Manchester City

We have, roughly, run the numbers and here is the XI your submissions have produced.

In many ways, City fans are spoiled for choice but there was also reasonable consensus about who should make this stellar line-up.

With 4-4-2 the most chosen formation, it does mean perhaps slightly unusual positioning for a couple of these players, but it certainly would not hold them back.

And a strikeforce of Erling Haaland and Sergio Aguero would light up the Premier League.

Nicola Pearson
BBC Sport journalist

Image source, Getty Images

The statistics might say playing at home is an advantage - but what happens when it is not?

So far this season, 53% of Premier League matches have been won by the home team - the highest ever rate in a single campaign.

On the flip side, just 26% have been won by the away team - the lowest rate since 2010-11.

However, this has not been the case for all teams.

For some, being on the road has been more favourable. Tottenham are perhaps the most contrasting example having the joint-most points away from home with 13, but the second-worst in front of their own fans with just five points.

In the second part of her chat with BBC Sport, performance psychologist Marie Cartwright explained: "With crowds when playing away from home, there is a reduced scrutiny as a whole for away teams in that those crowds expect the home team to be the ones in charge. The players feel less judged. The pressure is on the other side.

"Another reason could come down to something in psychology I like to call simplification of the task. The team has a better collective identity when they are away.

"The human brain still goes back to the cavemen days. We have to, as a collective, fight for something. We have to protect our name. It goes back to that hunter-gatherer-against-danger mentality.

"When players are in front of a home crowd, there can be a bit of playing up to the individuality.

"I really do believe that collective identity has a strong enough influence because it amplifies the purpose and the belonging - let's belong together, let's be stronger together."

The focus might be on the players' performances being impacted by being home or away, but what about the managers?

Wolves, West Ham and Nottingham Forest make up three of the bottom four for their home records so far this term, and all have changed their manager in recent weeks.

"100% managers and coaches can be affected, and sometimes even more so because there is so much riding on that one person," Cartwright said.

"The decision-making is the main thing. The crowd is chanting - 'take this player off, do this' - and it can lead to rushed decisions, particularly when the noise becomes relentless.

"Then there is the emotional regulation and touchline behaviour. A manager is pacing up and down, mirroring the stress state, and players see that. It can lead to mimicking and players feeling that stress too."

The impact on teams psychologically playing home or away is apparent, so how can they make the most from these different conditions?

"Our brains are wired to think negatively - it's a protection mechanism," Cartwright said.

"So when it comes to performing home and away, those players and managers who deal with it best are those who know how to use the noise and scrutiny and move on quickly from it - an ability to have a reset routine and regulate their emotions in these pressurised situations."

Read more from Marie in part one of her chat around the impact of playing at home here

Emlyn Begley
BBC Sport journalist

Image source, Getty Images

Generational goalgetter Erling Haaland will get a crack at his first major tournament next summer, after leading Norway to the 2026 World Cup.

And the Manchester City striker did it in sensational style, scoring 16 goals in eight qualifiers - netting at least once in every one of those games.

That makes him the top scorer in World Cup qualifying in any continent.

The 25-year-old's goalscoring record for Norway is nothing short of phenomenal.

He has hit 55 goals in 48 matches for his country and in fact he is only the sixth player ever, and the first in 53 years, to score 50 goals in fewer than 50 caps.

Norway's previous top scorer was 33-goal Jorgen Juve, who held that record for 90 years.

Over a year has passed since Haaland last failed to score in a game for Norway.

Including games for City, Haaland has scored 32 goals in 20 games this season.

For the first time in a generation, Norway fans will experience the joy of supporting their team at an international tournament.

Their nation competed in the World Cups in 1938, 1994 and 1998, and Euro 2000.

Haaland's father, Alf Inge, played at the 1994 tournament. Erling has previously said being better than his father was a big career ambition for him.

Alfie never won a trophy with clubs like Nottingham Forest, Leeds and Manchester City.

Erling has won the Treble with City, another title too and trophies in Austria and Germany.

