Summary

  • The Justice Committee takes evidence on the Children (Scotland) Bill

  • Topical questions features queries about Caledonian Sleeper complaints and primary school overcrowding

  • MSPs debate improving Gypsy/Traveller lives

  • An SNP MSP leads a debate on the Showmen's Guild

  1. Could parental alienation impact cases involving domestic abuse allegations?published at 10:25 Greenwich Mean Time 14 January 2020

    SNP MSP Rona Mackay raises the issue of parental alienation and how this could impact domestic abuse allegation.

    Parental alienation is when a child rejects a parent as a result of psychological manipulation by the other parent.

    Mr Maxwell accepts it is a "controversial point" but insists parental alienation must be one of the topics on the training list for those working with children.

    I would refute the suggestion it would divert allegations of domestic abuse, he adds.

  2. Children can pick up on a parent's angerpublished at 10:22 Greenwich Mean Time 14 January 2020

    June Loudoun from Grandparents Apart UKImage source, bbc
    Image caption,

    June Loudoun from Grandparents Apart UK

    June Loudoun from Grandparents Apart UK says sometimes the adversarial nature of the legal system creates larger problems between a couple.

    Ms Louden agrees children can pick up on a parent's anger and form their opinions based on that.

    Finding out what is happening and not making it a competition would help to minimise this, she adds.

  3. Call for training for collecting views of young childrenpublished at 10:19 Greenwich Mean Time 14 January 2020

    Ms Gilruth wonders about taking evidence from very young children.

    Dr Whitcombe says direct questions should not be avoided, but observe the child through play and other mechanisms to understand relationships with parents.

    She says a different skillset is required for this than what solicitors have.

    Mr Maxwell agrees there needs to be the appropriate training for the people doing this work.

  4. Background: Policy aims of the Children (Scotland) Billpublished at 10:14 Greenwich Mean Time 14 January 2020

    According to the Scottish government, the policy aims of the Children (Scotland) Bill, external are to:

    • ensure the views of the child are heard in contact and residence cases
    • further protect victims of domestic abuse and their children
    • ensure the bests interests of the child are at the centre of contact and residence cases and Children’s Hearings
    • further compliance with the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC) in family court actions.
  5. 'We need to understand what is going on for the child'published at 10:11 Greenwich Mean Time 14 January 2020

    Dr Sue Whitcombe

    Dr Sue Whitcombe, a chartered psychologist, focuses on the influence that can be brought to bear on children.

    She says a child can give very different views in front of either parent, pointing out they can be vehemently against contact and then enjoy it later.

    "We need to understand what is going on for the child."

    A child learns from a very young age that it might not be acceptable to talk about another parent due to their mother or father getting upset, which will lead to their views changing she adds.

    We must find out why a child does not want to see a parent as it is usually a sign of psychological distress.

  6. Children must be given time to relax and share viewspublished at 10:08 Greenwich Mean Time 14 January 2020

    SNP MSP Jenny Gilruth begins on the topic of children's participation in decisions made about them.

    She seeks further information on the suggestion children may be under pressure or influenced by parents or other family members.

    Ian Maxwell from Shared Parenting Scotland
    Image caption,

    Ian Maxwell from Shared Parenting Scotland

    Ian Maxwell from Shared Parenting Scotland says children will sometimes say different things to each parent because they want to say what parents want to hear.

    It is therefore important to ensure children are given proper time when collecting their views, he adds, suggesting there should be at least three meetings so the child will feel more relaxed.

    Mr Maxwell adds that a child saying negative things about a parent they are not seeing must be considered "carefully" because when given time they will often be happy to have contact with that parent.

  7. Background: New bill to improve Scotland's family courts publishedpublished at 10:00 Greenwich Mean Time 14 January 2020

    ChildImage source, Getty Images

    Proposed new laws to improve the experience of children involved in family courts have been published by the Scottish government.

    The Children (Scotland) Bill, external follows a consultation which took into account the views of young people.

    Ministers say they want to ensure the justice system does not contribute to young people's distress.

    Campaigners said the legislation was "vital" for child victims of domestic abuse.

    The proposals are intended to update the 1995 Children Act, to reflect changes within modern families.

  8. Justice Committee begins shortly...published at 09:41 Greenwich Mean Time 14 January 2020

    The Justice Committee will continue its scrutiny of the Children Bill, external at Stage 1 shortly.

    MSPs will take evidence from:

    Child in distressImage source, Thinkstock

    and then from:

  9. Welcome to Holyrood Livepublished at 11:41 Greenwich Mean Time 13 January 2020

    Child upsetImage source, Getty Images

    The Justice Committee continues its consideration of the Children Bill. This proposed legislation aims to improve children's experiences of family courts.

    Topical questions will feature queries about Caledonian Sleeper complaints and primary school overcrowding.

    The Scottish government will then lead a debate on how best to improve the lives of Gypsy/Travellers.

    Local authorities will use £2m of the funding to improve accommodation and sitesImage source, Google
    Image caption,

    Local authorities will use £2m of the funding to improve accommodation and sites

    MSPs will then celebrate the work of the Showmen’s Guild of Great Britain and Northern Ireland in the evening's member's debate.