'Are Celtic actually stronger now despite Kyogo exit?'published at 16:48 6 February
16:48 6 February
Kheredine Idessane BBC Sport Scotland Senior Reporter
There's a constituency among the Celtic support that believes the club have really missed a trick by not pushing the boat out to replace departed striker Kyogo Furuhashi.
A failure of vision, strategy, ambition, is how they see it. A failure of recruitment which manager Brendan Rodgers is adamant will be addressed going forward.
If Celtic knew last summer the Japan striker wanted to leave, surely groundwork could have been done to source an adequate replacement by the end of January?
I have a lot of sympathy with that view. Indeed, on this very page last week I opined this was the prime time for the blazers to stick their necks out, as well as the chequebook.
Didn't happen. Yet I find myself wondering if the Parkhead garden is not still pretty rosy? Could Celtic actually be just as strong, if not stronger, despite the admitted failure to bring in a like-for-like replacement for Kyogo?
The answer lies with Jota. Despite the fact the club are fairly well off for wingers, the return of the Portuguese fan favourite has raised the bar yet higher in terms of quality on offer to the manager.
Jota may not score as many goals as Kyogo but he will create them for others. In two short cameos already, he has contributed a goal, an assist and the kind of quality deliveries from out wide that Celtic have been missing.
For all their fine play, assists and goals, I'm not sure Daizen Maeda and Nicolas Kuhn cross a ball as well as the new number seven. The former two are more likely to cut infield in search of goals, as their stats indicate - 35 between them this season already. It really is a remarkable number.
Rodgers' ability to rotate arguably the three best wingers in the country is a fearsome weapon. In the absence of Kyogo, the manager can also say to the striker he paid £9m for in the previous transfer window: "Right then, Adam. Show me you're the main man up front."
Idah has scored four goals in his last three games. Two of them away to Aston Villa in the Champions League.
Rodgers may privately lament the lack of the new striker he coveted but he has returned one of the most gifted players in the Premiership.
As a direct consequence, others are flourishing alongside him. Yes, Kyogo is gone, but are Celtic really weaker than they were at the start of January?
On this day 14 years ago... an Old Firm thriller at Ibroxpublished at 16:36 6 February
16:36 6 February
Image source, SNS
Image caption,
Jamie Ness set the tone for the afternoon with a long-range strike in the opening three minutes
Fourteen years on, it's still a game that takes the breath away.
Walter Smith's Rangers welcomed bitter rivals Celtic to Ibrox with a place in the quarter-finals of the Scottish Cup at stake.
If only what followed was so straightforward.
Teenage midfielder Jamie Ness set the tone with a superb strike from distance a little over two minutes in, before Celtic's Kris Commons levelled 15 minutes later.
Celtic goalkeeper Fraser Forster had a day to forget in Govan. Not long after nearly gifting a goal to Rangers via Steven Davis - whose shot cannoned off the crossbar - he conceded a penalty and was shown a red card for bringing down Steven Naismith.
Steven Whittaker did the business from the spot to fire the hosts back in front with a man advantage, too. Not for long, though.
After a spell of pressure, captain Scott Brown curled in an effort from distance to haul Celtic level once more.
Davis and Nikica Jelavic came close, but the winner couldn't be found.
Level on the scoreboard, the sides were level on numbers too when Naismith was shown a red card after two yellows.
After a captivating cup clash, the sides couldn't be split and to a replay they went. More red card mayhem followed in that 'shame game', with Rangers having three players sent off as Mark Wilson's strike sent Celtic through 1-0.
'Ludicrous finish' - new-found potency from 'defender's nightmare' Maedapublished at 12:41 6 February
12:41 6 February
Martin Watt BBC Sport Scotland
Media caption,
'What a finish' - watch Celtic's Maeda score sublime chip
A finer goal you will struggle to see this season.
From their own byeline, Celtic worked the ball upfield with a seven-pass sequence to Daizen Maeda.
The forward still had plenty to do, but his deft and delicate finish from just inside the Dundee box was exquisite, arcing over goalkeeper Trevor Carson and under the crossbar.
Michael Stewart described it as a "ludicrous finish" on BBC Scotland Sportsound, while Lee Miller went even further: "That's one of the best goals I've seen."
The goal was Maeda's second in four minutes and Celtic's fourth in the 6-0 destruction of Dundee, taking the Japan forward's tally to 18 in his most productive season for the club. His previous best for Celtic was 11.
