Summary

  1. get involved

    'I’d be a bit surprised if they both joined Arsenal'published at 12:48 British Summer Time

    Phil McNulty Q&A

    Phil McNulty
    BBC Sport chief football writer

    Benjamin Sesko and Viktor GyokeresImage source, Getty Images

    Alex: I've seen people speculate that Sesko and Gyokeres both want Arsenal due to their Instragram followings (Sesko followed Arsenal and Gyokeres following a London security agency used by Raya among other Arsenal players). How reliable is this as an indicator of where a player will end up?

    I always think it’s best to wait for actual concrete information. We’ve had another favourite recently where we have seen speculation about whether players are on the move or not depending on whether they are in out of new kit launches.

    Put it this way, I’d be a bit surprised if they both joined Arsenal.

  2. get involved

    Get Involvedpublished at 12:42 British Summer Time

    #bbcfootball, WhatsApp 03301231826, text 81111 (UK only, standard rates apply)

    Charlie: A new manager aside, it's all been a bit quiet at Tottenham so far this transfer window. Do we REALLY need to save everything for the last 12 hours?

    I cannot fathom why Spurs haven't got the proper business done yet. Eze should be on the Insta feed by now with his new shirt! Same old Levy, get a cheap one done, sell some shirts, and forget the first team. Get Eze done today please Daniel. COYS.

    Paul, frustrated as my son has just 'borrowed' my new away shirt

  3. get involved

    'I expect Spurs to be active in a significant way in the market'published at 12:38 British Summer Time

    Phil McNulty Q&A

    Phil McNulty
    BBC Sport chief football writer

    Thomas Frank - Spurs' managerImage source, Getty Images

    Jonty, London: Phil, what is your view on Spurs' activity this summer? We heard another round of promises from Levy, yet all we sign are 17-20 year olds. Once again it seems dawdling is costing us top targets or are they a smokescreen as they were never really targeting them? Any momentum from winning the Europa League is being completely pulled from under Spurs by incompetence at the top. Thomas Frank could be on a hiding to nothing here.

    Early days yet, Jonty - and that is very definitely a glass half-empty viewpoint. They made the move form Mathys Tel permanent, and the very well-connected and reliable Matt Law from the Daily Telegraph is reporting strong interest in West Ham United’s Mohammed Kudus.

    Frank will surely have had some assurances about recruitment before making the move, so I fully expect Spurs to be active in a significant way in the transfer market.

  4. get involved

    'I’m not sure this United team can be rebuilt quickly'published at 12:33 British Summer Time

    Phil McNulty Q&A

    Phil McNulty
    BBC Sport chief football writer

    James: Hi Phil, what do you think of Manchester United's transfer strategy? Cunha, trying to sign Mbuemo and heavy links to Gyokeres. Seems like it's just trying to buy players who had a good season last year as opposed to scouting and confirmed long-term ability and/or potential.

    Hello, James. It seems to be a move towards signing players who have proved they can cut it in the Premier League, and I think that is a sound start on what has to be a massive rebuild.

    I’m not sure this United team can be rebuilt quickly, considering how mediocre it is, but those two players – and we are still waiting on the Mbuemo deal to progress – will certainly give them more quality and threat right away.

    I feel they need an upgrade on Andre Onana in goal and a quality central striker, but how much of that can be done this summer remains to be seen.

    Mztheus Cunha signs for Manchester UnitedImage source, Getty Images
  5. Postpublished at 12:26 British Summer Time

    Right, back to Phil McNulty's Q&A.

    We have some questions coming up on:

    • Arsenal's striker search
    • Tottenham's slow start to the transfer window
    • Manchester United's summer strategy
  6. Recap - Today's transfer headlinespublished at 12:23 British Summer Time

    Here's today's main transfer-related headlines...

    A reminder, we're also running a Q&A with BBC Sport's chief football writer Phil McNulty, who will attempt to answer your transfer-related questions.

    You can ask Phil a question on X using #bbcfootball, on WhatsApp (03301231826) or by texting 81111 (UK only, standard rates apply).

  7. Postpublished at 12:22 British Summer Time

    Craig Nelson
    BBC Sport reporter

    JD is referring to the news that Chelsea have agreed to pay a £60m fee to Brighton to sign their 23-year-old Brazil forward Joao Pedro.

    This seems like a good moment to recap today's main headlines and talking points...

