'It has improved decision making' - Doncaster on VARpublished at 14:22 5 May 2024
Watch SPFL chief executive Neil Doncaster talk to the Sportsound team about VAR
Watch SPFL chief executive Neil Doncaster talk to the Sportsound team about VAR
Rangers defender Connor Goldson is out for the season after picking up a knee injury in training. Ridvan Yilmaz and Ryan Jack returned to training this week but only the former has any chance of making it against Killie.
Attackers Abdallah Sima (hamstring) and Rabbi Matondo (knock) remain sidelined while Danilo (knee) and Oscar Cortes (muscle) are out for the rest of the season.
Kilmarnock midfielder James Balagizi picked up a knee strain and is out but will be back for the St Mirren match the following week.
Greg Stewart has recently had a hernia operation but could be back for the end of the season, while Kyle Magennis remains out long term with a hamstring problem.
Kilmarnock's place in European football next season has been confirmed after Dundee were defeated by St Mirren on Saturday.
Derek McInnes' side now lead the Dens Park outfit by 11 points with three games to go.
The Ayrshire club have a six-point lead over fifth-placed St Mirren, who have played a game more.
The club wrote on X: "We’ve known it has been coming, but results elsewhere today confirms that Kilmarnock will be playing European football next season.
"Thank you to everyone who has supported on this crazy journey! Now let’s secure fourth".
Iona Ballantyne
BBC Sport Scotland
Joe Wright wishes he could "bottle" Kilmarnock's campaign, with the Rugby Park club on the cusp of European Football.
Having moved to Ayrshire at the start of last season, the defender endured a gruelling season last year as Killie staved off relegation.
But this term, Wright says the sense of positivity has made coming to work a pleasant experience.
"You obviously look forward to the summer and your break away, but if you could bottle this season it'd be brilliant," the 29-year-old said.
"When you're playing with good players, it just makes your game easier. It's just been enjoyable coming in every day.
"It doesn't feel like a job, you're with your friends and just having a good time."
Kilmarnock are keen to nail down fourth place, says Wright, but would need to win at Ibrox if they're to do so this weekend.
"We want to do that [confirm Europe] as soon as possible," Wright added.
"Mathematically, it's not quite there yet, and with everyone playing each other it can look more comfortable than it actually is.
"We've always got that motivation as a team. When you're playing against the Old Firm, you know you've got to be at is as a group. The games against Rangers have been close.
"It helps when you have positive results and performances, you go into these games without fearing anyone."
We asked for your views on who has been Killie's player of the year. It seemed to be a tough choice for the Rugby Park faithful.
Here are some of your suggestions:
Neil: Player of the season for me would have to be Matty Kennedy.
John: Take your pick from Danny Armstrong, Lewis Mayo, Will Dennis or Marley Watkins.
Steve: Great season. Armstrong the stand out player by far. Looking forward to him tearing up Europe.
Andy: For a player most thought would be a decent squad player, Watkins has been absolutely outstanding. He works his socks off, he’s scored some fantastic goals and his link-up play has been a vital part of the team’s success.
Grant: Tough call to pick a player of the year. Mayo has been outstanding, Kyle Vassell has led the team brilliantly, David Watson brilliant, Kennedy and Armstrong superb and creative. But for me the accolades go to Watkins, who without a shadow of a doubt has been unplayable at times.
Robert: Watkins, Stuart Findlay, Armstrong, Dennis or Kennedy all have good cases for player of the season but my choice would be Mayo. Incredible consistency in every game he has played.
Rangers have won eight of their last nine league meetings with Kilmarnock, with the exception a 1-0 defeat on matchday one this season.
Kilmarnock have lost each of their last six league visits to Rangers since a 1-1 draw in March 2019 under Steve Clarke.
After winning 10 home matches in a row across all competitions between December and February, Rangers have since won just one of their last four at Ibrox (D2 L1), conceding in all four games.