A World Cup appearance was probably the only thing his dad's career had over his.

"Norway will never win the World Cup," Haaland Jr told Time Magazine in July., external

"If we would qualify for the World Cup, it would be like another big nation winning it. It would be the biggest party ever. Scenes in Oslo would be incredible."

Manchester City are monitoring Eintracht Frankfurt left-back Nathaniel Brown, 22, who made his senior debut for the German national team in October. (Bild - in German), external

Want more transfer stories? Read Monday's full gossip column

Follow the gossip column on BBC Sport

Nicola Pearson
BBC Sport journalist

Image source, Getty Images

"Home advantage gives you an advantage."

It is a quote - among many - attributed to the famous former England manager Sir Bobby Robson - a simple, yet fair reflection of a historical format of football.

For as long as teams have played in leagues, games taking place home and away has been the norm, with the idea that playing at home will be to the benefit of that team.

But what is the impact of playing at your own ground in front of your own fans?

In the first part of her chat with BBC Sport, performance psychologist Marie Cartwright explained: "Home impact can be viewed in two ways. Sometimes it does have a positive impact, and what happens is there is an elevated motivation.

"What that means is the crowd energy increases adrenaline and that creates a momentum in effort and intensity in the players. It is also a familiar environment for the players, so that means it reduces the cognitive load. They don't have to think as much about anything else other than their play because they know the pitch, they know the routines, they feel settled.

"However, there are a couple of potential negative impacts as well, with the potential intensification in pressure in the home fans, most times, expecting dominance from the home team. That can lead to mistakes from players feeling bigger to them.

"There can then be what we call a threat state. The players might perceive consequences as high, so they feel they might be facing more criticism when they are at home."

While those who watch football know there are more factors than just where the match is being to take into consideration, the statistics do suggest the influence is there.

Since the Premier League started, the home win percentage has outweighed the away win percentage in all bar one season - the Covid-hit 2020-21 campaign in which fans were largely not allowed admission saw a 38% home win rate compared to 40% away win rate.

So how a team handles this additional crowd pressure seems to be a key factor.

"In psychology, there is something called the challenge and threat theory," Cartwright said.

"In reality what that means is a 'challenge state' can push the player into thinking, 'I've got this, I've got the resources to cope with this'. That leads to better decision making and quicker reactions.

"The threat state, on the other hand, players might think the consequences outweigh their ability to cope. In any match context, that can mean they have a narrow sense of focus, the focus is not quite the same, so the play becomes slower because of overthinking."

"It can also be called 'red brain or blue brain' - with red brain being the one with fear-based dialogue and internal negative self-talk, while blue brain is the cool, calm and collected one that can handle its emotions.

"What sits in the middle of these is distraction. How a player responds to distraction and filters out the noise, like the crowd, can impact which of these mindsets they move into and ultimately how the team performs."

Read more from Marie in part two of her chat about why teams some teams play better away from home and how it impacts managers - that will be on this page early next week.

Image source, Getty Images

We wanted your suggestions for Manchester City's all-time best Premier League XI.

You have provided us with an interesting selection so here's some of your picks:

Bob: 4-4-2. Ederson, Walker, Kompany, Dias, O'Reilly, Doku, David Silva, De Bruyne, Mahrez, Haaland, Aguero. Team of world beaters from a few years ago with added modern strengths.

Chris: 3-5-2. Ederson, Walker, Kompany, Stones, De Bruyne, Yaya Toure, Rodri, D Silva, Foden, S Aguero, Haaland. I'm not convinced Erling and Sergio could play together but can't leave either out. I'm sure that midfield would create for them both and score a few themselves!

Daveed: 4-4-2. Ederson - multiple trophies won already. Walker, Kompany, Dias, Gvardiol - again trophies amongst them and a blend of experience with Kompany captain. Silva, Toure, Fernandinho, De Bruyne - basically four of my six top players woven into a classy midfield. Haaland and Aguero. I'm just going big up front and they should surely feed of one another.

