Summary

  • Australians have voted against a historic Indigenous referendum

  • Australia's national broadcaster ABC projects that three states have voted no, effectively defeating the referendum

  • Australia's Prime Minister Anthony Albanese said he respected the outcome of the vote and called on Indigenous people to maintain their hope

  • Voters were asked to enshrine an Indigenous advisory body in the constitution that recognises Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people as the nation’s First Peoples

  • No campaigners said the Voice to Parliament racially divides the country and have questioned how it would operate

  • But Yes advocates said it was a modest yet profound change allowing Indigenous Australians to take their 'rightful place' in their own country

  1. A wrap of today's Voice referendum votepublished at 13:43 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    Ayeshea Perera
    BBC News

    It's just gone 11.30m in Sydney and we're winding down our coverage today of the referendum vote in Australia.

    If you haven't been following or are just logging on to see what happened, here's all you need to know about what transpired today:

    • A majority of Australians have rejected the Voice referendum, with a majority of people in all of the six states voting No
    • To succeed, the Yes campaign would have needed the support of at least four states, and a majority of the national votes
    • The Voice sought to establish an Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander body to advise the government on the issues affecting their communities. As well as creating an advisory body, the amendment sought to recognise Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders as Australia’s First Peoples in its constitution.
    • Australia Capital Territory, which includes the capital Canberra, is the only region that has voted Yes to the reform. However, it does not count as a state vote, and only goes into the national tally
    • Prime Minister Anthony Albanese said after the result that Australians need to find a way forward, and that the "moment of disagreement" does not define the people
    • South Australia's Opposition leader David Speirs called for PM Albanese to resign in the event of a resounding No vote from the Australian public
    • Yes campaign director Dean Parkin, in response to the result, said: "this is a base, not a summit. We will build on this." Yes supporters believe the reform would lead to real improvements - including healthcare and employment - in the lives of Indigenous peoples
    • No supporters argued that the Voice, a proposal to include an Indigenous-led elected advisory body in the parliament, was divisive, had not been "road tested" and was a "leap into the unknown"
    • Leading figure Warren Mundine in the No camp said the referendum was "built on a lie" and a waste of time and resources that could have been better spent on struggling communities

    Thanks for staying with us until now.

    And a huge thank you to all the reporters who have worked on bringing you this coverage. Reporting from Australia: Frances Mao, Tiffanie Turnbull, Hannah Ritchie, Katy Watson, Isabelle Rodd, Nicole Ng, and Simon Atkinson. And from our team in Singapore: Joel Guinto and Derek Cai.

  2. How have previous referendums fared?published at 13:19 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    The rejection of today's Voice referendum is not unusual in Australia.

    Australians have voted in 44 referendums since the Federation of Australia was formed in 1901, but only eight of those have passed.

    The most recent one before today's vote was on whether Australia should become a republic. That was held in 1999 and returned a No vote of 55%.

    It’s been more than 40 years since Australians last approved a change to their constitution. In 1977, the country voted Yes on a referendum consisting of three questions regarding a retirement age for judges, whether voters in Australian territories (not just states) could vote in referendums, and whether the government could hire covers for temporary vacancies in the senate.

    But if it feels like Australia held a major non-political vote more recently, you might be thinking of the 2017 vote on marriage equality. That was a plebiscite, which is a non-binding, temperature-taking vote on an issue, which returned a 61% vote in favour of same-sex marriage.

  3. 'Australia rejected the proposition to divide us on ancestry or race'published at 12:49 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    Australia's opposition leader Peter DuttonImage source, Getty Images

    More comments from opposition leader Peter Dutton who says that Australians would always reject a proposition which divided its people into different categories.

    "One of the great attributes of the Australian public is that we all see ourselves as equal. It doesn't matter if you came six months ago, or 60 years ago, or have 65,000 years of ancestry in this country. We are all equal Australians," he said.

    "I think the Australian public rejected the proposition to divide us on the basis of ancestry or race and that is a great thing for our country. We shouldn't shy away from that. Our nation's rulebook is incredibly important. It underpins the success of our country.

