Summary

  • MSPs agree to the government's Scottish Rate Resolution, setting income tax for 2020/21.

  • There were 58 votes for it, 50 against and five abstentions.

  • Stage Two amendments to the Budget resulting from the SNP-Green Bill were unanimously passed by the finance committee

  • The general principles of the Budget Bill were agreed to last week with 65 MSPs backing the principles and 54 voting against them

  • The final budget debate begins tomorrow afternoon from 3.05pm - join us for extensive coverage as ever

  1. Basic free trade deal would make Scotland £9bn worse off by 2030published at 14:19 Greenwich Mean Time 4 March 2020

    Mr Russell says there has not been agreement on how the devolved governments will be involved in the second stage of negotiations.

    Agriculture, environment and fisheries will be at the heart of these negotiations, all of which are devolved areas, he says.

    The section of the document on justice issues is "unacceptable in tone and sentiment" the cabinet secretary adds, highlighting Scotland has a separate legal system to the rest of the UK.

    The minister says if the basic free trade sought by the UK government is agree, Scotland's GDP would be 6.1% - or £9bn - lower by 2030 than if the UK remained a full EU member.

  2. 'The UK government is now in the hands of ideological extremists'published at 14:13 Greenwich Mean Time 4 March 2020

    Brexit Secretary Mike Russell
    Image caption,

    Brexit Secretary Mike Russell

    Mike Russell explains this statement is about the publication of the UK government's approach to negotiations with the EU.

    The Brexit Secretary says the approach of this document will make people worse off financially in Scotland.

    "The UK government is now in the hands of ideological extremists," Mr Russell tells the chamber.

    He bemoans the lack of involvement of the devolved nations in creating this document.

    Mr Russell, now officially known now as the constitution, Europe and external affairs secretary, says the devolved nations are once again being managed, not engaged.

  3. Brexit: What to expect from UK-EU trade talkspublished at 14:11 Greenwich Mean Time 4 March 2020

    Katya Adler
    Europe Editor

    David Frost (l) and Michel Barnier (r) will lead the negotiating teamsImage source, Reuters/AFP/GEtty
    Image caption,

    David Frost (l) and Michel Barnier (r) will lead the negotiating teams

    So this is it. After three messy years negotiating the UK's exit from the EU, Monday was the day that trade talks finally began between the two sides.

    David Frost, the UK's chief negotiator, arrived in Brussels in the afternoon, armed with 100 advisers and civil servants, preparing to spread themselves across 10 working groups, focusing on everything from fishing to financial services to truck drivers' cross-border access.

    Negotiations are to take place once every two or three weeks from now until the summer at least, alternating between Brussels and London - with the prime minister insisting a deal must be struck by the year's end.

    On the edge of your seat with excitement, are you?

    Thought not. But should you be?

  4. Postpublished at 14:09 Greenwich Mean Time 4 March 2020

    This X post cannot be displayed in your browser. Please enable Javascript or try a different browser.View original content on X
    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    Skip X post

    Allow X content?

    This article contains content provided by X. We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as they may be using cookies and other technologies. You may want to read X’s cookie policy, external and privacy policy, external before accepting. To view this content choose ‘accept and continue’.

    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    End of X post
  5. Brexit: UK government negotiation mandate statementpublished at 14:05 Greenwich Mean Time 4 March 2020

    EU, Saltire and Union Jack flags in a potImage source, Getty Images

    Brexit Secretary Mike Russell will now deliver a statement on the UK government negotiation mandate.

  6. Call for NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde to review gender reassignment policypublished at 14:01 Greenwich Mean Time 4 March 2020

    Social Security Secretary Shirley-Anne Somerville
    Image caption,

    Social Security Secretary Shirley-Anne Somerville

    Social Security Secretary Shirley-Anne Somerville says the Scottish government expects everyone to be treated with consideration, dignity and respect when using NHS services.

    The government supports the appropriate use of single sex exemptions by service providers where it is proportionate, adds Ms Somerville.

    Ms McAlpine says NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde's gender reassignment policy says a female patient distressed at the presence of a "male bodied trans identified person in the next bed", should be told that person is female.

    Ms McAlpine calls on the minister to speak to the board about reviewing its policy.

    The minister says women's rights must be protected by health boards, while abiding by the exceptions in the Equalities Act.

  7. Background: The dividing lines over Scotland's gender lawspublished at 13:53 Greenwich Mean Time 4 March 2020

    Protesters demonstrated outside Holyrood last June calling for reform of the Gender Recognition ActImage source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    Protesters demonstrated outside Holyrood last June calling for reform of the Gender Recognition Act

    The Scottish government is proposing to make it easier to legally change gender. Supporters say the plans are vital to ensure transgender people are treated with dignity - but one woman who used hormones and surgery to become a man, only to regret the decision, has described the proposed reforms as "dangerous".

    Sinead Watson says she didn't have any issues with her gender as a child.

    It wasn't until she began to grow into a woman in her teens that a feeling of insecurity took hold, and she began to dislike her body and feel uncomfortable in her own skin.

    When she was in her early 20s, she told BBC Scotland's The Nine, she typed into Google "something along the lines of 'I'm a woman, I wish I was a man'."

    The results page introduced Ms Watson to the concept of gender dysphoria, defined by the NHS, external as discomfort or distress caused by a mismatch between biological sex and gender identity.

    Read more here.