Andrew: 4-1-3-2: Donnarumma, Walker, Kompany, Stones, Cancelo, David Silva, De Bruyne, Rodri, Sane, Haaland, Aguero. Legends and legends in the making together. Absolute world beaters.

George Mills
BBC Sport senior journalist

In a recent addition of the Football Extra newsletter, Roger asked BBC Sport: Players are frequently injured on international duty - such as Chris Wood for New Zealand last season, which may have ultimately cost Nottingham Forest a Champions League place. Are clubs compensated by the country or does insurance cover compensation?'

Since 2012, Fifa's Club Protection Programme has covered the salary of players injured on international duty - although there are some conditions.

Firstly, the player must be out of action for a period of at least 28 consecutive days and the injury must have been sustained during an "accident", which is defined in very boring and legally-specific detail in Fifa's guidelines, though it covers most of the examples you could think of.

The scheme pays the salary of an injured player up to the maximum amount of €7.5m (£6.6m) until they are declared fit to return for their clubs.

Transfermarkt lists Chris Wood as missing 18 days - three games - with the hip injury you mention from last March, suffered on international duty with New Zealand. As he returned inside 28 days, Forest would not have been eligible to claim compensation.

There are a couple of clubs who will currently be beneficiaries of this scheme though, including Newcastle United, whose £55m summer signing Yoane Wissa is yet to make an appearance since suffering a knee injury while playing for DR Congo.

Sign up to read more from the Football Extra newsletter

Ask Me Anything is a service dedicated to answering your questions.

We want to reward your time by telling you things you do not know and reminding you of things you do.

Find out more here

Shamoon Hafez
Manchester City reporter

Image source, Getty Images

After finishing third in the Premier League last season, seeing an early exit from the Champions League, losing the FA Cup final and suffering a shock exit at the Club World Cup, questions were rightly being asked whether Pep Guardiola and Manchester City could regroup and go again.

Was last term the start of a downfall or merely a blip?

Sunday's dismantling of champions Liverpool, extending their run to just one defeat in their past 14 games, emphatically answered any doubts.

After going under the radar in the early part of the campaign, City seem like they are back to their old selves and teams in England and across Europe will now be paying closer attention.

The side are spearheaded by the prolific Erling Haaland, who has rightly taken many of the headlines this season, but Guardiola's team is sprinkled with a supporting cast unheralded so far.

Midfielder Nico Gonzalez had a difficult start following his move from Porto in January but is starting to make the number six position his own in the absence of Rodri, while Nico O'Reilly continues to grow at left-back, keeping Mohamed Salah in his pocket at the weekend.

Phil Foden is back to his best, earning a recall to the England set-up. Ruben Dias and Josko Gvardiol are a formidable centre-back pairing. There is plenty for fans to be excited about.

Now comes the most demanding part of the campaign with 10 games to be played from 22 November until the end of the year, with tough trips to places such as Real Madrid, Newcastle and Crystal Palace on the agenda.

City's victory over the Reds following Arsenal's surprise draw at Sunderland cut the deficit to four points and it does not need spelling out how good Guardiola sides are at hunting down the leaders.

Come through this next period unscathed and the chase for the title will well and truly be on.

Gary Rose
BBC Sport journalist

Image source, Getty Images

This season Nico O'Reilly has very much established himself as a regular at Manchester City, making 10 Premier League appearances so far, scoring one goal and providing two assists.

It led to him picking up his first England cap on Thursday and impressing in the 2-0 win over Serbia.

Interestingly, however, left-back was not initially his calling.

Previously describing himself as a box-to-box midfielder who grew up admiring Yaya Toure and David Silva, he was deployed in the full-back role last season by manager Pep Guardiola through necessity because of injuries.

At one stage last term, City went on a run of one win in 13 games and boss Guardiola told BBC Sport the upturn in results after that "would be difficult to imagine" without O'Reilly's contributions.

"I loved the emotion he plays with," former Manchester United and England defender Phil Jones said.

"He is always controlled with his emotions for a young player, to play in those magnitude of games.