    "Australians have stood up today to defend that, to defend our history and to make sure that our future is certain."

  4. Strongest Yes in Melbourne city, strongest No in rural Queenslandpublished at 12:37 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    The strongest Yes vote - 73% - was in the city electorate of Melbourne, typically viewed as one of Australia's most liberal. The seat is held by the leader of the Australian Greens party, Adam Bandt.

    Meanwhile, the strongest No vote - 84.1%- was in Maranoa, a rural electorate in country Queensland, which is the seat of Nationals leader David Littleproud. The Nationals are the junior partner of the conservative opposition coalition. Mr Littleproud was one of the prominent opposition politicians out campaigning today and criticising the Voice.

  5. In pictures: Yes voters react to referendum resultspublished at 12:30 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    A Yes supporter reacts at the Inner West for 'Yes2023' official referendum function at Wests Ashfield Leagues Club on October 14, 2023 in Sydney, Australia.Image source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    Yes supporter at the Innert West in Sydney in tears following the results

    A Yes supporter reacts at the Inner West for 'Yes2023' official referendum function at Wests Ashfield Leagues Clubes Club on October 14, 2023 in Sydney, Australia.Image source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    Three Yes supporters at Wests Ashfield Leagues Club in Sydney

    Another Yes voter the same function at Wests Ashfield Leagues Club reacting to the resultsImage source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    Another Yes voter at the same function at Wests Ashfield Leagues Club reacting to the results

    NSW minister Joanna Haylen watches on with her children in Sydney as the votes are talliedImage source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    NSW minister Joanna Haylen watches on with her children in Sydney as the votes are tallied

  6. All six Australian states have voted against the Voicepublished at 12:20 British Summer Time 14 October 2023
    Breaking

    The national broadcaster is projecting that the No camp will win in Western Australia.

    This means that all six states have rejected the passage of the Indigenous referendum.

    In addition to a national majority, the Yes camp would have needed at least four out of six states to win - but it was clear just two hours after polls opened that this wasn't going to be the case.

    Australia Capital Territory, where the capital Canberra is located, is the only region projected to have voted Yes to the reform. But territories are not state votes, and only count towards the national vote.

  7. 'Referendum was built on a lie' - Leading No campaignerpublished at 12:16 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    Warren Mundine, a leading No campaignerImage source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    Warren Mundine, a leading No campaigner

    In light of the referendum results, the ABC earlier asked Warren Mundine, a leading figure in the vote No camp, if reconciliation is dead in Australia.

    "No, just because a proposal put forward was rejected by the Australia public?" said Mr Mundine who is an Indigenous man.

    "There are two things that I have heard in the polling booth is that people are sick of bad outcomes, and they are sick of governments making things up, they want it fixed," he said.

    Mr Mundine said the referendum was a waste of time and resources, and should never have been called in the first place. "They were promised something that didn't exist," he said, "It was built on a lie that Aboriginal people did not have a voice."

    "You sort of wonder why we spent hundreds of millions of dollars when we should have actually been spending that money on those communities that are struggling," he added.

  8. 'They've embarrassed themselves in front of the whole world'published at 12:06 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    Frances Mao
    BBC News, Sydney

    Aunty Shirley Lamas

    Aunty Shirley Lomas, in the room at the Yes campaign headquarters in Sydney, said she had grown up in a segregated Australia.

    She said she was wearing blue, for autism, to represent her profoundly disabled son who received poorer health care and access as an Indigenous man.

    “I don’t understand people voting No - visceral voters will always vote No because they have a deep seated ingrained fear.

    "But we won’t go away. They’ve embarrassed themselves in front of the whole world.

    "And tomorrow’s another day. We’ll be back. We’re not going anywhere. We’ve been here all this time you won’t push us around.

    She said she wasn’t despairing - “we’ll just go back to the drawing board.”

  9. We did not need to have this referendum: Duttonpublished at 11:57 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    Opposition leader Peter Dutton characterises the Voice as "the referendum that Australia did not need to have."

    "The proposal and the process should have been designed to unite Australians, not to divide us.

    "What we've seen tonight is Australians literally in their millions reject the Prime Minister's defensive referendum."

