Liverpool 0-1 Aston Villa

Villa are now unbeaten in their last four league trips to Anfield

• Villa maintain impressive recent record at Anfield

• Balotelli makes home debut for Liverpool

• Sterling only named on bench for home side

• Cleverley makes first Villa outing

Gabriel Agbonlahor's early goal gave Aston Villa a battling victory at Anfield that moves them up to second place in the Premier League table.

Agbonlahor struck from a corner after nine minutes and, despite dominating possession, Liverpool were unable to break down the visitors' well-organised defence.

Villa remain unbeaten, with 10 points from their first four games giving them their best start to the season since the 1998-99 campaign, when they went on to finish sixth.

Paul Lambert's side worked hard, were well organised and were good value for their win but, worryingly for Liverpool boss Brendan Rodgers, his first attempt at rotating his newly-strengthened squad ended in a frustrating defeat.

At the start of a spell of seven games in 21 days, Rodgers' selection was partly enforced by Daniel Sturridge's injury while training with England, but the Reds manager now knows how much his side rely on the striker and fellow England man Raheem Sterling, who started the game on the bench.

Some of Liverpool's summer signings were meant to provide the initiative in their absence - with six making the starting XI.

But, although Adam Lallana enjoyed an encouraging debut and Lazar Markovic again looked lively, Mario Balotelli was anonymous on his first home start.

Villa goalkeeper Guzan faced just one shot on target during the 90 minutes

The home side also had problems at the back and their failure to deal with Villa's threat from set-pieces was punished after nine minutes.

Philippe Senderos saw his header blocked from Ashley Westwood's corner but Javier Manquillo could not stop Agbonlahor from scrambling home the loose ball.

The Reds did not learn their lesson, and Senderos should have done better when he was left unmarked from a Westwood free-kick, sending his header over.

Villa were also looking dangerous on the break but their cause was being helped by Liverpool's lack of cohesion and cutting edge going forward.

To their credit, Villa chased and harried whenever the Reds had the ball but, with Balotelli being well-marshalled by Senderos, the home side barely threatened despite dominating possession.

Visiting keeper Brad Guzan did not have a serious save to make in the first half and things did not improve for Liverpool when Sterling was finally introduced on the hour mark either.

With Villa still defending resolutely, Rodgers went for a different approach when he sent on two strikers, Rickie Lambert and Fabio Borini, after 70 minutes, bringing Balotelli's unsuccessful evening to an early end.

The home side increased the pressure but a finishing touch continued to elude them, with Dejan Lovren heading over and Philippe Coutinho firing against the post.

That was the nearest Liverpool came to an equaliser, and Rodgers will need his new-look side to show a vast improvement in the final third when they face Bulgarian side Ludogorets Razgrad in the Champions League on Tuesday.

Liverpool manger Brendan Rodgers: "We were slow in our pressing and passing early on and gave away a bad goal, but then we upped it.

"It was a frustrating day but I think it was a combination of Aston Villa defending well and us failing to find that wee bit of quality. We had enough of the ball but could not find the penetration in the final third."

Aston Villa manager Paul Lambert: "It is one of toughest places to come in Europe, let alone Britain, but I think we deserved the win.

"There is a lot of momentum on and off the pitch at this club, the players have been excellent as a group and the supporters have stuck with it and now our young guys are turning into young men."

Balotelli was making his home debut for Liverpool while Cleverley had his first outing for Villa

Agbonlahor's only other goal against Liverpool in the Premier League came back in October 2006

Sterling was unable to influence the outcome after replacing Lallana in the second half

Paul Lambert has never tasted defeat at Anfield as a Premier League manager

Check out the best photos from today's Premier League games on the BBC Sport Facebook page.