Maeda's finishing hasn't always been his strongest attribute during his Celtic career, but this term has seen a marked improvement.
The 27-year-old, who now has five goals in his past five games, grabbed a double against Dundee from an xG (expected goals) of just 0.57. Maeda attempted two shots, scoring both, while his six touches in the opposition box was the most of any player, likewise his three chances created.
His industry - a facet that makes him a fans' favourite - was also on display, with Maeda competing in seven duels and winning possession three times.
"The thing that frightens me, he never looks tired," former Scotland striker Miller added.
"He is a defender's nightmare. I do not know where he gets the energy from."
'Totally unstoppable' - your views on Dundee demolitionpublished at 12:21 6 February
12:21 6 February
We asked for your views after Celtic hammered Dundee 6-0 to go 13 points clear at the Premiership summit.
Here's what some of you said:
Andy: Sublime performance, so glad for Adam Idah. I was one of his many critics but I'm glad the big man has made me eat my words and he's a true Celt as well.
John: Not quite the Larsson chip, Daizen, but not bad coming in from the wrong wing! We must hold on to Greg Taylor. Idah working so hard and leads well.
Stephen: Great performance, great result. Totally unstoppable. Maeda was absolutely fantastic, as was Arne Engels. He's starting to show why Celtic paid so much money for his services.
Peter: For once we scored the goals that our excellent team play deserved. Very impressive. Competition for places in starting line-up will keep everyone on their toes. Play like this every week and another domestic treble is assured. Maeda's second goal was a thing of beauty. Engels impressive.
John: It looks like Kyogo will not be missed in these run-of-the-mill league games. The real test will be against European opposition and Rangers. Maeda has the flexibility to play through the middle as he does with Japan but Idah is tightly holding in to the number nine jersey with his four goals in three games.
Idah has 'taken responsibility' after Kyogo exit, says Rodgerspublished at 10:18 6 February
10:18 6 February
Image source, SNS
Celtic boss Brendan Rodgers believes Adam Idah is thriving on the responsibility of filling the void left by Kyogo Furuhashi.
Republic of Ireland striker Idah made it four goals in three games with the second in Wednesday night's 6-0 rout of Dundee as Celtic stretched their lead at the top to 13 points.
"He was always going to have to be patient here and obviously the nature of having a brilliant striker in Kyogo, who fitted a lot of how I want the team to play and pressing and everything else," said Rodgers.
"He comes in and he has to fit around that but he still made big contributions.
"I think he's taken that responsibility now and he sees this as an opportunity for him because he knows at Celtic he has to produce and you have to produce consistently.
"So pleased for him, he's just moving different now and he's getting a real handful.
"His goal was very good, makes a good run, gets his shot off, doesn't lie about the floor, gets up and then he's able to get the rebound and a really good finish. Very pleased for him."
Celtic 6-0 Dundee: Key statspublished at 09:37 6 February
09:37 6 February
Image source, SNS
Celtic's Daizen Maeda has contributed to goals in his past four games in the Premiership (four goals, four assists). The Japan forward's current three-game scoring streak streak is his longest in the competition.
Dundee have failed to win in their past four games in the Premiership, their last longer winless streak was from 24 August 2024 to 5 October 2024, a run of five games.
Celtic have kept a clean sheet in 18 of their 25 games, more than any other in the Premiership this season.
Celtic have scored 18 goals in the last 15 minutes of the second half, more than any other team in the Premiership this season.
Dundee have conceded 13 goals to opposition substitutes in the Premiership this season, more than any other team.
Celtic 6-0 Dundee: Analysispublished at 23:02 5 February
23:02 5 February
George O'Neill BBC Sport Scotland
Image source, SNS
When Kyogo completed his move to French side Rennes, it posed questions about what Celtic's attack might look like for the rest of the season.
Here, they showed they are still a devastating force without the Japan striker, lead by his international colleague Daizen Maeda.
His pace in behind the Dundee defence was a constant threat and he looked completely unfussed by switching wings, harrying the opposition throughout the game
The 27-year-old created three chances - the joint-most of any player - and had more touches in the opposition box than anyone else.
His second goal reflected how high his confidence levels are at present, sending an arcing first-time shot over a helpless Trevor Carson and into the top corner.
Adam Idah scored his fourth goal in his last three outings as he continues to step up in Kyogo's absence, and Jota showed his class too on his first start since returning to Glasgow.
The Portuguese winger's cross for Maeda's first was a delightful pick out, and he will only improve as he gets more minutes into his legs.