    Dutton added that Prime Minister Albanese "clearly was not across the detail, and he refused to explain or answer reasonable questions from Australians."

    Albanese earlier criticised the conservative Liberal coalition for refusing to endorse the Voice proposal - noting that no referendum has ever passed in Australia without bipartisan support.

  10. This result does not divide us: Opposition leaderpublished at 11:45 British Summer Time 14 October 2023
    Breaking

    Australia's opposition leader Peter Dutton is speaking now.

    "What matters now is this result does not divide us as a people. What matters is that we all accept the result in this great spirit of our democracy.

    "All of us know people who have voted Yes and people who voted No, but to those of you who voted Yes, let me say these few words:

    "As the leader of the Coalition, who has supported the No campaign, while I disagree with your position, I respect your decision to have voted yes."

  11. 'Tomorrow we must seek a new way forward' - Albanesepublished at 11:37 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    Australia's Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has finished speaking now - where he called for a new way forward.

    "Tomorrow we must seek a new way forward with the same optimism," Albanese said, adding that he still believes the referendum was the right thing to do.

    "We argued for this change, not out of convenience but out of conviction," he said.

    "But when you do the hard things, when you aim high, some times you fall short and tonight we acknowledged, understand, and respect that we have."

    "As prime minister, I will always accept responsibility for the decisions I've taken and I will do so tonight."

    "This moment of disagreement does not define or divide us. We are not Yes or No voters, we are all Australians, and it is as Australians together that we must take our country beyond this debate."

  12. Tears and silence as Prime Minister speakspublished at 11:24 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    Tiffanie Turnbull
    BBC News, Darwin

    Minutes after the projection that the Northern Territory had also voted No, the room here in Darwin fell silent as Prime Minister Anthony Albanese appeared on screen.

    Several people cried, others shook their heads as he addressed the nation “I never imagined or indeed said that it would be easy. Very few things in public life worth doing are,” he said.

    “Just as the Uluru Statement from the Heart was an invitation extended with humility, grace and optimism for the future, tonight we must meet this result with the same grace and humility.

    “And tomorrow we must seek a new way forward with the same optimism.”

  13. Albanese asks Indigenous people to 'maintain hope'published at 11:16 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    Directly addressing Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people, Australia's prime minister Anthony Albanese asked them to maintain hope.

    He said he realised the campaign has been a "heavy weight to carry" - and that the result would be very hard to bear.

    "So many remarkable Indigenous Australians have put their heart and soul into this cause, not just over the past few weeks and months, but through decades, indeed lifetimes, of advocacy. I have been honoured and humbled to stand by you and witness your extraordinary courage and grace, your great love for our country and your deep faith in our people," he said.

    He added that while constitutional change may not have happened tonight, "change has happened in our great nation".

    "Maintain your hope and know that you are loved," he said.

    Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese (C) stands with Indigenous rights activist Noel Pearson (R) and Northern Territory Chief Minister Natasha FylesImage source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese (C) stands with Indigenous rights activist Noel Pearson (R) and Northern Territory Chief Minister Natasha Fyles

  14. Watch Albanese speaking livepublished at 11:06 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    Australia's Prime Minister Anthony Albanese is addressing the nation on the outcome of the vote.

    Click the play button above to watch live.

  15. Albanese: I respect decision of Australian peoplepublished at 11:03 British Summer Time 14 October 2023
    Breaking

    Australia Prime Minister Anthony Albanese is addressing the nation.

    In his first comments he said that while he did not see the outcome he hoped for, he "absolutely respected" it.

  16. 'We will build on this' - Yes campaign directorpublished at 10:59 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    Frances Mao
    Reporting from Sydney

    Yes campaign director Dean Parkin addresses the crowd
    Image caption,

    Yes campaign director Dean Parkin addresses the crowd

    I'm at the Yes campaign headquarters as the director of the campaign Dean Parkin addresses the crowd gathered there. He thanked the estimated seven million Australians who voted Yes, and the 80,000 volunteers.

    "This is a very difficult result, a hard result. Thank you to the millions who've joined us and accepted us in this movement. But obviously this was not the result we were seeking, not the result anyone of us wanted.