"He has got that real good state of mind - he plays on the edge, but he is calm.

England manager Thomas Tuchel added: "He seems to be very shy, he doesn't speak a lot, but he is very intelligent on the pitch and adapted so well to all the new things we demand from him."

Image source, Getty Images

Read the full article here

Image source, Getty Images

Manchester City defender Nico O'Reilly says it was a "dream come true" to make his England debut against Serbia at Wembley Stadium, adding that he has already set his sights on a spot in Thomas Tuchel's official World Cup squad.

"I'm over the moon," O'Reilly told BBC Radio 5 Live after the 2-0 win. "It has been a very special night making my England debut - a dream come true for me and my family.

"I want to thank everyone who has helped me get here, my mum, stepdad and sister. For them to watch me play here at Wembley is a crazy feeling.

"I got told I would be starting earlier on in the day. We had a meeting where the squad was announced and I was in the team. I was calm and excited.

"I knew it was a big moment but I was calm, level-headed and just ready for the game.

"Everything happens for a reason and it comes at the right time. I take it game by game and day by day. I will keep working hard and keep going.

"The World Cup squad is an aim of mine. I would love to be there. I just need to keep working hard and hopefully I'll be there."

Image source, Getty Images

We wanted your suggestions for Manchester City's all-time best Premier League XI.

And you delivered!

Here's a first bunch:

Rushy: 3-4-3. Ederson, Stones, Kompany, Walker, B Silva, De Bruyne, D Silva, Rodri, Foden, Haaland, Aguero. Dangerous lack of width for sure, but more than made up for by sheer firepower up front. Great creativity, composure and energy in midfield. A defence that combines strength and pace, Walker and Vinny, with considerable technical skill, Stones and Ederson.

Martin: 4-4-2. Hart, Zabaleta, Kompany, Dias, Clichy. KDB, D Silva, Fernandinho, Y Toure, Aguero, Haaland. Best of the old and new. We have been fortunate at City to have the best of the best. There are so many superb players that I could list.

Milo: 4-2-3-1. Ederson, Zabaleta, Kompany, Dias, Kolarov, Y Toure, Fernandinho, De Bruyne, D Silva, Sane, Aguero. Honourable mentions: Hart, Walker, Laporte, Dunne, Rodri, B Silva, Ireland, Gundogan and Sterling. Haaland so unfortunate but Kun is in a realm beyond legend.

Timothy: 4-3-3. Donnarumma, Walker, Stones, Dias, Gvardiol, Rodri, De Bruyne, Foden, Mahrez, Haaland, Sterling. This squad is technically strong and capable of winning trophies each season.

Charlie: 4-4-2. Ederson, Cancelo, Kompany, Dias, Zabaleta, Silva, Rodri, De Bruyne, Foden, Aguero, Haaland. At peak form and fitness, there's nothing this team can't do. An honourable mention to Fernandinho missing out to Ballon d'Or winner Rodri.

Sid: 4-4-1-1. Donnarumma, Walker, Kompany, Dias, O'Reilly, Rodri, Sane, Foden, De Bruyne, Doku, Haaland. This team could be world beaters.

Image source, Getty Images

Five Premier League stadiums will host fixtures during Euro 2028.

Uefa have selected nine venues across the four host nations - England, Scotland, Wales and the Republic of Ireland - to stage the 24-team tournament.

Manchester City's Etihad Stadium will host England's opening group game should Thomas Tuchel's side qualify for the competition directly.

Tottenham Hotspur Stadium, Villa Park, Hill Dickinson Stadium and St James' Park are the other Premier League grounds that will be used across the 51 matches overall.

The last-16 games will take place at each host stadium except Wembley, with England set to play at Newcastle United's St James' Park if they win their group, or Everton's Hill Dickinson Stadium if they finish second.

Chelsea have not made a move for Real Madrid and Brazil forward Rodrygo, 24, who is interesting Manchester City and Tottenham. (Fabrizio Romano), external

Want more transfer stories? Read Thursday's full gossip column

Follow the gossip column on BBC Sport

It's international break so let's have a bit of fun to pass the time.