Nicolas Kuhn's introduction off the bench showed the depth of quality Rodgers has at his disposal and he put the icing on the cake with a whipped left-footed strike late on.
On this showing and given the big gap, it seems a certainty that the league title will be staying at Parkhead come May.
Celtic 6-0 Dundee: What the manager saidpublished at 22:37 5 February
22:37 5 February
Image source, SNS
Celtic manager Brendan Rodgers: "Definitely one of the best [performances] of our season.
"From minute one to the 93rd minute we had a real hunger in our game and real quality in our game.
"Tony's [Docherty] team over the course of the season have, in the main, defended well and been very strong and we saw that up there when we played against them.
"But we were never going to make the same mistake as what we did in the 3-3 game.
"I think you saw the difference tonight with the counter-pressing and the numbers around the ball and winning the duels, and that gives us the possibilities to play and when we play like that then we can produce great moments.
"We play so many games and our idea is to improve every game. We want to be able to effect games through to the end. Jota is still finding his way but you can his his class and his quality on the ball. Daizen [Maeda] has 18 goals now, Nicolas [Kuhn] 17 goals, and obviously Adam [Idah] gets his goal.
"It's been a really good season up to now. You arrive to this point in a good place and then you've got to keep your foot to the floor. We have to stay concentrated, keep showing aggression on the pitch and keep our humility."
'Dreadful window' or Celtic 'wise not getting held to ransom'?published at 14:28 5 February
14:28 5 February
We asked for your views on Celtic's business in the January transfer window.
Here's what some of you said:
Chris: The board have let the fans down and more to the point they have let Brendan Rodgers down. Kyogo wanted to part ways months ago and yet they waited until he walks out the door before attempting to try and find a replacement. If the board don't want to spend any money to buy players then why should the fans spend our money to go watch the club?
RC: Dreadful window for Celtic. If we knew Kyogo wanted away, several options should have been scouted and shortlisted from long-term solutions to shorter-term options. Definitely weaker in terms of squad depth. Jota the only silver lining. Fingers crossed Idah/Maeda stay fit!
Denis: It's always difficult to get the right players in without paying through the nose. The players Celtic are looking at think they're more valuable than they are. If they are that good then I'm sure other top European clubs would be interested. So, we shouldn't be pushed into paying more than they are worth.
Clem: Difficult one, but disappointing. If we had brought in Adam Idah after his exploits last season in this window, we would most likely be delighted. But we needed to replace Kyogo in some form. It does ask the question of where our ambition is? Celtic can and should be able to cater for two quality strkers. So overall, a disappointing window.
James: I am happy with the return of Jota.. The departure of Kyogo is a loss but his form has not been great under our manager and his best goals tally came when Jota was supplying the goals. Onwards and upwards with an opportunity to give Johnny Kenny and/or Daniel Cummings a go. Who knows, they may save us a fortune.
Eddie: We've got as far as we can in Champions League, we won't get past Bayern so wise not getting held to ransom and paying over the odds. We have enough in the tank to win the domestic trophies, so wait till the summer and spend wisely.
'It's been one of my dreams' - Schlupp 'super excited' by Celtic movepublished at 11:45 5 February
11:45 5 February
Image source, SNS
Jeffrey Schlupp says he has fulfilled a dream by joining Celtic and wants to achieve "great things" with the club.
The 32-year-old Ghana international completed a deadline-day move from Crystal Palace to the Scottish champions for the remainder of the season.
Schlupp, who could make his debut against Dundee tonight, told Celtic TV: "I'm super excited. It's actually been one of my dreams, as much as many others, to play for such a great club like Celtic.
"I had the pleasure of playing here about nine years ago in a pre-season match, so I've actually been to the stadium before and the atmosphere and everything about it was something exciting.
"So as soon as the opportunity came up, I was really excited about it."
Schlupp is relishing his reunion with former Leicester City team-mate Kasper Schemichel - the pair helped the Foxes to Premier League glory in 2016 - and the opportunity to pursue a domestic treble, as well as facing Bayern Munich in the upcoming Champions League play-off.
"Kasper was one of the first people I spoke to when this opportunity came up," he added.
"He messaged me and we spoke, and he told me about how great the club is, how much I'll enjoy playing here, and I can't wait to link up again.
"I've watched the other Champions League games and the boys have performed so well in it.
"I want to repay the manager for the faith he has in bringing me here, and hopefully I can do that with some good performances and hopefully we, as a squad, can achieve some great things."