  8. get involved

    Get Involvedpublished at 12:18 British Summer Time

    #bbcfootball, WhatsApp 03301231826, text 81111 (UK only, standard rates apply)

    Is Brighton now effectively a feeder team for the Champions League clubs? They've raked in an absolute fortune from sales to Arsenal, Chelsea and Spurs, but this constant asset stripping must be frustrating for Brighton fans? They clearly scout very well, buying unknown players who they can then sell on for huge profits, but, while this is good business, it's a rough way to treat a fan base. Brighton could probably have been top 6 if they'd not parted with so many players.

    JD

  9. Pitch-side interviews & dressing room cameras 'a really interesting development'published at 12:11 British Summer Time

    Phil McNulty Q&A

    Phil McNulty
    BBC Sport chief football writer

    Nelson Semedo of Wolves being interviewed by TNT SportsImage source, Getty Images

    Dan: What do you think of plans to interview subs pitch-side and allow cameras in the dressing room, Phil?

    Hi, Dan. I think it’s a really interesting development and I’m intrigued to see how it works in practice. Details are still a little sketchy but we know subs will be allowed to cool down first.

    Details have yet to be released on how often this will happen in matches, or how many matches it will apply to.

    Dressing room access will be restricted and never allowed during team talks, quite understandably. It’s a common practice in the United States so will be quite a departure.

  10. get involved

    'All clubs will believe they have unique selling points'published at 12:04 British Summer Time

    Phil McNulty Q&A

    Nolberto, London: With only the 'big 6' able to offer wages of 200k per week or more due to the regulations, wouldn't it be more sensible for teams with pedigree like Villa, Forest, Newcastle, Everton etc to wait until the 'big boys' have finished shopping? Trying to compete with the likes of Chelsea is surely a fool’s errand, isn't it?

    Wouldn’t that be a bit defeatist, Nolberto, especially if you’re Aston Villa and Newcastle United, who have challenged the established order in recent seasons?

    Everton tried to sign Liam Delap, even though they knew they were in competition with the likes of Manchester United, Newcastle United and Chelsea, where he eventually went.

    They hoped to put together a pitch that might make him believe Everton was the best place for him and should be applauded for doing so.

    All of the clubs will believe they have some unique selling points, and it is quite right that they don’t just stand aside and let the so-called “big” clubs have a free run.

    Nothing ventured, nothing gained - occasionally they may get a "yes".

  11. 'Football is a very ruthless business'published at 11:57 British Summer Time

    Phil McNulty Q&A

    Phil McNulty
    BBC Sport chief football writer

    Paul Mullin playing for WrexhamImage source, Getty Images

    Tom in London, a Swansea fan whose sentiment has long been eroded: Q for Phil McNulty - as Paul Mullins moves on from Wrexham despite club legend status, is there any room for sentimentality in football? Has there ever been?

    Not when it really matters, Tom. Ultimately football is a very ruthless business, not a natural home for sentimentality. That’s more for the fans.

    Still doesn’t mean you can’t recall those wonderful memories Mullin has left behind at Wrexham, but if you’re looking for sentimentality, I wouldn’t come to professional football.

  12. get involved

    Get Involvedpublished at 11:52 British Summer Time

    #bbcfootball, WhatsApp 03301231826, text 81111 (UK only, standard rates apply)

    Hugh, Liverpool: Re Ken in Newcastle - you could always sell us Isak, I’m sure an extra £120m would help you get deals done…

  13. 'I would not worry Liverpool are over-doing it'published at 11:46 British Summer Time

    Phil McNulty Q&A

    Phil McNulty
    BBC Sport chief football writer

    Jeremie Frimpong signing for Liverpool.Image source, Getty Images

    Mike, Liverpool fan in Teesside: Hi Phil. People are largely lauding Liverpool's transfer business so far this summer. Looks like there could be more signings to come. On the back of the previous summer window, when very little business was done, they won the league comfortably. Do you think they are in danger of doing too much, having too much change and preforming worse than last year as the new signings take time to bed-in and gel as a team?

    Hello, Mike. Interesting that I’ve had questions from Liverpool fans concerned they might be doing too much business after getting them from fans fearing they were not doing enough this time last year.

    As I mentioned before, I think Liverpool’s team did need strengthening despite winning the title, and they have done it in exactly the areas you might expect so far, at right-back, left-back and in the forward positions.

    Now it is about sales, then I can see more incomings, maybe in central defence and up front. I would not worry they are over-doing it. This has not been a scattergun series of acquisitions. It has been done with structure and purpose – and has strengthened the squad.