Now we know football existed before 1992, but for the purposes of this little exercise, keep it Premier League please.

So tell us, who would be in your dream Manchester City's Premier League XI?

The debate starts here.

Send your suggestions

Shamoon Hafez
Manchester City reporter

Image source, Getty Images

Last month, Pep Guardiola described Rayan Cherki as "one of the huge talents I have ever seen" and now Real Madrid star Kylian Mbappe has had his say on the Manchester City forward.

France captain Mbappe has played with some sensational footballers during his illustrious career including Lionel Messi, Neymar and Karim Benzema.

But speaking before his side's World Cup qualifier against Ukraine on Thursday, Mbappe said: "Cherki is a special talent. He has a gift that he is exploiting, this innate and very spectacular talent."

Cherki scored on his City debut against Wolves but was ruled out for six weeks with a thigh injury. However, since returning, he has chalked up two goals and two assists - both for Erling Haaland - in his past four games.

Mbappe added: "He has integrated very well into the group, just as he integrated very well at Manchester City, which is not easy.

"We can see that he has already created a special connection with his number nine."

Mbappe and Cherki could face each other on 10 December, when City travel to Real Madrid in the group phase of the Champions League.

Freddie Pye
Fan writer

Image source, Getty Images

About this time last season, I spoke of the natural traits and abilities of Matheus Nunes - such traits and abilities that are incredibly difficult to find in the game. Pace in transition and defensive recovery, power in physical duels, and an eye for a cross-field ball or cross into the box.

Fast forward to the weekend, and the Portugal midfielder-turned-full-back played a crucial role in Manchester City's win over Liverpool providing an assist for Erling Haaland with a remarkable ball into the penalty area from wide, and defensively remained outstanding against the visitors' attacking threat.

The same applies to Jeremy Doku. When City signed the Belgian from Rennes in the summer of 2023, it was blatantly obvious to many that this was a wide player with immense talent - perhaps abilities in attack that no other player within the game can replicate.

However, the 23-year-old has somewhat struggled to add end product to his output, despite being unstoppable in one-versus-one situations or attacking phases over five and 10-yard spaces.

Doku's showing against the reigning Premier League champions on Sunday felt like his ultimate crowning moment, and a real turning point for a player who has one of the highest ceilings in the City squad.

IIt is perhaps a little too early to throw him into the conversation as a future Ballon d'Or winner, but given the profile of players usually put forward for football's top individual prize, it is not beyond the realm of possibility in the next decade.

Pep Guardiola said after the game that Doku would never be a top scorer for Manchester City, and perhaps that is largely down to the team's set-up that is geared towards feeding Haaland.

But when games are tight, and when Doku has small pockets of space to operate in, the lightning winger could find himself in goalscoring opportunities more often.

At a time when City are rebuilding and transitioning, Doku - alongside the likes of Haaland, Rayan Cherki and Phil Foden - could be the man to carry this Guardiola era into its latest, exciting attacking phase.

Find more from Freddie Pye at City Xtra, external

Pat Nevin
Former footballer and presenter

Image source, Getty Images

Sunday was a grand old day for Pep Guardiola in every way. It was his 1,000th game as a manager and his team gave him the present of an exceptional display against one of their great rivals.‌

Erling Haaland's opener had his boss as excited as I have ever seen him. It was close to the perfect Guardiola goal, passing out from beside their own corner flag. Every outfield payer got a touch; they kept the ball for what felt like an eternity if you were a Liverpool fan before Haaland's header eventually left keeper Giorgi Mamardashvili helpless.

That tight passing build-up was a metaphor for the game. It resembled an elongated rondo training drill, where the Liverpool midfield looked like it was outnumbered two to one.

The complete confidence to play out of tight situations, to take the pass when marked but still retain possession and to trick or dribble out of trouble if a pass wasn't on, was bordering on perfection in that first half from City.‌

That style has always been the base of Guardiola's philosophy and here it was back again for 45 minutes, just like the grand old days of Kevin de Bruyne, David Silva et al in their pomp.