Celtic v Dundee: Pick of the statspublished at 09:34 5 February
09:34 5 February
Image source, SNS
Dundee remain winless in 45 meetings with Celtic in all competitions (D7 L38), although the sides' 3-3 draw last month was the first time the Dark Blues scored 3+ goals against the Hoops in a match since October 1988 (3-2 win).
Celtic have won 20 of their past 22 home games against Dundee in all competitions (D2) since a 2-0 defeat in May 2001. The Hoops have won their past six home games in a row over Dundee by an aggregate score of 24-3.
Celtic have won each of their past seven home league games by an aggregate score of 23-0. The Hoops last won more in a row without conceding at Celtic Park in March 2014 (9).
Dundee have won their past two away league outings, as many as their previous 17 beforehand (W2 D5 L10).
After scoring in the 3-3 draw between these sides last month, having also scored two league goals for Dundee earlier this season, Celtic's Luke McCowan is the first player to score both for and against the same side in a Scottish Premiership season since Tony Watt with both Dundee United and Motherwell in 2021-22. He's the frst to do so for and against Dundee in the competition since Simon Murray in 2017-18.
Celtic to miss out on Strelec? Scottish gossippublished at 08:12 5 February
Strelec's father says a move to Celtic for his son in January would have been "great". (Record), external
New Tottenham forward Mason Melia, 17, had been a target for Celtic. (Sun), external
Kieran Tierney, 27, is set to return to Celtic from Arsenal this summer and the Premiership champions' manager Brendan Rodgers reveals a January move to Glasgow for the Scotland defender was "never close". (Herald - subscription), external
Football finance expert Stefan Borson believes Celtic will bank more than £40m from European participation this season. (Football Insider), external
Ayr United manager and former Celtic and player Scott Brown is not interested in the vacancy at Motherwell. (Sun), external
Scott Brown would appear to be staying at Ayr United for the time being
Idah wants to be 'main man' in attack for Celticpublished at 20:48 4 February
20:48 4 February
Image source, SNS
Celtic striker Adam Idah is excited about the prospect of an extended run of starts going into the second half of the season.
The Republic of Ireland international, 23, has scored three goals in two games since Kyogo Furuhashi was sold to Rennes and the Scottish champions have not signed another striker.
"Of course, it's nice for me, obviously, that potentially I've got a lot more game time on my hands, but at the end of the day, it's not my decision whether the club signs a striker or not," he said.
"I want to be the main man, and I want to have that role and responsibility to try and help the team.
"So it's exciting times for me, and hopefully I can carry on the goal scoring that I've been doing."
Idah now has 11 goals for the season, with 20 of his 34 appearances coming from the bench.
"You want to play as many minutes as you can and I'm ready to take that role now," he added.
"But it's all about the team. I don't think I'd be too bothered if another striker came in, because at the end of the day, we all want the same thing, and that's to win as many trophies and titles as we can."
Rodgers 'won't have joy killed' by lack of business in Januarypublished at 18:18 4 February
18:18 4 February
Image source, SNS
Brendan Rodgers says he "can't have the hump" with Celtic's transfer business in January as it would hamper his "motivational style of management".
The manager admitted the squad is "lighter and tighter" but has learned "not to kill your joy over things you can't actually control".
The league leaders brought Portuguese winger Jota back to the club before signing Premier League winner Jeffrey Schlupp on a loan deal until the end of the season.
"I think what's very, very important is that what you learn through experience is the emotional transfer," Rodgers said when previewing the Scottish Premiership game with Dundee on Wednesday.
"Because if you have the hump, with the greatest respect, then as the coach and the leader, my leadership style is very much a motivational style where I like to teach, I like to inspire and I like to motivate.
"Now, you've got to be in a good mood for that, in the main. As I said repeatedly, with experience you learn not to kill your joy over things you can't actually control. As we're sat here now, we can do absolutely nothing about it."
Rodgers said he understands supporters' frustration at not signing a replacement for striker Kyogo who left for Rennes, but, added he "doesn't want to pin the blame on anyone" for any deals not transpiring.
"I think as a collective, it wasn't ideal how it ended for us," he added.
"We have to, as a club now, go away and look at that, like we'll do in every window, that's what you have to do. I don't want to pin blame on anyone here.
"I said it myself, we wanted another striker, so we're not hiding behind anything, and absolutely, the supporters will look and see what a top striker has gone out - a legendary striker - and we haven't replaced it.
"So I understand that, but, all I can do is affect what we have now work and work very, very hard and finish off what has been, until now, a great season for us."
