Summary

  • Australians have voted against a historic Indigenous referendum

  • Australia's national broadcaster ABC projects that three states have voted no, effectively defeating the referendum

  • Australia's Prime Minister Anthony Albanese said he respected the outcome of the vote and called on Indigenous people to maintain their hope

  • Voters were asked to enshrine an Indigenous advisory body in the constitution that recognises Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people as the nation’s First Peoples

  • No campaigners said the Voice to Parliament racially divides the country and have questioned how it would operate

  • But Yes advocates said it was a modest yet profound change allowing Indigenous Australians to take their 'rightful place' in their own country

  1. 'PM should resign in event of a big No win' - South Australia opposition leaderpublished at 09:59 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    South Australia Opposition leader David Speirs says he thinks Prime Minister Anthony Albanese should resign if the final result of the referendum is a resounding No.

    "I think the damage he has done to our country and to the very fabric of what it means to be Australian is quite frankly heartbreaking," he said to Australian reporters.

    "It'll be up to the Prime Minister and the federal Labor Party tomorrow to make a call on what he does now - but I think he should resign, he said.

  2. It was all over in under two hourspublished at 09:44 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    Tiffanie Turnbull
    BBC News, Darwin/Garramilla

    Before the polls even closed in the Northern Territory, the referendum was all over.

    We watched the ABC declare its defeat in an empty room full of yes signs.

    It'll probably be an hour before volunteers and campaigners start trickling in here, to the official Yes 'party' - if they do at all.

    But it's already clear this evening will not be a celebration.

  3. 'Not surprised by the results so far' - Senator Lidia Thorpepublished at 09:42 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    Independent senator Lidia ThorpeImage source, EPA

    Independent senator and the leader of the Indigenous 'Progressive No' camp Lidia Thorpe, told Australian Broadcasting Corporation that the results coming through so far are in line with what she expected to see.

    "I'm not surprised that we've got No votes coming out strongly, because people don't either know what it is about or that in terms of the Blak Sovereign Movement, we don't want to go into the constitution, and I think we have been loud and clear about that and we have certainly got a lot of support," she said.

    "This country going to the referendum to decide on our destiny was the wrong thing to do, and that's where we as Aboriginal people need to come together and make those decisions for ourselves. That's what a treaty can do. That's what truth telling can do."

    "You don't need a referendum for a treaty. And you don't need a referendum for extra senate seats in the Parliament."

  4. Referendum has been defeated: ABCpublished at 09:27 British Summer Time 14 October 2023
    Breaking

    ABC has said that South Australia is the fourth state to vote No - meaning that the referendum has failed.

  5. Indigenous voters: A No result would be 'heartache'published at 09:22 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    Media caption,

    Indigenous voters: No would be a 'heartache'

  6. ABC projects No for Tasmania and Yes for Australian Capital Territorypublished at 09:14 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    With 12.4% of the vote counted, the Australian broadcaster says it is clear that Yes will not be able to obtain a majority in the state of Tasmania.

    They spoke to some people who voted no in Tasmania. One of them said: "I voted no because I don't think we should put a line between us and them. We are all one people."

    Another said: "It's one for all and all for one in Australia. That's why I voted no."

    In the Australian Capital Territory, 2.6 percent of the vote has been counted, and Yes has a clear majority, the ABC projects.

  7. New South Wales projected as voting Nopublished at 09:05 British Summer Time 14 October 2023
    Breaking

    Australia's most populous state New South Wales, which has Sydney as its capital, has been projected to vote no according to the Australian Broadcasting Corporation.

  8. No leads Yes in early vote countingpublished at 08:58 British Summer Time 14 October 2023
    Breaking

    The Voice referendum vote counting in Melbourne AustraliaImage source, Getty Images

    Election officers have started tallying votes in states where polling has closed.

    A partial tally by the National Electoral Commission, based on 1,394 of 8,253 total precincts, shows No leading Yes with 58.04% versus 41.96%.