  8. Single sex exemptions under the Equality Act 2010published at 13:51 Greenwich Mean Time 4 March 2020

    SNP MSP Joan McAlpine asks the Scottish government, in light of its commitment to uphold the single sex exemptions under the Equality Act 2010, what its response is to concerns that this could be undermined by allowing male hospital patients who identify as female, including those who have made no physical changes, to be placed in wards that match their gender identity.

  9. Social Security and Older People questions...published at 13:49 Greenwich Mean Time 4 March 2020

    Old folk and social security collageImage source, bbc/Getty images/PA

    MSPs quiz social security and older people ministers during portfolio questions.

  10. Minister points to £95m extra for councilspublished at 13:43 Greenwich Mean Time 4 March 2020

    Local Government Secretary Aileen Campbell
    Image caption,

    Local Government Secretary Aileen Campbell

    Local Government Secretary Aileen Campbell says an additional £95m has been allocated to local government on top of that announced in the draft budget.

    Mr Stewart says the recent £95m does not account for inflation and years of cuts and does not resolve the "blackhole" in capital funding.

    Ms Campbell recognises challenges across the whole of public finance driven by ten years of austerity from the UK government.

  11. Council budgetspublished at 13:40 Greenwich Mean Time 4 March 2020

    Tory MSP Alexander Stewart asks what action the Scottish government will take to protect local authority services, in light of the claim by COSLA that the proposals in its draft Budget "will hit vulnerable communities the hardest".

  12. Coming up...Brexit and income taxpublished at 11:30 Greenwich Mean Time 4 March 2020

    The BudgetImage source, Scottish Parliament

    1.30pm: Portfolio Questions: Communities and Local Government; Social Security and Older People

    2.10-2.40pm: Brexit statement – UK government negotiation mandate

    2.40 - 4.10 pm: Scottish Rate Resolution debate

    4.10 - 5.30 pm:STEM in Early Years Education debate

    5.30 pm: Decision Time

    5.30 pm: Members’ Business: Emma Harper – Eating Disorders Awareness Week 2020

  13. MSPs agree to all the amendments to the Budget Billpublished at 11:25 Greenwich Mean Time 4 March 2020

    Finance Secretary Kate ForbesImage source, bbc
    Image caption,

    Finance Secretary Kate Forbes

    The finance secretary explains her amendments are to give effect to the budget deal agreement with the Greens and also reflect revised portfolios.

    All amendments are agreed unanimously by the committee.

    That ends the Stage Two consideration of the Budget Bill, join us tomorrow for the final debate and expected passing of the budget.

  14. The evidence session on the budget draws to a closepublished at 11:19 Greenwich Mean Time 4 March 2020

    Mr Cameron says it is "hypocritical" to complain about uncertainty around consequentials when the government has used those consequentials to reach a deal.

    Ms Forbes replies: "If the UK government, if the Conservatives, fail to deliver on their promises that they made to the electorate in the December election and therefore we see a cut, whose fault is that?"

    "I'm not here to give evidence, cabinet secretary, you are," says Mr Cameron.

    And with that we move on to debate and vote on the budget amendments.

  15. Scottish budget had to be based on UK Conservative Party manifestopublished at 11:18 Greenwich Mean Time 4 March 2020

    Tory MSP Donald CameronImage source, bbc
    Image caption,

    Tory MSP Donald Cameron

    Tory MSP Donald Cameron asks if the cabinet secretary accepts the draft budget used Barnett consequential of £468m in excess of the Treasury's forecast of over £1.1bn as per the spending round of last September.

    The finance secretary accepts that £1.1bn of additional resource budget was allocated at the UK spending round, to which she added £142m of anticipated consequentials from the forthcoming UK budget.

    Ms Frorbes says that is part of the £468m with the remainder being capital.

    The cabinet secretary tells the committee that the government has based decisions on the best available evidence.

    The question will be if the UK government meets its commitments made during the election campaign, as the Treasury has continually cited the pledges in the manifesto, she adds.

  16. Background: Cash for the cops increases in budget dealpublished at 10:58 Greenwich Mean Time 4 March 2020

    The budget deal means an overall an increase of £60 for police spending:

    • £18m to police services
    • £13m for frontline services
    • £5m for capital investments
    PoliceImage source, Getty Images
  17. Police and fire service budgetspublished at 10:55 Greenwich Mean Time 4 March 2020

    Labour MSP Alex Rowley
    Image caption,

    Labour MSP Alex Rowley

    SNP MSP George Adam turns discussion to police budgets and Ms Forbes says the government will have exceeded its commitment to maintain revenue budgets next year.

    Labour MSP Alex Rowley asks about the fire service budget and whether enough cash has been allocated to meet the pay offer.

    The finance secretary confirms the fire service budget is protected, but the Scottish government is not involved in pay negotiations with staff.

    There is an uplift of £6.1m to meet modernisation aims for the fire service, she adds.

  18. Reserves and resource borrowing of £93m in place to deal with volatility and uncertaintypublished at 10:50 Greenwich Mean Time 4 March 2020

    Finance Secretary Kate Forbes
    Image caption,

    Finance Secretary Kate Forbes

    Mr Fraser says income tax reconciliations in the current budget came to £204m and the current projected sum for the following year is £550m.

    How prudent is it to start spending future years' income, he asks, with a bigger issue to address in a year's time.

    "This is a judgement call," replies the finance secretary, arguing she has protected the reserve and she has left £93m of resource borrowing headroom to address volatility and uncertainty coming down the line.

    Kate Forbes points out there are issues with the fiscal framework which means her borrowing powers will not cover the income tax reconciliations at over £500m next year.