West Indies v England: Hosts' fightback limits England advantage

  • Published
Shivnarine ChanderpaulImage source, Reuters
Image caption,

Shivnarine Chanderpaul, 40, made his Test debut in 1994

First Test, day two, Sir Vivian Richards Stadium, Antigua

England 399: Bell 143, Root 83, Stokes 79; Roach 4-94

West Indies 155-4 (66 overs): Brathwaite 39, Samuels 33

England lead by 244 runs

West Indies fought back to limit England's advantage on the second day of the first Test in Antigua.

The tourists lost their last five wickets for 42 runs as they were bowled out for 399, with Ben Stokes falling for 79 and Kemar Roach taking 4-94.

Although West Indies slipped to 99-4 in reply, they recovered to reach 155 without further loss by the close.

James Anderson claimed his 381st Test wicket to move to within two of Ian Botham's record for England.

Media caption,

Jordan preaches patience in Antigua

England's immediate objective on the third day will be to remove the obdurate Shivnarine Chanderpaul, who made an unbeaten 29 off 98 balls in his 162nd Test.

He and Jermaine Blackwood spent almost 29 overs adding 56 in the evening session, a partnership typical of a game which has been attritional rather than enthralling.

England can still claim to hold the upper hand in their first game since their dismal World Cup campaign, and captain Alastair Cook will be pleased by the discipline shown by his bowlers under clear skies and on a largely placid surface.

But they were left to reflect on the no-ball that cost Ben Stokes the wicket of Blackwood, who edged to Cook at slip on 21. It would have reduced West Indies to 133-5.

"It's not a wicket that you can run through a team on," said Chris Jordan. "You just have to hang in and be patient."

BBC cricket correspondent Jonathan Agnew

"West Indies bowled well, but England's lack of resistance was poor. Ben Stokes will be hugely frustrated he didn't go on to get his second Test hundred, while Jos Buttler, who made an uncharacteristic 22-ball duck, never got to grips with the conditions. It suggests a lack of confidence within the team, and that's hardly surprising."

Read more from Aggers here

Stokes was the only member of England's five-strong attack who failed to take a wicket, off-spinner James Tredwell - playing his second Test five years after his debut - the most economical of them with 1-22 off 15 overs.

Anderson, playing his 100th Test, looked the most penetrative, angling one across the left-handed Devon Smith in the ninth over of West Indies' reply to provide Jos Buttler with the first of three catches.

Darren Bravo failed to withdraw his bat in time to Jordan, while Stuart Broad located Marlon Samuels's edge with a fuller delivery that held its line.

Ex-England spinner Graeme Swann on Test Match Special

"West Indies have looked to blunt the England attack rather than take it to them. The dismissal of Marlon Samuels was a fine bit of bowling from Broad, as was the catch from Jordan to get rid of Brathwaite, but other than that it's been dull as dishwater."

It took a splendid one-handed catch low down at slip by Jordan off Tredwell to remove opener Kraigg Brathwaite, who batted 37 overs for his 39.

But Blackwood, having hit Tredwell for six off his second ball, calmed down somewhat in alliance with Chanderpaul to keep England at bay for the remainder of another day extended by the slow over-rate.

Earlier, England's hopes of pressing on well beyond 400 were ended by the loss of four wickets for four runs after they resumed on 341-5.

Stokes had added only eight to his overnight 81 when he guided Jerome Taylor straight to gully, before Tredwell was caught behind off Jason Holder.

Roach accounted for a flat-footed Buttler, whose duck spanned 22 balls, and Broad sliced the same bowler to backward point in his next over.

From 361-9, England were thankful for a last-wicket partnership of 38 between Jordan and Anderson which was ended when the latter chipped Samuels tamely to short cover.

Listen to Geoffrey Boycott and Jonathan Agnew review the second day's play on the Test Match Special podcast.

Image source, Reuters
Image caption,

Kemar Roach's haul of 4-94 took his wicket tally to 117 in 30 Tests

Image source, Reuters
Image caption,

Dancers enjoy England's collapse from 357-5 to 399 all out on the second morning

Image source, Getty Images
Image caption,

James Anderson removes Devon Smith to move to within two wickets of Ian Botham's England record of 383 Test wickets

Image source, Getty Images
Image caption,

James Tredwell, playing his second Test, has Kraigg Brathwaite superbly held by Chris Jordan

Image source, Getty Images
Image caption,

Ben Stokes had Jermaine Blackwood caught at slip off a no-ball, which would have left West Indies 133-5

Around the BBC

Related internet links

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.