  9. 'Two questions - but they're only letting us give one answer'published at 08:40 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    Simon Atkinson
    Australia producer, BBC News

    No voter Rob Muller holds campaigning cards
    Image caption,

    Rob Muller, 73 worked as a commercial pilot, and spent many years flying in and out of remote communities

    Rob Muller is is in favour of recognising Indigenous people in the constitution, but objects to the Indigenous advisory body.

    “They’re basically asking two questions. Do we want to recognise them, and if we do it's a Voice... but they're providing space for one answer."

    “I don't know why they didn't put recognition in legislation and see how it all works, then maybe later on try to increase it to something else."

    He said he feared the impact the result might have. “After all this, it's going to take quite a while to heal.

    "It worries me that it is going to create a lot of division and I think people are not going to forget it very quickly.”

  10. Not all votes are equal - why?published at 08:27 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    Tiffanie Turnbull
    Reporting from Darwin

    At the heart of the Voice debate, is the Northern Territory.

    Almost a third of its population is Indigenous. The Uluru Statement from the Heart - which calls for the Voice - was written here. And many Aboriginal communities which advocates say the reform is designed to help are here.

    But when people who live in NT go to the polls today, their vote will count for less than other Australians.

    Australia’s referendum rules require a double majority for them to pass - that means a majority of voters nationwide must write yes, but also that majority support in four of Australia’s six states is needed.

    And that second metric excludes the NT and the Australian Capital Territory.

    Though they have much smaller populations than the states, a lot of people who live here say it leaves them feeling like second class citizens - and in the NT’s case, suppresses the voices of many people who this debate is about.

  11. Undecided voter convinced by Yes team at polling boothpublished at 08:16 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    Tiffanie Turnbull
    Reporting from Darwin/Larrikia Country

    Anna Sarmento
    Image caption,

    Anna Sarmento said she's voting Yes after learning what the proposal means

    I just spoke to one voter in Darwin who said she had been in two minds "because I didn't really understand the process".

    After speaking to a Yes campaigner however, Anna Sarmento said it was the obvious choice for anyone who wanted positive outcomes for Indigenous people.

    She pointed out that in the Northern Territory - where most government intervention occurs -more than 30% of the population is Indigenous.

    "We need more representation and it should have been done long, long time ago.

    "There's all sorts of [bad policy] happening which these people have no control over. Because they don't have that representation."

    Anna Sarmento (centre) and Yes campaigners
    Image caption,

    Darwin local Anna Sarmento (centre) and campaigners at a voting booth

  12. Other states and territories still votingpublished at 08:09 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    Across the country, polling booths were open from 0800-1800 but Australia is a big place, so it has three separate time zones.

    South Australia, Queensland, the Northern Territory and Western Australia are still voting.There are also votes coming in from Australia’s offshore territories.

  13. Polls close in Australian statespublished at 08:04 British Summer Time 14 October 2023
    Breaking

    Voting is now finished in the most populous states of New South Wales and Victoria, as well as Tasmania and the Australian Capital Territory.

    The referendum needs a majority of the national vote and a majority of states approving to succeed.

  14. Polls about to closepublished at 07:55 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    There's less than 10 minutes untill polls close. We can expect results to start flowing in soon after - so stay with us.

  15. Opposition figures double down on Voice as “risky”published at 07:52 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    A person holds up a "Vote No" placard at a rally against the Voice referendum in Melbourne, Australia September 23, 2023.Image source, Reuters

    In a final message to voters, Nationals leader David Littleproud told the ABC that his party would not be pushing to legislate the Voice to Parliament, if today’s referendum fails.

    Littleproud said voters should not feel “guilted” about the result, calling for the “democratically determined position that the Australian people will make” to be respected.

    "We have always had a longstanding view, if this referendum was about constitutional recognition and that alone, we would have supported it. That would have been a unifying moment."

    And addressing the media in Perth, Western Australian Liberal Senator Michaelia Cash doubled down on the Voice as a “risky” proposal.

    “If the Voice does get up, it’s risky, it’s unknown, it’s permanent, but more than that, regardless of the outcome tonight, the one thing Mr Albanese has done is divide this nation.”