Maybe that, as much as the 3-0 dismissal of a close rival, is what everyone else should be concerned about.

Sign up to read more from Pat Nevin in his Football Extra newsletter

Chris Collinson
BBC Sport statistician

This season, Manchester City have covered more ground than any other side in the Premier League at 1268.7km - An average of 115.3 km per game.

In comparison, seven teams ran more than City in the top flight last term, with Pep Guardiola's side averaging 109.8km per game. This means they are running 5.5km per game more so far this campaign.

In terms of sprints, only Nottingham Forest and Southampton averaged fewer per game than City last season (127), whereas only five teams have sprinted more per match than the Manchester side this campaign (149) - that is 22 more than last time out.

When focusing on their win at home to Liverpool on Sunday, Manchester City ran almost nine kilometres more than than the Reds (118.0 km v 109.2 km) - only twice has a team outrun their opponents more in a Premier League game this season.

It is easier to outrun an opponent when they are a player short, so when we only consider matches without a red card, only once has a team outrun their opponents more in a top flight match this term than City did against Liverpool - which was the former champions themselves in their 4-0 opening day win at Wolves.

The three instances where a team has outrun their opponents by more than eight kilometres in a game of 11v11 this season have all been Guardiola's side.

Sin bins? Bonus points? Two goals if you score from distance?

Imagine a world in which you could reinvent football.

It's a dream, of course. Just a bit of fun. But stick with us.

What if you had the power to change any of the game's laws and potentially bring to an end countless hours of discussion about handball, offside, video assistant referees, or anything else you want to?

Some of BBC Sport's familiar football faces have offered their own potential rule changes.

Watch them above or read more here

Former Liverpool, Stoke City and Scotland midfielder Charlie Adam has hailed Manchester City boss Pep Guardiola as a "genius", adding that his side can "never be ruled out" of a Premier League title race.

Speaking on BBC Radio 5 Live's Monday Night Club, Adam said: "Pep Guardiola is such a good manager because he wants to evolve.

"He has understood what the challenges of the Premier League are and he is willing to change.

"But he has still kept his real strong principles in terms of how he wants to play and how he wants to build.

"Their start to the season wasn't probably what they expected or wanted.

"You can always see them winning 10 or 12 games in a row, without doubt."

• Not a Man City fan? Find and follow your Premier League club

However, ex-Premier League striker Chris Sutton does not believe City are "out of the woods" just yet.

"I still think there is a massive overreliance on Erling Haaland," Sutton explained.

"He has scored 14 Premier League goals so far this season and their next top scorer is on one goal, so if anything happens to him it would still be a concern."

Watch the full episode on BBC iPlayer and listen on BBC Sounds

Manchester City and Real Madrid are both interested in Liverpool and Hungary midfielder Dominik Szoboszlai, 25. (AS - in Spanish), external

Want more transfer stories? Read Tuesday's full gossip column

Follow the gossip column on BBC Sport

Image source, Getty Images

Manchester City might have made a statement of intent in the title race with their 3-0 win against reigning champions Liverpool last night and moved four points behind Premier League leaders Arsenal before the international break.

But they are still some way off catching the Gunners, according to Opta's Premier League predictions.

The Opta supercomputer's latest update has Pep Guardiola's City finishing about seven points behind Arsenal at the end of the season.

Opta still gives Arsenal 63.6% chance of winning the title this season with City only having a 22.9% chance of becoming champions in the latest set of simulations.

Liverpool, meanwhile, have only a 7% probability of defending their title with Chelsea marked at 2.75%.

Predicted points after 38 games:

Arsenal - 80.19

Man City - 73.50

Liverpool - 68.23

Chelsea - 63.34

Aston Villa - 60.76

Crystal Palace - 59.32

Man Utd - 56.37

Bournemouth - 56.31

Brighton - 55.93

Tottenham - 54.97