Kilmarnock are unbeaten in their last five Scottish Premiership away matches (W1 D4) and could win back-to-back top-flight matches on the road for the first time since October 2020.
James Tavernier has been directly involved in 11 goals across his last 10 Scottish Premiership matches (seven goals, four assists). Overall, his 26 goal involvements (17 goals, nine assists) this season are the most of any player in the competition.
Kilmarnock are no stranger to a result against the Old Firm this season but can they do it at Ibrox on Sunday?
Who do you think should be in the starting line-up in Govan?
Put yourself in the manager's shoes and pick your XI here.
Sandy Armour
Fan writer
One well-used football cliche is 'if you can't win, make sure you don't get beat' - that's exactly what Killie did at the weekend.
Hearts played as well as any team has at Rugby Park this season, in the first half anyway. We rode our luck on occasion but the desire and battling qualities were there for all to see.
We might have even sneaked a win at the end, although that would have been a bit cheeky. But it was a good point - and with other results going in our favour, the passport has now been taken out the drawer and is sitting on top of the suitcase.
We are now nine points clear in third with only four games remaining. There is more chance of Ayr winning a trophy than there is of Killie missing out on a European adventure next season.
It is Ibrox next on Sunday to face a Rangers team who are the only side to have beaten us in the last 18 league games, but we can play with some freedom against a group of players who are showing some nerves in recent games.
Sandy Armour is the editor of the Killie Hippo fanzine.
It's been a superb season for Derek McInnes' Kilmarnock side, but who has stood out to you?
We want to know who you would choose as the club's player of the season.
Iona Ballantyne
BBC Sport Scotland
Derek McInnes says the atmosphere at Kilmarnock makes his job easier after admitting it's "nice" to be nominated for the SPFL manager of the year award.
The Ayrshire club have gone from fending off relegation last season to sitting on the brink of European football this term.
Despite their improved fortunes, the Rugby Park boss doesn't believe he's become a better manager, but says the recruitment and squad has turned things around.
"It’s nice to be in good company," McInnes said. "Not something I was thinking about, but once it was mentioned it’s nice. It’s always a reflection on the whole club.
"This season has been a lot easier to manage even though you get the recognition for it because your team is doing well, and that’s all down to recruitment and the players.
"I don’t think I’ve become a better manager this year than I was last year, I actually think that last year was a tougher test for us, but this year has been so enjoyable, it really has.
"And that’s down to the players every day and it’s down to the staff I’m working with. I still have that enthusiasm – when I wake up I can’t wait to bounce into work and I want my players to feel that work is a good place and hopefully that can continue.
"I’ve really enjoyed the season – four games to go and hopefully there’s a couple of highlights still in us."
Iona Ballantyne
BBC Sport Scotland
Kilmarnock manager Derek McInnes has been talking to the media before his side's Scottish Premiership trip to Ibrox on Sunday.
Here are the key points from his press conference:
Says "it's nice to be in good company" with his PFA Scotland manager of the year nomination, and stressed it is a reflection of the positive work being done by the club as a whole.
Insists that last season was a tougher test for him as a manager - "you probably feel you do more as a manager in a season like that, you do a lot of your better work when you have to deal with a crisis".
McInnes pointed to the "brilliant" recruitment done by the club last summer, which he says has been a key factor in their climb up the league.
Spoke about the lack of celebrations among players and staff when Kilmarnock secured a top-six finish. McInnes stressed that the goal is European football and wants to seal that as soon as possible.
McInnes wasn't aware of the SFA's VAR review panel saying 26 Premiership decisions have been incorrect since the start of the season. He says there is "still a bit to go" before the in-game process is "slick and as good as possible"
Twenty-six decisions since the start of the Premiership season have been deemed incorrect by the Scottish FA's VAR independent review panel.
The tally, based on incidents requested by the panel or submitted for consideration, is a rise of 10 since February's last meeting of the group.
Not among the incidents included was one where Hibernian claimed the Scottish FA agreed an error had been made.