    Cash also said the Opposition would work to achieve better outcomes for Indigenous Australians by undertaking a review of wasteful government spending.

  16. Inside the Yes 'field strategy'published at 07:42 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    Hannah Ritchie
    Reporting from Melbourne/Naarm

    Throughout this campaign, tens of thousands of Yes volunteers have crossed the country to have "face-to-face" conversations with voters, hoping to cut through what has been a noisy - and often acrid - debate.

    "Our pathway to winning has always been a field strategy," says Larissa Baldwin-Roberts, who leads the activist group GetUp.

    "The only way you can persuade people is to have a values-based conversation...But that's an incredibly labour intensive thing to do."

    The Widjabul Wia-bul woman and other Voice advocates will be hoping that the people power being deployed by Yes has reached enough undecided voters to turn around months of polling results that are suggesting a sizeable No victory.

  17. Voice architect: ‘We are dealing with the legacy of colonisation'published at 07:27 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    Simon Atkinson
    Australia producer, BBC News

    One of the architects of the Voice and most prominent faces of the Yes campaign is Noel Pearson.

    The Guugu Yimidhirr man is also an influential figure in Australian Indigenous affairs.

    The Cape York Partnership he founded tries to empower and improve the lives of First Nations peoples in the north of Queensland, with a particular focus on education.

    When we met in Brisbane last week to film an interview for our coverage of this referendum, he said Australia was "going through a process of trying to address the legacy of British colonisation" and that the disadvantage among Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities was "still egregious".

    Media caption,

    'We need this vote to chip away at British legacy'

  18. In pictures: Campaigning around Australiapublished at 07:16 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    Surf lifesavers keep watch at a Sydney beach next to a Yes signImage source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    Lots of Yes placards were seen around Sydney's beaches this morning

    A surfer carrying his board walks past a Vote Yes signImage source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    ...including at Bondi Beach

    A sign in Canberra making reference to the Aboriginal Tent Embassy - a grassroots group part of the Progessive No campImage source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    A sign in Canberra making reference to a grassroots group part of the Progessive No camp

    Canberra signageImage source, Reuters
    Image caption,

    The type of slogans we're seeing from both sides - seen outside a Canberra polling place

  19. What are the main arguments against the Voice?published at 07:04 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    The official No campaign says the Voice is a "radical" proposal that will "permanently divide" the country by giving First Nations people greater rights than other Australians.

    It also argues the Voice is "a leap into the unknown" because it hasn't been "road-tested", pointing to the lack of detail about how it would operate.

    Leading constitutional experts say the Voice does not confer special rights on anyone. And if the reform passes it would be up to parliament to design the Voice, giving lawmakers the power to change it over time.

    Grassroots groups - such as the Indigenous-led Blak sovereign movement - have spoken out against the Voice for other reasons though. Their argument is that it would be "another powerless advisory body" and that treaty negotiations should be prioritised instead.

    A 'no' sign is seen at Clovelly Surf Life Saving Club reads: This Voice is Risky, Unknown, Divisive, PermanentImage source, Getty Images
  20. 'I spoiled my ballot'published at 06:50 British Summer Time 14 October 2023

    Simon Atkinson
    Australia producer, BBC News

    Reuben Elias from Redcliffe near Brisbane posted an empty ballot paper as he didn’t know which way to lean
    Image caption,

    Reuben Elias from Redcliffe near Brisbane posted an empty ballot paper as he didn’t know which way to lean

    In Australia you do have to vote – or face a $20 fine - but you don’t have to cast a vote that counts.

    Reuben Elias from Redcliffe near Brisbane said he ‘voted’ early, but had simply posted an empty ballot paper as he didn’t know which way to lean.

    “I put in a blank, so it's invalid. It‘s too undecided what the Yes are saying and the No are saying, so this way I can’t be accused of being a racist,” he said.

    I asked if he really thinks that being a ‘No’ vote would mean he was seen that way?

    “Probably. I think so. There's a lot of conflict. I believe this is dividing the country, not bringing it together. So that's why I voted the invalid," he told me.