Aberdeen's Leighton Clarkson celebrates scoring to make it 1-1 during a William Hill Premiership match between Aberdeen and St Johnstone at PittodrieImage source, SNS
Image caption,

Leighton Clarkson equalised in the second half for Aberdeen

Aberdeen manager Jimmy Thelin says his side need to "be true to our identity" after a draw with St Johnstone at Pittodrie stretched their winless run to five games.

Makenzie Kirk pounced to give the lively visitors the lead after James McGarry sclaffed Matt Smith's cross off his own face as he attempted to clear.

However, half-time changes from Aberdeen manager Jimmy Thelin again made the difference as his side improved after the break.

Ante Palaversa teed up his fellow substitute Luis 'Duk' Lopes, who drove into the box and cut back for Leighton Clarkson to tap in the equaliser.

It was Aberdeen's fifth game in two weeks and, after three draws and two defeats, Thelin admits his side need to learn to cope with a heavy schedule.

"It's not only about fitness, but mental capacity," the Swede told BBC Sport Scotland.

"We need to keep believing and being strong in our conviction in how we want to play, be true to our identity.

"During seasons you always have good periods, and some tougher periods. It's how you manage those periods and get out the other side."

In difficult conditions both sides struggled to fashion clear chances at Pittodrie, with the teams sharing only five shots on target.

Aberdeen goalkeeper Ross Doohan reacted quickly to smother Nicky Clark's fierce effort, before Nicky Devlin's crucial block denied Adama Sidibeh.

Meanwhile up the other end, St Johnstone goalkeeper Josh Rae pushed away a curling shot from Duk.

But in the end neither side could find a winner, which leaves Aberdeen nine points behind leaders Celtic having played a game more.

St Johnstone are ninth, two points in front of bottom side Hibernian.

Aberdeen momentum stalls

After a blistering start to the season, the busy winter schedule and injuries are catching up with Aberdeen.

The energy, pressing and daring attacking play which carried them to 13 straight victories have all dropped a level.

At the back there is uncertainty, with goalkeeper Dimitar Mitov and left-back Jack MacKenzie injured, and centre-backs Slobodan Rubezic and Gavin Molloy caught in two minds about whether to squeeze or sit off, leading to some awkward moments.

In midfield there are more gaps, less forward passing and fewer bodies getting into the box to create chances.

In general, everything is less connected and convincing.

It was summed up by St Johnstone's goal, when the usually reliable Sivert Nilsen gifted the ball away, compounded by woeful defending from McGarry.

Thelin did get a reaction again after making three changes at the break, with Palaversa's wonderful pass allowing Duk to surge forward and set up Clarkson.

However, the continuous slow starts - Aberdeen have scored 70% of their goals after the break - are now more troublesome without the same energy in the second half of games.

Aberdeen look like they could do with a reset and with no game next weekend it might be a timely break.

St Johnstone bright but need wins

St Johnstone will take a lot of confidence from claiming a point at Pittodrie, where only Celtic have won this season.

However, they might feel they could have won it having shaded the game in terms of chances, with Lewis Neilson hitting the crossbar at 1-0.

Simo Valakari has changed the style of play and they are a side full of energy that look to play forward and combine in tight spaces.

Nicky Clark was brilliant again in knitting things together, while Kirk continues to grow at this level.

Kimpioka, with more composure and tighter control, could have made more of the space he was afforded on the break but his pace frightened Aberdeen.

The biggest plus is they have conceded just twice in their last three matches, which is a huge defensive improvement.

The caveat for Valakari is the good performances are not yielding enough wins, with just two in seven games since the Finn took charge.

Other than a trip to Celtic Park on 29 December, they have very winnable games coming between now and the beginning of January.

They need to make the most of those opportunities.

What they said

Aberdeen manager Jimmy Thelin: "Our performance was not the level we want. We did not come out with the same intensity we did against Celtic.

"We need to find a way back to being more stable in our performances between games because we have been a bit up and down now."

St Johnstone manager Simo Valakari: "A good performance from our boys against a very good team. Excellent first half, we created good moments and were solid.

"Credit to Aberdeen for how they scored, but the rest of the match we kept them to not being as dangerous."