The governing body later disputed that assertion, made after Hibs were not awarded a penalty after Aberdeen's Nicky Devlin handled in February's 2-2 draw.
The 10 incorrect decisions shared with Premiership clubs on Wednesday were:
Rangers 2-1 Aberdeen (6/02/24): VAR intervention was correct, but final outcome should have been yellow card to Rangers' Dujon Sterling. Referee retained his on-field decision of a red card.
St Mirren 2-0 Dundee (7/02/24): VAR intervention was correct, but final outcome should have been yellow card to St Mirren's James Bolton. Referee retained his on-field decision of a red card.
Ross County 1-1 St Mirren (27/2/24): VAR should have recommended an on-field review. Final outcome should have been penalty awarded against Ross County for handball.
Hearts 1-1 Hibernian (28/2/24): VAR intervention correct, but penalty decision, which led to Hearts' equaliser, should have been overturned - no foul and no penalty should have been awarded.
Kilmarnock 1-2 Rangers (28/2/24): VAR should have recommended an on-field review. Final outcome should have been penalty decision, which led to Kilmarnock opening the scoring, overturned - no handball offense against Rangers.
Hearts 2-0 Celtic (3/3/24): VAR should have recommended an on-field review. Penalty decision should have been overturned - no foul and no penalty should have been awarded to Celtic.
Hearts 2-0 Celtic (3/3/24): On-field decision correct, no penalty to Hearts. Handball should not have been awarded for spot-kick that led to opening goal.
Motherwell 0-1 Aberdeen (16/04/24): VAR should have recommended an on-field review. Penalty to Motherwell should have been awarded for handball.
Hibernian 1-2 St Johnstone (6/4/24): VAR should have recommended an on-field review. Penalty should have been awarded to Hibs for foul by St Johnstone goalkeeper Dimitar Mitov.
St Mirren 1-2 Hearts (6/4/24): VAR intervention correct, but penalty should have been awarded to St Mirren for a foul on Conor McMenamin by Aidan Denholm.
David Watson says Kilmarnock manager Derek McInnes has played a "massive part" in a breakthrough season that has resulted in him being nominated for PFA young player of the year.
The 19-year-old has been a key cog in McInnes' midfield this term, playing 41 times and scoring five goals.
Kilmarnock, currently nine points clear in fourth, have all but secured a European place in a campaign Watson feels has surpassed his personal expectations.
"It's been good to feature as many times as I have," the midfielder said. "I didn't go into the season with too much expectation, from then I think I've kicked on.
"A lot of it comes from the players around me and the gaffer, that gives me confidence. They trust me so much and have every faith in me.
"[McInnes] been a massive part to my game. He's worked closely with me, especially with adding goals because he put that demand on me.
"I had a target to get five and I've got that. I'm trying to better that now."
Nick McPheat
BBC Sport Scotland
The Scottish Championship title, Premiership survival, a place in Europe all but secured, now a PFA manager of the year nominee.
In just over two years in charge of Kilmarnock, Derek McInnes has gone beyond expectations as Rugby Park boss.
After securing instant top-flight promotion in his first few months as manager in 2022, top-flight survival was achieved last season.
Yes, the 2022-23 campaign could have gone better. McInnes would have aimed higher than guaranteeing survival on the final day, but ensuring Kilmarnock remained in the league laid foundations for a mightily impressive 2023-24 season.
A summer of shrewd recruitment and stellar home form have been key in not only securing a top-six place, but almost certainly a spot in Europe next season.
McInnes' achievement has been recognised by his peers, who have voted him on to a three-man shortlist for manager of the year, along with ex-assistant Tony Docherty and Falkirk manager John McGlynn.
If McInnes claims the award, he will be in fine company. The only other Kilmarnock manager to win the prize is Scotland boss Steve Clarke, who was also the last man to guide the Rugby Park side to a European finish.
