'Freak incident' but do Leeds need to find a new goalkeeper?published at 12:36 8 October 2024
Adonis Storr
Fan writer


With one second of injury-time left last Friday night, away at then-Championship leaders Sunderland; at a ground where no away team had left with even a point, a wayward cross flicked off Junior Firpo's head, landed in what Pascal Struijk described as a "hole", spun wickedly past Illan Meslier and into Leeds United's empty net.
It looked like Meslier had made a huge error but on analysis it was the kind of freak occurrence where the impact was magnified by the time, setting and the player it involved.
The frustrations of Leeds fans with Meslier have been simmering under the surface for some time.
Meslier has consistently underperformed against the statistic that attempts to define a goalkeeper's shot-stopping ability – post-shot expected goals minus goals allowed. Over-performing goalkeepers are in credit, under-performers have a negative score.
Meslier has never been in credit with this metric at Leeds. In this season's Championship he sits 18th, the same place he finished last season. In the last two Premier League campaigns Meslier was 20th and 19th respectively and in the past five seasons he has conceded 35 goals more than statistically expected.
Meslier is 24 and years away from the average peak for goalkeepers. He is likeable, and has potential, but can Leeds afford to keep waiting for him to improve?
The Frenchman seems nervous at times, his distribution is a shadow of the display away at Arsenal in the FA Cup in January 2020, where he dazzled, spraying inch-perfect long passes all around the Emirates. He has saved one penalty in 20 for Leeds, and conceding record-breaking numbers at times in the Premier League looks like it has hurt his confidence.
It was a freak incident that provoked the discussion, but do Leeds need to find a new goalkeeper in January?
Find more from Adonis Storr at The Roaring Peacock, external