  14. get involved

    Get Involvedpublished at 11:41 British Summer Time

    #bbcfootball, WhatsApp 03301231826, text 81111 (UK only, standard rates apply)

    Re: Adam, Croydon 11:05 - 100% Liverpool have sold some flops, but a fair few have flourished or made the club that bought them some serious profit. Neco Williams, Harry Wilson, Dominic Solanke, Taiwan Awoniyi, Raheem Sterling. Van den Berg has been decent too. And they’ve just sold Kelleher and Trent for a combined £22m!

    Jonny

    Re Adam from Croydon at 11:05. If the Williams he mentions about Liverpool rejects is Neco Williams at Forest he is completely wrong. Neco has turned into one of the best attacking full-backs and was part of one of the meanest defences last season.

    Rich in Nottingham

  15. 'Very frustrating for Newcastle and Howe so far'published at 11:38 British Summer Time

    Phil McNulty Q&A

    Phil McNulty
    BBC Sport chief football writer

    Newcastle manager Eddie Howe wavingImage source, Getty Images

    Ken, Newcastle: Hi Phil, why do we (Newcastle United) seem to be struggling to get deals done. Eddie said he wanted business done early but we haven't been able to attract our top targets. It's a little bit of a worry.

    Hi Ken. It has been frustrating, as I was at Newcastle on the last day of the season when Eddie Howe said it was imperative business was done quickly – but this has not happened.

    It is not as if they have not been trying, but they have been unable to agree deals and now it looks like Joao Pedro, a prime target, is off to Chelsea.

    I think this was always a fear behind the scenes at Newcastle, with the attraction of London and extending the ex-Brighton clan of Marc Cucurella, Moises Caicedo and Robert Sanchez.

    Still plenty of time to bring in new faces – but there is no escaping the fact it has all been very frustrating for Newcastle and Howe so far.

  16. Postpublished at 11:35 British Summer Time

    Craig Nelson
    BBC Sport reporter

    Maybe we should start an offshoot to this live on out-of-context sightings of Phil McNulty.

    Maybe not.

    Right, back to the serious [transfer] business at hand.

    Over to you Phil...

  17. get involved

    Get Involvedpublished at 11:34 British Summer Time

    #bbcfootball, WhatsApp 03301231826, text 81111 (UK only, standard rates apply)

    Thanks to browser cropping I opened BBC Sport to see the headline ‘Transfer news latest: Chelsea agree fee for Pedro & Phil McNulty’ - I mean I know they’re building a big squad, but I didn’t see that signing coming!

    James, in need of a second coffee

  18. Postpublished at 11:31 British Summer Time

    Craig Nelson
    BBC Sport reporter

    Thank you Mick for putting that image of Phil McNulty tearing it up at Glastonbury into my head.

    I'm thinking maybe something similar to the headmaster character played by Greg Davies in the final scenes of the first Inbetweeners movie - shirt off, with school tie around his head and maybe some neon face paint?

    Made my morning that has.

    For those who missed BBC's Glastonbury coverage, there is plenty on iPlayer to get stuck into.

    I am sure Phil is rocking out to it now as he answers your questions...

  19. 'I would not agree with a mandatory retirement age for international footballers'published at 11:25 British Summer Time

    Phil McNulty Q&A

    Phil McNulty
    BBC Sport chief football writer

    Mick: Hi Phil, I'm glad you made it back from Glastonbury. Should the FA put in place a mandatory retirement age for international football to allow the England Under-21s to develop into the European Championship and World Cup-winning team we all know they're capable of becoming?

    Hi Mick. No Glasto for me I’m afraid. My days of outdoor concerts were restricted to Monsters Of Rock.

    I would not agree with a mandatory retirement age for international footballers:

    • A) What age would you consider appropriate?
    • B) It would have to apply to everyone and the FA would be mad to put itself at such a disadvantage if it did not apply across the board.

    A non-starter in every respect, especially as I doubt not a single country would agree to it.

  20. get involved

    Get Involvedpublished at 11:21 British Summer Time

    #bbcfootball, WhatsApp 03301231826, text 81111 (UK only, standard rates apply)

    Both teams could do a lot worse than including Diogo Jota in a deal for Marc Guehi. Seems like the team is improving around Jota and he's not been able to step up. Could be a decent fit for Palace as another forward option in Europe.

    Andy