Sean McGill
BBC Sport Scotland
Kilmarnock fans already knew they had a player on their hands in the shape of David Watson last season.
But this term, the 19-year-old has taken his game to a new level.
Derek McInnes challenged his young midfielder to make himself more of a threat going forward in the summer, giving him the task of adding goals to his bite and determination.
Watson has done that, and in some style. There was the gorgeous touch-and-finish winner at Pittodrie. The raker at home to St Johnstone. The mazy that took out multiple St Mirren bodies in that incredible comeback win - from right-back, it's worth noting.
He has also scored twice at the home of the champions, including a 92nd-minute equaliser in the Ayrshire side's 1-1 draw at Celtic Park in February.
His 24 chances created are the most of any teenager in the Scottish Premiership this season.
It's been a breakthrough campaign for the teenager, with Kilmarnock fans well aware of inevitable interest in a young player of his talents.
His already lofty stock could be elevated if he were to be awarded PFA Scotland young player of the year.
To do so, he'll have to beat fellow Scottish midfielder Lennon Miller of Motherwell and Dundee's Lyall Cameron, as well as Rangers' Northern Irish winger, Ross McCausland.
One thing that could hamper Watson's chances is his lack of starts in recent months, with Liams Donnelly and Polworth forging a formidable partnership in the heart of Killie's midfield.
Despite fewer minutes in the second half of the season, Watson's standing as one of the most exciting prospects in the division remains hard to argue against.
Watch Sportscene analysis of Kilmarnock's goalless draw against Hearts
Jonathan Sutherland
Sportscene presenter
Another week, another clean sheet for Kilmarnock.
The Ayrshire club's centre-halves have all been solid this term, but Stuart Findlay has looked particularly assured in recent weeks.
His performance in the goalless draw with Hearts was another reason for Killie fans to hope for his permanent return in the summer.
Watch all the action from Rugby Park as Kilmarnock and Hearts played out a goalless draw. (Available to UK users only).
We asked for your views on Kilmarnock's goalless draw at home to Hearts on Saturday.
Here's what some of you said:
Anon: Hard-earned point. We played our best football in the last quarter of the game when our three subs injected new life into our play. Although we didn't trouble their keeper till late in the game, we may well have taken three points but for an excellent late save. Happy with the point as the woodwork came to our rescue in the first half.
Adam: Good draw, game of two halves. Hearts good first half, Kilmarnock in the second and nearly stole the game in the last minute, unlucky! Overall a good 0-0 draw.
Anna: Always going to be tough against Hearts and the 0-0 proved that. We couldn't create many chances of note, but the defence was resolute and strong. Shows how much Derek McInnes has improved things in the squad. Not losing could mean a point closer to a European place next season and that would be a richly deserved reward.
David: Strong first-half performance by Hearts petered out in second half. Killie grew into the game second half despite poor refereeing decisions. Fair point for both teams - overall great defensive display by Killie - and Lewis Mayo must be knocking on Steve Clarke’s door given list of injury doubts.
Derek McInnes reckons Kilmarnock’s hard-earned point against Hearts could be a crucial moment in their quest to clinch fourth place.
Despite making a bright start, McInnes’ side were under the cosh for much of the goalless stalemate in which the visitors twice struck the woodwork.
Kilmarnock remain in the driving seat in fourth place after just one defeat in 12 league fixtures.
"It absolutely could be [a crucial point], nobody has got a crystal ball, but it's difficult to pick up points in the top six, particularly when the Old Firm are going for a title," manager McInnes said.
"It takes us up to 52 points, which is great shooting from my players.
"We set off at the start of the campaign to make sure we weren't in the position we were last year, we then tried towards top six. We've been there for the majority of the season and have carried ourselves like a top six team.
"Once we got that point at Tynecastle a couple of weeks ago, there was no real celebration from us - it was what's next?
"Fourth spot is next and that's what we're working towards, we need to make sure that the focus is there to go on and finish the job."