

    Mr Greer says: "This is not a government fit to take us out of this crisis. They are the crisis."

  20. 'It's a bad deal for Scotland'published at 15:12 Greenwich Mean Time 5 December 2018

    Scottish Green MSP Ross GreerImage source, bbc
    Image caption,

    Scottish Green MSP Ross Greer

    Scottish Green MSP Ross Greer says the "chaotic dying" Tory party is responsible for the Brexit crisis.

    Mr Greer says the loss of EU environmental and labour enforcement should be a concern for all of us.

    The Scottish Green MSP argues: "It's a bad deal for Scotland."