    Campaigners and activists, supporters next to me had tears in their eyes. The man next to me was wiping tears from his face.

    A man in the crowd wipes tears from his face
    Image caption,

    A man in the crowd wipes tears from his face

    Mr Parkin addressed both the supporters in the room and those who voted No "with hardness in their hearts".

    "What we've done in the seven months since this campaign took off, we've created a base of one million people a month, seven million Australians who voted Yes. We've now created a base of support for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people in this country. It is a base, not a summit. We will build on this."

  17. Voters in Western Australia still casting ballots - though it will not change outcomepublished at 10:43 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    Polls in Western Australia, where Perth is located, only close in about 30 minutes. So voters are still standing in line to cast their ballots.

    That's despite the outcome of the result already widely declared across the country.

    One woman who was set to vote Yes found out about the results while in the queue at the polling station. She told the ABC that she felt deflated and disappointed.

  18. What is the Voice and what were the arguments for and against it?published at 10:34 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    Ayeshea Perera
    BBC News

    A defaced 'Vote Yes' sign is seen in Bassendean in Perth in Western Australia where polls have not yet closedImage source, EPA
    Image caption,

    A defaced 'Vote Yes' sign is seen in Bassendean in Perth in Western Australia where polls have not yet closed

    If you're just joining us, the latest news is that Australians have voted No and rejected a historical Indigenous referendum known as the Voice.

    Here are some details about what the referendum was about and what we know about its outcome.

    What is the Voice?

    The Voice sought to establish an Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander body to advise the government on the issues affecting their communities. As well as creating an advisory body, the amendment sought to recognise Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders as Australia’s First Peoples in its constitution.

    What did the No campaign say?

    The official No campaign said the Voice was a "radical" proposal that would "permanently divide" the country by giving First Nations people greater rights than other Australians.

    It also argued the Voice is "a leap into the unknown" because it hasn't been "road-tested", pointing to the lack of detail about how it would operate.

    Grassroots groups - such as the Indigenous-led Black sovereign movement - have spoken out against the Voice for other reasons though. Their argument is that it would be "another powerless advisory body" and that treaty negotiations should be prioritised instead.

    What did Yes campaigners say?

    They said Constitutional recognition of Indigenous peoples as the first inhabitants of Australia would drive practical change and argued that having an Indigenous-led elected advisory body would deliver real improvements in areas such as life expectancy, infant mortality, health, education and employment.

    They believed such a body would also help governments use funding more effectively and also symbolically give Australia a chance to reconcile with its past as it charts its future.

    How was the vote called so quickly?

    In order to succeed, the Voice needed a majority of voters in a majority of states. That means over 50% of the population and at least four out of the country’s six states would have needed to say Yes. But early vote counting showed very quickly that three states - Tasmania, South Australia and New South Wales - had voted No, meaning that the referendum could not pass.

    Stay with us as we bring you more updates on reactions to this outcome.

  19. Bracing for reactionpublished at 10:21 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    As the votes count continues to roll in, we'll bring you all the reaction from across the country.

    Yes figures are already expressing heartbreak and frustration, but we're yet to hear from key No campaigners, who are gathering in Brisbane tonight.

  20. 'Devastated with the result' - Leading Yes campaignerpublished at 10:04 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    "I'm devastated," Thomas Mayo, the leader Yes campaigner, told the Australian Broadcasting Corporation, in response to the rejection of the Voice to Parliament referendum.

    "We need a voice, we need structural change." he said. "But we have seen a disgusting No campaign that has been dishonest with the Australian people, and have lied to the Australian people."

    He said he doesn't know what's next, but that he remains sure that the public is ready for the reform.

    "I disagree that this is a bad idea, we needed this foundational change to be recognised and a representative body, not politicians who purport to speak for us, but for us to choose our leaders ourselves," he said.

    eading Yes campaigner Thomas Mayo is interviewed at the Inner West For Yes2023 Official Referendum Function at Wests Ashfield Leagues ClubImage source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    Thomas Mayo at the Inner West For Yes2023 Official Referendum Function