Rodgers on transfer window, Dundee & 'not having the hump'published at 17:48 4 February
17:48 4 February
Image source, SNS
Brendan Rodgers has been addressing the media before Celtic host Dundee in the Scottish Premiership on Wednesday night.
Here are the key things he said:
On the January transfer window, Rodgers said the club "done some really good business" but conceded "one or two things didn't quite drop" and so "the squad is lighter".
Rodgers reiterated he "wanted" to bring in a forward replacement for Kyogo, but stressed it's "never as plain and simple as people think".
The manager admitted "we could've done better" but added: "I'm not going to become frustrated now and kill my joy of working here every day by thinking, 'what could have been'."
He confirmed a deal to bring Kieran Tierney in in January "wasn't close".
Rodgers stressed "he can't have the hump" if he wants to continue being the manager who "inspires and motivates".
He is hopeful the "physical and pacey" Jeffrey Schlupp will be involved against Dundee.
The manager said the 3-3 game against Dundee last month "was easy to analyse" and assured his side "won't be so soft in defence".
'You simply cannot lose talismanic striker then fail to replace him'published at 15:29 4 February
15:29 4 February
Tino Fan writer
"We always want to come out of the transfer window stronger than when we entered it."
It's become one of the biggest cliches in football and one that's rolled out by club chief executives and chairmen on a biannual basis.
So, are Celtic stronger now than we were at the turn of the year? Yes and no. But mostly no!
Yes, we've added superstar quality on the wings in returning hero Jota - a move that has roundly unified the fanbase.
But no in the sense that we've lost Kyogo Furuhashi, a move that by contrast has completely divided opinion.
I say divided, but it's pretty clear cut for me. You simply cannot lose your talismanic striker, a scorer of 85 goals in three-and-a-half seasons in the Hoops, and then not replace him.
With every respect, spare me the Johnny Kenny/Daniel Cummings chat. Two talented but unproven youngsters who may or may not have a future at the club.
And while Daizen Maeda can play striker, he's spent three years at Celtic as a left winger, so again that would be far from a like-for-like replacement for his now departed countryman.
If you're unsure about the requirement for a striker, then ask the man whose opinion matters more than most.
We simply need to look back at Brendan Rodgers' own quotes from just a couple of weeks ago where he was unequivocal in his desire for a new frontman.
Dress it up however you like. That request has not materialised.
It would be remiss of course not to mention we have added further by bringing in utility man Jeffrey Schlupp on a loan move until the end of the season.
And the fact another returning hero, Kieran Tierney, will also be a Celtic player once again by next season.
But neither of these moves bear any relevance to our now wafer-thin options up top, and that is what's causing most concern among fans, as well as potentially the manager himself.
Rodgers has been in this position before, and many will speculate that a lack of backing in the transfer market played a part in his exit first time around.
The real fear among supporters is we may now see history repeat itself.
His next few press conferences will say a lot about just how happy – or not – he is about how the January window has played out.
No new Celtic striker a surprise - Allanpublished at 15:25 4 February
15:25 4 February
Kheredine Idessane BBC Sport Scotland Senior Reporter
Image source, SNS
Former Celtic midfielder Scott Allan is "surprised" the club didn't bring a striker in during the transfer window following Kyogo Furuhashi's exit to Rennes.
Brendan Rodgers had confirmed the club were seeking a striker in January after Kyogo informed them "a number of months" ago of his wish to leave.
"I was surprised but in the January window Celtic have obviously looked at options, whether that was loan deal or a permanent one, and they haven't managed to get someone across the line," Allan told BBC Scotland.
"You're looking at the options, they've obviously got Adam Idah, who they spent £9m on in the summer. He'll be looking to come to the fore now that Kyogo [Furuhashi] has gone.
"They've got Johnny Kenny, who had a successful loan spell at Shamrock Rovers, and young Daniel Cummings, who they had offers for from West Ham.
"It will be interesting to see what they do. They've obviously got Daizen Maeda as well who we know can play up top and has done for Japan.
"Jota came back and Celtic would be hoping that would maybe soften the blow with Kyogo going. Come the summer, that will be the main priority for Celtic, getting a number nine in to replace Kyogo.
"There are reasons why they didn't make any rash decisions to just jump the gun and take someone in just for the sake of it. Celtic obviously have a good points gap in the league and have done what they started out to do at the start of the season by progressing in the Champions League, with that huge tie coming up against Bayern Munich."